Reviews

Below deck on the sunken wreck illustrated by Mandy Foot

cover image

Lothian, 2012. ISBN 9780 7344 1282 9
(Age: 4+) Marine life, Rhyming tale. One of a series produced by Lothian, all illustrated in Mandy Foot's distinctive style, this is a rhyming tale of a what has happened beneath the waves. Others in the series, The wheels on the bus, All set for the big wet, and so on can be found on Mandy's website.  Each is bold, distinctive and uses humour well to get across its message.
Two children dive on the wreck of the old sailing ship lodged firmly on the bottom of the ocean floor. In diving around the wreck they come across many identifiable objects, an octopus, shark, schools of fish, dolphins, starfish and so on, as well as clutter from the wreck, a wheel, treasure chest, spyglass, lamps, and a fishing net.
Small children will have some fun recognising the range of animals drawn, of locating them all, and finding the sea horse which appears on all the pages. The tale can be read aloud before using the book as a search for clues about what happened to the ship and ponder about what it might be called.
Fran Knight

Clementine Rose and the surprise visitor by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House, Australia 2012. pbk., 128pp., RRP $A12.95.
And so begins the first in a new series of books by Jacqueline Harvey, who is also the author of the Alice-Miranda series. Clementine Rose is just five years old, and gets into all sorts of situations that young girls can relate to and which make her lovable and fun. She has a pet teacup pig called Lavender, and between them, they bring new life to both Penberthy House and Lady Clarissa. But when scary Aunt Violet comes to stay with her mysterious black bag, things take an awkward turn . . .
This is a book for the newly-independent reader who is looking for a recognisable character and the support of short chapters, an easy-to-read style with a splash of humour and cute illustrations that add a richness to the story. Many young girls will see themselves in the story, either as Clementine Rose or a close friend. While this is the first in the series, others are in the pipeline and it's delightful to find an author who is prepared to let their little girl heroines be little girls, not 5-going-on-15.
You can recommend this to parents for their daughters' Christmas stockings with confidence. There's a book trailer at http://jacquelineharvey.com.au/ (scroll down) and no doubt she will have her own website in time.
Barbara Braxton

Getting over Garrett Delaney by Abby McDonald

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2012. ISBN 9780763655075.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Seventeen year old Sadie has been in love with her best friend Garrett Delaney ever since he came into her life. Together they read Proust, go to art movies and listen to 80's indie rock. However he is oblivious to her obsession and when he falls in love with another girl at a summer literary retreat, Sadie decides it is time for her to have a total detox of Garrett Delaney. With the help of a 12 step plan, her new job and friends at the cafe, including a good looking chef, Josh, Sadie embarks on a life getting over Garrett.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. I followed Sadie in all her ups and downs as she came to realise that she couldn't keep waiting forever for Garrett to notice her. I applauded as she came to grips with her feelings, cried with her through her bad moments and enjoyed reading about the friendships she made as she worked as a barista. It is a coming of age story too, as Sadie realises that she has to make her own life without Garrett and when doing this finds out just what she wants in her friends and job. She sorts through her books and finds that she wants to keep some of the literature that she and Garrett both read, but other books she discards. She tries different movies and music finding that she enjoys new things that once she and Garrett made fun of. Most importantly, she discovers the joy of making new friends.
The themes of friendship and self-perception and moving on are handled with humour and sympathy by the author. Teenage girls will empathise with Sadie as many will have had an unrequited crush or know someone who obsesses over a boy who doesn't notice them at all. Readers who enjoyed Lola and the boy next door by Stephanie Perkins and books by Sarah Dessen should enjoy reading about the tribulations and fun that Sadie has while learning about herself and growing up.
Pat Pledger

There's a monster under my bed who farts by Tim Miller and Matt Stanton

cover image

ABC Books, 2012. ISBN 978 0 7333 3125 1.
(Age: 6+) Picture book. Body parts. Humour. The monster in this house farts at the most inappropriate times. He farts under the bed, he makes enormous smells in the toilet, his belly rumbles so badly that he blocks out the television, in the car, everyone is overcome, in the supermarket, people avoid the family because of the smells emanating from one of its members. The monster is able to fill the balloons for the birthday party, but when a fart blows out the candles on the cake, he is evicted. And so on it goes, the young boy complaining about the monster who farts better than his Dad, or who farts under the kitchen bench or in the bath, but we must turn to the last page to work out just who this monster is.
The wide eyed characters in this funny story will grab the attention of the book's readers, laughing along as they begin to realise just who the monster is, recognising situations at home and sometimes in the classroom. The bold illustrations reflect the story well. Readers will laugh at the faces made by all concerned and the contrasting style of illustration with the images set against a one colour background will entreat the readers, inviting them to look more closely at the images of the boy and his family.
This book would be a wonderful adjunct to lessons about body parts and their uses, as well as a cautionary tale to discuss when the obvious happens either at home or in the classroom.
Fran Knight

Marty's Nut-Free Party by Katrina Roe

cover image

Wombat Books, 2012. ISBN: 9781921633362.
Recommended for children aged 3 and above. Party animal, Marty the Monkey, loved nothing more than going to parties. At each he'd arrive early and leave late. His favourite treat at every party was the big bowl of nuts that always seemed to be present. Unfortunately for Marty, whenever he ate peanuts, he would get sick . . . so sick, in fact that he ended up in hospital. When the Doctor told him he was allergic to peanuts, Marty thought the Doctor was just being mean. Despite his promises to his mum, when Marty went to Emma's party he decided his mum would never find out if he ate just one peanut. Of course, the naughty little monkey again woke up to find himself in hospital. After being banned from attending any more parties and missing several, Marty finally convinced his mum to let him go to Gemma's birthday party. Although he did the right things and ate the food his mum had packed for him, he ate a piece of cake. Even the trace of nuts Marty must have eaten saw him again return to hospital. When his mother finally throws Marty his very own nut-free birthday party, his friends decide that there really is no party without Marty and all of their parties in future could be nut-free to ensure that he can attend.
Although I found this book to be somewhat didactic, perhaps for young children it would appear to be less so. The illustrations are bright, stylised and simple and certainly give the story a lot of appeal. Certainly, it revolves around an important issue and, with so many children in schools suffering from various allergies, would be an asset to any classroom or library. Teachers would undoubtedly be grateful for such a simple tale to use as a starting point for discussion with Junior Primary classes and it should fit into a health program with ease.
Jo Schenkel

The emu that laid the golden egg by Yvonne Morrison

cover image

Ill. by Heath McKenzie. Little Hare, 2012. hbk., RRP $A24.95. ISBN 9781921894008.
'A long time ago, amid hills dry and brown
A flock of wild emus moved into town
They were hoping to find something wholesome to eat
So they set up their base at the end of Main Street . . .'

Because of the drought, these emus weren't fussy so they tried everything that looked like food, even cans of soft drink carelessly thrown away. But Emma decided she wanted a big, fat juicy, black beetle and when it escaped her snapping beak she set off on its tail and trail. The beetle escapes but Emma found something else instead . . . some kernels of corn in a creek.

'It was strange-looking corn, oddly heavy and bright
And before long her stomach no longer felt right'.
The rest of this hilarious story is about what happens to Emma, creating a uniquely Australian version of Aesop's classic The Goose that laid the Golden Egg. Poor Emma! She falls victim to Nasty Ned and Pongo Pete who decide rather than stealing a golden egg from the nest every day, it would be much easier to kidnap the bird. And to use that time-honoured cliche, you'll have to read the story to find out what happens. But it is a tale that has to be told. Miss 6 and I loved it!!
Yvonne Morrison and Heath McKenzie have teamed up previously to write other Australian parodies of legendary tales such as The Cocky who Cried Dingo, and Town Possum, Outback Possum and their magic and chemistry just keep getting better. This is my favourite so far. I love the use of the word 'flummoxed' and the other superb vocabulary that has been woven into the rhyme - just fabulous for extending young minds, and their own writing. How much richer and engaging is 'The pair hoisted Emma on top of their nag' than 'They lifted Emma onto their horse'? Perfect picture books are those where the text and illustrations enhance each other into a seamless whole, and the Morrison-McKenzie combo achieves this brilliantly.
On the surface, it is just a rollicking good yarn but there are so many themes that could be explored such as the impact of drought on our native creatures; littering and unexpected consequences (and this could be compared with sea creatures swallowing plastic or the bears scavenging rubbish bins in Canada); greed and honesty - the list goes on. Even though its primary audience is younger children, this is definitely a picture book for older students as well as they can compare the original to the parody and all the literary avenues that that opens up. But, better still, have the students put their Nasty Ned and Pongo Pete hats on to devise a plan to kidnap an emu! Think of the creative and imaginative thinking such a task would produce.
This books fits into the Australian National Curriculum on so many levels, it's a must-have. (And for those of you with little people, it would be just perfect for the toe of the Christmas stocking!)
Barbara Braxton

Good night sleep tight by Mem Fox

cover image

Ill. by Judy Horaeck. Scholastic Australia 2012. ISBN: 978174283579.
(Age 3-6) Recommended. Another wonderful offering from the creative hive that is Mem Fox and Judy Horaeck, very much in the illustrative style of Where is the Green Sheep?. According to Fox, this book is a reproduction of something she produced in 1988, based on some information she had heard, that children who come to school knowing 6 Nursery Rhymes are usually in the top reading group by age 8 - so she wrote a book weaving in 7, factoring in one extra, for good luck.
The book features two young ones, Bonnie and Ben, and their male babysitter, Skinny Doug. This was so refreshing to see, all too often, aside from the token 'Dads are AWESOME' style books, much of the picture book world of young children is animals, children and mothers. Having a male care giver was a refreshing change - especially to the young test audience I read this with, who very much enjoys having male carers, both at home and in out of school hours care.
The structure of the book is simple - Skinny Doug spouts a series of rhymes at bedtime for Bonnie and Ben, who greet each offering with 'We love it! We love it!' 'How does it go? Will you say it again?', to which Skinny Doug responds 'Some other time - but I'll tell you another I heard from my mother.'
This is a book which is ideal for those aged 3 - 6, and would be a valuable addition to any home or school library.
Freya Lucas

Flying Kites: Friendly Street Poets 36 edited by Judy Dally and Louise McKenna

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2012. ISBN 9781743051009.
Having just finished this collection of poems I have become acutely aware of one thing; I should read more poetry. Our 'modern' lifestyle seems to mean that we have far too many competing demands and far too little time. My reading time is divided roughly into three equal parts; Adult Fiction, Young Adult Fiction and Adult Non-Fiction. Where is the time for poetry you ask? I do read the odd collection of a trusted favourite but nowhere near enough.
This 36th anthology from the Friendly Street Collective reminds me why people write poetry and why we should read it. I can't pretend to have loved every poem in the collection but the standard was uniformly good and there were some seriously fine poems that I re-read more than once. The beauty of any anthology is that you have lots of styles and subject matter to choose from and here is no exception. Standout poems for me were John Pfitzner's Pointless, Sharon Kernot's Dear Publisher, and both efforts from Mike Hopkins, The Adelaide Taxi Driver's Prayer and my personal favourite, Last of the Cat Poems.
Stephen Bull

Fashion notebook by Julia Stanton

cover image

A and C Black, London, 2012. 128 p.
(Age: 12-16) This English publication describes itself as a personal style companion. It aims to inspire teenage girls to create their own fashion style. It should help young fashionistas to plan and create their own wardrobe.
There is a lot of room in this notebook for personal notes, sketches, photos, cut-outs, designs and the rating of current trends eg tribal or clashing prints. You can learn how to draw silhouettes and then create fashionable items to outfit them. You can learn how to make mood boards, and learn about colour and colour wheels. As well as fabric design there is the opportunity to design fashion accessories - shoes, hats, bags, make-up and nails.
Colour is used extensively throughout this publication with colour illustrations and coloured borders on the pages. This is an attractive, quality publication in a sturdy, spiral bound format.
Also included are an Introduction, Contents and Credits as well as Apps. for iPhone, iPad, Android and BlackBerry devices. There are quotes by fashion industry identities eg fashion designer Gianni Versace and fashion journalist Diana Vreeland
This book is suitable for girls 12 -16 years. One Year 8 girl, to whom I spoke, especially likes the patterns and the apps., and thinks that this book would make a great Christmas gift. Its publication late in 2012 means that it is just in time for the Christmas market.
As this is essentially a notebook for one individual to use, if it were purchased for a school library, it would be best housed in a Reference collection. One word of caution, however . . . a focus on teenage fashion means that this book will have a short life as fashions change and evolve.
Margaret Strickland

Penguin and Pinecone by Salina Yoon

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781 4088 2905 9.
(Ages 3+) Picture book. Friendship. Flagging the reason behind writing the book with its sub title, A friendship story, this unusual tale about a penguin finding a pinecone in the snow will intrigue younger readers. Pinecone becomes the penguin's friend and they do everything together, but Penguin is aware that Pinecone is not in his correct habitat, despite having made him a nice warm scarf. He is told that it is too cold for Pinecone, and so he makes preparations to take Pinecone back to his own home. This he does, leaving a trail of rocks in a heart shape around the place that he leaves Pinecone. Sometime later, Penguin returns to visit Pinecone and sees that he has grown into a big strong tree and the two remember each other and recall their friendship. But Penguin cannot stay there and so returns.
The overstated message is one to warm the hearts of the readers, and would be a simple text to initiate discussions in the classroom about friendship and loyalty, about the selflessness of love and the pleasure that it can bring.
Fran Knight

Black Spring by Alison Croggon

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921977480.
Using Wuthering Heights as a template, Croggon has mixed fantasy with this retelling of Bronte's Gothic classic. The structure is the same as in the original; the narrator is well developed as the housekeeper who grew up with the Cathy and Heathcliff characters, Lina, and Damek. She tells their story to the convalescing outsider from whose perspective the story unfolds. Technically the structure is well managed but the addition of witches (Lina is one) and a most disturbing system of vendetta seemed a distraction and the constraint of sticking to the original meant that these elements were not well integrated. Readers of Croggin's Pellinor series will read and enjoy this book, especially those who have not read Wuthering Heights, and it could be a useful opportunity for senior students to use it as a paired text to help them analyse the original.
Sue Speck

Today we have no plans by Jane Godwin

cover image

Ill. by Anna Walker. Viking, 2012. ISBN: 9780670075201.
Highly recommended for younger children. The busy life of a young girl and her family is broken down, day by day. With calendars, lists, school notices, homework and invitations pictured on the front end papers, any parent with young children will identify with the activities and responsibilities of getting everything organised to keep on top of the daily routine. Each day at school brings a new activity for the girl, with Saturday no exception. With swimming lessons, orchestra, after school care, library visits, shopping and weekend sport, the girl becomes more and more tired as the week progresses. When Sunday arrives, the family loves nothing more than to announce that they have 'no plans'. Finally each member of the family has time to rest, relax, play, create and appreciate nature and the small things in life, as well as simply enjoying one another's company before their return to rushing and routine.
The wonderful pairing of Jane Godwin and Anna Walker is truly a match made in heaven. Godwin's rhyming, engaging text is sure to delight adults and children alike as it tells the story of a busy week. Walker's free flowing, sketches and water-colour paintings complement the story perfectly. The differences in the end papers at the beginning contrast brilliantly to those at the end as the conclusion of the book shows no lists, alarm clocks or the like but instead depict the fruits of a day spent on creative pursuits and relaxation. This could be used in Junior Primary classrooms to discuss family activities, sequencing, days of the week, appreciation of nature and the value of time spent dreaming. A truly beautiful book!
Jo Schenkel

Speechless by Hannah Harrington

cover image

Harlequin Teen Australia, 2012. ISBN: 9781921796579.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. I absolutely loved Harrington's first novel, Saving June, so I was excited to see this one. I am not sure why we get it at least 6 months before the US market, but for whatever reason, thank you! Speechless is almost the perfect teen contemporary novel, and will be very popular amongst 15 and 16 year old girls.
Chelsea is living a precarious life. Her deepest fear is that her BFF, Kristen, popular cheerleader material, will suddenly realise how boring Chelsea is and dump her for more wealthy, more good looking, more daring girls. So Chelsea plays dangerous games, gossiping, judging, and criticising her peers to entertain Kristen in a desperate attempt to keep her friendship. Readers know this a slippery slope and it's inevitable she will make a complete fool of herself, but even when it happens, it's shocking and horrible.
The consequences are monumental and the one thing Chelsea dreaded happens: Kristen dumps her completely and publicly, and Chelsea's life at school does the predictable thing: dives from winner to loser, popular to shunned, heckler to heckled. If I had one criticism of the book, it was the way other students treated Chelsea. The sheer amount of bullying she deals with is horrifying, and hopefully unrealistic. Maybe kids do suffer as much as Chelsea does, but I sure hope not.
Chelsea chooses a life of deliberate silence. Not trusting herself to speak, she stops altogether, and the story shows how the people around her react to this provocative behaviour. Many adults don't cope, so imagine the younger crowd. Needless to say, the plot now becomes fairly standard teenage fare: Chelsea bonds with new quirky people, finds a part-time job, and learns to live with the mistake she has made. Her honesty and resilience in dealing with her bad behaviour, and the treatment she receives afterwards, allow great character development. Harrington's writing is full of humour and affection.
This novel is not long or drawn out; Harrington keeps it tight and strong. The love-interest is a terrific character, honest and loyal. The new best friend has her own story, and Chelsea's family aren't left on the (unrealistic) sidelines. Themes include bullying, peer pressure, romance, family relationships, coming-of-age, friendship, and identity.
Trisha Buckley

Superworm by Julia Donaldson

cover image

Ill. by Axel Scheffler. Alison Green, 2012. ISBN 9781407132044.
(Ages: 4-8) From the author illustrator team that bought you such masterpieces as StickMan and The Gruffalo comes Superworm - a rollicking tale about a worm who is flexible, helpful and loved by all. Much like Donaldson's other work, the hero of the tale finds himself in some strife, which he overcomes, returning again to the place where he is loved and adored.
This is one of the strongest selling points of the book - Donaldson's work quickly becomes familiar to children - they know there will be adversity, and sometimes the situations the main characters find themselves in can be quite precarious indeed - but that this will be overcome, and things will return to their natural state of equilibrium soon enough.
Superworm is everything a hero should be - he's super long, super strong, and keen to lend a hand. He prevents baby toad from being squashed, becomes a skipping rope for bees, saves beetle from drowning, but then . . . disaster strikes, in the form of a crow, an evil wizard, and some treasure hunting.
The illustrations are bright and vibrant, with the 'baddies' having suitably shifty eyes, and the 'goodies' being drawn with aplomb.
This is a delightful book, and would be a great addition to any collection, for ages 4-8.
Freya Lucas

That's what I'd do by Jewel

cover image

Ill. Amy June Bates. Simon and Schuster, 2012. Hardback. ISBN: 9781442458130.
This is a beautifully illustrated piece, with the watercolor, gouache, pencil and pastels illustrations lifting the rhyme, which limps along as a story, not flowing very well, but comes into its own as a song.
Mother and baby are pictured in beautiful environments, both indoor and outdoor, with whimsical additions such as hearts, flowers and animals. There are many butterflies to count within the pages, which adds a nice touch, an extra visual focus for the child being read to.
Described by the author as a devotional letter, the book certainly reads that way, at times even a little over the top. I felt that there were opportunities within the illustrations to be more inclusive of diverse parenting practices - for example the mother was pictured feeding the baby with a bottle - however there can be no doubt of the love of the mother for her child in these illustrations.
The content of the story itself is simple and time honoured - if I was a painter, a carpenter, a rabbit, this is what I would do. The mother in the story is clearly besotted with her child, and their relationship which is played out on the pages is a very special one.
I would recommend this book for libraries frequented by new parents of all kinds - there is much about this book which would appeal to mothers in the first flush of baby love.
Freya Lucas