Reviews

American Savage by Matt Whyman

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2014. ISBN 9781471400698.
In this sequel to The Savages the family has moved to the US to avoid discovery of their cannibalism. Mother, Angelica has become a fitness fanatic while father Titus is putting on weight - 'it is inevitable that meat sourced from these parts would carry a little extra fat' p11. Son Ivan tries to fit in by joining the football team at school but he is not good at it and is being bullied while the vegan lodger Amanda is having trouble finding work. The other members of this tight knit family are the kindy aged Katya and grandfather Oleg all of whom have strong family values - 'a family who ate people together stayed together' p44. The cannibalism is explained as sustainable, there being too many humans on the planet, and targeted, only loners who no-one would miss. Slaughtering is done humanely and the meat respectfully eaten. The vegan character does not have a problem eating human as it complies with all her food principles. No horror here but somehow more disturbing. Ivan looked at his bullies 'not as empty jocks but as tender cuts' p87 Angelica's decision when her personal trainer becomes enamoured is to direct Titus to make him the next victim as he would be leaner than their usual meat.
I found the characters' ordinariness and the cannibalism over-explained and the plot hampered by this. There is some compromise found in the end but the story struggled to engage. Middle school students might like the idea of such a family and extreme problem solving. I doubt they would find the moral aspect an issue.
Sue Speck

Juicy juicy green grass, and other fun songs by Peter Combe

cover image

Ill. Danielle McDonald. Scholastic, 2014. ISBN 9781743620648.
(Age: 3-6) Picture book, Songs, Humour. Four songs, Juicy juicy green grass, The silly postman, Tadpole blues and Red says stop are included in this brightly illustrated and attractive book for pre- school children. Accompanied by a CD with Peter Coombe singing these songs, they will be able to be preformed easily by a group of younger children or used as a sing a long.
The first song, Juicy juicy green grass bemoans the fact that the grass has now died, and the sheep singing the song is waiting for its source of nourishment to return. The sheep eats green grass for breakfast, lunch and dinner and is very hungry. The silly postman brings along an increasing number of things when he deposits a letter in the letterbox until her got the sack. Tadpole blues has a tadpole going through the changes it needs to become a frog, and being very worried about what is happening to its body. Red says stop is about the traffic lights and what each colour means.
Each song is amusing and will have children easily singing along, while taking in an important message. Each is a learning tool for younger learners.
Fran Knight

Friday Barnes 1: Girl Detective by R. A. Spratt

cover image

Random House Australia Children's, 2014. ISBN: 9781742759623.
(Age: 10+) No doubt you would all be familiar with the wonderful world of Nanny Piggins. Now R. A. Spratt introduces us to a new character, Friday Barnes, who I am certain will prove every bit as popular as the porcine prima donna.
Friday Barnes is a Matilda-esque child, thoroughly neglected by her remote scientific parents - the surprise and unplanned child after a neatly organised delivery of four older siblings. Left basically to her own devices for eleven years, Friday is an exceptionally intelligent girl who has read everything she can lay her hands on (starting with all the scientific texts which are the only reading matter in her house). Her only respite from the remoteness of her parents and her carefully camouflaged presence at school is the weekly contact with her Uncle Bernie, an insurance investigator.
When Uncle Bernie is faced with a terrible investigation (the theft of a diamond necklace worth squillions) that seems unsolvable, Friday decides he needs her help and with the resourcefulness of her own clever brain plus the help of her fictional hero, the great Poirot, Friday reveals the culprit and earns herself a huge reward.
Friday is not a mercenary child but the reward money solves her own problem - where to go to high school (since the university turned her down though she blitzed the entrance exam - apparently they weren't prepared to take on a 11 year old student!). She promptly pays her fees for the most exclusive school in the country, Highcrest Academy, figuring that attending a school which operates on a profit margin, it will at least be easier to bribe her way out of sporting events.
What Friday does not count on is that far from being anonymous at Highcrest, she suddenly finds herself investigating problems from missing homework to wildlife smuggling as well as dealing with some of the nastier pupils.
While Friday still hasn't figured out the point of high school, she has gained her first friends ever and solved some very tricky mysteries - just by being herself.
Readers, particularly girls, of about 10 plus will greatly enjoy this fun read.
Sue Warren

Rory and the Monstersitter by Rosie Reeve

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 978140884551.  
Highly recommended for readers aged 5+, young children with an adult, and independent readers aged 7+. Rory and the Monster Sitter had me smiling and if Rory's mum and dad ask you to babysit then say no! Rory and the Monstersitter is a lovely picture book about a young monster, Rory, who loves to cook. When his parents go out, Rory has the chance to cook something (or someone) new for dinner. The babysitter?
The pictures are detailed, the characters funny and the story short. It would be a great story to read to children in the classroom and use to deconstruct a narrative. It is also good for looking at alternative ending to stories.
Kylie Kempster

Magic Animal Friends: Lucy Longwhiskers gets lost by Daisy Meadows

cover image

Orchard Books, 2014. ISBN 9781408326251.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Magic Animal Friends: Lucy Longwhiskers gets lost is a short novel aimed at girls aged 8+. Lily and Jess are best friends and it is holidays. They both love animals and enjoyed helping around Lily's family animal hospital. Imagine their surprise when they discover Friendship Forest, a magical place with talking animals. They are brought to Friendship Forest by Goldie the cat who the girls had looked after in the human world. Goldie believes the Forest is in danger and needs the girls to help with a witch.
Magic Animal Friends: Lucy Longwhiskers gets lost is a quick moving adventure for girls and is highly recommended for independent readers just moving into novels. The text is easy to read and will appeal to any girl who loves animals and magic.
Kylie Kempster

Happy Pants by Heather Gallagher

cover image

Ill. by Liz McGrath. Wombat Books, 2014. ISBN 9781921632938.
(Age: Pre-school - 2) 'When mummy wears her happy pants we build sandcastles, go out for babycinos and have lots and lots of cuddles.' But things change dramatically when she comes home with Baby Darcy - her happy pants stay in the wardrobe. No matter what, there is no more happy mummy. Even though Daddy steps up, there's nothing quite like a happy mum. Feeling betrayed and confused when nothing he does works, things come to a head for the family when the happy pants are accidentally ripped and the little boy asks, 'How can you put a band-aid on your heart?' Even though the focus is on sad feelings, Liz McGrath's bright illustrations keep it from being a sombre story and there is such a feeling of hope towards the end that you just know mummy will have her happy pants on again one day.
With perinatal depression affecting one in seven women, this is an important book to have in the library's collection so that young children who are in such a situation can learn that they're not the only child with a sad mummy, it is not their fault and that things can get better. Primarily written for a preschool audience, nevertheless there are many in the F-2 cohort who are welcoming new siblings and who must be at risk of being in a family where PND happens.
At the same time, it has a place in your parents' collection so sufferers and their partners can understand that help is available. It includes a range of organisations that can offer support for those who suffer, and their families, but it's most important purpose, in my opinion, is to bring this condition into the open where it can be talked about as a common occurrence, not something that is to be ashamed of or to feel guilty about. It is more than just 'baby blues'. Normalising it through a children's picture book is a powerful way to do this, particularly if it is promoted through your links with the new parents in your community.
There's an interview with the author that is worth reading.
Barbara Braxton

Dancing on knives by Kate Forsyth

cover image

Vintage Books Australia, 2014. ISBN 9780857983466.
(Age: Senior secondary) Recommended. Dancing on knives is an original story of a dysfunctional family living in a coastal town in New South Wales. The story is largely told through the eyes of Sarah, the eldest girl, who has made herself a prisoner in her own home for five years. She suffers from acute anxiety which Forsyth describes with both vivid clarity and sensitivity. The view of Sarah '(creeping) inside like an injured animal seeking sanctuary' and 'failure tasting like vomit in her throat' (p146) evoke compassion rather than frustration. Sarah is reminiscent of Laura in The glass menagerie but for Sarah the addiction is romance novels which she consumes voraciously as her choice of mind-opiate, but does little to satisfy her until she discovers Women in love which strikes a resounding chord.
In her 'prison' Sarah is surrounded by her three brothers, of whom Tom is the most understanding, and a stepsister, the brat, Kate. But with the use of flashbacks we are also introduced to her now deceased mother and her more influential grandmother Consuela who has left her the silk wrapped Tarot cards 'to help her see more clearly'. But what pervades this particular menagerie is the tempestuous Augustus, the father, who has a wild passion born out of his Spanish ancestry and his artistic disposition. Gus's moods set the tone for the house so when he disappears only to be found later hanging from a cliff the household is sent into further disarray, particularly as questions concerning the cause of his accident arise. This is the suspense which holds the plot together, but this novel is far from just a mystery. Its strength lies in Forsyth's ability to develop her characters deeply so that, as far as this world may be from our own, we can at some level relate to and empathise with them.
Like the Little mermaid in the brutal story of her childhood, Sarah is dancing on knives and we only hope that one day she may escape such torture.
Barb Rye

Kelsey and the quest of the porcelain doll by Rosanne Hawke

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2014. ISBN 9780702253317.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Pakistan. Floods. Family. Dolls. When Kelsey goes to Pakistan where her parents will assist with the aftermath of devastating floods, the girl is unsympathetic. She would prefer to stay at home with her friends, her bedroom with its collection of Barbie dolls, her friend's swimming pool and her beloved Nanna Rose. But little by little she becomes involved in the lives of the family of her father's co-worker, and begins to open her eyes to the chaos that has destroyed their lives. While she watches her father help build new houses for those who have lost everything they had, and her mother attend to those who come into her clinic, Kelsey befriends Shakila, and offers her the doll she brought with her from Australia.
Communicating via Skype, Nanna Rose sees just how ill-at-ease Kelsey is at the start and begins to tell her a story which continues every time they speak. The story of Amy Jo, a porcelain doll which is posted to a little girl, gets lost in the process then has a quest to find her owner and the person who will love her. The two stories are told in alternate chapters, and eventually intersect but not before the reader has been given an insight into another country which will stay with them long after the book is finished. Rosanne's stories always have an underlying affinity for those with lives far less comfortable than our own, opening the readers' hearts and minds to people living in quite different worlds, showing us that our thoughts are not so different, as we all value family, friendship and love.
With this wonderful story, Kelsey's eyes reflect the devastation of the floods, the tireless efforts by many to rebuild Pakistan, and so makes the background of the people's lives an important part of the story.
For classes, this would be an essential part of any unit concerned with multiculturalism, looking at other countries, taking a world view of society and specifically teaching about Pakistan.
Fran Knight

Ten Christmas crackers by Karen Erasmus

cover image

Hachette, 2014. ISBN 9780734415622.
(Age: 4-6) Picture book. Christmas. Sung to the tune of 'Ten green bottles', this countdown to Christmas Day via the many things we associate with Christmas, is the first Christmas book I have seen this year, and there are still six months to go!
The bright breezy illustrations are sure to appeal to a younger audience, obsessed with the trappings of Christmas, the tree, crackers, Santa Claus, Christmas pudding and presents for example.
Each double page counts the number down from ten to one, ten being the crackers, and one being the present. Other pages include 8 flying reindeer, 3 Christmas stockings, which roll easily off the tongue, while a few like North Pole elves, and handmade presents, are a little clumsy to say. Children will enjoy rehearsing and getting their tongues around some of the lines, and practice will always make it sound better.
The whole spirit of the book revolves around family and doing things together, pages show children with their pet dog, parents and grandparents. It has a warm feel to it, which overrides the image now usually associated with Christmas, that of giving more and more presents. The image is of the children doing something: busking, helping with making the pudding, making their parents' presents, while a nice touch is the single Christmas stocking on each bed.
This would be a fun addition to the Christmas story books in the classroom or library, ready for the last month of the year.
Fran Knight

Let her go by Dawn Barker

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2014. ISBN 9780733632228.
The blurb of this book suggests it is 'part thriller, part mystery'. It is neither of these. It is instead a family saga based around the complications of surrogacy.
As a result of suffering from lupus, Zoe McAllister discovers she is unable to have children and her sister Nadia agrees to be the surrogate. What follows is the long and drawn out account of what happens after the child, Louise, is born. This family, it seems, is never happy. Zoe lives in fear that she will lose her daughter and Nadia suffers from guilt and longing for the child she agreed to 'relinquish'. Lachlan, Zoe's husband quits his job in the Kalgoorlie mines but comes home a changed man, the reasons for which are not revealed until the end of the story. Throughout the narrative Baker makes the reader privy to the innermost thoughts of both Nadia and Zoe in an attempt to show both sides of the dilemma. This however does not always generate the reader's sympathy for either character. The male characters, husbands of the stepsisters, are only shallowly drawn, which may be the way of things in this situation but the love that is supposed to exist between Lachlan and Zoe is only stated and rarely shown.
One character who is clearly portrayed is the teenage Louise. With her, Baker reveals the angst of being a teenager, who simultaneously wants the love and affection of her parents but also fights against them.
In Let her go Barker wanted to 'make people think and talk about the ethical issues of surrogacy and the psychological effect on everyone one involved' (p332) and, in this, she succeeds but the road to eliciting that discussion is not always gripping or entertaining.
Barb Rye

My grumpy day by Felicity Gardner

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2014. ISBN 9780734415448.
Picture book. My grumpy day is the second book by Felicity Gardner to feature Max, the very cute gorilla. Written to be shared by preschoolers and their carers, it invites a discussion of the emotions we all experience, especially dealing with 'the grumps'.
Max lives in the jungle with his family and a wide circle of animal friends and is usually quite cheerful, however this day he wakes up grumpy. Everything it seems is wrong. His cereal, which looks remarkably like Froot Loops, is 'yucky', he doesn't want to share, play games with his tutu wearing friends or play in the pool. He just wants to be left alone, much to the surprise of a pack of curious meerkats. Max finds that's no fun either especially when he sees his friends sharing a picnic lunch.
Mum of course has the solution when he apologises for his behaviour and confesses to having 'the grumps'. There is no cure better than a kiss, a cuddle and a good laugh.
The colourful full page illustrations enable the reader to see Max's range of facial expressions as he grumps through the day, including a tearful Max watching the picnic, contrasting with the other animals enjoying themselves as they share and interact with each other.
The simple language of the story is easy to read with his complaints highlighted in eye-catching colours and textures, as is the solution. Finally we see Max rolling around laughing and bringing balloons to share at the picnic in an ending banishing 'the grumps' at least for now.
Sue Keane

The protected by Claire Zorn

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2014. ISBN 9780702250194
(Age: 14+) Recommended. On the front cover A. J. Betts describes The protected as 'a tender story of grief, trust and healing - Hannah broke my heart'. Nothing could be more accurate.
The story is told in Hannah's voice as she reveals both her life after her sister's death in a road accident and, with flashbacks, to the time before. It is through these flashbacks that the reader is given an insight into the horrible life that was Hannah's first years of high school, where she was the victim of vicious physical and cyber bullying. In her own words she describes herself as 'a floater' who is subjected to the 'dead animal stares' of Tara and her 'clones'. But the most poignant and heart wrenching aspect of Hannah's ostracism is the loss of her best friend, Charlotte, who gradually shifts her allegiance to the clones. In one short sentence, 'Eventually the 'merger' happens.' Zorn powerfully evokes the shifting relationship of these two once close friends until eventually Hannah realises that despite Charlotte's attempts '(Hannah) was only a piece of sentimental childhood memorabilia she couldn't bring herself to throw away'
Hannah's clear unselfpitying reflection on what is happening only adds to the sympathy we feel for her.
Then Hannah's sister Kate is killed in a car accident in which her father was the driver and she, another passenger. The family is almost completely destroyed: her mother is incapable of doing anything and her father struggles on after sustaining considerable injuries. Ironically, for Hannah, it is this event which changes her school life. Although she is still a 'floater' she is no longer bullied and even strikes up a friendship with Josh Chamberlain, who being new to the school, is oblivious to the school social structure.
The climax of the story should be her father's court case where Hannah is required to give evidence, but cleverly Zorn downplays this event creating a more realistic move towards healing than a sudden revelation that may have been used by other more sensationalist writers.
While there is much to feel sympathy with in this novel, there is another side as well. Hannah's sister Kate is not the loving and caring sister: she disowns Hannah at school and fails to protect her from the bullies, fearing instead for her own social status. Also with the pathos there is humour, albeit sometimes black, that adds another dimension. Zorn's description of Mrs Rorke the maths teacher 'continuing the noble tradition of torturing students with trigonometry' being just one example.
In The protected Zorn vividly and entertainingly portrays the time and place in which this novel is set by her creation of realistic characters and authentic use of language.
Barb Rye

Our island by the children of Gununa and Alison Lester and Elizabeth Honey

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780670077687.
'Our island lies beneath a big blue sky,
surrounded by the turquoise sea.
Turtles glide through the clear salt water.
And dugongs graze on the banks of seagrass...'
And so begins the text of a most stunning pictorial book about Mornington Island, the largest of the Wellesley group in the Gulf of Carpentaria, the result of a collaboration by the children of Gununa - the main township - and Alison Lester and Elizabeth Honey. Focusing on the stunning wildlife that inhabits both land and sea, the illustrations have been done by the children of Mornington Island State School using wax crayons and food dye wash. This makes the focal point of the pictures stand out against the background which blurs and blends as dyes do and the landscape does. Beginning with the sunrise and following through the day until the ghost crabs make patterns on the sand, the local dogs sing to the moon and the island finally sleeps, this is a celebration of life in a unique environment where the connection between the land and life is almost indivisible. Even though the text is kept to a minimum, the choice of words has been carefully selected to match the pictures giving the whole thing a poetic quality that echoes the rhythm of the day, emphasising the gentle passage of time. Overall, a sense of peace and pride just exudes from this book.
The stories of both the island and how this book came about are fascinating in themselves - all royalties and a dollar from each sale are going back to the school to fund community art projects - and provide another layer to what is already an amazing book.
Each of us lives in a unique community, whatever its geographical setting, that has its own special undercurrent of life that goes on and on, providing a continuity that might be interrupted by humans but not destroyed. How fascinating it would be to have students look beneath the surface of their everyday lives to discover what is there, how it is sustained, how it is impacted by us and then use Our island as a model to share the findings. Students would have to draw on all their senses and cross all curriculum boundaries to discover and portray the daily, unchanging routines of nature that cycle on through their lives.
A wonderful work that will probably make the reader want to book a trip to an island paradise immediately!
Barbara Braxton

Magic animal friends: Molly Twinkletail runs away by Daisy Meadows

cover image

Orchard Books, 2014. ISBN 9781408326268.
Rainbow magic books have been a popular choice for six to eight year old girls transitioning to chapter books. Magic animal friends is a new series from the same group and aimed at a similar audience. Molly Twinkletail runs away is the second book of this series featuring friends Jes Forester and Lily Hart and a magical forest populated by cute talking animals.
As Jes and Lily set off to help in the Wildlife Hospital run by Lily's parents they encounter Ginger the cat which had guided the girls to Friendship Forest on their first adventure. Once again they enter the magical forest and meet their talking animal friends who are preparing for a fair. Here they encounter Molly Twinkletail who loves helping, but being so small, is not allowed to help on the family stall and so is offering her help to all and sundry.
Just as Molly scampers off, Grizelda the evil witch appears. She is determined to take over the forest, making it a dark and gloomy place. This time she has sent her servants, the dirty, ugly Boggits, to destroy the Treasure Tree from which all the animals gather their food. It is up to the girls and their animal friends to save the tree, rescue Molly who has tried to help the Boggits by getting them a drink and send the Boggits back to Grizelda's Tower.
With the sparkly cover, map of Friendship Forest, easy to read text interspersed with line drawings of cute animals and the ugly Boggits, this series follows the formula which has been so successful in the past for the Rainbow magic group, this time drawing on a love of small creatures rather than fairies.
Sue Keane

The destiny of Violet and Luke by Jessica Sorensen

cover image

Sphere, 2014. ISBN 9780751552621
(Age: 18+) Be warned, the language in this story of star-crossed lovers is 'strong', there is a very explicit description of sexual intercourse, the story includes drug taking and ends in a very dark way. If this is still for you and your school fiction collection, read on. Violet, a beautiful and contemptuous young woman, has been traumatised by witnessing the killers of her parents leaving their bodies, and by the years of unfeeling foster-parenting that follow. Luke, an attractive but sexually ruthless freshman, has been traumatised by his mother's neglect and insistence that he inject her with heroin. Violet eventually becomes a drug dealer, though not user, and meets Luke at university. Both are keen to succeed and work to support themselves. Both are unpredictable and unstable, but are attracted to each other and gradually form a loving relationship, the first in their lives. They share a small apartment with several others and seem to be building trust. However, this fragile connection is destroyed when the investigation into Violet's parents' murders is reopened. Together they realize that Luke's mother is implicated. Violet abandons hope of happiness and in despair returns to an abusive drug-dealing foster parent. The novel has the ring of a soap opera, as the characters are unbelievably attractive and their smouldering passion continues to grow despite attempts at rejection and outbursts of rage. Young readers may find interest in the off-on relationship and in the drama of the murder, but the story ends in a very dark way, and there is not a lot of literary merit in it.
Jenny Hamilton