Reviews

Post from Paul Collins, author of the thrilling book, Mole Hunt

cover image

I grew up in a house without books. One occasionally materialised from a drawer - it was a green-spined mystery title by Erle Stanley Gardner. I used to look at it on its rare appearances, and wonder what a book was doing there. None of my family read - my brother, a director of a printing company, hasn't read a book to this day. But we both read comics. We'd devour Marvel Group Comics such as Captain America, Spiderman, Daredevil, the Uncanny X-Men, etc. And I think this is why I write the way I do- it's not 'literary', nor really 'character-based', but I'd like to think an amalgamation of both, but surely driven by action. There is of course a place for all writing and we just need to find our niche.
Regardless of style or motivation, writing novels can be an arduous and unrewarding business. It's one of the few jobs in the world where someone can work for a year and there's absolutely no guarantee that he or she will be paid. So imagine working for a year maybe as a carpenter, plumber, whatever, and getting told after a year that your work isn't up to standard and sorry, we're not paying you.
More authors than not go through this scenario. I went through it with Mole Hunt. Over four years it was submitted to most of Australia's major publishers and some via an agent in the UK and the US. Many replied saying how good it was, but -
Penguin UK praised it to the hilt saying if they didn't already have Artemis Fowl, the young James Bond, etc, they'd be keen. Another prominent Australian publisher told me Mole Hunt reminded her of what she used to love in science fiction - but it wasn't for her imprint, which was more contemporary literature. But of course, rejection is rejection.
Having learnt the hard way, I know that persistence is the key. I'm reminded of when I first started submitting Dragonlinks (book one in The Jelindel Chronicles), my personal best-selling book. It was at the beginning of a fantasy craze in Australia. Every major publisher rejected it. Three years went by and finally a publisher at Penguin left and I resubmitted the manuscript without telling the new publisher that Penguin had already rejected it some years earlier. It worked. The publisher bought it. Published in 2002 it's still selling today.
Why dystopian fiction? Well, I've written it in the past with The Earthborn Wars published by Tor in the US (The Earthborn, The Skyborn and The Hiveborn). Fifteen years before The Hunger Games, I also wrote a virtual reality dystopian novel with a remarkably similar plot called Cyberskin. People dying from a terminal illness can sign their lives over to a legal 'snuff' movie company and get killed live for the audience (for payment, of course, a life insurance policy that goes to their grieving family). They're pitted against a superior fighter who is an enhanced fighting machine.
So it's a genre that I feel comfortable with. I think dystopian fiction also lends itself to fast-paced filmic action, which is usually attributed to my writing. Sometimes it's best to stay with what we know and love. My own favourite authors are Eoin Colfer (Artemis Fowl) and Philip Reeve (Mortal Engines). I can just as easily see these books as films, as I can my own Mole Hunt.
Although I suspect the time of the anti-hero is nigh, I was a little worried about Maximus Black. He's obviously a sociopath, and demonstrates this propensity by killing two people in the first chapter. But just today I started reading Scorpio Rising by Anthony Horowitz. His baddies make Maximus look like an apprentice sociopath. Scorpio agents manage to kill a truckload of people in the first hundred or so pages. So that's one piece of doubt off my mind - perhaps killing in comic-book fashion in YA fiction isn't so prohibited after all. Further doubt has been eroded by various reviews that are appearing. Bookseller and Publisher said it was 'bitingly clever' (I don't usually get quotes like that!) and a cross between The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, Dexter and Total Recall. Now if the book lives up to that description I suspect I'll have an enthusiastic readership. Other reviewers refer to it as being so fast-paced it would give Matthew Reilly a nosebleed, while another said she couldn't put the book down (must be that magnetic cover!).
Paul Collins
Melbourne June 2011

Head Spinners by Thalia Kalkipsakis

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742373454.
(Ages 8+) Recommended. Brooke has a weird bump on her arm, it's not itchy and it doesn't hurt, it has a warm tingling feeling and its growing. Jamie didn't steal anything from the Big Cow Cafe, so how did  the fish sandwich end up in his bag? He doesn't even like smoked-trout sandwiches. Danny's dad is absolutely bonkers but this, this is the weirdest, most dangerous thing he has ever done. Why on Earth is he speeding after another car?
This book has six awesome, excellent and amazing stories that will leave your head spinning. I think this book is great. I enjoyed all six stories, my favourite though would have to be Night Sight. I would definitely recommend this to people who like silly, suspense filled stories that are just different, even if just for a laugh. I hope if you read it (which I highly recommend) you enjoy it.
Tahlia Kennewell (student)

The Glass Collector by Anna Perera

cover image

HarperCollins, 2011. ISBN: 978-0-7322-9153-2
Recommended. Friendships and family are important, more so sometimes than your standing in life. This is obviously what Aaron believes. Born a Zabbaleen, Aaron is forced to work with the rest of the men to scavenge rubbish off the busy streets of Cairo. Living with his abusive stepfamily and with the low price of recyclable goods scraping a living is much harder than it once was.
Aaron did always have a special way with the glass; only his practiced fingers could gather so much broken glass without cutting himself. Aaron knows more about glass than anyone he knew, the colours, the lights and beauty that is and can be made from glass. Caught with a stolen perfume bottle it seems that the delights of being a glass collector are now denied him. An outcast with nowhere to go, Aaron must learn the error of his ways and repent for his sins to be allowed back into the community and to have any chance at being with the girl he loves.
A book full of complications, desperation and passion, The Glass Collector was short listed for two awards: the Costa Children's Book Awards and the Branford Boase Award. I think that Anna Perera has captured the thoughts and feelings of the characters brilliantly. The Glass Collector is written in both present tense and first person. This does well to display the thoughts and feelings of life in a poor village.
This sensational novel confronts several difficult topics and life ideas including desperation, faith, social standards and wealth.
Kayla Gaskell (Student, 15)

The Magic Fairy Folk Collection by Enid Blyton

cover image

Egmont, 2011. ISBN 9781405257572.
If you go to a person's house and you see their garden has a special place for the little folk, with wishing wells, toadstools, a birdhouse or two and butterflies and fairies dancing from overhead branches, and little gnomes fishing in a pond or resting on a rock, then there is a fair chance that person has been touched with a bit of fairy dust.  And if you go inside and find that Miss Nearly 5's bedroom is more like the inside of a fairy dell, complete with misty, starry sky, then you can be assured of it.
So it's no wonder that that person loves Enid Blyton's tales of the magical folk who so entranced her that she was reading before she went to school, and that she is going to share that enchantment with her own little folk. And when a compendium of some of the most-loved tales is published, that person is going to pounce on it and instead of reading her university texts, she's going to transport herself back to her childhood.
So that's what I've been doing. This collection comprises The Book of Fairies, The Book of Pixies and The Book of Brownies and has over 50 separate stories that are just the right length for reading aloud as a bedtime story and sending little ones off to sleep with gentle magical thoughts.
But if I take my grandma's hat off and put my teacher librarian one on, my experience is that these stories are a great transition between the instructional home reader and the independence of the 'chapter book'. Because each story is complete in itself, even though it is only a few pages long, young readers manage this "new reading" well and my library collection always had a great selection of Blyton's stories available that were very popular. This compendium would have been a brilliant addition.
Politically correct or not, old-fashioned or not, I'm putting my hand up to say I am a Blyton fan and her stories have pride of place in my personal collection. Perhaps it's time to take this generation back and introduce them to an old favourite.
Barbara Braxton

Interview with Karen Tayleur

cover image

at Mary Martin's Bookshop, The Parade, Norwood, South Australia (18 May 2011)
Meeting Karen Tayleur for lunch surrounded by books was the best of both worlds for me. Karen was in Adelaide as a fellowship recipient of the May Gibb's Children's Literature Trust  an award which means a month spent in a furnished apartment at Norwood, free of the interruptions which might occur at home, a place of contemplation and quiet.
For the last few weeks, Karen has been researching and writing drafts for her next two novels. One a gothic romance, is for young adults and the other will be for younger readers and central to that idea, meant going to Moonta to peruse the cemetery for ideas and names for her Cornish story.
But Karen has written a range of stories over the past eight or nine years, many of which have become favourites in schools, some being used as class sets. From her days working at black dog books, she was involved in the series of netball stories called, All Stars, writing Bree and Mel. This series for the middle primary student was fast paced and involving, telling the story of the members of the netball team, one at a time, showing their interlocking lives and how their different backgrounds directed their choices. Published in 2005-6, the series is often stored as a group of ease of access in primary school libraries, having several different authors.
The stories of David Mortimer Baxter have also proved popular, as they take a moral precedent and look at it more closely. In Lies, for example, David is told not to tell lies, but this does not sit well when he is then asked to lie not to hurt someone's feelings. The series of 6 books tells its story neatly with a lesson to be learnt at the end, but they are not didactic or preaching, simply funny.
Her first novel for older readers, Chasing boys (2008) took a different tack, with a book about a girl changing schools,and trying vainly to fit in. Karen infused the story with gems of observations of young adults, probably enhanced by her dealings with her daughter and her friends.
After the success of this book, Karen wrote Hostage (2009), and my favourite, 6 (2010). Both of these novels, again aimed at the young adult readership, tell of teens in situations which seem very close to home. Hostage begins with a girl kidnapped by a young man she knows, who loses his cool in a chemist shop. Not quite ordinary but the day spent with the two in his car, seems very ordinary as they drive around Victoria in search of her father. The shift in power in the story and the idea of just who is hostage to whom is a never ending thought as Tully begins to take stock of her life and just who is important to her and why. 6 too is breath taking as the opening scene tells the reader that 6 people have been in a car which has only 5 seat belts and has crashed with one dead. The suspense through the book, trying to find out who has died, while Karen goes back and forth, writing from differing points of view is entrancing, right to the end. Both of these books are used in schools as class sets, and as part of Literature Circles, comparing them to other books on similar themes.
Not to be restrained as a fiction writer, Karen has also written a non fiction book, Burke and Wills, Explorers off the map (2010), for black dog books in their engrossing series, Our Stories. Talking about Burke and Wills can be quite daunting as so much has been said,and so many people have their own story about what happened. It is another Australian story where a failure has achieved iconic status. Karen handled all this well, producing a book which tells us in plain English what the trip was all about, who the characters were and what happened. Inviting double page spreads, the pages have small boxes of information, maps, document and photographs, all designed to be read easily by the primary school student.
If this is not all, Karen has also edited a book of short stories, Short and Scary (2010), also published by black dog books, with stories by well know and lesser known authors, alongside new authors, resulting in a successful group of short stories sure to be well used in classrooms.
Since resigning from black dog books to concentrate more on her writing, Karen has found some part time work at the Victorian Writer's Centre, where she mentors younger writers and does manuscript assessment.
For more information see her website and follow her blog .
Fran Knight
(Children's literature enthusiast and reviewer)

Waiting for later by Tina Matthews

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781921720055.
(Ages 5+) Picture book. Warmly recommended. When Nancy goes searching for someone to ply with her or read her a story, or play cards, or give her a swing or tickle her, she is rebuffed by them all. Mother and father are too busy, her brother is cooking, her aunt hanging out the clothes and grandfather is busy mowing the lawn. All tell her that they are too busy and to come back later. Later is the refrain on each page as Nancy looks for companionship. Instead she climbs a tree, finding that the leaves tell her a story and the limbs allow her to swing fro them, and the leaves tickle her as she swings. All the things she wanted from the others she is getting for herself in the tree.
The story promotes several messages with an underlying subtlety. Parents and family ignore the child to the detriment of all. Many students reading this will tell stories of how their parents have not enough time for them, and the story asks people to re-evaluate their time spent with their children. But Nancy finds she is able to fend for herself, able to fill in her time by herself, able to occupy herself without the family. This too will be a telling discussion point with students. What is there that they can do by themselves? Do they need an adult or older sibling with them? But like all good stories, the family is reunited at the end, each learning something that will enhance family life.
Each page is illustrated using a Japanese woodblock technique giving the story a grounding in the familiar, the home and garden. Shown in wonderful detail, the illustrations beg the reader to notice and talk about what they see. The New Zealand author, Tina Matthews, a passionate promoter of the Free Range Kids movement seeks to advance her cause in the best of ways, through a simple and warm hearted story of a family.
Fran Knight

Anna and the French Kiss by Stephanie Perkins

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143206262.
Recommended. Anna and the French Kiss is an excellent coming of age story for young teenagers to read. There's something in it for everyone, from comedy, to adventure but most of all to love. It is a tale that will leave you feeling light heartened and elated for ages after you've put down the book.
The story begins in America but quickly changes to France when the main character Anna is forced to live there by her over-bearing father. Despite obvious resentment her feelings soon change after she falls for Etienne St Clair, the charismatic, gorgeous boy who lives on the floor above her. Her love takes a back step when she finds out that he has a permanent girlfriend, something that won't ever change, no matter how she feels.
Throughout the book it is easy to get lost inside the world of Anna, St Clair and the culture and joy of European France. Once you start reading you won't be able to put it down until your eyes have finished reading the very last word.
Amelia Rohrlach (Student, Year 11)
Editor's note: Amelia gave this 4.5 stars out of 5

Take two by Sienna Mercer

cover image

Egmont, 2011. ISBN 978 1405256971.
Revamped! by Sienna Mercer
Egmont, 2009. ISBN 978 1405243711.
(Ages: 10+) Warmly recommended. Two new books in the series, My sister the vampire, will have readers pleased. In Revamped, the twins,Izzy and Olivia have now been together for a while, taking in the fact that one is a vampire, but finding they have much in common. But when Izzy's dad says he has decided to move to Europe and that they must move, the girls are distraught. They make up their minds to work together to change his mind.
In Take two, the girls are thrilled to find a favourite teen actor in their town and so try to get to know him. But when Izzy does some snooping around, she finds that someone on the set has a major secret.
Both books are very readable, short, fast paced and involving from the start. As with all the books in the series, they should prove very popular with upper primary readers, with the tension of keeping their secret, all through the book.
Fran Knight

The Swiss Family Robinson by Johann Wyss (retold by Martin Powell)

cover image

Graphic Revolve series. Raintree, 2011. ISBN: 978 1406 224986.
En route from Switzerland to Australia, the Robinson family is ship wrecked on a deserted island. They must discover what their new home has to offer in order to ensure their survival. As they learn about the island, they come across many unfamiliar plants and animals, some of which threaten their existence. Over time, the family grow accustomed to their new home and existence and even welcome a stranger to their midst.
Although I find this story to be quite familiar, thanks to having seen a film of the same name in my childhood, I cannot be certain as to how true it is to the original story. I found most of the text to be grammatically correct, apart from the following statement, 'It's a wild fig tree, which have probably grown here since Biblical times!' This glitch was possibly over-looked due to the limited word count and vocabulary used in this series. Certainly, the graphic novel format makes this tale accessible to even children for whom reading does not come easily. The illustrations brought forth similar feelings to those I had as a child. I would happily go and live in such a tree house as is portrayed in this book!
Jo Schenkel

Stresshead by Allayne Webster

cover image

Omnibus, 2011. ISBN 9781862918207.
(Age: 13+) Recommended. Denise (Dennie to her family and friends) is having a really tough time. With her mum acting super weird, her boyfriend being a total jerk and her Year Eleven results withheld, she doesn't even have her best friend Kat to turn to. Kat has problems of her own. How can Dennie cope with the stress?
First things first, this is not your average run-of-the-mill teenage LOL novel. It deals with some issues rarely seen in this genre, such as accidental pregnancy, depression, and even breast cancer, in a sympathetic and nice way. As well as dealing with the affect of these issues on the patrons themselves, it also took into perspective the way it affected the whole family, and how different people may react. It was a very interesting book, especially as the characters were realistic.
On of the things I loved about this book was the dialogue. It was snappy, original, and down-to-earth, which is also the main quality of this book. It was very down-to-earth and easy to relate to. Overall, it was a nice read. Great dialogue and realistic events made this one worth reading, although it was let down by a sluggish-at-times pace and boring finish.
I recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

Dork Diaries: Pop Star by Rachel Renee Russell

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2011. ISBN: 978 0 857071187.
Recommended for ages 9 and up. Nikki is a self-confessed dork! Her dad is a pest exterminator who drives a van with a giant roach on the roof and he is the reason that Nikki has won a scholarship at her new school. Her mum demands regular family times and often asks that Nikki look after her little six year old sister, Brianna. Although she has two great friends, Chloe and Zoey, they don't know the truth about Nikki and her family. When McKenzie, an externally attractive but internally nasty person from her class, sees Nikki performing a song and dance routine at the local pizza bar with Brianna, she and her 'mean girl' friends film the event and upload it to YouTube. With this as blackmail material, McKenzie tries to stop Nikki and her friends from entering a talent competition to be held at school.
This is the third book in the Dork Diaries series and contains a winning format for younger girls or slightly older disinclined female readers. Although the protagonist is aged fourteen, the overall content of the book would still be suitable for younger children. With themes of friendship, honesty, resilience, bullying, cyber bullying, first love and being prepared to stand up for what you believe in, this could possibly be used as a class text. Containing large, well spaced bold font, presented as diary entries and liberally scattered with cartoon style illustrations, this series is similar to the Louise Rennison books. It is bound to fill a niche for girls in the same way The Diary of a Wimpy Kid does for the boys.
Jo Schenkel

Pip and Posy: the little puddle by Axel Scheffler

cover image

Nosy Crow, 2011. ISBN 9780857630049.
From the illustrator of The Gruffalo comes another Pip and Posy story for the very young. This time Pip comes to Posy's place to play, and because it is too wet to play outside, they have to stay indoors. They have heaps of fun, so much that Pip forgets to go to the toilet and has an accident. But Posy brings a level head to the situation and soon the friends are happily playing again, even if Pip does look a little strange.
It's a simple story based on a very ordinary situation and that's what engages the age group. They can relate to both characters, and the illustrations are just enchanting. There's even a lesson to be learned by grown-ups in this one.
Barbara Braxton

Being here by Barry Jonsberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 978 1742373850.
Leah Cartwright lives in a nursing home and suffers from Alzheimer's disease but is aware that she is in her declining years. When Carly, a sixteen year old student interviews her for a history project, Leah recounts her childhood living on a remote farm with only her mother for company.
Leah's loneliness of childhood is reflected by her existence in the impersonal care facility. Despite her assurances to Carly that her life was not unhappy, the reader is left with a real sense of sadness for a childhood spoiled and lost.
Being a puritanical Christian with an unhealthy, dogmatic, Old Testament view of life, Leah's mother is arrogant, ignorant and completely indifferent to the views, needs and rights of others. What Leah forgives and understands as circumstantial behaviour is nothing short of child abuse in emotional and physical form, perpetrated by a domineering bully.
The suffering of Leah's childhood is moderated by the character of Adam, a boy of her own age who manifests as an imaginary friend yet develops substance, influence and presence to a degree which must be determined and rationalised by the reader.
Through Leah, Jonsberg conveys the message that we are in control of our stories. As a child, Leah was completely and utterly powerless to alter any tangible aspect of her life and she had no recourse to social authorities, friends, family or witnesses of any kind. In the midst of this powerlessness however, the child responds by re-writing her story in her own imagination, creating an escapist, alternative experience which merged and also diverged with her reality. It could be considered that this response is a symptom of mental illness which would be an understandable outcome produced by the mother's psychiatric problems.
Interviewed by Carly, Leah has the opportunity to tell her story to a person who at first appears completely disconnected in a cultural and generational sense, yet who becomes captivated by the tale. Talking together, the pair offer insights which touch each other and a meaningful relationship beyond the school project is formed.
The theme of story telling continues with Leah's desire to commit her life to tape, almost as a statement but with an attempt to positively influence Carly, thus altering and participating in her life story.
This narrative will be interpreted differently by readers as Jonsberg invites them to take some responsibility for bringing the character of Adam to life and making conclusions about his nature and purpose.
Rob Welsh

The Lake of Dreams by Kim Edwards

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN: 978 0 670 92029 7
Recommended for secondary students. Following her mother's minor accident and incapacitation, Lucy, between jobs and beginning to question her relationship and what she is doing with her life, returns to her family home for a brief stay. Arriving at the place of her childhood, Lucy is unsettled by the memories of not only her father's death but also her first youthful romance with Keegan Fall, a local man with whom she is reunited. Suffering from jet lag, and unable to sleep, Lucy explores a part of the house her mother has kept locked. Practicing the skills she learnt from her father, she picks the lock on a window seat and discovers a blanket and some old brochures about women's health and the suffragette movement. Her temporary lack of direction and inquisitive nature lead her to investigate the history of these items and, in doing so, Lucy uncovers some well hidden family secrets.
Written with flowing, descriptive text, many paragraphs in this novel lent themselves to being read aloud. Edwards has produced a well-paced and engaging novel about family history, love and relationships. The modern day story is cleverly intertwined with the historic tale and the selfishness displayed by Lucy contrasts with the selflessness of other characters from the past. This could perhaps be used by secondary students as a paired text, contrasted with Mary Lawson's Crow Lake. Both revolve around the untimely deaths of parents and the ways in which such events can affect those left behind.
Jo Schenkel

7 Souls by Barnabas Miller and Jordan Orlando

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143206255.
(Age: 14+) Mary is a wealthy and popular teenager living in New York City. On the morning of her seventeenth birthday, she wakes up expecting presents. Instead she finds herself naked and scratched in a department store, and no recollection of the night before. Soon her life starts falling apart, and she has no idea why. She thinks that someone is out to get her, but who? Isn't she the popular girl everyone loves?
7 Souls is definitely original, I can most certainly say that. The problem is, perhaps it was a bit too original. The plot is very strange and some elements are a little annoying. The main character, Mary, is very hard to relate to, and the dialogue is quite clumsy, as though the writers themselves weren't sure what the characters should be like. The pace is slow at the best of times and some of the supporting characters are much undeveloped. But this book redeems itself from those flaws with a couple of things. First, the description. This may be why the pace is a little sluggish, but anyway the description is vivid and powerful, and makes the story far more interesting than it would have been. Second, the plot. Although it is very strange, it actually makes for an intriguing idea, and a truly chilling prospect. It is quite a scary book.
This book is not for everyone. A lot of pages coupled with a very strange plot means you could either love it or hate it. Either way, it is still a fairly decent read.
Rebecca Adams (Student)