Reviews

Mary MacKillop: Australia's first saint by Gabiann Marin

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2012. ISBN 9781921928192.
(Age: 7+) In 1866, Mary MacKillop and Father Woods opened a school in Penola. At the time, their determination to provide an education for all children, regardless of family income, was remarkable. The first colonial governments to introduce free, compulsory schooling did so six years later and the last followed suit in 1893.
The life of the founder of the Josephite movement is told in Mary MacKillop: Australia's first saint. Gabiann Marin has revealed how Mary MacKillop's attitudes were shaped by her family and experiences and how her practical, if sometimes unconventional, thinking enabled her to create a new religious order and establish schools and other institutions in Australia and New Zealand. Mary MacKillops' eventful life and her dedication to both religion and education, make her a challenging subject for a brief biography. The author has succeeded in charting the development of both aspects of this dynamic educator's life and achievements, as well as conveying her ability to inspire others and her resolve when facing criticism from some church and government authorities.
The text is written in short sentences, with minimum elaboration, and a moderately large font. Chapter headings, as well as a timeline at the end of the book, guide readers through the stages of Mary McKillop's life. The hand-painted illustrations by Angela Grzegrolka are sympathetic and in keeping with the publishing style of other titles in the Aussie heroes series. Readers unfamiliar with Catholicism may be unclear about the meaning of some of the terms used, while the use of words now considered to be inappropriate when used in relation to Indigenous people, mars an otherwise readable and informative story.
Gabiann Marin's conclusion that Mary MacKillop's legacy is significant to all Australians is certainly justified by the life story of a woman whose initiative, conviction and commitment to equity, helped to promote the belief that education is a right not a privilege.
Elizabeth Bor

This is me: The autobiography by Ian Thorpe

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2012. ISBN 978 1 4711 0122 9.
Highly recommended. This story gives a unique insight into the world of competitive swimming at the very highest level. As the story unfolds we can follow Ian in his return to competitive swimming after his early retirement. We see the incredible amount of hard work and dedication involved in sport at the highest level. Sacrifices are made and the wonder is not why he retired so early, but how he lasted so long.
The chapters follow the time in the lead up to the Olympic trials and the attempt to gain a place in the team. I especially liked the way he describes his relationship with the water and how that can tell him what he needs to do with his stroke and how elite swimmers can become quite territorial about their water.
Interwoven is the story of a remarkable young man who had fame thrust upon him and had to endure an intrusive press whilst going through everything that any teenager has to go through whilst fighting off depression which at that stage had not been diagnosed.
What emerges is a complex young man who has achieved much, his charitable work and empathy with indigenous Australians is just one example. You cannot help but think that he is entitled to be left alone to get on with his swimming and other works and that there is still much to come.
David Rayner

One gorilla: A counting book by Anthony Browne

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781406325799.
(Age: Pre-School - 6) Highly recommended.  Picture book. Diversity. Former Children's Laureate and author of timeless classics like Willy the wimp and Gorilla, Anthony Browne has once again come up with a stunning book that children will love. Starting off with one gorilla, two orang-utangs and three chimpanzees, Browne counts on through the primate family finishing his counting with 10 lemurs. But that is not enough for him. He extends this beautiful book with the words: 'All Primates. All one family. All my family...' which are illustrated with a self-portrait and in a stunning conclusion, with the words, 'And yours', he has drawn a huge range of faces, of many colours and cultural diversity.
Readers new to Browne's work are in for a treat and those who are familiar with Browne's artistic talent will revel in the beautiful portrayal of expressions on the primates' faces. No two have similar facial expressions, some look happy, some are old and wrinkled, some shy but all are done in exquisite detail, with attention given in particular to whiskers, which I personally found fascinating!
But this is more than just a counting book. Children and adults will have a wonderful time looking at each page and comparing the difference in the animals' faces. There is much to discuss about the primate family and about similarities and differences in each family group, especially our own.
My grand daughter, aged 3, loves Anthony Browne so much that she informed me on Skype that she didn't have some of Anthony Browne's books. In the back of one of her books were the cover illustrations of Anthony Browne's books and she showed me which ones she was missing. I am the Book Grandma, so of course I purchased them for her. I can't wait for her to see this very special book. In the classroom, astute teachers could have a lot of fun looking at Browne's wonderful pictures and extending children's thoughts about the diversity of the people who live in the world.
Pat Pledger

1001 Aussie crack-ups from Camp Quality

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2012. ISBN9781742833194.
(Age: Primary) Recommended for children who like jokes. There are 100's of jokes contained in this volume. They have come from Australian children, celebrities and the public and would keep entertained even those children who like to tell jokes over and over again. Perhaps they would give some variety to the long suffering adult who has to listen to the same joke repeatedly.
Here is a sample of one of the jokes and it will give you an idea of the fun that will be had with this book:
Where did the Aussie general keep his armies? In his sleevies (Sebastian Terry, 100 Things charity campaigner).
A Contents page organises the book into different topics. Examples are: It's an emergency (Which Australian reptile is always sick? A crookodile.); Goody geography (Which country has the most microbes? Germ-any.)
The purchase of this book will support kids with cancer. Camp Quality is the children's family cancer charity that 'believes in building optimism and resilience in the lives of children and families.' This includes a belief that laughter is the best medicine. Children also have the opportunity to send in a joke to Camp Quality and it could be published in the next year's joke book.
This would be an ideal gift for children with a sense of humour and the source of many chortles in a library.
Pat Pledger

I can jump puddles by Alan Marshall

cover image

Penguin/Viking, 2012 (c1955). ISBN: 9780670076840.
Highly recommended. Alan Marshall's partially autobiographical novel I Can Jump Puddles is a wonderful tale of hardship and hope in the Australian outback; this is an emotional story guaranteed to move the reader. This novel provides the reader with a highly detailed picture of what it was like growing up in early twentieth century Australia. Set in the first person Alan recounts the suffering he endured and the doubtless commitment he showed when trying to be like the other boys.
Alan is the unfortunate sufferer of Infantile Paralysis, an incurable ailment which can cause various degrees of paralysis; however he is lucky enough that the paralysis is contained to his legs. Legs which he is told will never allow him to run races or break in horses like his father. A boy of the bush, Alan doesn't allow his condition to hold him back and he persists in walking and swimming and riding. He refuses to give up on his dreams and shows extraordinary strength of character in this superb novel about never giving up hope.
I would highly recommend this novel for people of all ages as it is a perfect representation of true events and of rural living at the time. While I cannot say that Alan Marshall's writing is unparalleled I cannot stress enough how satisfying and life affirming a read this is.
Kayla Gaskell (Student, Year 11)

I made lattes for a love god by Wendy Harmer

cover image

Allen and Unwin, Sydney, 2012. ISBN 9781742379913
(Age 14+) This is the second YA novel by Wendy Harmer and again follows the ups and downs in the life of teenager, Elly Pickering. So it is a sequel of sorts and continues the humorous tone of I Lost my Mobile at the Mall.
However, Harmer's first novel cleverly shone a spotlight on the use and abuse of social media by the teens in her novel. This added a unique touch to a story which was essentially about friendship woes and broken hearts. Although I Made Lattes for a Love God focuses on the cult of celebrity, this in itself is less original and the plot unfolds in a rather predictable pattern: Elly and her sister must learn some humiliating lessons about friendship and loyalty before the world is restored to normality. Furthermore, the drama queen lurking in Elly was well balanced in the earlier novel by her sharp intelligence. Unfortunately, in Harmer's new novel there is far too much drama queen. Indeed, how two such intelligent girls as Elly (English award winner) and her sister Tilly (Chemistry whizz) could be so lacking in smarts when it comes to Jake Blake, teen mega-star and mega-celeb, may push the bounds of credibility even as readers chuckle in bemusement.
Elly's parents are well-drawn, in fact this novel could well be an ode to mothers, for it is Mrs Pickering who is able to steady the ship both professionally and personally, thus saving some characters' careers and her own daughters' further embarrassment. And Grandma's words of wisdom again help Elly to resolve some of the conflicts in her life, especially when it comes to handling secrets.
Harmer handles dialogue well and knows how to write a funny line. So, for teen girls looking for a light read, this novel is sure to please, especially if it is their first taste of Wendy Harmer and Elly Pickering. However, lovers of I Lost my Mobile at the Mall may feel a little let down by this continuation of Elly's life as bright, savvy Elly can only be seen in the last few pages.
Deborah Marshall

The boy who howled by Timothy Power

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781599908526.
(Age 8-12) Recommended. Callum lives in the Wild with his family, a pack of North American Gray Wolves. To Mom he is a 'furless mascot', Dad sees him as dinner and his Aunt Trudy, Uncle Rick and Grandpa tolerate him because Mom, as Alpha female, protects him.
Whilst he has vague recollections of a human family, having been adopted by Mom who found him abandoned in a clearing when he was three, Callum crawls along on hands and knees with the pack, trying desperately to fit in, and avoid being eaten.  
As the story begins Callum is about to be left at the edge of the wood to fend for himself, having been supplied with clothes from a school bag Mom stole earlier from a camp site in the woods.
This begins Callum's education into the ways of the human world. Not only does he need to relearn how to communicate, though he seems to have a remarkably good memory of language from his pre wolf pack days, he needs to learn to fit into the social structure of the human world.
As luck would have it Callum, or Clam as he calls himself, is wearing the uniform of the Hargrove Academy for the Gifted Bright and Perceptive Child and consequently begins school which brings a new set of problems. One day with a class of his peers is more complicated than living in the wolf pack.
He meets a range of quirky and interesting characters, Tom, Dick and Harry, the homeless men and Buzz Optigon, world famous wildlife wrangler, amongst them who help him develop his social skills.
Recommended for 8-12 year olds this book will appeal to boys who may identify with Callum's struggle to understand where he fits and how to behave. Identifying different characters such as Billy the bully, as an Alpha male but discovering his behaviour is not in keeping with a leader, is a lesson for both Callum and the reader. Whilst the family reunion and ending seem a little subdued and I was disappointed we didn't meet the wolf pack again, the author's use of humour throughout will appeal to even the reluctant reader
Sue Keane

The Wolf Princess by Cathy Constable

cover image

Publisher: Chicken House. ISBN: 9781908435347.
(Ages: 12+) 4 stars. Magical, inspiring and it kept me on the edge of my seat. This book is about a girl, Sophie, who's an orphan. But when she's chosen to go on a trip to Russia she finds more than she bargained for . . . I recommend that you read the book to find out what.
Although the book is predictable, it's still wonderful. I also learnt a bit about Russian culture and that is what all books should be like: you should be able to take a little away with you after reading it. Do read this lovely book as its magical and worth it!
Lilly S.(Student)

Tanglewood by Margaret Wild

cover image

Ill. by Vivienne Goodman. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 978
Highly recommended. Picture book. Environment. Friendship. I found myself gulping back tears from page one as we hear of a tree, Tanglewood, alone on an island in the middle of nowhere. Dolphins swim by, debris washes up on the beach, clouds pass overhead, but Tanglewood remains all alone.
Vivienne Goodman's intense and meticulous illustrations stir the imagination from the start as we see shells, leaves, bones on the beach, the roots of the tree clinging to its solitary existence, seals swimming by, and large sweeps of spectacular blue sky overhead.
From the double page panoramas of the island and the clouds and then the stormy seas, we turn the page, to find quietness after the storm, a rainbow has appeared, and into the tree, a seagull has fallen.
Tanglewood shelters the gull as it rests after the melee, hoping it will stay, but it cannot. It needs to return to its family a concept it must explain to the tree. It belongs to the sky and its companions, but in leaving promises to return.
Tanglewood keeps itself ready for the gull's return, and we see the breadth of the seasons come and go as Goodman renders a series of illustrations clustered together like pages in a photograph album, reinforcing the image of time passing.
The words and images in this incredible book overwhelm the senses as the loneliness of the tree is portrayed. Readers and listeners alike will feel joy at the last few pages as the tree's loneliness is resolved and the gulls do something for the tree. The warmth of giving, of family, of togetherness is redolent throughout, making this book a wonderful adjunct to a class's discussions about family. For older students discussions around technique of both author and illustrator would do no better than having this book as their guide. But for anyone wanting a quiet few moments of reflection then this book will reward its readers over and over again.
And what a pleasure to see Vivienne Goodman's distinctive, intelligent illustrations again.
Fran Knight

Butcher Paper, Texta, Blackboard and Chalk by Ruby Hunter and Archie Roach

cover image

One Day Hill, Distributed by Scholastic, 2012. ISBN: 9780980794847.
Highly recommended for all ages. Beginning with Archie Roach's wonderful foreword, filled with love and respect and written as a dedication to his long term partner, Ruby Hunter, this book is an inspiration. On first glance, because the illustrations are filled with vibrant colours and Ruby's naive style, some may fail to be immediately engaged. Personally, I found them to be quite enchanting and can imagine children trying to re-create her style in their own work. Likewise, the songs appeared to be simplistic and repetitive and not certain to engage every reader/listener immediately. When seen as a whole, however, the package is truly one I found to be impressive and heart-warming. The songs, written by the children of the Cape York Peninsula, together with Ruby and Archie, bring the countryside and culture of the children alive, thereby fulfilling Ruby's dream.
This project was obviously a long time in the making and, sadly, Ruby didn't live to see it to its completion. The accompanying CD is simple and joyous but it is the DVD which truly shows her amazing personality and passion for both the task and the children with whom she created the songs. Archie cites her childlike naivete and freedom in relating to the children and this is especially obvious in the footage which appears. I have a whole new appreciation for her work and approach to the children through having seen these excerpts. Already, I have used the book as a focus while working with several of my classes and have been proud of the songs/poems they created about their location too. I think this would be a wonderful addition to any classroom or school library.
Jo Schenkel

On two feet and wings by Abbas Kazerooni

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. 258 pgs., p/b. ISBN: 9781743311059.
(Age: Suitable for upper primary - lower secondary) Highly recommended. On two feet and wings is based on real events that happened to the author Abbas when he was 9 years old. This is Abbas' story as he remembers it. The story starts in Tehran in the 1980's during the Iran-Iraq war where Abbas lives with his mother, father and grandmother. With Iran reducing the Army recruitment age to 8, Abbas' father decides he must get his son out of Iran. Abbas will leave for Turkey with his mother to apply for a British visa. Abbas' father is unable to travel with them because his passport was confiscated by the new rulers of Iran. It is at the airport that Abbas' mother is told she can't leave Iran. Abbas is forced to flee the country by himself, leaving his parents and everything he loves behind. At the age of 9, Abbas is alone and terrified in the strange and frightening city of Istanbul. He doesn't speak the language, has to fend for himself, find his way around, apply for a British visa and guard against being taken advantage of.
This is a gripping and page turning debut novel by Abbas Kazerooni, now a lawyer in California. It is an inspiring and moving true story, told from a child's point of view. The courage shown by 9 year old Abbas is inspiring and On two feet and wings is a book that can be enjoyed as much by 12-14 year olds as by adults.
Michelle Thomson

Coming home by Sharon McGuinness

cover image

Ill. by Shannon Melville. Wombat Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921633775.
(Ages: 5-9) Highly recommended. Gemma cannot understand why her father seems to be so sad. She watches him as he sits alone in his garden and sees how he can laugh with his friends when they come around, but then how he goes into a silent mood when they leave. She dances and talks and laughs but he doesn't seem to listen. Then one day he feels the sun on his face and he starts to smile.
Very few picture books look at the topic of depression, which, from the notes at the back of this book, one in five people will suffer from in their lifetime. Sharon McGuinness has tackled this tough topic with sensitivity and hope, vividly portraying how Gemma feels when her father is depressed. Nothing that Gemma does to try and lift her father's mood works. Children who are living with someone who suffers from depression will be able to identify with Gemma as she tries her best to understand the greyness that surrounds her father. The ideas contained in this book will assist children to gain an insight into the illness of depression, allowing them to know that it is not their fault. Adults who suffer from depression themselves will better understand the effects that it has on family members.
The illustrations by Shannon Melville complement the text and add to the understanding of the nature of the illness. Starting with blacks and greys the pictures are coloured to show the depth of the illness but by the end of the book, the illustrations are in warm yellows and blues demonstrating the light that has come back into Gemma's father and her life.
Information is given at the back of the book about the importance of seeking help and support if someone the reader knows seems depressed and links are given to various organisations that can help. Author royalties will go The Black Dog Institute, which has endorsed the book.
This is an invaluable book for a library to have because it would be of immense help to many children who know or who are living with a person with depression.
Pat Pledger

Maddy West and the Tongue Taker by Brian Falkner

cover image

Ill. by Donovan Bixley. Walker Books Australia; 2012. ISBN 978192197767.
Know any 8+ readers interested in witches, magic and adventure? The then this is the book to keep them reading. With a ninja, a monkey, a Bulgarian wrestler and a feisty girl with an amazing talent added to the character list they will be looking for more books by Brian Falkner.
Maddy's Mum took her to the doctor when she started speaking Japanese to get her 'fixed'. The doctor found out that she could speak other languages too and really didn't think she needed fixing, indeed he thought she was extraordinary.
After her mother arranges for her to appear on television, where she demonstrates her ability with languages, strange things begin to happen to Maddy. She meets an old man on the train who warns her about dark magic and then a Professor Coateloch calls and convinces Maddy's parents to let her travel with her to Bulgaria to help translate some ancient scrolls. Whilst Maddy is quite excited about the journey she soon discovers that there is more to Professor Coateloch and the ancient scrolls.
Kidnapping, magic spells of great power, an exciting trip up the mountain and a heroic rescue, make for heart stopping conclusion to the story.
The friendship between Kazuki and Maddy is a feature of the story as is the importance of communication, especially as one of the spells, the 'Tongue Taker' of the title, takes away the ability to communicate, a person's language. Maddy's ability to speak and read any language will reaffirm in some children the benefits of being multilingual.
The detailed illustrations by Donovan Bixley add to the drama of the situation. I particularly love the picture of Maddy and Kazuki driving as they are speeding down the mountain.
Sue Keane

Breathe by Sarah Crossan

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781408827192.
Recommended. Sarah Crossan has imagined the unthinkable - a treeless, oxygen deprived world where the Ministry rules and the people are divided into Premiums and Auxiliaries.
Quinn, as a Premium, has it all, especially oxygen.He and his family can breathe easily. However, the Auxiliaries, like Bea and her family, and Alina, must pay for every breath that they take and it is hard to work and earn when there is never enough energy giving oxygen.
Bea has four options: to be chosen for the Ministry's Leadership Program where she will gain Premium status; remain an Auxiliary and spend a life struggling to breathe; be banished to, or escape to the Outlands where she will most certainly die without the life giving canisters of oxygen. Alina has no choices.
Part 1 of the series, Breathe, presents the reader with a realistic picture of a destroyed and controlled world where every breath is literally accounted for. Yet even in this world, small pockets of resistance flourish, giving voice to those who challenge the Ministry and where an act of terrorism is the growing of a tree.
Conspiracies abound as Quinn, Bea and Alina narrate individual chapters of the book, giving the reader a different voice and viewpoint as they forge an unlikely alliance where no-one completely trusts the motives of the other.
Crossan avoids the sentimental as she presents the reader with a detailed depiction of a possible future. She has developed a believable range of characters and events that, as she intended, leaves the reader wanting more.
Ros Lange

Maze cheat by B.R. Collins

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. 310p. ISBN 9781408827604
(Age: 12+) Fans of Game runner, will need no recommendation for the sequel, complete with a female protagonist rather than a male 'Gamerunner'.
The citizens of Ario's dystopian future world are forced indoors by toxic acid rain that erodes skin and eyes, unless one can afford protective clothing. Naturally, many are drawn into the challenge of the world of virtual computer games. Ario is a 'Cheat' by trade, assisting players in their attempts to beat various levels of 'The Maze', an interactive computer game designed and operated by an all-powerful corporation called Crater. Ario, considered by many to be the best Cheat, is able to make a good living at Dion's underground 'tankshop' by selling her cheat codes.
Since the expansion of The Maze by Crater, Ario's cheats appear to fail just as Gamerunners conquer 'the roots', harming more than just her reputation. To redeem herself, Ario develops a cheat to take a beautiful female Gamerunner, Pir to the 'end game'. But a brief, although subtly homoerotic friendship foreshadows Pir's death in The Maze. Afterwards, the divide between reality and virtual reality becomes murky as Ario alone realizes that Pir's thoughts and experiences have been used to expand the game worlds further. Like writers of The Matrix, Collins explores the mind-body conundrum as we grapple with our perceptions of reality and the final paradox of losing in order to win and vice versa.
Rick, the prodigal son of Crater's chief programmer, Daedalus (undoubtedly named after the creator of The Labyrinth in Greek mythology), is rescued by Dion's Tankshop and eventually both Ario and Dion agree that he is their best shot at stopping Crater from devouring more minds and lives.
Maze Cheat will appeal to teenagers as it is set in a very gloomy, dystopian city. There's a futility in the restrictive indoor landscape, leading to recreational drug taking and an obsession with virtual worlds. However, the writing is fast-paced and we have to admire the complex relationships between the characters - they struggle to comprehend their own inner worlds as much as they seek to overcome their political and environmental powerlessness. Ario's drive to survive and thrive in an ugly world dominated by an evil conglomerate, is probably a more resonant rite of passage than most.
Deborah Robins