Reviews

Saving Private Sarbi by Sandra Lee

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781 74237 557 1.
(Ages 11+) Recommended. Animals in war. When this story made headlines around the world, it drew attention to the animals that are deployed during war, adding another dimension of courage and loyalty to those fighting overseas. Sarbi, a Labrador/Newfoundland cross, was trained as a EDD (Explosive Detection Dog) and after a warm up stint at Melbourne's Commonwealth Games in 2006, was flown to Afghanistan with her handler, known as D. There she sniffed out IED's (Improvised Explosive Devices) saving the lives of many people in the booby trapped rods in the Uruzgan Province.
But it was after a battle with the Taliban that Sarbi went missing, presumed killed. September 2008 saw the convoy ambushed by the Taliban, and after many Australian soldiers were wounded, and equipment lost, they made it back to their base, not having the capability of staying to search for Sarbi. With D in hospital and then sent back in Australia, reports filtered through of a black dog being seen, but there were also rumours of the dog being killed, so no story was able to be verified. When at last someone came forward as a go between from a Taliban leader asking for money for the return of the dog, people were hopeful that this was Sarbi.
This is a fascinating account of the war in Afghanistan, seen through the eyes of the animals deployed to ensure the place is safer for all concerned. The author goes to great lengths at the start of the book to explain animal behaviour and the training of the animals in the army's care. For animal enthusiasts this will be an absorbing read, and for those interested in how the animals are trained, robustly enlightening.
Other stories are given augmenting the deeds of these animals, and we hear not only of the animal deaths but also of our soldiers. The book gives a sound background to the war in Afghanistan, and the presence of our troops and their work. For students and adults alike wanting to find out more about the war in Afghanistan, this is an easily read introduction to a complex issue, and also a heart warming story of one dog's life.
Fran Knight

Darkest Mercy by Melissa Marr

cover image

(Wicked Lovely Bk. 5). HarperCollins, 2011. ISBN 9780007346158.
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. This is the final installment in the best-selling Wicked Lovely series. Within the faery courts, the evil fairy Bananach is thirsty for war, killing and provoking the other faery courts to start what she is hungry for: a colossal fight to the death. Within the Summer faery court, the queen Aislinn is preparing to fight, while worrying for her Summer king, Keenan, and her lover, Seth. Within the Winter faery court, the icy queen Donia is worried for her people, and also preparing to fight. But as Bananach grows ever more violent, will they ever survive this ordeal?
As this is the fifth book in a lengthy series (that I have not read), it was a little hard to understand at first. But this book does manage to stand on its own, and it does manage to be very good. The author has woven an intricate and fascinating world that is refreshingly original, and filled with intriguing characters. This book had several quite violent scenes, and the concept of the summer queen and court is that it is a place for passion and loving. These various scenes may not be suitable for younger readers.
This is book is easy to read, but not so easy that it becomes condescending. The best part of this book is easily the characters. Hardly is there such a wealth of differing personalities, actions and dialogue in a teenage fantasy novel.
What Melissa Marr has done for faeries is reinvent them into something new and exciting, much like Stephanie Meyer did for Twilight (although this book is much better in terms of plot, literature and characters).
I highly recommend this book/series.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

The Chimney Corner Collection by Enid Blyton

cover image

Egmont, 2011. ISBN 9781405260152.
If you are looking for a stocking filler of engaging, magical stories then this new collection of Enid Blyton classics is the perfect choice. There is a reason that Blyton has remained a favourite throughout generations - this was originally published in 1947 - and this is the ideal opportunity to introduce this generation of emerging readers to her fantasy world. There are 60 stories in the collection ranging from The Magic Walking Stick to Old Ugly the Water Grub, each full of Blyton's inimitable characters and the perfect length to read-aloud or read-alone. Even the title of the collection suggest curling up somewhere snug and just reading, particularly during those January days when the novelty of the Christmas toys has worn off or the batteries are flat.
Despite their age and the traditional black-and-white drawings, these stories remain popular. When I was in the library, I had a special shelf for Enid Blyton and despite having a sizeable collection built from scouring second-hand shops and book fairs, there were seldom any available for borrowing. The circulation stats were amazing. With 2012 being the National Year of Reading, perhaps it is timely to connect parent and child through story and celebrate these tales so familiar to many. This collection would be an ideal starting
point.
Barbara Braxton

Girls Don't Fly by Kristen Chandler

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143566588.
Girl Don't Fly, written by Kristen Chandler, follows the endearing story of a teenager stumbling her way through the realms of self-discovery. Myra, already juggling the crumbling bricks of her family fortress, has her feet fail beneath her and the world seemingly fall out of the sky when her 'prince' dumps her. As the previously steady foundation of her life deteriorates slowly under her, Myra is forced to reconsider her so-called 'doormat' approach to life in order to save herself from falling. Suddenly, like the gulls she so passionately admires, Myra has the overwhelming urge to fly . . . fly as she contends with her ex for a position on an expedition to an island . . . fly recklessly into the arms of the expedition's promoter . . . and, ultimately, fly as the strong, self-respecting woman she longs to become.
Surrounding such a well-intended, kind-hearted main character, this novel immediately draws on the emotions of readers and creates an intimate feel for the audience. Girls Don't Fly harbours a certain down-to-earth nature; all characters and events hold a sense of reality resulting in issues that are easily related to and engaged in. Chandler effectively uses clever metaphors to announce each chapter, introducing humour and charm into the story. Overall, a recommended novel, particularly for middle to late teenagers. Girls Don't Fly explores the evolution of a formerly timid and reliant teen into a thriving independent woman through hectic, dramatic and hilarious high school drama . . . a journey that will stay with me forever!
Emilia Corbo (student)

Weava the wilful witch by Tiffany Mandrake

cover image

Ill. by Martin Chatterton. Little Hare Books, 2011. ISBN 9781921714023
(Ages 7-12) Recommended. From the Little Horrors series comes the story of Weava Charm, a witch who loves causing trouble and is hoping to get her letter of acceptance into Hag's Abademy of Badness. While waiting for her letter she goes to the city to visit her big sister Merry, but to her dismay she finds Merry is now calling herself Mary, and living as a normal human! To make matters worse, Mary expects Weava to pretend to be human too, and takes away her wand and broomstick. When Weava finally gets her letter from the Abademy, it comes with a task - she must perform a 'new and original act of breathtaking badness.'  Weava is determined that her act of badness should be to convince Merry to live as a witch again, so with the help of a mischevious kit-fae, she sets about trying to trick her sister into using magic.
As with all the titles in the Little Horrors series, Weava is sure to be enjoyed by children who like a bit of mischief and humour in their stories. With likeable characters who don't always make the best of choices, students will find a refreshing change from the normal saccharine sweet fairy stories. Martin Chatterton's delightfully expressive illustrations help bring the characters to life.
Donella Reed.

Pan's whisper by Sue Lawson

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1 742032 06 1.
(Age: 13+) Pan's Whisper tells the story of Pandora, a teenage girl who can no longer live with her mother and is put into the care of a foster family. It is set in Australia and the author tells the story of Pandora's trouble settling into the new family, being accepted at school, learning to trust and the feelings of not knowing where she belongs. The story switches back and forth between present day and the memories of the past as Pandora writes to her sister, unveiling the memories from the point of view of Pandora and the point of view of her older sister who constantly struggled to protect Pandora from their mentally ill mother. It is not until Pandora finally feels she belongs that the memories of her past catch up and she realises what her sister did for her and she finally has the strength to accept her life and her past.
The author uses description and emotion to draw you in to Pandora's battle and I would recommend it for girls aged 13+, who are independent readers, to adults as it does switch back and forth between memories and while the themes are explained with care, it does tackle mental illness and abandonment and child neglect issues.
Kylie Kempster

The Pied Piper of Hamelin retold by Michael Morpurgo

cover image

Ill. by Emma Chichester Clark. Walker Books, 2011.
(Ages 7+) Recommended. Picture book. Folk tale. The cautionary tale of the Pied Piper taking the children from the town following the non payment of a debt owed him when he cleared the town of its rats is retold in this handsomely produced hard cover book published by Walker Books. The story is revisited, enlarged and modernised, given a contemporary tweek to make the moral unambiguous to the modern reader.
Beset with mounds of rubbish, children who need to beg in the streets for their supper, and families that go without, while orphaned children live in shanties on the outskirts of the town, a plague of rats causes problems, not only for the orphaned children who have to fight for the scraps from the rats but also the wealthy as they find the rats inside their houses, eating the food in the larders.
When a strangely dressed Piper comes to town, offering to rid the town of its rats, he demands only a gold coin for the work, but in doing so, the mayor refuses to pay him, and so the Piper promises that worse will happen. And it does - he plays his flute so that all the children in the town follow him to the mountains, where they disappear behind a crevice. The lame beggar following some way behind is told by the Piper to return to the town, and offer the people their children back in return for cleaning the town and making everyone equal, with enough to eat, a house to live in and a warm fire in winter. It takes the town a whole year to clean their town and provide food and shelter for all, and so the Piper leads the children back, to the relief of all.
A tale with a moral that will be discussed and talked over in many classes, not only as an old folk tale, but a story of the disparity between rich and poor, first and third worlds, literate and illiterate, educated and non educated, town and city: encouraging children to think about how this gap can be bridged.
Morpurgo's rewriting brings it up to the minute and Clark's illustrations are wonderfully evocative, showing clearly the line between the haves and have nots.
Fran Knight

Australian and world records 2012 by Jennifer Corr Morse

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781741699036.
(Age 8+) In the age of the Internet, the enduring appeal of world record books may be a mystery to some but not to librarians, teachers and parents. They know from experience that these books provide hours of browsing enjoyment to young readers. Australian world records 2012 is no exception.
Unlike The Guinness book of world records, its Australian cousin will satisfy the curiosity of those who want to identify everything of record-making proportions in their own country. Among the superlatives are the biggest, the smallest, the hottest, the most remote, the wettest, the driest, the deadliest and the most popular. Twenty-two pages devoted to sporting records will resolve any argument about who has kicked the most goals in AFL matches or which horse has won the most Melbourne Cups.
The Australian records precede a section on world records but Australia still features as the country which consumes the most ice-cream, is home to record breaking animals and has produced several high-achieving athletes. The inclusion of icons of popular culture underscore the book's principal purpose - infotainment.
The text is crafted in short sentences to appeal to younger readers and is supported by statistics, graphs and high quality photographs. The font is a little undersized but will suit most primary aged children. While the book lacks an index, the table of contents is adequate. The information has been selected to fascinate readers without resorting to the more morbid attractions offered by some other books of this kind.
Australian and world records 2012 is entertaining and informative. Readers are assured of time well spent wondering at the more curious aspects of life on earth. They may even learn something new about Australia and just a few will decide that reading can be fun after all.
Elizabeth Bor

VIII by H. M. Castor

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780 14 356728 8.
(Ages: 14+) Historical Fiction. Castor writes the story of Henry (Hal), who became arguably the most famous English monarch, Henry V111. From his beginnings as the Duke of York (a spare heir) loved and protected by his mother and shunned by his father, the handsome young prince believed he was destined for greatness.
Tall, broad-shouldered and accomplished at all aspects of courtly life: religion, poetry, music, languages, history, hunting, sport and swordsmanship, Henry was eager to be noticed and believed he had an important role to play. His father, Henry VII, doted on his older brother Arthur, and could not persuade Henry that his role was to be un-noticed, that he should be no threat to the heir to the throne.
Portents, omens and visions proved to Henry that he was to be the greatest king England had seen. He and his sons would provide England and France with a dynasty that would last through history. His belief that God had shown him the visions and given him the omens and would annoint him as King ruled the rest of his life.
He believed that the inability of his wives to provide him and England with a son was God's condemnation of his wives not himself. The two biggest ambitions of his life; to reclaim France as his rightful inheritance and to establish a stable dynasty were denied him (even though he had a son, Edward, he wasn't Henry's idea of a strong healthy heir).
Castor depicts Henry towards the end of his life as losing touch with reality as his visions became more regular, more disturbing and his reaction to them more public. This view of Henry VIII is different and interesting but glosses over many of his actions.
The book is very readable and moves at a pace which keeps the reader involved. It is an insight to aspects of the Tudor Court but tends to skip over the more bloodthirsty moments, and there were plenty of those!
Mark Knight

The sense of an ending by Julian Barnes

cover image

Jonathan Cape, 2011. ISBN 9780224094153.
The Sense of an Ending won the 2011 Booker prize for its author. The main character, Anthony, finds himself in later life forced to consider the accuracy of memory, the nature of history and the value of life itself. He remembers himself and his two friends delighting in intellectual games, the pat phrase and the glib assertions that came with senior history studies at school in the sixties. However, Adrian, the acknowledged brilliant new student, challenges their assumptions. History, he says, is the point where the 'imperfections of memory meet the inadequacies of documentation'. The three are shocked by a classmate's suicide, seemingly because his girlfriend falls pregnant. Adrian tells the others that suicide is the only true philosophical question. Some years later, after graduating with a First from Cambridge, Adrian himself commits suicide.  Was this connected to Adrian's girlfriend, Veronica, who had previously been Anthony's girlfriend for some time? Decades after this event, Anthony, who has lived an unexciting life, is divorced and living alone, is forced to remember the events of the time when Veronica's mother leaves him a sum of money and Adrian's diary. Mystified, Adrian contacts Veronica who won't hand over the diary but does give him a copy of a vitriolic letter that he wrote to Adrian about his relationship with Veronica. Anthony is appalled at his own venom, of which he has no memory, and he is still denied the documentation of the diary. He is further mystified when Veronica, without explanation, pugnaciously shows him a group of disabled people. With the help of a carer and the only scrap of diary that Veronica gives him, he eventually arrives at some understanding of what happened to Adrian many years ago, and why he made the choice that he did. Anthony, who has always seen himself as settled and peaceable, realizes that there is no room for complacency in life. The novel is about memory and responsibility, guilt and remorse. While the ending is not totally convincing the themes are powerfully explored.
Jenny Hamilton

Health edited by Helen Sykes

cover image

Future Leaders, 2011. ISBN 9780980332056.
(Age 15+) Once again Dr Helen Sykes, of the Future leaders program, has assembled contributions from experts and young writers to produce a thought-provoking book. This year's theme is global health with an underlying message of social justice. Two of the commentators - Gustav Nossal and Fiona Stanley - have high public profiles. All have impressive qualifications as well as experience in research and the education of medical practitioners. Some serve on advisory boards and raise community awareness of health issues.
Gustav Nossal's overview of major challenges is followed by articles on subjects related to three aspects of healthcare. The first is the campaign to reduce the impact of chronic and infectious diseases. The second concerns the problems common to members of specific sectors of society including children, adolescents, the elderly and people in Indigenous and rural communities. The third is the need to reassess the education of doctors, the implications of climate change and the priorities of health systems in the 21st century.
The writing of all of the contributors has an academic stamp. They present balanced arguments supported by documented evidence, an approach which enables them to provide considered and authoritative assessments of controversial issues, such as anti-vaccine activism. Some of the writers are more aware than others of the need to define medical terms and use subheadings to make complex subjects accessible to lay readers.
All but one of the younger writers, have harnessed the power of fiction to highlight the emotional cost of health issues. The results are a moving counter-balance to the carefully considered scientific arguments of the experts. A lone philosophical essay examines the role of the emotions in ethical decision-making.
Health combines the wisdom of current leaders with the remarkable intelligence and maturity of those to come. It is not always easy to read but anyone willing to make the effort will not only be rewarded with insights into some of humanity's most pressing problems but may also be convinced of the need to provide existing solutions to the millions who need them.
Elizabeth Bor

Sarindi's dragon kite by Janine M Fraser

cover image

Ill. by Elise Hurst. Angus and Robertson, 2011. ISBN 9780 7322 8776 4.
(Ages 9+) Warmly recommended. Asian themes. When Sarindi is asked what he wants for this birthday he knows immediately that the dragon kite he has seen in the village is his dream. But the date is May 27, and is the day an earthquake strikes Indonesia, destroying villages and killing thousands. Sarindi's mother is heartbroken, as their house although shaken, is relatively untouched, but she has not heard from her sister and her family in Bantuil. So Sarindi and his father set out in their becak to the town to find out what has happened. They survey the appalling damage, finding that their relatives' house has been completely demolished and Sarindi finds his cousin's doll in the wreckage. Going to a camp set up for the survivors, they find that Sarindi's cousin, Agi is in the orphan tent, she is the only one left from her family.
In a story form, the author tells a moving tale of the destruction of the earthquake which struck Indonesia recently. The view taken by Sarindi allows younger readers to see the devastation clearly, to feel the impact on one family and how it has affected them, and then the wider impact on a beloved family living closer to the eye of the storm.
It is a wholly moving and involving read, augmented by Elise Hurst's drawings, which convey the closeness of the families in the story and gives a glimpse into the lives led by Indonesian children.
Fran Knight

My Perfect Life by Dyan Sheldon

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN: 9781406336825.
Recommended. For those who were desperate to return to Dellwood High after Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen, your chance has arrived! My Perfect Life, the sequel by Dyan Sheldon, follows Lola Cep and Ella Gerald on their mission to beat Dellwood's queen bee, Carla Santini, at attaining the role of Student President. But Ella and Lola couldn't be an anymore different pair of allies. Ella Gerard has everything; her own phone, her own television, her own video and even temperature control. Her life is perfect. So it's a wonder to everyone how she can be best friends with the eccentric, outspoken and obstinate Lola Ceps.
When the girls discover Carla is running for President, after many an argument, they finally agree on doing everything they can to ensure she doesn't win the votes of their peers. And so My Perfect Life evolves, with Lola and Ella relentlessly battling against Carla to see who will win the top spot . . . with hilarious consequences! From their posters to their rallies, each girl running for president constantly attempts to better the other, providing the reader with 229 pages of amusement and entertainment as the easy-to-relate to characters embark on their journey to win!
Throughout the novel, the diversities between the two main characters arise and their friendship is challenged. However, they overcome these disputes with the help of their mutual goal, proving that opposites do attract and that friendship conquers all. The novel also explores the road to self-discovery, the importance of self-confidence, and expresses that all it takes to achieve your dreams is trying your best.
Having read this book from cover to cover without putting it down once, I found My Perfect Life to be a light, enjoyable read which stood out due to its unexpected ending!
Lucymarie Silvestri (Student)

Scaly-tailed possum and echidna by Cathy Goonack

cover image

Ill. Katruna and Marlene Goonack, Myron Goonack. Magabala Books, 2011. ISBN 089 1 9212449 19 0.
(Ages 4-7) Warmly recommended. Aboriginal People - Dreaming. This story of the scaly-tailed possum and the echidna and how each came to be, following the echidna stealing food from the possum's pandanus tree, will delight younger readers, for whom the book is a comfortable size to hold. With bright, energetic pictures and bold colours, the book will have instant appeal.
When the scaly tailed possum came down from its pandanus tree, the echidna took its opportunity to climb it and steal the nuts. When the possum returned, it fought the echidna and when the echidna fell, the thorny parts of the tree stuck into him, making him spiky too. He grabbed the tail of the possum and to this day his tail is smooth while the rest of his body is furry.
The story tells the younger readers just how these animals came to be that way, and shows the power of the Wandjina, the great spirit, in meting out appropriate punishment for wrong doings. This is a story from the Wunambul people of North West Western Australia in the Kimberley region, and this story is retold by the Goonack family. Photos at the front of the book shows the story being passed onto the younger generation, while the books is augmented by a superb map and information about the animals in the story and the writers and illustrators. For more information about Magabala's stunning range of books see the website.
Fran Knight

The Beauty of Humanity Movement by Camilla Gibb

cover image

Atlantic, 2011. ISBN 9780857891716.
Old man Hung, a Vietnamese pho maker is the centre of this complex tale from which inter-generational stories of artistic martyrdom, romance, survival and family drama radiate. Pho, (what Westerners would consider a beef broth), is to Hung's loyal customers a work of art having deep cultural significance. As a boy, Hung was sent from a country village to Hanoi in the 1930s to work with his uncle and the nation's torment at the hands of foreign powers is conveyed to the reader through his ruminations.
French Colonialism, Japanese invasion, post-war portioning, hostilities between the North and South, intervention by China, Russia and America all contribute elements to this evolutionary tale which might have been irretrievably bleak. Somehow, the irrepressible spirit of Hung, who symbolises the tenacity and stoicism of his people carries the reader through a mire of appalling suffering, Buddhist teaching, familial devotion, courage and political philosophy are the armour which protects the characters against oppression, cruelty and corruption.
Depiction of mindlessly destructive agrarian reforms which caused wholesale starvation and political machinations which were little more than bloodthirsty purges are unfortunately historically accurate and mirror the Chinese and Russian experience of extreme Socialism. This is not a wholly bleak story however. The optimism shown by the characters in the more benign political climate of Doi Moi (where trade and private ownership is allowed) is captivating and provides hope.
The presence of an American born Vietnamese woman who deals in art and who hopes to understand the fate of her politically defiant father brings about interaction with locals who are endearing for their respect, decency and wonderful humour.
The book is more than a lesson in political history. This is a deeply spiritual story, yet the reader also comes to understand the characters' celebration of simple pleasures. This is particularly evident in the constant references to food, made more noticeable by the suffering caused by starvation in earlier times.
Rob Welsh