Reviews

May Gibbs Children's Literature Trust Creative Time Fellowship by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

I have just spent the past month in Adelaide, living in a gorgeous little apartment affectionately known as The Burrow, in Osmond Terrace, Norwood. Last year I applied for a Creative Time Residency with the May Gibbs Children's Literature Trust and was thrilled to learn that my application had been successful. I had thought about applying in previous years but could never see my way clear to having a month away from work. Since taking the huge step at the end of 2012 to write full time, I was absolutely delighted to have this opportunity.
Adelaide was completely new to me - and I have to say after a month, it is now one of my favourite Australian cities. I love the ease with which you can get around; traffic, what traffic? I really enjoyed the cafe culture of The Parade in Norwood and on the couple of occasions that I was able to venture further afield to the Barossa Valley and Victor Harbour, I can attest to the fine wine and food and stunning countryside.
The primary goal of the residency is to give children's writers and illustrators a block of uninterrupted time to work on their craft. There are also some opportunities to do school visits or work with local libraries, earning a little bit of money along the way.
I went to Adelaide with the goal of finishing the draft for the ninth instalment in my Alice-Miranda series, Alice-Miranda in Japan. So there I was in Adelaide, writing about Tokyo and all things Japanese. It was great to be able to write all day and into the night if things were going well, or to take a walk around Norwood, spellbound by the beautiful architecture and meeting friendly folks along the way - including Boston, a little floppy eared rabbit whose 7 year old owner, Abbey, takes for walks each afternoon.
My four weeks were punctuated by events with the Norwood, Payneham and St Peter's library, working with local schools; Norwood, East Marden and East Adelaide and another event with the Glenelg library and two of the Catholic schools nearer the coast. My publisher arranged for me to do four book signings on Saturdays with; Dymocks Rundle Mall, Dillons Norwood, Collins Edwardstown and lastly, on national bookshop day I spent the morning at Mostly Books in Mitcham. It was lovely to meet so many enthusiastic readers, teachers, librarians and booksellers across the city.
I had the pleasure of meeting Pat Pledger and Fran Knight over coffee and delicious cakes and I also spent time with Rebecca Bird and James Williams from the legendary Pegi Williams Bookshop in Walkerville.
A highlight of my time was an additional opportunity to visit Griffin Press, where Random House (and numerous other publishers) have their books printed. I had always wondered how books were made - for me it was a bit of a magical process. You send the page proofs back and 'voila' they return as a book. I wanted to be able to tell children what really happens. And now I can. I was excited to see the process but you can imagine how thrilled I was to learn that my own books were being printed, collated, bound and packaged that very afternoon. It was quite a surreal moment.
As a not for profit organisation, The May Gibbs Children's Literature Trust relies heavily on the work of a volunteer committee. This amazing band of women looked after me so well; with airport and school visit transfers, food, coffee and friendship. I cannot thank them enough and I am looking forward to seeing them all again when I return to Adelaide for a book tour in 2014.
At the end of my time, I'd added 40,000 words to the manuscript and ostensibly completed the draft. I've come home this week to lots of reading and re-drafting but I was pleased to have achieved as much as I did and thoroughly enjoyed the opportunity to join the alumni of Creative Time Fellows.

My Band by Elizabeth Lea

cover image

Ill. by Chantal Stewart. National Library of Australia, 2013. ISBN: 9780642277701.
(Ages: 4-6) Recommended. Nonfiction. Subjects: Music, Musical Instruments. My Band by Elizabeth Lea and Chantal Stewart is a great, lift the flap book that introduces the young reader to ten different musical instruments explaining how they are played and their musical family. Each double page spread starts with the same question, a young girl asks, 'I'm off to play in the band. See if you can guess which instrument I am going to play...'
On the opposite page on the front of the flaps are pictures showing part of the instrument and the starting letter inviting children to guess what is underneath.
The central band of colour across each page accentuates the text, and the simple colourful illustrations of the young girl playing each of the instruments are great visual cues for discussions about bands, orchestras and music. At the end of this fact book are eight projects for children to make their very own instruments with everyday household objects. These instruments include panpipes, an oboe and a tambourine.
This book is fun to read with the repetitive text, information hidden under the flaps and great projects to make. This is a great addition to the classroom, music room or home library.
Recommended for 4-6 years of age.
Rhyllis Bignell

Seventeen and Gone by Nova Ren Suma

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2013. ISBN 9781742976143.
(Ages: 14+) Seventeen and Gone is a chilling tale about girls that go missing when they're 17 told through Nova Ren Suma's poetic, evocative prose.
It's a story of one girl's devotion to finding out what has happened to Abby, a girl found on a missing poster. It's also the story of how that girl can lose herself in the process in this psychological thriller.
Within its pages, we find out about Lauren's commitment to finding out what happened to these missing girls, and she is the only one who has the courage to wear on and look for what happened even when their families and authorities have given up. Her perspective blurs the lines of reality, one day she'd be in school and the next she'll seeing spirits of the lost girls and they will be making her do things.
The writing is poetic, chilling and beautiful, and captures the heart of the novel perfectly. Through Nova Ren Suma's writing, we experience the strange and confusing hallucinations and feelings that the main character has as she slowly loses grip on her sanity.
I found Seventeen and Gone to be a thrilling adventure, with its overarching mystery about what happened to Abby and the things that were happening to Lauren in the process. I read the whole novel in one day, because I was glued to this strange and haunting tale.
Seventeen and Gone explores some very real issues, including not giving up on missing persons (in particular, girls when they turn 17) and the mentally unstable. It's certainly not a fluffy read, but one that helps us to understand some darker issues in life and may encourage others to reach out for help.
Jeann Wong

Flora's War by Pamela Rushby

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2013. ISBN: 9781921665981.
Highly recommended for readers aged 13+. Between April 25 1915 and January 9 1916, the Battle of Gallipoli, also known as the Dardanelles Campaign, raged between British/French Allies and the crumbling Ottoman Empire in modern day Turkey. It was a defining moment for both sides but for Australia and New Zealand, arguably the most significant military episode in their respective histories, giving rise to an enduring national identity and the concept of the ANZAC spirit. Since then there have been countless books, discussions, films, articles and other retellings both fact and fiction, of the tragic casualties suffered - a shocking almost 30, 000 Australian soldiers dead or wounded as a result of combat.
Pamela Rushby has previously explored through fiction and nonfiction, Australia's part in significant wars, Ancient and Modern Egypt and archaeology and in this new novel, combines all of these ingredients to present a very different slant on the ANZAC story.
Flora is a young girl, newly transitioned from schoolgirl to young woman, the daughter of a well-known Australian archaeologist who enjoys an annual sojourn in Cairo, helping her father with his current dig. In 1915 however, Cairo is a very different city from all her previous visits, with endless rows of army tents, drilling troops and dedicated young nurses in abundance. Far from Flora's anticipation of a whirl of social engagements as newly emerged 'young lady', within a very short time Cairo is hurled into the bloody Dardanelles Campaign aftermath as waves of wounded soldiers are transported from the Gallipoli battle- many of them in near-fatal condition. The normal structure of hospitals and nursing staff cannot cope with this flood of piteous survivors and every possible building is commandeered to accommodate those who recover and volunteers are hard pressed to transport and nurse them.
Flora's account of the Gallipoli tragedy is told compassionately and provides the reader with a little known side to the well known history of this disastrous military venture. The personal relationships woven throughout the story lend depth and emotion to the characters and their situations and the reader is drawn into the atmosphere of the dark days they endured. The author has used extensive research to provide solid factual recounts of the events.
This novel would make an extremely valuable addition to any secondary library as well as a significant contribution to the study of World War 1 and Australian Identity (ACARA Year 9 History Strand).
Sue Warren

Sea Hearts by Margo Lanagan

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742375052.
UK title: The Brides of Rollrock Island, David Fickling Books, 2012.
(Age 15+) Highly recommended. CBCA Winner Older readers, 2013, Ditmar Award for Best Novel (2013), Aurealis Award Nominee for Young Adult Novel (2012), Norma K Hemming Award (2013). Rollrock Island is a small remote community where seals frequent the beaches. Strange stories are secretly told of witches who have power over the seals and of seal wives, beautiful women whose seal skins have been stolen and who have married the fishermen on the island. Misskaella is a tiny young girl, who is bullied by the island children and overlooked by the young men. When she discovers that she has the power to give the young men the seal bride that they so desire, the consequences of this choice are far reaching.
Lanagan has taken this old Celtic folk tale and teased out the emotions that face everyone when a young man buys himself an irresistible sea-wife. Told from different viewpoints the reader is taken along on a journey of desire, revenge, of loyalty and love and of longing for the sea. The feelings of the husbands who are so attracted to the seal women that they hide their skins where the women can't find them are explored as well as the fathers who mourn for their daughters who don't thrive on land and must be returned to the sea. So are the feelings of the offspring, the young boys who know how much their mams love them but how much they long for the sea and the women who are abandoned by their husbands for the sea wives. Even Misskaella's fate and grief as a result of her meetings with the seal king is described poignantly although the reader can have little sympathy for her manipulation of everyone's feelings as she relentlessly pursues her revenge on the islanders.
This is beautifully written and rich tale that vividly showcases the beauty and darkness of Lanagan's prose. The setting of Rollrock Island sings to the reader, who can almost smell the sea water and easily imagines the rocks, the fishing village and the isolation of the community.
Sea hearts is a story for the mature, imaginative reader who will find much to stimulate discussion and thought in its themes and authorship.
Pat Pledger

The top team by Sally Rippin

cover image

Ill. by Stephanie Spartels. Hey Jack series. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2013. ISBN 9781742975429
(Age: 5-7) Highly recommended. School Life. Friendship. Cooperation. Competition. The top team is the latest chapter book in Sally Rippin's Hey Jack series. In each story Jack is introduced by the emotions he's feeling; here he's grouchy. A black and white sketch of Jack with clenched fists, a big frown and angry thoughts illustrate his mood. Jack is angry because the teacher Ms. Milton hasn't paired Jack with his best friend Billie B. Brown (star of her own series.) He's paired instead with Alex who is much better at Maths than Jack. They both learn to cooperate and encourage each other with the daily lessons.
The books are easy to read with the large font and simple sentences, making them a great beginning chapter book for emergent readers. Sally Rippin adds values and life lessons in each story. In The top team both Jack and Alex learn teamwork, cooperation and the need to value each other's strengths. The black-and-white illustrations bring life to Jack and his classmates and add insight into their emotions.
These books are a favourite at school and are highly recommended for 5-7 year olds. These books are targeted to the boy reader; however they can be enjoyed by everyone. They are great to read to a class and can stimulate healthy discussions on moods, emotions and values.
Rhyllis Bignell

The demon trappers series by Jana Oliver

cover image

Macmillan, 2013. ISBN 9781447241744.
(Age: 15+) This volume has two books under the one cover: Forsaken and Forbidden, book 1 and book 2 of The demon trappers series. There are two other books in the series, Forgiven and Foretold. On the back it states 'For older readers'.
The books revolve around the story of Riley Blackthorne, who has always wanted to be a Demon Trapper like her father who goes hunting demons with his sidekick, Beck. In the first book she is training as an apprentice Demon Trapper which, with school, takes up all her time. When younger she had had a huge crush on Beck but her interests now lie with Simon a fellow apprentice. When a Grade Five Geo-Fiend confronts Riley at the library and her world crashes around her, she takes on a massive struggle again the demons. The second book continues the saga with Riley growing in skill and confidence as a Demon Trapper.
This is an exciting start to the series. Riley is a strong heroine who has to grow up in a hurry. Her fights with the demons are exciting and the world building is well done. Supporting characters are well rounded and the action is more important than the inevitable love triangle.
An easy to read, quite addictive duo of books that is pure escapism and will be enjoyed by readers who like this genre featuring demons.
Pat Pledger

Zombelina by Kristyn Crow

cover image

Ill. by Molly Idle. Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9780802728043.
(Age: 4+) Picture book. Zombies. Humour. Family. Zombelina loves to dance. She dances with a spectre, dances like a ghost, wiggles with werewolves and boogies with bats, but more than anything she loves dancing for her family, her mother, the witch, her father and brother, both vampires. In their house at Twisted Tree Lane are all the things which make up ghost and scary stories, which readers will love to find in the colourful illustrations.
Sometimes when Zombelina gets engrossed in her dancing, parts of her body come off, and a leg may end up in the air but she keeps going. Mum and Dad enroll her in a real ballet school, buying her all the accoutrements which she will need as a ballet student.
She practices with all her might, until on the night all the girls are arranged on the stage, she comes down with stage fright, and cannot move.
But no worries, her parents save the day in this endearing look at family love and support.
Girls particularly will enjoy reading about this little girl and her attempts to learn ballet, and boys will love the background of the house at Twisted Tree Lane.
Fran Knight

Mucked up by Danny Katz

cover image

Allen & Unwin 2013. ISBN 9781742379258.
Tom is trying to survive Muck Up Day at his school when the Year 12s return to create havoc in the school with toilet paper, super soakers filled with fish sauce, eggs and various other unpleasant things as well as a baby pig.
The story is written from Tom's point of view as a Year 9 student, it is also filled with cartoon style pictures and maps. This I think is one of the problems with the book. In design and layout it appears more suitable for a younger audience than the actual story suggests. Whilst some of the episodes are undoubtedly funny, especially the baby pig, others are less so, and the so called pranks of the Year 12s appear to be little more than mindless vandalism with little regard for the safety of students or care for facilities. The school staff also seem to be incapable of preventing what is happening and in the end are somewhat of a caricature that I found distinctly not funny.
I have trouble deciding where this book would fit in the library. The layout and humour suggests younger students whereas the content is more suited to middle school readers.
David Rayner

Beauty and the beat by Kate Forster

cover image

Smitten series. Hardie Grant Egmont, Richmond, 2013. ISBN 9781742972541.
(Age: 16+) This novel is a pleasant enough foray into the romance genre but hardly groundbreaking. Somewhat formulaic in style, plotting and characterisation, we know from the opening chapter that the 'Princess Perfect' Mia and the 'bad-boy' Rob will be together by novel's end because they so clearly can't stand each other as they make eye contact across the crowded hall at their school assembly. This is pretty standard Mills and Boon territory. Or maybe it is simply following the script of the musicals that Mia adores (and Rob despises)? For music forms the background to these characters' lives and to the storyline.
Of course, we soon discover that neither character is quite as the other one assumes them to be: beneath her Princess Perfect facade, Mia is a bundle of self-doubt with a serious anorexia problem whilst Rob isn't so much a bad boy as an understandably angry young man, due to family grief. Both find solace in music and eventually, in each other's arms.
Bossy Mia may not be the most likeable girl at the opening of the novel but readers are sure to be smitten by hunky Rob with his smirk, his sadness and his hidden kind heart. His responsible approach to sex is sure to win some hearts too.
For teenage girls looking for a light romantic novel with plenty of pop culture and musical references, this story will no doubt provide an entertaining read.
Deborah Marshall

Chook Chook: Little and Lo in the city by Wai Chin

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2013. ISBN: 9780702249754.
(Age: 7-9) Highly recommended. Family Life. Pets. Modern China - social customs.
Chook Chook: Little and Lo in the city is author Wai Chim's second story set in rural China. Mei Lin's pet chicken Little and her rooster Lo now live happily on the farm after their previous misadventures. She loves watching them dance and is very protective of them. After the death of her father, her brother Guo is struggling to cope with looking after their farm and her mother Ma is finding life difficult. Mei Lin's happiness is threatened when Ma decides to marry the one-eyed local butcher Jin. After the wedding life changes on their farm, smoked pigs are stored in the cellar and an aggressive rooster Itchy causes problems in the chicken house.
What is Mei-Lin's only course of action? She runs away to the city to find her brother Guo who is now studying at university. Along the way she meets street-wise orphan Cap who helps her navigate the dramas of train travel and city life. Little and Lo play an important role in the resolution of this narrative.
The Chinese country and Guangzhou city setting of this junior novel add a unique backdrop for the action. Each of the characters Mei Lin encounters have universal qualities that the reader can understand like kindness and helpfulness - Cap and the old woman on the train, or authoritarian like Professor Law. They also are quintessentially Chinese.
I would highly recommend this novel for readers from 7-9 years of age. This novel provides the reader with a slice of Chinese life with adventure, family dramas, pet chickens and a feisty young girl protagonist.
Rhyllis Bignell

Possum magic animals by Mem Fox and Julie Vivas

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781862919730.
(Age: 0-3) Recommended. Board Book. This little book has beautiful illustrations of the animals from Possum Magic. Julie Vivas' delightful illustrations are a joy to examine, the faces of the birds and animals just gorgeous to look at.
It is a sturdy treasure that would be a delight to give to babies as a gift, but also very useful for the young child who might like to trace the large words with their fingers as they learn the names of Australian animals like possum, snake, kangaroo, dingo, emu, echnida, wombat, koalas, kookaburras, and then end the book with the words, friends and good night!
Pat Pledger

Broken melody by Trudy Adams

cover image

Wombat Books, 2013. ISBN 9781922074911
(Age: 13+) Broken melody is the first person recount of a 17yr old's physical, emotional and psychological abuse at the hands of her foster parents. While friends and teachers commiserate and boost Danae's self-esteem, conversely, her foster parents are really villains and her foster siblings also damaged.
Danae Blackburn, the narrator and main character learns to play the piano exceptionally well with little instruction and an almost total absence of self-esteem.
The healing power of music and Danae's newfound religious faith sustain her through a great many complications in her bid to win a national music competition. The plot has sufficient twists and turns although they are entirely predictable and when combined with the didactic narration, events unfortunately contribute to our overall disbelief. The janus-faced foster parents are complex and believable, but the novel itself fails to haunt us.
Young Adult readers will ultimately decide whether Broken melody aligns with Trudy Adam's intention as expressed on her Christian publisher's website, 'I wanted to explore the battlefield that takes place in a person's mind when they have been consistently told they are 'nothing' or 'worthless'. Having worked with young people for almost four years, I also wanted to create a story that was relevant to the current generation.'
Deborah Robins

Snowy and snuffles ill. by Felicity Gardner

cover image

Lothian, 2013. ISBN 9780734413888.
(Age: 4+) Picture book. Friendship. This slight story of two wombat joeys is all about friendship and doing things together. But Snowy does some terrible things, stretching the bounds of friendship and family life, and I would think their mother's patience. Snowy upturns his food bowl on Snuffle's head, covers him with water in the bathroom, tips him off the swing in the park, and when he messes up the art room, he is made to clean it up, mother baking a cake for the two when the chore is finished.
Despite all that Snowy does to Snuffles, he is still his best friend, and they do everything together. The thrust of the tale is that they are very different and can still be best of friends. The soft illustrations reflect the Australian wombat well, including a rare white wombat. For those readers with a sibling who is very different from themselves this will strike a chord, and for those wanting a tale about a family with some chaos then this may be appropriate. The humour in the tale is reflected in the illustrations.
I seem to be seeing more of these sorts of books, where there is no author, simply an illustrator acknowledged. Why the anonymity? It seems very odd to me. Perhaps it is someone in the publishing house?
Fran Knight

The big dry by Tony Davis

cover image

HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN: 9780732297633.
(Age: 12-14) Highly recommended. The harsh drought-stricken landscape totally dominates the lives of thirteen year old George and his younger brother Beeper. They are desperately trying to survive after their father fails to return from a shopping trip. Blasters, strong destructive winds, cause havoc, buildings crack and crumble, invasive red dust seeps into the houses and water is scarce. In this dystopian environment that has lasted for years, people have developed violent survivalist skills, selling water, stealing food and turning in abandoned children to the Welfare Authorities.
George and his brother decide to leave the safety of their house and search in vain for their father. On their return a strange girl has invaded their space and threatens their very existence. She is more worldly wise and has developed skills of self protection. Emily challenges their thinking and confronts George's distorted view of reality. Their reclusive neighbour Mr. Carey and the rabbitoh man also aid in the boys' survival.
Powerful imagery and a driven plot take the reader on a journey through a tough reality. Measured phrases, gritty internal dialogue and unanswered questions add to the tension of the author's narrative.
I would highly recommend this novel for readers 12-14 years of age. As a class novel, students could discuss the impact of the climate change and drought, the development of survival skills and the need for self preservation.
Read this novel with a glass of fresh cool water, valuing each drop!
Rhyllis Bignell