Reviews

Shadows by Robin McKinley

cover image

Puffin, 2013. Kindle edition. ISBN 9780141969534
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Magic. Maggie hates Val, her new stepfather. He seems to be surrounded by strange shadows that no one else can see. A refugee from Oldworld where magic is still used, he just doesn't seem to quite fit into Newworld, where magic has been banned and everything must have a scientific rationale. Maggie's great grandmother had been a magician, but that was a long time ago and anything that reeks of magic must now be hidden. Then Maggie meets a gorgeous boy Casimir who is from Oldworld too, and together with her friends Jill and Takahiro, and her dog Mongo, they face shattering events and must rely on Val's help.
McKinley is an award winning author and the quality of her work demonstrates both her creative writing skills and the wonderful imagination that she brings to the worlds that she creates. She doesn't write long series, most of her books are one-offs, and each is very different, giving her fans, and I am one, something to truly look forward to.
Shadows is similar to her wonderful vampire book, Sunshine, in that it has a familiar feel to the setting. Although Maggie's world is quite different to ours, her family, her friends and her work at the animal shelter make the reader feel comfortable while taking in the ideas of magic being banned and strange shadows stalking her stepfather.
McKinley's characters are beautifully rounded. Maggie is a great character. The story is told in the first person by her and through her observations the reader gets to know everyone really well. Although she hates Val, she tries to hide this because her mother loves him so much and her little brother adores him as well. Jill is a trusty friend and Takahiro just blew my mind away. The romance is low key but really satisfying. And of course, Mongo the dog and the other dogs at the shelter are fully realised characters as well.
There is plenty of action both from the point of view of the characters getting to know each other, and from facing the magical elements. To write much more would be to give away the plot, but it is riveting and I was left wishing that there was more to come. This is one book that is on my re-read list, as are all the others that McKinley has written. This will appeal to fans of Diana Wynne Jones to whom the book is dedicated, and to readers who want a story with unique world building and memorable characters.
Pat Pledger

City of monsters by D.C. Green

cover image

Monster School, bk 1. Ford St, 2013. ISBN 9781925000078.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended for capable readers. Fantasy. From Ford St Publishing, comes D.C. Green's latest book for children, the first in a new series. Now let me see... let's take some gnarly grommets, angst-ridden kids with attitude, misfits of various descriptions and some seriously divided peer groups and mix them all together in a monster mash of hilariously epic proportions.
Enter PT aka Swamp Monster who turns up at Monster School and somehow, almost by default, becomes part of the Dead Gang. Amidst this incongruous group of oddballs (even by monster terms!) PT aka the Heir Apparent of Monstro City is both intimidated and accepted by a vampire, an abnormally huge spider, a zombie, a shape shifter, a mummy, a troll and forest goblin - none of whom are 'accepted' by the ruling class of Mafia goblins. After all, PT (Thomas Regus) is a 'hume', that is, a human and so far outside the norm of Monster School as to be viewed in the normal scheme of things as... well, basically... dinner!
With Monstro City being ruled by Lord Boron, both Regent and PT's tutor, PT is stifled and appalled by his confinement to the dark quarters of the Palace, his father and brother having disappeared (amidst rumours of vampire intervention) and his mother in a strange deep coma.
Rebelling against his everyday life - really? A teenager rebelling? Go figure! - PT connives at an escape to Monster School to undertake his own education regarding his kingdom with both extremely amusing but also heroic results.
Readers, young and old, will recognise many students/young people, with whom they have interacted and relish the humour and innate sense of justice expressed through the characters and their actions.
Look out for the next instalment - this one will be a real winner with both boys and girls. The characters are endearing, despite their monstrous attributes and the reader becomes fully engaged with the whole adventure - and who can resist a fully grown dragon? Magnificent, dangerous and wise, Kalthazari completely dominates the climax of the adventure and provides the segue to the next instalment.
Highly recommended for capable readers from 10+ (the characters' 'voices' will need some careful reading).
Sue Warren

I love you night and day by Smriti Prasadam-Halls

cover image

Ill. by Alison Brown. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408839737.
(Age: Preschool-6) Recommended. Love.
A celebration of love, this picture book sends out a loud and heart warming message about the power of love that a parent has for a child:
'I love you wild, I love you loud.
I shout it out and I feel proud.
I love you night, I love you day.
In every moment come what may.'
Vivid colours bring the illustrations alive and are a perfect complement to the story that just begs to be read aloud by a parent who wants to reassure a child that he or she is well loved. It would be an ideal present for parents and is sure to be a book that becomes a favourite with both adult and child and is an ideal way for both to express love.
I particularly enjoy books that extol the virtues of love and this one could be paired with Sam McBratney's Guess how much I love you and Margaret Wild's On the day that you were born.
Pat Pledger

Her Majesty's pleasure: A centenary celebration for Adelaide's theatre of the stars

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2013. ISBN 9781743052297.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Theatre. Adelaide History.
Presented in full colour illustrations in a large format book, this history of Her Majesty's Theatre in Grote Street in the Adelaide CBD is just a wonderful read. The author, Frank Van Straten has complied the stories and history of the grand theatre from his amazingly broad experience and collection, while doing extensive research to make this a necessary companion to any study of Adelaide's theatre scene as well as its architectural heritage. And so well written, the stories of this marvelous theatre feel familiar and shout to be recounted. From vaudeville days in the aptly named chapter, Act One, when Stiffy and Mo trod the stage, with the likes of Lilli Gantrey or Ada Reeve, or held plays such as The Mallee Root and The Bushwoman, or encouraged patriotism with shows about ANZAC, the theatre, then called The Tivolli was a proud part of Adelaide's theatre-going population.
Each of the book's major sections, Act One and Act Two, are offered in chronological listings of what happened through the years, the date being the simple heading for each paragraph or two, making it an easy book to dip into.
A foreword by Barry Humphries reiterates the importance of the theatre and recalls his often quoted words that this theatre is his favourite in Australia. These words are followed by an Overture and Prologue, and the two chapters are rounded off with a section on The Future written by the CEO of the Adelaide Festival Centre, Douglas Gautier. The copious illustrations are amazing, not only detailing a history of the theatre, but showing the changes in Adelaide as the theatre went through its paces. It is a wonderful book for browsing, for adding to the history of Adelaide and for making people look again at this theatre in the heart of the city.
Fran Knight

Never fade by Alexandra Bracken

cover image

The darkest minds bk 2. Harper Collins, 2013. ISBN: 9780732294595.
(Age: 13+) The darkest minds never fade is a book formed from an interesting concept and a very real possibility warped into fantasy. A killer disease has swept through the children of America, wiping out all but a small percent. Survivors are sent to camps to be monitored by doctors and specialists who are working towards finding a cure, but these children are no longer the kind to sit quietly and wait and these camps are no longer the patient sort. Survivors are quickly found to have talents, almost superpowers, and are classed into categories based on their talents. Being children, few escape their camps and even fewer live to tell the tale, but a special few become involved with The Children's League, a society formed for the purpose of freeing those frightened, abused children from the camps and the clutches of madness. If nothing else this book brings to light the very real issues of how a government could choose to deal with this kind of mass mutation.
The book is based around the story of Ruby, ex-escapee of brutal concentration camp, Thurmond, and current associate of The Children's League. Something is wrong with The Children's League; Alban is having a difficult time keeping his agents in line, particularly those who despise the idea of being sent on missions with Psi children such as Ruby and her team. After well orchestrated 'accidents' which resulted in the deaths of several Psi children Ruby's team is sent on a renegade mission to find the lost research of 'The Professor' and the key to curing the disease which caused the mutations. Running into old friends along the way and going through more than any child should ever have to go through, Ruby races against the clock to stop the bad agents from corrupting Alban's vision of freeing all the kids and returning the American life to a (would be) normal state.
As this is the second book in the series I would recommend it for teenagers and young adults. If nothing else it provides a range of interesting concepts and makes you consider your place in the world.
Kayla Gaskell (Student)

Mouse bird snake wolf by David Almond

cover image

Ill. by David McKean. Walker, 2013. ISBN 9781406322897.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Picture book. Allegory. Creation. While the gods sleep on high, exhausted after creating the world with all of its variety, three children, Harry, Sue and Little Ben, wander the earth, in awe of what they see. But there are gaps.
After a while, they experiment to see if they can fill the blank spaces and so Little Ben imagines a mouse and creates it out of the resources around him, willing it to life. Each of the children is excited by this and Sue goes on to create a bird. The gods on high see the bird and wonder at it, but return to their slumbers.
Then Harry dreams up a snake. He moulds it out of the clay on the ground and wills it to life, offering the sorts of noises it will make. But it proves less alluring than the bird and the mouse, and the children are a little frightened of what has been created, and baulk, while the snake slithers into a hole in the ground. But then he creates a wolf.
An allegory for modern times, the story parallels the creation of all we see, and in particular, the things we would prefer to have been left out. Just like Pandora, the evil things brought into the world astonish and bruise the children, but here, they are able to revoke the wolf, although it still lurks beneath the earth. I love the feel of the story, that people have created good things but also some not so welcome. In the hands of an encouraging teacher or parent, the discussions about what is good in the world could be impressive. This could lead on to discussions about their responsibility in making the world a safer place.
The illustrative techniques used are as different as the story, inviting the readers to ponder why the illustrator has used this style and discuss how the style parallels the story, giving it a surreal edge.
Hints in both the story and illustrations, point to other stories, building up a multi-layered effect, where readers can bring in other stories they have heard. Moulding animals out of clay, the images of the older boy taking up more room on the page as he creates the snake and then the wolf, the gods on high resting in clouds, the image of the snake as evil, and so on, all parallel other creation stories from differing cultures which beg to be discussed.
Fran Knight

A breath of frost by Alyxandra Harvey

cover image

Lovegrove legacy, bk 1. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408836354.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Paranormal. Witchcraft. Romance. Mystery. It is 1814 and three cousins, Emma, Gretchen and Penelope discover that the Lovegrove family have a legacy of magic. Amidst the splendour of Regency balls and beautiful ballgowns, the Greymalkin Sisters come prowling through the gates of the Underworld that Emma has inadvertently opened. Debutante witches are murdered and Emma is mysteriously drawn to their bodies, causing the Order of Keepers to suspect her of murder.
The book opens with a bang as a young girl Moira clambers over the rooftops of London and breaks into the house of a dead witch to steal her glass eye. The exhilarating action continues on with the introduction of Emma and her cousins at a ball where there is a ghostly fire and a debutante is found dead. Here Emma discovers that she has a heritage of magic and together with her cousins Gretchen and Penelope they face danger, not just from the ghouls and hellhounds and the Greymalkin Sisters but from members of the Order who are afraid of their powers.
The Regency setting is fabulous, with its descriptions of dance lessons, etiquette, ballrooms and gowns contrasting with Moira's background of slums and thieving. The elements of magic including a Woodcutter's son, a white stag and familiars for each of the debutante witches, are cleverly written and build up an atmosphere of enchantment. The battles between the creatures from the Underworld and Emma's growing powers are enthralling.
Although the story is peopled with a vast array of characters, including the three cousins, their mothers, fathers, girls at the exclusive finishing school, Moira and Cormac, a Keeper who has no magic, it is still easy to follow Emma's story. She grapples with a mother who has gone mad to protect the cousins and her growing magic powers. Her attachment to Cormac who seems to have lost interest in her, provides food for the lovers of romance who won't be disappointed.
Fans of Alyxandra Harvey won't be disappointed in this story of clever heroines, magic and romance and will look forward to hearing more about the Lovegrove legacy.
Pat Pledger

Little Red Riding Hood, retold by Alison Jay

cover image

Scholastic 2013. ISBN 9781742760711.
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Fairy tales. The story of Red Riding Hood is retold in this enticingly illustrated book from Scholastic. The usual theme is there, being met by a wolf which then ties Grandma up in the cupboard ready to eat Red Riding Hood when she arrives at Grandma's house. Most children will know the story and be able to predict what will happen along the way. A few changes from the original are included: the wolf does not eat Grandma, and his end is not as gruesome as others I have read. But it will entreat and delight the readers and listeners, some even discussing the differences between other versions.
The illustrations are a delight. With an old fashioned style, each picture is overlaid with cracking as if the paint is much older than it appears to be. The background village, the houses and their insides and are all drawn in a much earlier age, giving the impression of an age old story. And I loved the introduction of other fairy tales in the setting. Kids will eagerly find references to the Gingerbread House, the Gingerbread Man, Hansel and Gretel, the Woodsman, the Three Little Pigs and so one peppering the illustrations. Such fun.
Fran Knight

Losing Reuben by Leonie Norrington

cover image

Ill. by Beth Norling. Mates series. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781742990224.
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Aboriginal themes. Family.
When Mum and Dad and the kids go fishing at One Mile Creek, Mum counts the children as they have a large family. Even though Reuben is number nine, he knows that he is as loved as everyone else. This time however, Mum has had another baby.
While at One Mile Creek, Dad takes them fishing, showing the children how to use the net to catch enough for the family for tea. And this time, Reuben, the youngest is to be the anchor. He is rather concerned. He has never done this before, and he is aware that his small undeveloped frame may not be strong enough to hold the net.
But it all goes well, and after a big feed, they all lie down for an afternoon nap. Packing up, Mum counts them all in, one to nine but halfway home, remembers Reuben, number nine and that she now has ten. So back they go, finding Reuben where they left him, Reuben taking note of the rules Dad has insisted they follow, to stay calm and stay where they are. All is well.
In a few words, Leonie outlines this wonderful tale of a family on a fishing trip. The closeness of the family is obvious all the way through, their knowledge of the elders being passed on to the younger, Dad teaching his children all the while some survival skills.
One of the popular Mates series, this will be a wonderful addition to any library.
Fran Knight

The thing about luck by Cynthia Kadohata

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2013. ISBN 9781471116858.
(Age: Junior Fiction) Written by the well-known Newbery Award winner of Kira-Kira, here is a vivid picture of life on the vast wheat farms of the United States. Summer and her family have recently suffered great misfortune and they are about to be tested again. Summer's parents work for a custom harvesting company in Kansas - such contracting exists in parts of Australia too - but this year her mother and father must return to Japan to take care of elderly relatives. Summer's maternal grandparents decide to come out of retirement, with grandfather working as a combine driver and grandmother as a cook, with Summer as her helper. Young brother Jaz will come along too. It seems that the family is beset with further bad luck as the hard and long working days begin. Summer is a wonderful 'philosopher' - she mesmerises the reader with her knowledge, intuition and wisdom. She informs us about the harvesting process and includes her own little sketches of how things work. She sets the scenes beautifully in the first person narrative and identifies problems and consequences with assurance, often with humour, and is a sheer delight to read about.
She assumes responsibility for a great deal, knowing that her grandfather is struggling with the work, her grandmother continuing to experience extreme back pain and her brother still unable to lift his veil of invisibility. The weight of the world is on her shoulders!
This book is charming on all levels - the location, the characters, the experiences and the voice of Summer. Kadohata's storytelling skill is extraordinary. Just enjoy this book!
Julie Wells

Two boys kissing by David Levithan

cover image

Text Publishing 2013. ISBN 9781922147486.
As always, I can only speak subjectively and for myself. I understand and acknowledge that certain people will not only understand but identify with this book, and I happen to be one of those people.
A voice begins and ends this extraordinary novel - the voice of experience, the voice of those who have lived and died. The book is narrated by the chorus of a gay community past, victims of the AIDS virus.
Two boys kissing is a lurid and obvious title for so nuanced and complex a work. It comprises of very contemporary and very relevant stories about young gay men, detailing their relationships, social lives and pressures.
If nothing, this is a profoundly accessible insight into modern gay culture, but it is so much more. Another thing to note is how curiously devoid of camp humour the novel is. The themes are normalized and the characters remain beautifully, painfully human, a welcome change from the often gaudy glamourization of same-sex attracted characters.
The stark, nostalgic reminiscences from an anguished mass grave is a bold choice, and there is a poignant balance between the regret of the dead and celebration of love, a distinguished, discriminated, powerful love.
Two boys kissing is about much more than just two boys kissing. It is a triumphant ode to the fighters who continue to fight, a eulogy to a historic fatality. A celebration of boys who kiss and have kissed boys, both furiously alive and long gone.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

RAWR! by Todd H. Doodler

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9780545611186.
(Age: Preschool) Recommended. Rex finds being a dinosaur very hard. He is bigger than everyone in his class, even the teachers. Everyone can find him when he plays hide and seek, and his desk is too small. Everyone thinks he is scary, but really when he goes RAWR! he is just saying hello.
In vivid colour, a bright green Rex pops off the page, his yellow and black eyes gleaming out at the reader. The brightly coloured shapes of the houses, bus, cars and school grounds are just what small children will enjoy and the addition of soft material on the picture of Rex on the front cover will entice little fingers to touch and feel.
The text is simple and short and good to read aloud and the underlying messages about being kind, polite and helpful will be a boon for parents. The use of the word RAWR! will give occasion to lots of loud roars at bedtime and lots of fun for both caregiver and child as well as sending out messages that big and loud aren't necessarily scary.
This is a book that all little dinosaur lovers will enjoy.
Pat Pledger

Ubby's Underdogs: Heroes beginnings by Brenton E. McKenna

cover image

Magabala Books, 2013. ISBN 9781922142139.
This graphic novel is the second in a trilogy by Indigenous author/illustrator Brenton E. McKenna. Inspired by comic books from a young age and with a passion for both writing and art, McKenna has put his studies in Visual Arts to excellent use in this series which takes its setting and characters from his own hometown of Broome.
In post-WW2 Broome, the population was already a melting pot of multiculturalism with a rich history of plucky characters and exciting incidents. This second episode reintroduces characters from the first and continues the The legend of the Phoenix dragon.
The main protagonist, Ubby, is a young Aboriginal girl (based on McKenna's feisty grandmother) but her Underdogs encompass youngsters from a variety of backgrounds.
With a gripping backdrop of both Aboriginal and Chinese mythology, Ubby's Underdogs take on a mission to rescue their friend Sai Fong, the Dragon Summoner, from the rival gangs pursuing her for their own evil ends.
McKenna's art training is evident in the stylish presentation of this graphic novel - the black framing and outstanding use of colour heighten the intensity of the story. There is a 'manga' feel to the design which devotees of that genre will find appealing. While recommended for upper primary to secondary, I would suggest that some of the phonetic/accented dialogue may be a challenge for less than capable readers. Both boys and girls would relate to this book, as although Ubby is the leader of her rag-tag band, she is clearly not the most 'girly' girl.
The growing market for graphic literature attests to its popularity with a young generation who are far more visually influenced than those of the past. This series would be a fabulous addition to your Graphic shelves - or if you have not yet ventured into graphic literature this homegrown series may be a fine starting point. There has been some resistance from some quarters who suggest that graphic novels are 'easy' reading and therefore to be dismissed with scorn. Clearly they have not read any of quality, would be my response! This series could equally add to Australian studies as a springboard to discussion of Broome, the Chinese in Australia, the pearling industry and more.
Sue Warren

Ethan's voice by Rachel Carter

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781407135502.
Appropriate for upper primary students, this story is set on an English canal and the central character Ethan lives with his mother and father on a narrow boat. Life is simple for the trio who clearly struggle financially as the father seeks intermittent gardening work and the mother keeps a market stall to help maintain the family.
There is a sense of security, routine and belonging conveyed in the narrative, to the extent that this family is loving and happy despite the hardships. The biggest issue faced in their daily lives is Ethan's inability to speak which has led to taunting and bullying at school and subsequent withdrawal from mainstream education.
Home-schooled on the boat, Ethan is happy roaming and interacting with nature, yet he is clearly a lonely little boy, given that he can only communicate silently with his kindly mother and loving, yet stressed and tense father. When another boat moors nearby, a whole new world opens up for Ethan as Polly, a girl of his age, comes to visit and the pair set out on innocent adventures and exploration of the local environs. Importantly, Polly is a tolerant and undemanding soul who understands Nathan's nature and shows sensitivity regarding the speaking disability.
Narrative development is linked to Nathan's creative writing of a journal, ostensibly for his studies, which reveals the trials and tribulations of a Medieval Page who yearns to become a Knight.
The reason for Nathan's speech impediment is revealed gradually and his capacity to understand and reconcile it provides the framework for the story's conclusion. Within the tale are interesting little references to being blindfolded or not being able to use one's arms in games. This helps to demonstrate that other means can be adopted to fulfill a need, and also that the assistance of others in a trustful relationship is valid.
Ethan's and Polly's mutually beneficial friendship provides companionship, and confiding in each other enables them to cope with life's challenges.
Rob Welsh

I spy pets by Edward Gibbs

cover image

Koala Books, 2013. ISBN 9781742760704.
Preschool picture book with potential.
The game 'I spy' has been popular for generations keeping children occupied on those long and boring car journeys before the advent of electronic games and DVD players. The novel idea of observing the passing countryside seems to have bypassed the current young traveller but the game is alive in this series of picture books.
Edward Gibbs has used the concept of a peephole which neatly fits over one eye of the pet featured. He uses the cut out circle to highlight a colourful part of the animal's body and makes a feature of the adjectives used to describe his clue by employing a bold font. For example 'I spy with my little eye... something with shiny scales.' This clue is also followed by a speech balloon offering another clue generally about the food the animal eats. Turn the page and lo and behold a beautifully detailed goldfish with the hole fitting perfectly over the eye to give a seamless double page spread and another speech balloon with the goldfish declaring 'I am a goldfish'.
This book will be particularly attractive to the preschool reader as they identify the pets which range from a puppy to a chameleon or tortoise and learn a little about them. Other learning opportunities spring to mind talking about direct speech and other features that could be clues for each animal.
Due to the descriptive clue I immediately felt the coloured circle and was disappointed that there was no texture. Too many feelie books given to the grandchildren obviously!
Sue Keane