Reviews

The convent by Maureen McCarthy

cover image

Allen and Unwin, Sydney, 2012. ISBN 9781742375045.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. This is a delightfully engaging novel about four women tied together by family and setting: the Abbotsford Convent, Melbourne. The novel opens in contemporary times with Peach, a 19 year old university student seeking a summer job at one of the convent's cafes. She flags at the outset that this story will be about the past, about the impact of the lives of three other women on her own... but she doesn't yet know the missing link - the convent itself.
And so the reader moves back and forth between Peach and the stories of Sadie (whose child was taken from her in 1915), her daughter Ellen (brought up in the convent in the 1920s) and Cecilia (a young nun at the same convent in the sixties). It is not only the setting that ties these women together, it is also religion and babies. And their stories have a modern echo in Peach's own life, for her dear, damaged friend Det, is pregnant - will she keep the baby or give it up for adoption? And how will her plans impact on Peach, herself an adopted child? As Det is an artist with a studio in the convent, the ties of place and birth are even stronger.
This novel is written with warmth and intelligence. The characters are very real, their personal struggles are sympathetically evoked and so their lives are immediately engaging. With only one first person narrator (Peach) the reader is able to learn more about her back story than Peach herself, so our interest in the mystery of this family saga is constantly being tweaked. On one level, this story is about a young girl coming to terms with her history, her identity and her sense of family; it is about the ties of friendship and romance. But layered over this is the broader and richer story of changing times, of opportunities for women, of the impact of motherhood and religious conviction and love. It is a story with warmth and heart and style; a winning combination from well-known author, Maureen McCarthy.
Deborah Marshall

Again by Emily Gravett

cover image

Again by Emily Gravett
Macmillan Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 9780330544030.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Reading. It's not often you see a book that successfully appeals to both children and adults alike, but this one does. A treat for all readers, especially those long suffering parents and carers who read and reread a book to their impatient charges, again and again. In this delightfully illustrated book, baby dragon just adores his nightly read with his mother. The story in his favorite book concerns a red dragon called Cedric, just like him. The Cedric in the book never goes to bed, but goes out at night tormenting trolls and grabbing princesses to make into pies. An increasingly frustrated baby dragon wants the story read to him again, and as he blusters about prodding his mother to read the tale over, he becomes redder and redder, until finally his anger gets a little too much. And the story being read to him changes as well, as the Cedric in the story is changed by Mum to be one that does go to sleep, a hint to her charge that rather falls on deaf ears.
Beautiful touches appear on every page: the look on the baby dragon's face, the snuggle blanket, the motifs on the blanket, the increasingly tired mother as her image becomes more and more prone, the increased demands of the baby; all are instantly recognisable by the adult reading this book to the children, and parallel what happens in their homes. The climax of the story will bring hoots of laughter from the very willing audience, and the last few pages will intrigue and delight all who read this tale.
Oh, and the endpapers are a treat as well - it's always an extra surprise to see endpapers so well incorporated into the story rather than be left blank.
Fran Knight

Hard nuts of history by Tracey Turner

cover image

Ill. by Jane Lennan. A and C Black, 2012. ISBN 9781408171882.
(Age: 9-12) Non fiction, Biography. Humour. Subtitled Who's who in hard nut history, this attractively presented book outlines potted histories of many famous and not so famous gutsy people, starting with Blackbeard, and then trawling through the lives of such people as Nelson, Boudica, Wu Zetian, Charlemagne, Attila the Hun, Abraham Lincoln, and Scott of the Antarctic, along with a smattering of women, Gracie O'Malley, Cleopatra and Mary Kingsley. A few nods to non British people are included, as are a few indigenous people, like Sitting Bull.
Each is given an outline of their life and times, with a ranking about their toughness. Often a double page offers the person's biography with more information about his times. For example, Nelson's double page is followed by information about the British Navy, while the pages about Ulysses S. Grant are followed by two pages about the American Civil War.
The book relates to a website which can be accessed via the Bloomsbury site (see page 7) which links to cards for downloading to make a game of the book and its contents. At the end of the book can be found a questionnaire asking how hard a nut you are, and a timeline of the hard nuts in the book, with an excellent glossary and comprehensive index. All designed to get kids involved in learning about history through the people who have some notoriety, the book makes history and its fact finding element fun and involving, and uses the internet to further engage the modern reader.
Fran Knight

Stories for 7 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Random House, 2012. ISBN 9781742756622.
Stories for 8 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight. ISBN 9781742756808.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Short stories. With authors like Jacqueline Harvey, Phil Cummings, Deborah Abelah and Vashti Farrer contributing stories to this series (and there are two more, one for 5 and one for 6 year olds), Random House can't go wrong. Short stories are always sought after: a teacher wanting a five minute filler before the bell, or wanting to model a story writing exercise in the classroom, or parents wanting a short story to read before bed, or a child wanting to read something within their operating range, these books contain a wide range of stories designed to please.
For 7 year olds, the range includes a very funny story by Phil Cummings inspired by the pool in his home town where one of his classmates decided it would be a good idea to take a surfboard. Another by J. B. Thomas tells us why the crow's feathers are black, another by Michael Pryor shows us a group of disappearing goats, while another by Morris Gleitzman cleverly parallels a science experiment to raise lots of laughs amongst the readership. Each is distinctly different and funny, and the book includes information about each of the authors at the end, as well as a page about when the story was first published, revealing that some have been published before and some are new. We are lucky that some of these hidden gems have been given a second outing.
For 8 year olds, the range of authors include Paul Jennings, Andy Griffiths and R. A. Spratt, with stories as strange and different as they could possibly be. Both of these books will be a hit in the school library.
Fran Knight

We love school illustrated by Lucie Billingsley

cover image

Hachette (Lothian) 2012. ISBN 9780734411570.
(Age: 4-6) Recommended. Picture book. School. Through a gaggle of dogs, the story is told of the first day at school. The routines are followed throughout the story, taking all young readers along with it. For the very young the experience of school and its routines is neatly outlined, allowing the child to assimilate all that happens in this place. The dogs allow a distance and give a comforting introduction to school procedures.
In rhyming couplets, the story develops as each animal prepares for school, unsure of what to expect. Once at school, they play with their own toys, paint some pictures, and then go out for a break, relieving themselves together except for one dog. They go for a walk, noticing all around them then take time out for lunch. Playtime ends with water play, then the dogs all settle down to sleep until they are picked up to go home with their art efforts for the day.
Each dog is given a different personality through the endearing illustrations. They are shown doing a range of activities which introduces the reader to the sorts of things to expect at school.
As a read aloud, or simply to look at by themselves, or as a classroom share book, this book has possibilities in lessening the anxieties of younger children hearing about school or about to start school.
Fran Knight

The girl from Snowy River by Jackie French

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2012. ISBN 9780732293109.
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Historical novel. In French's well known and loved style of historical fiction, she makes us fully aware of her love of the Australian bush, her adherence to early Australian bush poetry and her unflagging affection for those early pioneers who populated the bush beyond the cities. In the past she has used a time slip technique to deposit her character into a situation in the past where she must learn to survive. This one has a different sort of time slip where a character from the period following World War One, meets and talks with a Vietnam War veteran, his legs gone, pondering his future on the well known rock near her home. Flinty is the main carer in her family. Both parents have died, her brother is killed in Europe, her boyfriend who went to war has returned a broken man, her returned brother also finds it difficult to cope and has gone droving, and she has a brother and sister to care for. She cannot make sense of what is happening about her, just as Nicholas who she meets on the rock, cannot make sense of where his future lies. Both support the other, helping bring changes to their lives which at first they could not see happening.
Flinty comes to rely on her evening talks to this taciturn man, ensuring her siblings are in bed before she walks up the hill to step into a different world. He knows where her future lies, and hints about what may happen, always making sure he does not tell her specifics but says she will suffer sorrow but will come through it all. Readers will eagerly turn the pages as I did, after reading these lines.
This is an engrossing read, full of information about the two periods in which she has set her characters, redolent of the attitudes of both time, exposing the wide impact war has had on both of the main characters and all those about them. This heart warming story ranges between melancholia, sorrow, elation and happiness, as their stories unfold. And if it nudges slightly over the edges of sentimentality, none of French's army of fans will mind in the least.
Fran Knight

Spellbound: Tales of enchantment from ancient Ireland by Siobhan Parkinson and Olwyn Whelan

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 9781847801401
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Myths and legends. Irish myths. I haven't often come across ancient Irish folk tales so this was most interesting to read and so acquaint myself with those stories from their past. Beautifully illustrated in that flat patchwork style of illustrations peculiar to books of myths and fairy tales, full of rich colour and often with borders, the book kept me reading until the end.
The eight stories contain magic and mystery, telling of the ancient times, and will intrigue readers. Some reveal a man who by his own hand, destroys or upsets the love shown by a beautiful woman. In Butterfly girl a young very beautiful girl called Etain, is buffeted by those who both love and hate her. Beloved by a local lord she marries him only to find he already has a wife, who takes serious revenge upon the girl. From then on many things happen to her, but eventually she and her husband are reunited as swans. It's an amazing story of love (particularly the woman's) and retribution, of overcoming evil, of finding your way in the end.
Another, The enchanted deer, has a young woman found in the forest as a deer by day. She marries her rescuer only to be left alone for too long, so returns to the forest where her husband later finds their son. In Lord under wave, again, the man marries a woman who initially appeared as an old ugly hag, only to find in the night she changes to a beautiful young woman. They marry and all he has to do to keep her is not remind her of her past. He does! She flees! And then he spends time looking for her. Another odd mixture of love and magic, around a man's ability to see only what he wants and not the needs of his wife. The stories are all unusual and will make a great treat for students wanting to hear different stories read aloud or study as part of a different culture. For older readers, these may form the basis of a study of folk tales and their presentation of male and female roles. Each would be superb read aloud and set up a neat platform for discussion.
Fran Knight

Poo! A history of the world from the bottom up! by Sarah Albee

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781408171905.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Non fiction. Excrement. Humour. A history of how humans dispose of their waste material is given a very funny airing in this mammoth tome. With 170 pages jam-packed full of information rarely thought of, this book will fill in hours of harmless fun for kids and parents alike. Fascinating titbits about whether there were toilets in a pyramid or how a knight went to the toilet, or how the sewers of London came to be built, invite readers to linger on the pages and illustrations. Full of tales which will be told and retold amongst their peers, younger readers will eat this up.
The layout of the book is somewhat dreary, with blue and green colours used with copious white background and black print, but the information will warm the book to its target audience. The toilet rolls that decorate each page too, leave the reader in no doubt about the stance the author is taking, although I found the repetition in the first few chapters, of how and why the stuff is important along with reference to just a handful of pooers a little unnecessary. But again, the target audience will dip in and out of this book, gathering what information they want, discarding others along the way. This will cause a sensation amongst those hardened non readers, those for whom the Guiness Book of Records is the book they cut their reading teeth on, and for whom the many list books around now are snapped up. Others will come in when they can, reading it over shoulders, hearing about it on the playground grapevine, asking for it for Christmas. How ever it gets to them and why they pick it up will be of no consequence once they read and are drawn into the world of poo.
Fran Knight

The snow Womble by Elizabeth Beresford

cover image

Ill. by Nick Price. Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781408834244
(Age: 3-7) Picture book, Environment, Christmas. Elizabeth Beresford died in 2010, and her famously inventive and ground breaking stories about the Wombles are now being reprinted. The Wombles, conceived initially to clean up Wimbledon Common, first appeared in 1968 when environmental themes in children's literature were sparse. A television series followed and the Wombles became very well known in the United Kingdom with a song that most people can sing or at least hum. With their theme, 'make good use of bad rubbish' they proved to be a herald of good behavour.
In this book, The snow Womble, first published in 1975, only a hint is given of the original intent of the series of books. When the Wombles emerge from their burrows on a very wintry morning, the whole of the common is under snow and so very white and very clean. The young Wombles decide that they do not need to tidy up today so take some time off. Three decide to build a snow Womble, but while Bungo builds the model, Orinoco sleeps and Tamsk snowboards. The finished product is made to look like Great Uncle Bulgaria so that when Tamsk snowboards down the hills he calls out to uncle to move, which of course, he does not. The inevitable happens, and several valuable lessons learnt, especially when Great Uncle Bulgaria emerges from his burrow to hear the little Wombles talking about him.
At the end of this fun filled book is a sheet of stickers for kids to use, showing each of the Wombles.
Fran Knight

Picnic at Hanging Rock by Joan Lindsay

cover image

Penguin (Australia) 2012. First published (Australia) Cheshire, 1967. ISBN: 978067007685.
Recommended. 'Whether Picnic at Hanging Rock is fact or fiction, my readers must decide for themselves.' - Joan Lindsay.
My first impression of the text Picnic at Hanging Rock was that it would be an English story about well-behaved girls at a boarding school who went on a picnic; however I soon found that this classic is much more than this. The children's novel is a hauntingly atmospheric tale which has wormed its way into the hearts and minds of Australians providing an unsolved mystery of whether the story was indeed fictional. Our story starts at Appleyard College for Young Ladies where students and teachers alike are revelling in the holiday of St. Valentine's Day. The girls set off (with two governesses) on a long anticipated picnic to Hanging Rock and spend a lazy afternoon at the picnic grounds. However, while exploring; three senior girls disappear without a trace leaving their companion, Edith delirious with terror. The incident soon sets off a magnificent series of events.
A dramatic mystery without a conclusion Joan Lindsay shows a previously unknown devotion to her work. The novel was written over a period of four weeks and as much mystery surrounds the story as the publication (the novel was published purposely without the final chapter). Although the more pressing mystery of this novel is whether or not this is truly fiction? The author bids the reader to decide for themselves however I remind the reader that there is a grain of truth in every work of fiction.
Kayla Gaskell (Student, age sixteen)

Time between us by Tamara Ireland Stone

cover image

Doubleday Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 9780857531155.
Time between us begins in San Francisco, 2012, and moves backwards into a main setting, Chicago, 1995. Anna is a 16-year-old girl who dreams of travel and adventure, but these dreams are smothered by hum-drum teenage life.
Bennett is 17 (in 2012) and is trying to find his sister Brooke, who is lost travelling in the past. Destiny pulls the two teenagers together in their search for Brooke, and their struggle to face their doomed love affair.
Along the way, the couple are faced with a series of obstacles preventing them from fulfilling their two goals, and towards the end Anna is faced with a difficult and potentially like-changing decision.
The characters have been written before: the relationship in the center of the book echoes overtones of Stephanie Meyer's Twilight saga, and Bennett provides a mysterious, brooding Edward-esque figure. Tamara Ireland Stone weaves an intricate and involving set of scenarios to test her characters individually and as a unit. While the relationship between Anna and Bennett can be similarly found in many already existing novels, there is a sense of freshness and vibrancy injected into this typical romantic plot. The presence of time travel creates a quasi-science fiction mood, while the reality of the characters and their emotions brings it back into dramatic territory without letting the fantasy get too out of hand. The situation of the characters remains fixedly unrelatable, but the protagonists are fairly average and easy to identify with.
Tamara Ireland Stone is clearly a seasoned writer, as she weaves different locations and time periods cleverly and effectively.
Time between us is an unconventional and gripping love story, bound to challenge existing notions of romantic young adult fiction.
Isobel Davies (Student)

Possessed by Niki Valentine

cover image

Sphere, 2012. ISBN 9781847444561.
(Age: 15+) Possessed is the story of Emma Russell, a young woman from a simple working class environment who is a talented musician. Her abilities have resulted in the opportunity to study music at a prestigious university and it is here she meets identical twins Sophie and Matilde. For some reason they befriend Emma and introduce her to a life of champagne, parties and social status. Emma is naturally drawn to the quieter twin, Matilde and is devastated when she unexpectedly commits suicide. Bewilderingly, Sophie seems to thrive after the death of her twin but her relationship with Emma becomes increasingly bizarre.
Things begin to happen to Emma that border on the supernatural. She wakes up in strange places, loses great chunks of time and appears to have participated in events that she has no recall of. Sophie also begins to behave erratically, at times warm and loving and on other occasions cruel and spiteful. How much of these strange happenings can be attributed to grief? Emma becomes more and more fragile as the story progresses to the dark climax.
This book has been described as a psychological thriller, reminiscent of Black Swan and this description is probably the most apt. The reader has to grapple with many questions such as why the popular, affluent twins are attracted to wallflower Emma in the first instance and why Emma becomes so heavily invested in them so early in the story, particularly when the price of the friendship seems so high. However, like shifting sands nothing is quite what it seems and reality is continually distorted. The reader must draw their own conclusions as to where the truth lies.
Tina Cain

The Enormouse Pearl Heist by Geronimo Stilton

cover image

Geronimo Stilton Series, bk 51. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 9780545341035.
(Ages: 7-10) Highly recommended. This series is the most popular in our library; the novels hardly spend any time on the shelf! Each book is a fabumouse, fast-paced adventure featuring Geronimo Stilton the editor of The Rodents' Gazette. The readers love the colourful word-art, bright illustrations and cheesy puns.
This book stays true to type as Geronimo and his friends embark on another exciting escapade. Petunia Pretty Paws an environmentalist and TV reporter (who is Geronimo's crush), invites him to go scuba diving in the South Mousific Ocean, staying on Shell Island. Whilst diving for the first time, Geronimo discovers a giant blue oyster with a huge glowing pearl inside. This leads to a rollicking adventure with plenty of problems from the Provolone family. When Geronimo publishes a special feature about the pearl in The Rodent's Gazette more difficulties occur. Luckily Aunt Sweetfur, Benjamin and Bugsy Wugsy help to save the day.
This series is a great for boosting the independent readers' confidence. They are written in the first person making it easy to empathise with Geronimo and his quirky character traits. He sometimes lacks in self-belief and has a great support network of friends and family. This book starts with a colourful illustration of all of Geronimo Stilton's colleagues, family and friends in his office at the Gazette and ends with a detailed map of Mouse Island.
I would highly recommend this book as a great addition to the series. Reading them with a class can lead into some cheesetastic learning activities: rebus stories, writing a new adventure for the characters, mapping skills, develop class newsletters adding different font styles and types as embellishment.
Rhyllis Bignell

Kicking and dreaming; a story of heart, soul, and rock and roll by A. and N. Wilson (with Charles R. Cross)

cover image

Harper Collins, New York. 2012. 279p.
(Senior secondary - adult) Autobiography. I have to confess that I have no predilection for biography, where selected omissions can invent an entirely different portrait. The travelogue of the two sisters fronting American rock band Heart is penned by Charles R. Cross but written as if alternating the voices of Ann and Nancy Wilson.
Kicking and Dreaming proves to be a typical name dropping memoir and as such will appeal. A lifestyle of free love and drugs seems glossed over and the girls surprisingly conservative, all things considered. Whether any seamy events remain unselected or not, these women share a strong sense of family - a lifelong devotion to parents, siblings, childhood friends and to each other. Yet both sisters despite their recurring insecurities about body image, infertility and relationships; share a passion for music and a dedication to the band they joined in Canada in 1972.
The most striking theme of the autobiography of the Wilson sisters, is their exploration of sexism in their industry. Fame provides a vehicle for Nancy, and Ann in particular, to confirm firsthand the insidious male domination of Rock music both on-stage and off. Fully aware that their performing and recording careers, though purporting to be unconventional, directly reflected society in this respect; the sisters nevertheless earned considerable respect as musicians, lead vocalists, song writers and as co-authors. And on cue, almost in affirmation, Heart will finally be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in April 2013. Only three bands fronted by women have received the honour - Jefferson Airplane, Fleetwood Mac and the Pretenders. Frequently lauded as an inspiration for more well-known musicians, featured often in Rolling Stone magazine and with 40 years of good record sales, this acknowledgement is certainly overdue.
The alternating voices of Ann and Nancy Wilson keep the perspectives fresh and the impression of autobiography credible. No 1 hits such as Crazy on You, Barracuda and Magic Man are impressive enough but anecdotes involving most of the great folk, pop and rock musicians of our time maintain our interest, most notably Elton John, Lynyrd Skynard, Pearl Jam and Paul McCartney. I know one die-hard Led Zepplin fan on campus will be checking out this one!
Deborah Robins

The Glass Forest by Andrew Peters

cover image

Chicken House, 2012. ISBN 9781906427474.
(Age: 12+) Arborium is a kingdom that exists in the towering canopies of ancient trees, presided over by King Quercus and protected from afar by Corwenna, Queen of the Ravens. Steeped in ritual and tradition it is home to Ark, who despite being only fourteen years old, has been bestowed with special powers which make him the principal defender of Arborium. The kingdom is under threat from Maw, an artificial, technology driven civilization characterized by towering structures of glass and steel. Maw wants Arborium because wood is a scarce and valuable commodity and whoever controls the forests wields enormous financial and political power.
Ark and his friends become aware that Maw has developed highly sophisticated weaponry which it plans to use to destroy the tree dwellers. Ark and his trusty ally, Mucum decide to enter Maw as spies to collect information which will enable them to thwart their enemy. It is a highly dangerous mission and time is against them. The envoy of Maw, Fenestra, is orchestrating the invasion and invites senior officials for a briefing. Mucum is able to trick her daughter, Randall, to plant a spying device but when they are uncovered all three are in immediate danger. Will they make it back to Arborium alive and how can they find a way to match the mighty resources of Maw?
This book is a sequel to Ravenwood and will delight fans and those who enjoy dystopian or alternate world fiction, such as Lord of The Rings. It is exciting, fast paced and sophisticated. Mucum provides tension relief with his comical banter and hints of a special connection between Ark and Randall add another dimension to the story which perhaps the author intends to explore in a further book. Although the book stands alone, it would be worthwhile reading the first one for greater background knowledge.
Tina Cain