Reviews

Hana's suitcase by Karen Levine

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781742317679.
(Age:10+) Recommended. War, Holocaust, Japan. As director of the Holocaust Museum in Tokyo, Fumika Ishioka wanted to have something tangible to present to the children who visited. She asked far and wide and only Auschwitz sent a box of things, including a suitcase with a girl's name printed on the top. This started the children visiting the centre, to ask questions, and so a small group of children along with Fumiko, investigated further. When in Prague she went to the Holocaust Museum and there found that the child had been killed at Auschwitz but she had a brother. This then led to further letters and enquiries, and finally the man was found and came to Tokyo to see the museum and talk to the children.
Told in alternate chapters, readers will easily assimilate the information about Hana and her family and what happened to them, alongside the story of Fumiko and her search. Each story compliments the other as we are breathless in wanting to know how each journey unfolds. One is very sad with Hana being killed in a camp, while the other brings her back to life as her brother is found and Hana's dream of becoming a teacher comes true.
The impact of this tale is powerful, its seemingly simple story of reuniting a man with his sister's suitcase is the basis for talk about where they were and why, how one survived and not the other, what happened to the rest of their family, and what happens today in remembering the horror of those times.
The original book is here presented with additions, telling what has happened since, and with additional chapters about Hana's brother, the letters received at the museum from children allover the world, the quilts, the displays, exhibitions and awards received by the original book. All add to the original story and will warm the readers that the story has lived on.
Fran Knight

The poppy by Andrew Plant

cover image

Ford St, 2014. ISBN 9781925000313.
(Age: 9+) Recommended. World War One, Villers-Bretonneux, Diggers, Picture book. The first of many such books to be published in 2014 and 2015, for the one hundred years anniversary of the beginning of World War One, and one hundred years since the first Anzac Day in 1915, this will be put alongside Sally Murphy's Do not forget Australia (Walker Books) and The promise, written by Derek Guille (Scholastic).
Picture books about our involvement in war have appeared consistently in the past several years, so there are plenty to chose from when stocking the library or putting on a display for one or other of the memorial days during the year.
The poppy recognises the commitment and effort made by the Australian, New Zealand and Canadian troops on April 24 1918, in holding back a German advance on the little French town of Villers-Bretonneux. Their courage and sacrifice is recognised by the town, and this book recalls the night many gave their lives. The children of the town chase after a poppy floating over the Rue du Victoria, the Victoria School with Do Not Forget Australia sign in every classroom. Beginning at the war cemetery outside the town, the route of the children and the poppy shows the readers just how Villers-Bretonneux remembers Australia and what was done on that day.
The bold illustrations outlined in black, stare out of the pages, as the children run along, freely because of the efforts made by these men. Several pages are standouts for me; the beginning and end pages reflect each other in giving a view from high over the hills around the town, the middle pages recall war with threatening clouds coming over the horizon rather than showing images of war, and the town itself is shown with its Australian references. As a tool in a class where war is being discussed, or freedom, or remembrance, this can be added to the fine array of books already published.
Fran Knight

Tough times: 1931: do you dare? by S. Mitchell

cover image

Do you dare? series. Puffin, 2014. ISBN 9780143308010.
1931 is a scramble through the mean streets of Melbourne's Fitzroy as seen through the eyes of Max, aged about eleven. It is two years into the Great Depression and unemployment is hitting Australia's working-class families hard. When the book opens, Max's father is still in work as a boot maker, although on reduced hours of two or three days a week. With three children and the family pet, Fungus ('a constant irritation underfoot') to feed, and the mortgage to pay, money is tight. Tom's love for his parents and siblings, especially his four year old brother Petey, are a highlight of the book. Tom's best friends from the Daredevils gang are Samson, whose Dad died in the Spanish Flu outbreak and who is really poor, and Frank, one of six children at a time when families were much larger than they are today. The book appears to be written to engage boys in reading and in history and will probably succeed at both, especially with a vein of backyard 'dunny' humour and bare bums (Fungus bites the seat out of the pants of Razor, the local hoodlum) to sustain them. Girls may find it harder to relate to the adventures, though the only female gang member, Joan, is a thoroughly modern miss and the most daring devil of them all.
The figure who underpins the second part of the book is 'Mac', a benevolent, white-suited gentleman who intervenes on Tom's behalf just as it seems inevitable that his family must be torn apart. Mac is 'Australia's Willy Wonka' - in real life, Sir MacPherson Robertson, founder of Robertson's chocolate factory. In his early life, MacPherson Robertson experienced greater privation than any of the characters in the book and in later life he was a genuine philanthropist. Students can extend their learning to the life and legacy of this great Australian. South Australian children can compare his efforts to counter the worst aspects of the Depression with Sir Edward Hayward's decision in 1933 to initiate the Christmas Pageant to raise the spirits of the people of Adelaide. Other Australian 'icons' such as Phar Lap and six-o-clock closing also provide opportunities to explore the social conventions of the era.
South Australian teachers may be familiar with Max Colwell's book Half Days and Patched Pants and play of the same name. Several scenes in Tough times: 1931: do you dare? would also be very suitable to act out. Even better, in keeping with the era, students could record and present the scenes as a weekly radio show.
I would recommend Tough times: 1931: do you dare? to teachers wanting a springboard into important local and global changes in our society that occurred within the memory of older family members of the students of today.
Francine Smith

Butter by Erin Jade Lange

cover image

Faber, 2013. ISBN 9780571294404.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Obesity. Bullying. Suicide. YALSA 2013 Teens' Top Ten titles, Telegraph's Top 10 YA books 2013. Butter is a lonely, extremely overweight boy who is ignored at school. Although he is a very talented saxophone player, Butter refuses to join the school band and efforts to control his weight have failed. Desperate for recognition, he sets up a website, ButterLastMeal.com, where he announces that he will eat himself to death on New Year's Eve. To his surprise, some of his classmates become morbidly interested in his plan, betting on what he will eat for his last meal and closing off access to the website to only people who can be trusted not to report what is going on.
This is a riveting read; I was totally engrossed as Butter describes how he got his nickname, his mother's futile fluttering about his eating, while enabling it, his father's seemingly indifference to his son and his heart-breaking anonymous online correspondence with Anna, one of the popular girls at school. Lange vividly describes Butter's feelings as he suddenly becomes popular with the in crowd at school. They invite him to go bowling, to parties and to sit with them in the canteen. Their perverse interest in his impending suicide and their attempts to ensure that news of it doesn't reach the authorities are all overlooked by Butter as for the first time he feels that he belongs.
This story delves into the heart and mind of a young man whose obesity governs everything that he does. The reader learns about his feelings, his struggles and his overwhelming need to belong. The bullying, both physical and online is told in a straight forward manner, and none of the characters are black or white, all have flaws and strengths. As a reader I was kept on the edge of my seat as I wondered how Butter would cope when his deadline approached.
This is a book that is a worthy addition to a library, not only because of its themes of obesity and bullying, but because of the way that it grabs the reader's attention.
Pat Pledger

Lost series by Tracey Turner

cover image

A & C Black, 2014.
Lost in the Desert of Dread. ISBN: 9781472907493.
Lost in the Jungle of Doom. ISBN: 9781408194652.
(Age 10+) Themes: Survival, Deserts, Rainforests. The Lost Series by Tracy Turner focuses on survival in four of the most difficult environments in the world. Similar in style to the Choose Your Own Adventure series, the reader is given vital clues to help them navigate the dangers and then after reading the scenario choices a choice is made.
In The Desert of Dread careful choices need to be made to survive the extremes of temperature, scorpions, hungry animals and dehydration. Factual pages help the reader understand why their choices lead to their demise. Topics covered include scorpions, Spotted Hyenas, salt deficiency, using your watch as a compass, sandstorms and sand cats.
The Jungle of Doom explores the frightening dangers of crash landing in the middle of the Amazon Rainforest. Careful reading of the survival tips is needed before the reader starts their journey. The need for water, fire and shelter is vital. Dealing with the predators, vampire bats, jaguars, electric eels and snakes is just part of the journey. With so many dead ends the reader can start again to plot their jungle escape.
These books are factual fiction and more suited to readers from ten and up as they deal with survival and death in harsh environments.
Rhyllis Bignell

Hero on a bicycle by Shirley Hughes

cover image

Walker Books, 2013. ISBN 9781406336115.
(Age: 11+) Recommended. War. Resistance. While his English mother and his sister, Constanza lie awake at night waiting for him to come home, Paolo cycles into Florence from their home, avoiding the many pitfalls that lie in wait for unsuspecting travelers during the last year of World War Two. His own father has joined the partisans in the hills, his family is looked upon with suspicion because their mother is English and their few friends have deserted them.
The war background is described in some detail, as the family goes about its business, waiting for the war to end, hoping their father comes back alive and well. But one night when two men intercept Paolo telling him to pass on a message to his mother, things change dramatically. Pressured into harbouring POW's, the family finds they are involved more deeply than they want to be, and it is Paolo and his bicycle that run the greatest risk.
Taking them into the city the following day, they walk into a trap and one is captured the other returned to the cellar. With Joe hidden, the family risks all, and tension fills the air when the Gestapo comes by ready to search their property.
This is an exciting read of a family pushed to helping the resistance during World War Two. With a fully described background and the fact that it is based upon a family that Hughes knew, the situation will enthrall the readers.
Fran Knight

Out of the Easy by Ruta Sepetys

cover image

Penguin, 2013. ISBN: 9780141347332.
(Age: 15+) Ruta Sepety's second novel takes us to the French quarter of 1950's New Orleans. Amidst the crime and corruption, we meet Josie Moraine, the daughter of a prostitute, who has grown up no stranger to brothel life, but who dreams of more. Josie's dream is to get out of New Orleans and attend college, and she also holds on to the hope that somewhere out there she has a father from whom she may have inherited some good, to balance out her mother's bad.
Sepety's has developed strong characters, whose depth and sense of loyalty paint a strong picture of community within the ghetto of post-war New Orleans. The protagonist, Josie, does seem somewhat larger than life in her ability to remain largely unmarred by the world in which she lives, and the brothel madam is held up as both a heroine and benefactress. While the novel did seem a bit too clean cut for the environment around which it revolved, it was full of fascinating characters and interesting details of community life within this part of the city.
Out of the Easy is an engaging novel that is easy to read but doesn't dumb down the language. It has been elegantly written, though I did feel that the plot, while containing several elements of intrigue, did not have as stronger resolutions as I would have liked.
This is a novel driven largely by character and setting, and both work well to weave a story that left me wanting more. I commend Sepetys for her efforts and would read other books by her.
Certainly not a novel for younger readers, though sexual references are not explicit.
Sarah Rose
Editor's note: Out of the Easy has been nominated for or won many awards, including YALSA Top 10 Fiction for Young Adults.

My Nanna is a Ninja by Damon Young

cover image

Ill. by Peter Carnavas. UQP, 2014. ISBN 9780702250095.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Humour, Family relationships, Love. Some nannas dress in punk, some in blue, but this one dresses in black, setting the scene for this funny tale of difference. Each page gives a familiar scenario for a nanna, how they dress, what they do in their spare time, how they eat, what they do on holiday. Many go swimming or ski or ride but this one practices somersaulting all day long. Some eat with chopsticks, or teaspoons or forks, but this one uses her shiny swords. Finally, it shows how each nanna puts the loved child to bed. Some read a story, some stroke the weary head, saying 'I love you', some yawn loudly, some yodel, but this nanna's kisses can't be heard, but the child knows that she has been there.
Beautiful watercolour illustrations accompany the story of difference, and show the nanna in all of her glory, being part of the child's life even though she does not do all the things the other nannas do. Kids will laugh out loud as each nanna is shown, then on turning the page they find out what the Ninja nanna does. I love the endpapers with the repeated illustrations of the Ninja nanna and the fact that it grew out of reading stories at his child's kindergarten and noticing that the grans were all the same.
This is a tale full of the love of life, despite how you look or act, despite what others do and expect of you. The love and companionship between a child and his grandmother is all that matters, not what they wear or do. In a classroom, this picture book could promote equality and sharing, discussions about difference, and the meaning of family.
Fran Knight

Goddess by Josephine Angelini

cover image

Macmillan Children's Books, 2013. ISBN: 9780330529761.
Goddess by Josephine Angelini is a fantasy novel that is the third and final book in a trilogy about the extravagance of the Greek gods. Helen is a young woman who is a daughter of the powerful Zeus and sister of the beautiful Aphrodite with powerful friends both on earth and on Olympus, Helen is a very powerful young woman. But when she gets flashbacks from the lives of other Helens throughout history and sees her friends playing different roles through time, Helen becomes torn when her one true love in every other life is her cousin in this one! Along with this new revelation, Helen is more powerful than herself and others fathomed due to the accidental combination of the different houses bloodlines with her two closest friends and torn affections, Orion and Lucas. This is a long prophesised occurrence and Helen soon learns something life changing from her uncle Hades about this new development. The world is in danger from the gods and goddesses of Olympus and she is both the cause and the saviour. Helen must quickly find a way to save the man she loves and resist him at the same time while saving the world and her semi-mortal family from her immortal one.
Goddess is a faced paced action novel that draws the reader in with curiosity and mystery, slowing the pace only to allow the timeless romance of forbidden love. This novel is well suited to older teens due to the action and romance themes as well as people who have read the other books in the series. Drawing you in with mythology, Goddess isn't a book that you can put down easily.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

The first voyage by Allan Baillie

cover image

Puffin, 2014. ISBN 9780143307679.
Set in the Stone Age, this novel considers how ancient people were able to migrate to the land mass referred to as Sahul (comprising Australia and New Guinea), the coastlines of which extended much further and which have significantly altered with the passing of the Ice Age.
In Timor, the violently aggressive Crocodile tribe seek to drive the small Yam tribe from the island by opportunistically killing members and trying to provoke battles. Left with nowhere to run and hide, the Yam tribe is doomed unless new territory is discovered and the leader, Eagle Eye chooses to follow migrating birds to a new land. The tribe must find materials and learn how to build and provision rafts for what would have been a terrifying voyage into the unknown.
Told from the perspective of young adolescent warrior Bent Beak, the story cleverly mirrors the experience of present day refugees who are prepared to risk their own and their children's lives on a perilous journey in order to escape violence and death.
Bailey has a considerable freedom to imagine the circumstances and actions of these ancient people and he writes with a great deal of humanity, prompting the reader to deeply consider the plight of desperate people. The nature of leadership is revealed, with Eagle Eye having almost no power to change anything whilst saddled with the responsibility of choosing the best outcome for his people. Ingenuity, group cooperation, roles and relationships are features of this tale which helps us to visualise the enormous task faced by those who came to inhabit our land.
This is a good book for young teenagers yet many will struggle to understand the massive geographical change which made the journey possible. The book's blurb is confusing, stating that it is set 30,000 years ago which does not seem to match the setting or title given the existence of Homo Sapiens in Australia for a minimum 40,000 years. However the 'first voyage' may refer to people venturing from this particular region. Similarly some readers may not comprehend the author's depiction of megafauna including a diprotodon which does not fit the era. The novel would have benefitted from a comprehensive foreword with better diagrams and information than are provided in the brief postscript. This may help young readers to visualise the arrival of ancient ancestors from various regions, joining others already here, by means of island hopping taking place over a huge time scale.
Rob Welsh

Jonathan! by Peter Carnavas

cover image

Ill. by Amanda Francey. New Frontier Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781921928611.
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. Humour. Jonathan loves to dress up and scare his family. He tries his dad and mum and his sister, but they all tell him the same thing, 'Not scary, Jonathan'. Disappointed, he leaves the house only to find a dinosaur. The dinosaur comes home with him and scares the family so much that they run away. A clever twist brings the story back to reality, as Jonathan learns that there are ways to scare people after all.
The seemingly simple story is augmented with witty illustrations, showing Jonathan as he tries to scare his family. The soft water colours suit the foursome, as they go about their daily tasks and activities, the warmth of the colours enveloping a loving family. I love the shadow of the dinosaur creeping over the house, and I love its stance at the door, waggling its hands around waiting to scare the family inside. Kids will love watching Jonathan's antics as well, recognising the stances he takes when disappointed.
In a classroom where different tales about being scared are under discussion, or attempts being made to make scary costumes, or a neat tale of a family, this book will suit a range of activities. And teachers and parents will make use of the repetition within the story to encourage listeners and readers alike to join in.
Fran Knight

How to Convince a Boy to Kiss You by Tara Eglington

cover image

HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN 9780732295189.
(Age: 13+) How to Convince a Boy to Kiss You by Tara Eglington is a fantastically relatable novel that deals with issues such as cyber bullying, heartbreak, insecurity, romance and friendship. The way Tara Eglington writes this inspirational and striking sequel to How to keep a boy from kissing you helps the reader become engrossed in this misshapen fairy tale of a love story and keeps the reader thoroughly interested from start to finish. This novel is suited very well to both younger and older teenage girls who like to read about romance and friendship.
Aurora is a teenage girl who has finally, after testing trials, found her perfect fairytale prince and is working to make her dream relationship become a reality. After a handful of unfortunate occurrences - some that leave her dream boy Hayden in the emergency department - Aurora's dating confidence deflates considerably. Amid this sea of misfortune and uncertainty Aurora's good friend Jelena has started campaigning to become student school captain and plans to include Aurora's Find a Prince/Princess Program as one of her feature campaign points. And, with her alternative dad trying to find love for himself, Aurora tries to find some balance in the her suddenly chaotic life, the fates decide to test her willpower as she keeps calm and fights her way through with warrior princess strength.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

My first book of baby animals by Mike Unwin

cover image

Ill. by Daniel Howarth. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408194645.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Animals. Baby animals. Within a question and answer format on each double page, this book shows many animals and their offspring. The first few pages give information about animals growing up, and how many babies some of the animals have, from an orangutan having just one baby at a time, to a turtle which lays more than one hundred eggs at a time, followed by an introductory 'Who is it?' which is replicated on every right hand page after that. After that the format begins, with the left hand side of the double page showing an animal and its baby, with some information and the right hand side page asking the question, 'Who is it?'
From tigers to giraffes, to polar cubs to puppies and kittens, the layout will draw in the reader wanting to know more about these familiar and not so familiar animals.
On the second to last page is a glossary of words, followed by a neat index, giving a picture of the baby animal, in alphabetical order with a reference page number.
Northern hemisphere it might be, but most of the animals are known and seen by children in the south, if not on television, then in zoos, and presented in this way, gives an easy introduction not only to that animals, and its offspring, but uses the correct terminology and introduces using a contents page, glossary and index.
Fran Knight

The Giggle Gum Tree by Juliet Williams and Elizabeth Botte

cover image

IpKidz, 2009. ISBN 9781921479182.
Lily and Amanda live in a very tall house made of purple bricks - it is so tall that it sways in the wind! Each day, they walk to school through the park and the path passes beneath a tree with beautiful draping branches that makes them giggle and puts them in a good mood for the day. They call it the Giggle Gum Tree. But not everyone likes the Giggle Gum Tree - Mrs Pritchet gets tangled in the branches and Mr Glumper trips over the roots that have broken the path. So they complain to the Tree Police and the girls are dismayed to discover a sign which says that the tree is to be chopped down in five days. They are no longer giggling. Quite by accident, they discover a plan that might save the tree and also the problem of their too-tall house - but will they be able to persuade the grown-ups to accept it?
Although the font is quite small, Miss 7 enjoyed reading this one and although she figured out what the girls' solution might be, how they achieved it brought a smile to her face.
The colourful illustrations are inspired by those in children's books of the 1950s and Miss 7 commented on the way the expressions of both people and creatures had been so well captured.
This is a story that really lends itself to a problem-solving exercise if you stop at the page with the sign and ask, 'Is chopping the tree down the only way to solve the problem?' Students will have fun letting their imaginations roam wild to find solutions and then comparing them to the answer that Lily and Amanda propose.
Barbara Braxton

The brothers Quibble by Aaron Blabey

cover image

Penguin Viking, 2014. ISBN 9780670076000.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Sibling rivalry. Family. All children will see through the antics of Spalding as he tries to deal with the advent of a new brother, Bunny. Spalding has been the only child for quite some time, used to getting his own way from his quiet, unassuming parents, a real 'King of the Castle', complete with cardboard crown. He swings his mighty sword upon his mighty stead, that is, until, Bunny is introduced.
From then on, pushed aside by his doting parents, he decides to cause mayhem, until he is sent to his room. His war footing however, is softened when his brother grows, as babies do, and he calls Spalding by name.
The change is slow, but change does occur. The reader will chortle as Bunny tells Spalding that he loves him, using a ladder to get up to Spalding's room when he is given time out, nestling his head upon Spalding's lap. All of these endearing ways wriggle into Spalding's heart, and as Bunny grows, their relationship changes again, and they are pictured arguing and Bunny hits Spalding with his ugg boot, just like all kids. Brothers at last.
The delectable illustrations from Blabey's brush add to the fun showing the glowering Spalding softening as Bunny becomes endearing, but then Bunny's face in using the ugg boot reflects Spalding's at the start of the book. Blabey's illustrations are just wonderful and add to the general humour and mayhem produced by the two boys.
Fran Knight