Reviews

Crown of acorns by Catherine Fisher

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9780340970072.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Three stories weave their way in this fascinating mystery by Catherine Fisher. A 17 year-old girl has arrived anonymously in Bath. Giving herself a new name, Sulis, she goes to stay with a new foster family, but lives in fear of being discovered by a mystery man from her past. A parallel story in the 18th century tells of Zac, the teenage apprentice to architect Jonathan Forrest, who dreams of building a circle of houses based on druidic principles. Working only because his father has gambled away their family fortune, Zac is destructive and consumed with envy. Then there is the voice of Bladud, a mythical figure, who has been cured of a leprous disease by the healing waters of the sacred spring of Sulis.
Fisher gradually builds up the suspense around the teen, Sulis, who is convinced that someone is following her. She is very frightened and I was intrigued by the mystery surrounding her fear, never being sure if she was delusional or actually was being stalked by the person who murdered her young friend. There is suspense too in the relationship between Zac and his employer, Forrest, and I was kept on the edge of my seat, hoping that Forrest's great architectural dreams would be fulfilled and not foiled by Zac's mean machinations.
It was interesting that one of the main protagonists, Zac, is not an attractive character at all and this added spice to the story. However, Josh, Sulis' co-worker is a wonderful caring person and her foster parents are portrayed very sympathetically.
The magical setting, Bath, will enthral anyone who has ever visited that wonderful city with its golden stone. Those who are new to the setting will long to visit it. An afterword by Fisher gives information about John Wood, architect of the King's Circle in Bath.
Pat Pledger
Editor's note: Crown of acorns is on the CILIP Carnegie Medal longlist, 2011.

Across the Universe by Beth Revis

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780141333663.
(Age 14+) Recommended. In this thought provoking science fiction book, the reader is taken on a trip aboard the vast spaceship Godspeed, as it goes in search of a new planet to colonise. Seventeen-year-old Amy leaves her life on earth behind and joins her parents, as part of the 100 specialists who are frozen and stored aboard the ship.  She expects to be woken up after a 300-year journey, but is traumatised when she is thawed too early and discovers that someone has tried to kill her. Not only that, but life aboard the ship is strange and frightening. Eldest, a Hitler-like dictator, leads the ship and is training a young man named Elder as his apprentice. The behaviour of the ship's inhabitants is passive and weird.
Told in alternative chapters by Amy and Elder, Revis builds up a fascinating picture of life aboard a spaceship and the dilemmas that face the people who live there. Interspersed is the mystery of who is trying to kill the people who have been frozen. Amy is an intelligent young woman and together with Elder and his friend Harley, set out to discover who is taking out the frozen bodies and leaving them to die.
At the same time Revis explores the morality of the ways that leaders have tried to keep people hopeful about their chances of survival and the use of drugs to keep them compliant. Elder is challenged by Amy's approach to people and what is happening on the ship. She is a strong independent young woman who is not intimidated by authority and who makes Elder look at his actions in a different light. The responsibility of leadership and the right of people to know the truth are explored.
Teenage girls will be attracted to this book because of its beautiful cover. The engaging characters, exciting plot and a touch of romance will keep them reading.
Pat Pledger

Luka and the Fire of Life by Salman Rushdie

cover image

Jonathan Cape, 2010. ISBN 9780224090216.
(For ages 11+ years) This is a classic quest story that takes up the adventures of Luka whose older brother is the hero in Haroun and the Sea of Stories, an earlier novel of Rushdie's. Luka's story is magic; this is evident from the first lines, as Rushdie envelops us in the smell and feel of other lands. This is a story that reveals much about the power of story and how our own stories are to be treasured as we pass them onto others.
Luka witnesses a circus coming to his town; one where the animals are obviously abused. He curses the circus owner and in an act of revenge a great sleep befalls Luka's beloved father, the great storyteller Rashid Khalifa. Luka discovers that the only way to revive his father is to travel to the World of Magic and steal the Fire of Life. As with any quest adventure, the hero's companions are indispensible and very interesting! Luka's imaginings and his father's stories merge and make the journey all the more exciting. It is wonderful to read this book for its story and descriptive language. Rushdie is a master of creating both. Undoubtedly, everyone enjoys a good quest and this is no exception. The complexity and detail, however, will mean that Luka and the Fire of Life will appeal to the more sophisticated reader.
Julie Wells

It's a Book by Lane Smith

cover image

Macmillan, 2011.
(Ages 7 - 70) Highly recommended. Living in a society obsessed with tweeting, texting, emailing and gaming this is definitely a parable for our times. Jackass (his trusty iPad under his arm) is curious to discover what Monkey is immersed in. 'It's a book' replies Monkey. In a series of deceptively simple sequences Monkey explains that it doesn't require a mouse or a password, you don't have to charge it and it doesn't Tweet or text.
Jackass gives it a try. He settles down, starts reading, can't stop and won't give the book back. Monkey, sanguine as ever, simply goes to the library to choose another.
This book hits the jackpot.  Lane Smith has created a simple layout, uncluttered pages, and a perfect balance of shape and colour, together with a message that makes you want to shout 'Yes!' This is a work of genius, a classic in only 121 words and there's a pleasing symmetry in that number. As book lovers the world over already know, whenever a reader and a book get together they embark on an intimate 'one to one' relationship.
What I love most is that it reflects Anthony Browne's message. As Children's Laureate he is denouncing the habit of pushing children to read 'proper' books (i.e. those without illustration). Here is a book that could generate endless debate about the nature of communication and entertainment. AND IT'S A PICTURE BOOK! It will be wasted on children under seven, who won't grasp the intended message, so don't let it fester in a kinder-box. Read it and spread the word. It's a Book!
Claire Larson

The Three Loves of Persimmon by Cassandra Golds

cover image

Penguin Books 2010. ISBN 9780143205012.
(For ages 14-16 years). This is a rather strange story that hovers between real and imagined worlds. A shy and vulnerable young girl, desperate for attention and affection, has her world tossed about by prospective lovers and strange companions. Persimmon is a florist, alone in the world, having been disowned by her family, which itself had split into two camps, the scientists and the artists; fruit and vegetable growers and flower growers. She takes the creative, artistic road, a dreamer and rather impractical, but valiantly attempts to make her new florist business work. Encouraged by letters sent to her by her now deceased Great Aunt Lily, she is also on a quest for love. Strange creatures aid her on her journey to love; a talking ornamental cabbage and a bewildered little mouse called Epiphany, and they share numerous romantic and adventurous episodes with the young heroine. Art, the theatre and flowers provide an interesting backdrop with the array of characters dreaming of things unattainable. Finally, hope and love are discovered.
The book is quite well written but the story struggles to keep its momentum, and it is difficult to ascertain the novel's readership.
Julie Wells

Yellowcake by Margo Lanagan

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742374789.
Short stories. Highly recommended. Ten new short stories from Margo Lanagan, collected together in one volume, will have people absolutely delighted. The originality and subtlety of this author's work is to be marveled at and her previous collections, Black juice, Red Spike and ahe book, Tender Morsels, will ensure a willing audience for this new collection.
From Ferryman to An honest day's work, each story brings with it a fresh and novel approach, one which will be the cause of much discussion and rereading. Ferryman uses the stories of old, the oarsman taking the dead across the River Styx to what lies beyond. A rich and unusual story develops, of the ferryman and his dutiful daughter, coming down to give him his lunch, singing as she descends the steps, their idle, familiar chatter contrasting with the bodies of the dead, who, zombie like, are queued up waiting for their last trip. While Into the clouds on high, we see a young woman, letting go of her family, her husband and two children, as she disappears to help others unseen. Where she has gone, no one knows, but she shimmers, hovering in the air, spreading a warmth to those around her. And the enigmatic The point of roses, had me rereading immediately, trying to find the clues hidden in the wonderful prose, of what and where this may have taken place.
Each story builds a setting at once known and unknown, characters brought to life with a few sprays of words, a story built seemingly from air, but always with a central core of tension, of not knowing what is going on, of people looking for answers in a sea of doubt..
Singing my sister down, from the Black Juice collection, is a story I have had with me since first reading it. It has now been paired with another that will intrigue, baffle and enthrall, An honest day's work, redolent of the whaling industry as little men carve and cut up a torso hauled out from the sea. One of many in this fine collection.
Fran Knight

The chimpanzee book: Apes like us by Dr Carla Litchfield

cover image

Black dog books, 2009. ISBN 978 1742030746.
Non fiction, Recommended. Dr Carla Litchfield, an animal behaviour scientist with ZoosSA, has written another children's book for black dog books, this time about the chimpanzee, giving a huge amount of information within a few pages, underscoring the need for people to be aware of the need for conservation, and entertaining the reader along the way.
Like the series, Wild Planet, published by this company, Apes like us has double page spreads of information with maps, short paragraphs of facts and lots of clear, explicit photographs, telling us about the difference between chimps and bonobos, behaviour, culture, habitat, as well as a large map to show us where they live. Some fascinating pieces of information are given in these pages: they are omnivore, eating mainly fruit but also monkeys and small animals, baby chimps stay with mum for eight years or so, they use tools, and so on. After these introductory pages, double page spreads are devoted to specific communities of chimps like those who live in Gombe (made famous by Dr Jane Goodall) or Bossou (where the chimps have learnt to cross a busy road) and Tai to name a few. Each page outlines where this group lives and marks out its differences to other groups.
Reading like a story, the information is at once fascinating and unsettling as we come to the pages where we learn of their habitat destruction. Of the million or so chimps once living in central Africa, some 300,000 remain. Dr Litchfield ends the book with suggestions about how the reader can help save these animals, and with its brief but useful index, content information and web sites, makes this a wonderful book for use n the classroom.
Dr Litchfield's book, Saving pandas is inspirational, and so is this. In this Year of the Forests, this would make a stimulating addition to the work done by classes on conservation, as the destruction of the forests is one of the major issues outlined by Dr Litchfield.
Fran Knight

Angel Creek by Sally Rippin

cover image

Text, 2011. ISBN 9781921758058.
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Jelly is not happy when her parents buy a new house so that she can go to high school. The only things that she likes are the apricot tree, which she has made her secret place, and Angel Creek, which flows behind her house. One night she and her cousins Gino and Pik are exploring the dark waters of the creek when they find a strange creature with an injured wing. It's a baby angel and they decide to keep it. But this strange, feral little thing that ferociously attaches itself to Jelly is not like a baby bird that needs mending, and somewhere there must be a mother.
With a compelling mixture of reality and fantasy, Angel Creek was such a fascinating story that I read it in one sitting. Rippin's picture of family life was one that rang true. It was easy to imagine the jealousy that Gino felt when the little angel attached itself to Jelly, and the contrast between Jelly's lovely relationship with her father and Gino's less than perfect one added a level to the family relations.
It is also a coming of age story. Jelly is a brave girl who can stand up against the bullying teenage boys on their bikes. She also begins to realise that her actions have repercussions. Like a bird that has recovered from its injuries, the little angel must be returned to its home and Jelly has to find a way to do that. She also discovers that change is inevitable. Her grandmother won't live forever and she can make new friends in her neighbourhood. The slight touch of romance with the boy who has helped her will appeal to young readers.
I love books about angels and I thoroughly enjoyed Angel Creek. Rippin's story has a unique take on angels and their origins and this story of a baby creek angel is fascinating and original. Readers who enjoyed this story might like to move onto the more complex Skellig by David Almond or Unfinished angel by Sharon Creech, and Waterslain Angels by Kevin Crossley-Holland.
Pat Pledger

The Double Life of Cassiel Roadnight by Jenny Valentine

cover image

Harper Collins, 2010. ISBN 9780007283613.
(Age 13+) Recommended. The runaway boy, who has no name, longs for a normal family life and somewhere to call home. He really looks like the photo of a missing boy, Cassiel Roadnight, and the temptation to know a mother and sister proves too much for him. He decides to take on the identity of the missing boy, but doesn't think through the repercussions of his hasty decision. All is not well in the Roadnight household and there seem to be dark secrets. Why did Cassiel disappear? Is he still alive or hiding out somewhere?
The story is told in the first person by the boy, although the reader doesn't get a name for the narrator until right at the end of the story. Valentine is a master at character building and all the emotions and fears of the people in Cassiel's disfunctional family are brilliantly described.
This is a compelling thriller. The tension that Valentine builds up kept me on the edge of my seat right to the end. As a reader I could see the risks that the boy was taking in pretending to be someone else and kept hoping that it wouldn't lead to complete disaster for him. The question of Cassiel's fate kept nagging at me. Was he missing or was he dead? If he was murdered what was going to happen to the boy? Would he be strong and smart enough to outwit a murderer? At the same time there is a parallel mystery. Where did the boy come from and why does he have such an uncanny resemblance to the missing Cassiel? Gradually small clues are left but I was still surprised when I learnt about the boy's background and Cassiel's fate.
Valentine writes intelligent and insightful fiction and this is a memorable book. It would make an excellent introduction to the mystery genre for young readers who might then go on to reading other mysteries, like those by Josephine Tey, who is thanked by Valentine for inspiration at the end of the book .
Pat Pledger

Unhooking the moon by Gregory Hughes

cover image

Quercus, 2010. ISBN 9781849162951.
(Age 12+) Highly recommended. When the Rat, a precocious ten-year-old girl, predicts the death of her father, Bob is sceptical but the Rat's predictions have come true in the past. When they find their father dead, they decide to travel from Winnipeg to New York in search of their uncle, who is rumoured to be a drug dealer. Setting out on their bikes, they encounter many adventures on their road trip including meeting up with a smuggler, a con man and a famous rap star. How can they find their uncle amongst so many people and survive on the streets of New York?
Hughes has created two of the most memorable characters that I have read in books recently. The Rat is an amazing girl, who, although suffering from seizures, is remarkably wise and brave. She can speak several languages and mimic anyone she meets. Her charisma is extraordinary and her leadership skills are remarkable. Her hatred of paedophiles is a theme throughout the book. Her older brother Bob finds himself in the role of follower and protector, always worrying about the Rat's fragility. Good looking and kind hearted, he moves along in the wake of the Rat's wishes and their sibling love is a highlight of the book.
Hughes' writing of dialogue is superb. The Rat uses the word 'beep' instead of a swear word and this provides much of the humour in the book. Other characters come alive through their conversation as well.
Unhooking the moon is not just an engrossing road trip; it is original and heart rending. It covers themes of mental illness, death, the effect of fame and homelessness in a seamless story that had me laughing and crying.
Nothing prepared me for the magic and gritty realism in the book although the fact that it has been awarded the Booktrust Teenage Prize, 2010 and shortlisted for the Guardian Children's Fiction Prize 2010, should have warned me that it would be an outstanding story. It deserves to be promoted vigorously by teachers and librarians to individuals, for class sets and literature circles. I believe that it will make its mark as a modern children's classic.
Pat Pledger

The magic brush by Kat Yeh

cover image

Ill. by Huy Voun Lee. Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 9781408815458.
(Age 4-7) Jasmine is a small girl who is too old for afternoon naps, unlike her little brother, Tai Tai. When her Agong  (Grandfather) comes to live with her family, he sets her on a magical path of mythological creatures and wonderful writing teaching her how to use brush and ink to write words and create pictures. When he dies, Jasmine teaches her little brother the magic of the calligraphy brush so that together they can recreate their artist grandfather.
This is a moving story about family love and being an artist. Agong is a patient grandfather who introduces Jasmine to the magic of making a wish. Together they use their imagination and paint and brush to conjure up the moon and stars and fly to rescue a baby dragon from the top of a mountain. Jasmine loves learning with Agong and is very sad when he is gone. However she loves her baby brother and when he is too big for a nap she teaches him all she has learnt.
Rich deep colours bring the story alive. The Chinese characters for key words in the text are drawn in the corners of the pages and there is an explanation of how to pronounce Chinese words at the end of the book. A brief explanation of Chinese art is also given. Children will also be intrigued by the information about Chinese treats.
Kat Yeh has used a clever way to introduce both Chinese culture and words which young children are sure to enjoy.
Pat Pledger

Gladiator by Simon Scarrow

cover image

Puffin, 2011. ISBN 9780141333974.
(Age 11+) Recommended. Lovers of historical fiction and action packed books will be delighted with this plot driven, exciting novel set in the time of ancient Rome. Marcus is a young boy who has been taken as a slave after his ex-centurion father was killed because he couldn't pay back his debts. His mother too is enslaved. Marcus is determined to secure her release by talking to General Pompeius the Great whose life was saved by his father in the aftermath of the rebellion by Spartacus and the slaves. Taken to a school for gladiators, he trains tirelessly and waits for an opportunity to escape.
The book is rich in historical detail and is a good introduction to Roman history and soldiers. I thoroughly enjoyed this portrayal of life as a slave in Roman times. I avidly read right to the end in a couple of sittings, longing to see if Marcus could survive his arduous training, the attacks by bullies and fights in the arena. A mark on Marcus' shoulder seems to point to an important secret, and canny readers will have fun predicting just what that brand means.
Life in the gladiator school was described in all its gory detail and was quite fascinating to read about. I won't easily forget the way the slaves were branded or the inhumanity of the Roman aristocrats and children watching fights to the death. Although there are bloodthirsty scenes, Marcus maintains his integrity and does not kill his enemies. In fact violence and bullying are depicted as wrong, and Marcus maintains a high moral attitude throughout the book, even when he is taunted and tormented.
This is the first in a series by Simon Scarrow, who usually writes for adults, and is a welcome addition to the thriller genre. Although the book is long, the sentences are short and easy to read, and this combined with the exciting plot, may appeal to reluctant readers. A website with information and a book trailer will also stimulate those who enjoyed the book. Gladiator is dedicated to Rosemary Sutcliffe and children may be tempted to read some of her outstanding historical novels.
Pat Pledger

The best ballgirl by Pat Flynn

cover image

Aussie Chomps. Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143505743.
Delving into the politics behind the scenes at a tennis championship makes riveting reading in Pat FLynn's experienced hands. With credible characters and a strong, believable setting, the story of the in infighting and bullying at the local tennis club makes for an absorbing tale.
Kirsten and her friends are part of the district tennis scene, all being coached by a local coach and with dreams of making it onto the tennis circuit. The club supervisor, the imperious Mrs Starling, also has dreams, not for herself, but her daughter Sally. With private coaching and a pushy mother, Sally seems to have it all, but Kirsten is doubly cross with her when she begins to take the attention of the one boy Kirsten likes, TJ.
In announcing that a major tennis championship will occur at the club and therefore needing ball girls and boys, the group trains with vigour, hoping to be picked for the jobs available. Kirsten would dearly love to be on court when her hero, Maggie Stephenson plays the final, but Mrs Starling does not chose her. Things conspire to make this happen.
A neatly told story of allegiances and friendships, the story incorporates an ugly parent and the sports scene at a tennis club. It will have a broad appeal to those who love reading about involvement in sports, the relationships between friends and for fans of the series, Aussie Chomps. It is well written with a believable and involving story line which will make readers look at the ball girls and ball boys with a different eye next time they watch tennis.
Fran Knight

Anna and the French kiss by Stephanie Perkins

cover image

Penguin, 2010.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Romance. When Anna is shipped off to a boarding school in Paris for her final year she is not happy. She has left behind her best friend, Bridge, a job at a cinema that she loves and a beginning romance with a gorgeous boy. When she meets charismatic Etienne at her new school things begin to look up. But Etienne is already in a serious relationship. Will they ever manage to get together for their French kiss?
The beautiful setting of Paris makes this book stand out from the usual boarding school romances. Perkins takes the reader on a wonderful tour of this romantic city. At the same time she doesn't gloss over the difficulties that Anna has in learning a new language and a new way of life. She describes the problems of ordering food in the canteen, buying tickets for the movies and travelling on the Metro, but these are overshadowed by the descriptions of the Notre Dame and the Latin Quarter. Readers will long for the chance to visit Paris and envy Anna for her experience.
Both the main characters and Anna's friends are strong and believable. Anna is an interesting girl, who is serious about wanting to be a film critic. She watches lots of movies and runs her own website with film reviews. Fans of films will love the references to movies that dot the pages. Etienne has lots of charisma and the girls at the school find him swoon worthy. However he does have a vulnerable side which he shows Anna, as he copes with his mother's cancer and his father's bullying. Fathers don't come off too well in this book, as Anna too doesn't seem to respect her father, who is an author. She thinks that his books and films are shallow and predictable. I found myself avidly following the various subplots involving Anna's friends both in Paris and Atlanta. The incident when Anna came home for Thanksgiving and found herself almost a stranger, having to re-establish her place in her family, was both familiar and touching.
Readers who also love a romance will not be disappointed. The novel hums with tension as Anna and Etienne explore their feelings for each other. Anna initially settles for friendship as Etienne has a girlfriend, Ellie, who is studying elsewhere, but there is definitely a serious attraction going on. Friendship is a strong theme in this book and Perkins explores the possibility of friendship between boy and girl as well as how a real friend behaves to her girlfriends.
Fans of Sarah Dessen and Maureen Johnson are certain to enjoy this book.
Pat Pledger

To Die For By Mark Svendsen

cover image

Random, 2011.ISBN 9781864719314. e-Book available.
(Best suited for 13+) Genre: Thriller/Survival. For his birthday, Christos takes his father's boat on his first solo voyage. He plans to fish and then camp overnight on a local island, but things go wrong when Christos runs the boat aground on a reef, attracting a four-metre tiger shark. And so begins the most terrifying night of his life.
This book is definitely one for fishing fans. Many of the fishing terms are confusing and the style of writing employed is also confusing to begin with, often moving disjointedly from sentence to sentence. The first few chapters are drawn out and wouldn't easily catch a young reader's attention.
When the shark does appear, the scenes are well-written and exciting, perfectly capturing the image of survival and fear. The description and disjointed sentences work well here, illustrating the terrified and desperate state of Christos's mind at this point. However, after the shark disappears from the story, the expected conclusion is prolonged with unnecessary sub-plots.
It is an all right book, but definitely one for those interested in fishing.
Rebecca Adams (Student)