Reviews

The Floods: The Royal Family by Colin Thompson

cover image

Random House, Australia, 2014. ISBN 9781742755328.
Is this the final book in The Floods series? As the 13th in the series The Royal Family seems to round off the story of Nerlin and Mordonna but as the Colin Thompson website suggests '..IT MAY WELL BE, THOUGH I WOULDN'T BET MONEY ON IT.'
In the usual chaos and amazingly outrageous and imaginative style of the previous books we are again drawn into the Royal house of Transylvania Waters where we find Nerlin, King of Wizards, wishing to retire from the stresses of Kingship and live out his days in the Enchanted Valley of the Impossible Waterfall raising chickens, ducks and quail. Though Mordonna is not keen to relinquish power, the vexed question of succession must be considered.
Unfortunately not one of their seven children are volunteering for the job, though Satanella decides to change back into a human having been a dog most of her life, and Betty, the youngest and most human like child has a secret desire to become Queen however Mordonna is adamant that she will not succeed.
In a convoluted story Gertrude, Nerlin's twin sister appears from the sewers much his horror when he finds out as he is forced to reveal a family secret that even Mordonna wasn't aware of and doesn't appear on the published family tree.
With Gertrude's help and the support of her siblings, Betty manipulates the situation and uses a bit of magic to achieve her aim while Nerlin enjoys a family reunion.
With the usual extensive referencing, explanations and author comments at the bottom of many pages, author generated illustrations and random additions at the end including Winchflat's Hats and an explanation of Ultimate Super Wizard Powers, the madness loved by all Floods Fans continues.
Sue Keane

This Star Won't Go Out: The Life and Words of Esther Grace Earl by Esther Earl with Wayne and Lori Earl

cover image

Penguin Australia, 2014. ISBN: 9780141354033 'Just be happy, and if you can't be happy, do things that make you happy. Or do nothing with the people that make you happy.' Esther Earl Sometimes reading an autobiography or memoir is so intensely personal that one develops an emotional connection to the hitherto unknown writer that is quite profound. Esther Earl's short life has been encapsulated in this collection of her sketches, letters, journals, photographs and fiction in a way that presents this remarkable teenage girl in the true essence of her sparky and bright personality. It is little wonder that her online presence in the last few years of her life generated such a following and influenced so many others. At age twelve, Esther was diagnosed with thyroid cancer which threw her own life and that of her family into complete disarray but inspiringly, never despair. In 2010, shortly after turning 16, Esther died leaving a legacy of grace, hope and love that continues to provide inspiration to thousands. Celebrated author John Green, a personal friend and fellow nerdfighter, dedicated the best selling The Fault in Our Stars to Esther, naming her as his inspiration for the novel. He also writes a moving introduction to this memoir. Through Esther's creative journaling we are privy to not only her thoughts, aspirations and dreams but her warm and loving family, friends and support network. This is a remarkable book and destined to become one of those that will serve to feed the souls of many who are in similar circumstances as well as inspire others to strive for the stars. Sue Warren

Indonesia: the story of a nation by Adrian Osterley

cover image

Trocadero Publishing, 2013. ISBN 9780864271433.
Indonesia: the story of a nation is part of the Asia-Pacific Relations series and its focus is the story of Indonesia as a nation from its earliest history through to its relationship with Australia today.
Each book has a modern layout with the text presented in manageable chunks accompanied by a range of photos, maps and tables that offer extra insight. A contents page and full index allow for easy location of information.
Even though there seems to be a demand by some to replace non-fiction titles with online resources only, such demands are ill-considered because they are ignoring the evidence that students, even those who are independent readers, prefer and need print resources when they wish to read deeply for meaning rather than just skimming a text as they do with online-based materials, and therefore we have an obligation to meet those needs. These series by this publisher are fulfilling this need with modern Australian Curriculum-related resources very well.
Barbara Braxton

Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell

cover image

Macmillan, 2014. ISBN 9781447263227.
Moving away from home to University is exciting, but for twins Wren and Cath, whose mother left when they were small and whose manic, highly creative father has relied on them for support there are more challenges. Wren decides she wants to live in separate student accommodation upsetting Cath who immerses herself in writing fan fiction as a coping strategy. Cath's 'canon' is the Simon Snow series of books by Gemma Leslie (Harry Potter analogy). Cath has a huge and growing 'fandom' following online for her stories that push the characters from the Simon Snow books into doing things the original author would never do. When she submits one of her stories for a university assignment she is devastated by accusations of plagiarism. There is of course the inevitable love story, which is very engaging and the resolution of the personal growth of the characters is well done but the most interesting for me was the exploration of the issues of intellectual property, creativity, collaboration, and ethics. Fan fiction is a modern phenomenon where stories are shared freely, remixing favourite fictional worlds.
Cath uses it as a stepping stone to finding her own identity and the writing of truly original fiction but for many it is just a way of extending their enjoyment of a book, and that has to be good. Senior secondary readers would enjoy Fangirl; though it is very American in its setting the themes of love and identity are universal. The cover cartoon illustrations of the characters are great and the book club link on the back has some good content.
Sue Speck

Choose Your Own Ever After: How to get to Rio by Julie Fison

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont Australia, 2014. ISBN  9781742977744.
It is refreshing to find a new spin on the Choose Your Own Adventure which was so popular years ago. Whilst from memory many of the old titles were aimed at boys and generally resulted in some paths leading to a fatal end, this book features teenage girls and all endings lead to an 'ever after' full of promise.
Kitty and her friends are about to start school holidays. After a longish introduction to the characters, covering the last few weeks of term and establishing the relationships between the girls and boys, the first choice is made. Does Kitty go camping with her 'besties', or with Persephone to the luxury resort of Paradise Point where, coincidently, Rio, the object of her affections, is also staying?
With camping, bonfires on the beach, pool parties, mobile phone problems and an encounter with members of a boys' band 'The Lads', the story lines become entwined especially when Kitty discovers the camping ground is only a walk away from Paradise Point.
The feel of the story is modern and the dialogue realistic and engaging as the holiday romance blossoms or faces challenges and that not all endings turned out as Kitty might have wished at the beginning. The choices offered are reflective of realistic situations and the dilemmas facing many teenager girls, especially if they are a bit shy as Kitty is portrayed. The beauty of the easy to read writing is that it is not difficult to go back and make a different choice just to see how it turns out.
I look forward to the next Choose Your Own Ever After title just to see what choices will be offered and how they affect the outcome.
Sue Keane

Clementine Rose and the seaside escape by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House, 2014. ISBN 9781742757513.
(Age: 8+) Clementine Rose and the Seaside Escape sees 5 year old Clementine and her family heading for the English seaside while their home is getting a new roof. Clementine meets Della and Freddy. She enjoys spending time with Freddy but tries to avoid Della - she's annoying. Freddy and Clementine love spending time at the beach and are surprised when they find a baby seal. When Della decides to go and investigate at night time, both children go after her, worried she will get into trouble. Watch out Freddy and Clementine, it looks like you might need rescuing!
Clementine Rose and the Seaside Escape is a descriptive novel aimed at girls, who read independently, aged 8+. It is a sweet story with easy to read text and is great for readers moving on to novels. The story is easy to follow, has a definite narrative structure and is accompanied by black and white illustrations.
Kylie Kempster

Wimpy Shrimpy by Matt Buckingham

cover image

Scholastic, 2014. ISBN 97817426761022.
(Age: 4+) Shrimpy is a worry wart so when his friends ask him to play he always says no - what if he got hurt or lost? One day, Shrimpy realises no one has asked him to play and he feels lonely. There is only one way to not feel lonely but is Shrimpy brave enough to play with his friends no matter the consequence?
Wimpy Shrimpy is a cute story about how important it is to try new things and be brave. It has gorgeous illustrations to engage the readers and will be enjoyed by children aged 4+; the text is suitable for independent readers aged 7+ and it would work well with the Child Protection curriculum in schools, encouraging children to discuss ways to be safe and the mixed feelings we can have.
Kylie Kempster

Cycling to Grandma's House by Jac Torres-Gomez

cover image

Ill. by Erin-Claire Barlow. Lulu Publishing. 2014. ISBN 9781483406374.
Luna has a challenge from her teacher . . . 'Find out the most incredible characteristic of being a girl or boy. Then present it to the class on Monday.' But she is flummoxed - what was so special about her that would connect her to every other girl in her town? Knowing she could rely on her to solve the problem, Luna asks hers mother who tells her she does have an idea but 'only the most courageous girl in our town could do a whole project about it.' Luna is intrigued, particularly when her mother says she will have to cycle around town to speak to a lot of women and that it connects not only them but also girls all around the world. And it is then the Luna learns about menarche, a girl's first period, and how different cultures celebrate this critical coming-of-age event.
Luna is excited by the idea and decides to head for her Mexican grandmother's house to find out more. On her way she meets her friends from a host of countries and cultures, and when she explains why she is cycling to Grandma's house, they share their stories of how menarche is treated and greeted. She learns much in such a short trip! When Luna presents her project at school on Monday, she is bombarded with questions, each of which every girl is likely to ask and Luna realises that cycling to Grandma's has been the discovery of a lifetime.
With a granddaughter who is likely to reach this milestone in the next couple of years, I was eager to review a book that addressed an issue not normally featured in a fictional setting. Yes, there are many non-fiction resources available that present the physical facts about menstruation but to find something that addresses the emotional side and could such a great be a conversation starter between mother and daughter is rare. Well-written in a format that straddles the picture book-novel bridge, and beautifully illustrated with bright, engaging pictures, this is a book that needs to be in every library. We need to de-mystify this important event and help our girls to take it as another stride in their journey to independent adulthood, as well as ensuring our boys are informed so they are compassionate rather than embarrassed.
The mission of the team behind this book is to 'empower communities everywhere to understand and address the barriers women face around menstruation'. This book is certainly a step in that direction.
Barbara Braxton

To the wild sky by Ivan Southall

cover image

Text Classic reprint. Text Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922147868.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Thirteen years of age is too young to have to deal with a life threatening emergency but when an aircraft pilot dies from heart failure, a group of children on board are forced to respond.
Gerald, the son of a wealthy pastoralist invites a group of friends to a birthday party at the family sheep station and the group travels in a light aircraft from the town. The lad is much admired by two boys, Bruce and Colin, and a girl, Carol, who is smitten by him. Bruce's twin sister Janet dislikes both Gerald and Colin yet has been invited along with Colin's immature younger brother Mark, from politeness.
Having flown beside his father in the past, Gerald has had the chance to 'take the wheel' and has some rudimentary knowledge of flying which enables him to recover the aircraft when the pilot dies. Maintaining altitude, direction and adjusting engine speed are completely new to him however and his epic struggle to master these over five hours in the face of an enormous dust storm is brilliantly portrayed. The author was a wartime pilot and his knowledge of light aircraft operation enables him to describe the myriad interconnected factors and implications in a way which allows the reader to appreciate the enormity of the situation. The tension is excruciating as Gerald grapples with both the aeroplane and the almost intolerable responsibility to try to save those on board whilst the passengers impotently wrestle their personal terrors.
A crash landing with only minor injuries to those on board is an amazing outcome but the group's trials are only just beginning when they realise that they have no idea where they are and that the chance of rescue is minimal given that they have flown off course for many hours.
Different aspects of leadership, heroism, fortitude and initiative are explored in the events which follow and it is delightful to revisit a story from the sixties which remains solid and captivating for modern readers. Southall writes honestly and does not hold back from revealing gritty and confronting aspects to survival, including the description of what we now call Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. The author was also way ahead of his time in promoting Indigenous pride and respecting the knowledge and skills which enabled survival in extreme environments. Some of the language and social propriety in the narrative is perfectly ridiculous under the circumstances and it is a shame that the convention of the time prevented him from using realistic dialogue. However this is an absolute must-read for those 12 years onwards who relish exciting survival stories.
Rob Welsh

A feast for wombat by Sally Morgan

cover image

Ill. by Tania Erzinger. Omnibus Scholastic, 2014. ISBN 9781742990187.
(Age: preschool) Recommended. Australian animals, Wombats, Friendship. Underground, Wombat does what wombats do, he scratches, snuffles and sleeps. But on waking he feels alone, so decides to go above ground for a dust bath and to see who is there. He finds Magpie, Dingo and Goanna having a wonderful time together. Wombat watches them for a while thinking how special they all are. He talks to Goanna who with its skilful legs can climb the tree without thinking. He offers to teach Wombat how to do this, but Wombat's short stubby legs are not equipped for this task. When he speaks to Magpie he sees what a beautiful voice the bird has and tries to emulate it. But his voice is not nearly as good, and with Dingo he tries to dance but does not succeed. Tired and down at heart, he heads back down his burrow, but the others tell him about his expertise, things they could not do, and invite him to a feast to celebrate.
So the four friends support each other, and the reader learns just what attributes these Australian animals have.
Erzinger, the illustrator has given us a soft edged group of animals, accurately showing each of their size, shape and colourings. No reader would be at a loss to know about these four animals, and may even notice that several other smaller animals make an appearance. A lovely read a loud and sharing book for younger readers.
Fran Knight

The Last Shot by Michael Adams

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316733.
The second book of a trilogy, The Last Shot is a fast paced, gripping read. Set in Sydney and the surrounding countryside in the not too distant future, it picks up the story hot on the heels of The Last Girl. A reader could get away without reading the first book in the series, but would lose a lot of the background . . . and why would you not read it - The Last Girl is a fabulous read as well. The Last Shot continues the dystopian future of a world that has disintegrated when overloaded brains saturated with social media and being plugged in to everyone else's petty everyday trivia suddenly have an evolutionary jump that means everyone is directly wired into everyone else's thoughts, unable to shut anything out. Most people become catatonic, but some escape the vortex of thoughts dragging all into overload.
The events in The Last Shot occur in the second week after 'the snap' that is the premise of the story. Many people by now are dead or dying. There is already a small-scale nasty new world order to contend with, so as well as being a survival story, there is an enemy to evade as well. The many intricacies the author covers in the book would make great discussion material. This novel is not for the squeamish though - it is realistically told, and many characters die.
Adam's trilogy (The Last Place will be published in 2015) is definitely a set for the school library. These books are on a par with John Marsden's Tomorrow When the War Began series and should appeal to many readers. Teachers considering this as a class novel would need to choose the first book, probably for Yr 10, and then make sure there are several copies of The Last Shot in the library!
Ann Veitch

Tigers on the Beach by Doug Macleod

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780143568520.
Previously, I read and reviewed Doug Macleod's CBCA Book of the Year short-listed The Shiny Guys. It was a gritty and macabre meditation on mental health, laced with experimental technique and dark humour. Macleod's most recent venture, Tigers on the Beach, while still tackling difficult subject matter (death) is much more whimsical and upbeat. Despite this new approach, the author's trademark biting wit and meticulous attention to detail are retained.
Tigers introduces us to Adam, an inquisitive and highly likeable teenage boy. The sudden passing of his cheeky grandfather sets into motion a series of events, including his extended family and their respective issues, and his own adolescent trials, particularly first love.
Two aspects of this novel stand out in particular. Firstly, the balance between elements is astonishingly sensitive and effective. Doug Macleod presents storytelling with humour and pathos, the absurd and the banal, contemporary and nostalgia, autobiography and originality. He does so in an uncannily natural and poignant way.
The second aspect of this novel which deserves praise is the author's talent for creating clever and engaging dialogue which flows beautifully. Each twist and turn-of-phrase highlights the wonderfully developed cast of characters and their dynamic interactions in a manner which is completely enthralling.
Without this, the novel would not be as strong, as the sharp dialogue and pace injects new life into the 'dysfunctional family' cliche.
The novel concludes with touching resolve and closure. I enjoyed Tigers on the Beach more than almost any book I have reviewed this year - it is a charming and anecdotal work, with a fine balance of emotional naivete and strength which will appeal to many readers.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

Women who made Australian History by Aisling Marlor

cover image

Trocadero, 2014. ISBN 9780864271464.
Immigrants who changed Australia . . . since 1901 by Victoria Macleay. Trocadero, 2014. ISBN 9780864271259.
Imperial China: Six centuries of all-powerful dynasties by Matthew Williams. Trocadero, 2014. ISBN 9780864271457.
Continuing the tradition, Trocadero Publishing have released three new titles in their series which matches the Australian Curriculum so well.
Women who made Australian History, from the They Made Australia series, introduces, acknowledges and celebrates women who have had a significant impact on what our nation is today. From the well-known such as Daisy Bates and Caroline Chisholm and Mary Reiby to the not-so such as Tilly Aston, Faith Bandler and Lucy Osburn, there are snapshots of their contributions covering almost every aspect of life succinctly detailing their work and paving the way for a deeper investigation of the impact of their achievements.
Immigrants who changed Australia . . . since 1901, from The National Identity, focuses on people whose names are familiar but whose origins are overseas. Many are names who are claimed by Australia as their own but who, in fact, came here with their family as a child or made the move later in life and have helped put this nation on the map for a range of reasons. While there are waves of immigrants who come here, such as the Chinese in the goldrush and the Europeans after the war, and whose impact is well documented and studied, this title focuses on the individuals whose stories may not have been told so often. From the familiar stories such as Petrov spy scandal, Simpson and his donkey and the achievements of Olivia Newton-John and Russell Crowe to the lesser known such as Tan Le, Charles Moses and Jennie Baines, the contributions of over 50 newcomers are outlined.
Both of these titles beg the question of who would today's generation add if they were asked to contribute a name and a story. Who has been left out that should be there? Should their heroes stand the test of time and are they likely to do so?
In Imperial China, from Asia-Pacific Timelines, the Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties who each claimed the 'Mandate of Heaven' as their god-given right to rule are put under the spotlight, From 1271 to the collapse of the Imperial system in 1911, students are introduced to the critical people and events of this time.
As with all the other titles that this publisher is producing to support the Australian Curriculum, particularly those topics in the Yr 5-8 band, each book has a modern layout with the text presented in manageable chunks accompanied by a range of photos, maps and tables that offer extra insight. Arranged in either alphabetical or chronological order, there are very easy to navigate.
Even though there seems to be a demand by some to replace non-fiction titles with online resources only, such demands are ill-considered because they are ignoring the evidence that students, even those who are independent readers, prefer and need print resources when they wish to read deeply for meaning rather than just skimming a text as they do with online-based materials, and therefore we have an obligation to meet those needs. These series by this publisher are fulfilling this need with modern Australian Curriculum-related resources very well.
Barbara Braxton

The ratcatcher's daughter by Pamela Rushby

cover image

Angus & Robertson, 2014. ISBN 9780732297138.
(Age: 11+) Recommended. Historical fiction, Plague, Australian history. A little known part of our early twentieth century is highlighted in this descriptive account of Brisbane in the first years of the new century, playing host to a disease only found in accounts of Medieval times. When thirteen year old Issy becomes a maid in an undertaker's house, she has never seen a dead body but the sight of a dead child and the ritual of burial becomes a fascinating backdrop to the life she is about to enter, as an inmate in a quarantine centre out of the city. Her father is a rat catcher, and from the start the reader is made aware of the increasing number of rats in the city, and when she helps her friend with her job as a maid at the local doctor's house, she overhears a conversation about a disease coming closer to Australia. It is only when the boy next door dies of appalling swellings that she hears the word,'plague' for the first time, and puts together the things she has heard.
This is an engrossing read. Rushby incorporates the inability of those in government to deal adequately with the disease and its consequences, the fear of many as they shun their friends, the over reaction of local authorities, the situation in the hastily erected quarantine camp outside the city and the divide between rich and poor, allowing those with money to be treated at home. In watching Issy learns that even her trusted employer is involved in protecting the rich from the ignominy of the disease.
Issy bravely carries on, and when her father becomes ill with the other appalling disease which caused he deaths of many, Influenza, she takes over his business, learning that there is more to life than being a maid in someone else's home. An entertainingly rich read about past times and a young woman's coming of age as she perceives there is life outside the narrow restrictions of the past.
Fran Knight

Bring on the birds by Susan Stockdale

cover image

Working Title Press, 2014. ISBN 9781921504594.
(Age: Pre-school) Recommended. Birds, Environment. In simple rhyming text, Stockdale showcases a number of birds, their bold bright colours standing out from the spare backgrounds. Each of the twenty three birds chosen for this book is presented on an unadorned page, making the bird and its plumage stand out for younger readers. The birds include, an owl, penguin, ostrich, peacock and crane, and while they are designated as swooping birds or swimming birds in the text, it is at the end that we find their real names and information about each bird illustrated.
Stockdale cleverly presents exotic birds in the majority of her book, coming closer to home towards the end with a heron, duck and robin, the final robin shown with children watching through the window. In this way she refines the number of birds known by the child bringing it back to something they may have seen themselves, watching in the garden. The bold illustrations, accompanied by large print text makes it easier for a child to read for themselves, or an adult to read out to a child, asking them to recognise things about the birds illustrated. Because she puts the birds into a category (eg diving or swimming) the text allows the child to ask questions or the reader to encourage questions or to give information. This is a user friendly book for pre-school age children introducing them to a wide variety of birds and how they behave.
Fran Knight