Reviews

Malini by Robert Hillman

cover image

Through my eyes series. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743312551
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Sri Lanka. War. Heroism. Religion. Surivival. When Malini is told by her father to run into the forest with her younger sister and hide, she does as she is told. All the villagers have been rounded up and herded to the coast where they will be used as a human shield, to slow the advance of the Sinhalese Army. Few will survive. It is 2009 and the civil war which has devastated much of north eastern Sri Lanka after the withdrawal of the British in 1948 is coming to a close.
Malini and her sister, Banni, must survive as best they can, refugees in their own land, eating what they can find, travelling carefully, hoping to find their grandfather's village many miles away before the soldiers of either side find them. Along the way they come across a group of three children also displaced by the war, and Malini cares for them too, all the while feeling beyond her age of fourteen. Their journey across Sri Lanka, exposes the atrocities on both sides, the impact of war on the ordinary people, the reasons behind the war. Above all we see the effect of such conflict on the children. Malini and her family are Tamil, from the north, and have been taught Sinhalese and English alongside their own language, being encouraged to accept all faiths. The children they meet are Sinhalese as is the girl who saves them from the soldiers, giving the reader an insight into the feelings of both communities.
Another in the excellent series Through my eyes, Malini will encourage students to view the unrest in other parts of the world through the eyes of a person their own age. With the civil war in Sri Lanka now at an end, readers will gain insights into the effect of war on the ordinary household, village or community. There is a timeline of the events in Sri Lanka since 1948, as well as a glossary and web addresses to find out more information, while others in this series are displayed at the end of the book. Highly recommended for classes where discussion of other countries is under way, or perhaps a literature circle is being undertaken using all the books in the series, or a book is being read aloud, the easy flowing text and appeal of the courageous main characters will ensure kids are hooked from the start. Insights into the Buddhist and Hindu beliefs of Sri Lanka sit alongside the themes of war, courage and refugees.
Fran Knight

Celia and Nonna by Victoria Lane and Kayleen West

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2014. ISBN 978925000603 (hardback). ISBN 978192000601 (paperback).
(Ages: 4+) Highly recommended. Some very apt books have come my way in the last week or so and this is one of them. This gentle and loving story of a little girl and her much-loved Nonna, and the changes that occur when Nonna's memory starts to fail is so very pertinent to our family at the present time.
It is difficult for little ones to understand that aging family members cannot always remember things, or indeed that they may change where they live. On Friday we celebrated my mother's 88th birthday and at times it is tricky for the two youngest great-grandchildren to understand why Nanny now lives in the place she does, or why she doesn't remember everything. Celia loves sleeping over at her Nonna's place. She always has a fuss made of her and she and Nonna cook together and play special games, but when Nonna starts to forget things, locks herself out of the house and so on, Nonna moves to a special place where people can help to keep her safe. There is no room for Celia to sleep over any more and nowhere to cook but there is room to put lots of drawings up on walls of the fun things that are special memories. In just the same way, Miss Just-Turned-Five spends much time creating beautiful artwork for her great-grandmother, just to make sure Nanny knows how much she is loved.
It was difficult for me to read this without emotion because of the intensely personal circumstances but this is a superb book to share with little people who are facing changes in their family due to aging, dementia or Alzheimer's disease.
The text and illustrations are simple, gentle and suitably engaging for a young audience and the endpapers are truly gorgeous (many of my friends and students know about my rapture over endpapers!).
Highly recommended for home and library shelves for sharing with small people from around 4 and up.
Sue Warren

Phyllis Wong and the return of the conjuror by Geoffrey McSkimming

cover image

Phyllis Wong Mysteries. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743318379
(Age: 9+) Recommended as a fun fictional fantasy for young readers. Mystery. Adventure. Time Travel. Magic. Illusion. This is a magical gem! The central character Phyllis Wong is a well-practised conjuror/prestidigitator that, despite her youth, uses her fast-fingered skills with sleight of hand tricks to entertain. Her staged actions to overcome a class bully lead to school suspension and ultimately a strange meeting in time with her Great-grandfather who was himself a renowned performer of illusion tricks. Time travel follows and almost coincidentally she becomes involved in a major police investigation into a potential crime involving the first folios of Shakespeare's play. Her ability to travel back in time enables her to meet the Bard and prevent a major injustice.
One of the delights of this book is her connections to some quirky adults and an extremely eccentric school friend.
This book is a highly entertaining narrative, with mystery, adventure, time travel and Shakespearean history united with a highly competent and independent female lead character who displays amazing intellectual skills and organisation. Her friend, Clement, is the ultimate bizarre sidekick, who adds a considerable comic element to her adventures in time.
Carolyn Hull

One minute's silence by David Metzenthen

cover image

Illustrated by Michael Camilleri. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316245.
Highly recommended for both Primary and Lower/Middle Secondary. As we approach the end of the year and Remembrance Day, as well as the ongoing centenary commemoration of World War 1 and the ANZACs' role, this powerful and deeply moving picture book will be a must-have for your collection.
We are all aware of David Metzenthen's skill as a writer and now combined with dramatic and poignant illustrations by Michael Camilleri, this is a book that begs to be shared across many year levels.
Beautifully told from both the Australian and Turkish perspectives, Camilleri chose to depict the combatants, using Year 12 students from the Sophia Mundi Steiner School as models, in contemporary dress and using both genders. This has the effect of visually demonstrating that ordinary young people were caught up in a bloody conflict of extraordinary proportions.
The traditional 'one minute's silence' is used as the recurring motif throughout the text as moments of huge impact are recounted solemnly and with elegant simplicity. The repetition of circular shapes and cogs connect to the passing of time in each minute's duration. Among the many visually stunning illustrations the double page spread showing the many small contorted bodies under the dark ground, as the ANZACs depart is heart-stopping. It reduced my normally boisterous Year 10s to complete stunned silence, such is its profundity.
Camilleri's illustrations are finely detailed, and by rendering them in monotones evoke the period of time - as does the choice of the sepia tones such as those on the cover. This also conveys the bleakness and despair of the Gallipoli campaign (or indeed any conflict) and the intense emotions. The reader can easily empathise with both sides in this desperate situation.
My boys were intrigued (naturally!) by the diagrammatic style illustrations of the shrapnel bomb and the rifle. Though clearly illustrated in the film/comic strip style action, the shooting of a young soldier is subdued, though obvious, and hence reduces the horror for younger readers.
In one minute of silence you can imagine sprinting up the beach in Gallipoli in 1915 with the fierce fighting Diggers, but can you imagine standing beside the brave battling Turks as they defended their homeland from the cliffs above...
Truly a reflective and evocative picture book, One minute's silence is, I predict, potentially an award-winning book for next year's lists.
Sue Warren

Bubble trouble by Tom Percival

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408838778.
(Age: Early childhood) Bubble trouble is a very apt name for this book. Rueben and Felix had always lived next door to each other and they were best friends. They were exactly the same age, same height (except for their ears), they were both left-handed and they LOVED to blow bubbles. Really, REALLY BIG bubbles! It was a perfect activity to do together until one day Rueben said, 'I bet I could blow a bigger bubble than you'. And so the contest is on - with each trying to blow the biggest bubble, building the most amazing bubble-blowing contraptions. But as the machines become more and more complex, the fun gets less and less. Even rules and judges and spectators didn't help. All they could think about was winning! Until one day.
Illustrated very gently in a lift-the-flap format and quite different from his Skulduggery Pleasant work, (there's an interview with him about his creations) this is a book that has many layers to it. Each time I read it I thought of a new way that it could be used in the classroom setting. Firstly, there is the maths aspect of comparing sizes accompanied by the languages aspect of the use of comparative and superlative language. Then there is the aspect of how bubbles are made, why they are usually round, and investigating whether the shape and power of the 'blower' affect the shape of the bubble. There's the design aspect of creating a bubble-blowing machine or something that will help them solve the issue at the end; and throughout all, the concept of what friendship means. My review copy was destined for a pre-schooler I know but I've decided to tuck it into my teaching tool-kit instead. Stories which can provide a whole day's cross-curriculum teaching are rare!
Barbara Braxton

Malala by Malala Yousafzai and Patricia McCormick

cover image

Hachette, 2014. ISBN 9781780622156.
(Ages: 12+) Highly recommended. War, Fanaticism, Refugees, Taliban, Islam, Women, Education. Subtitled, The girl who stood up for education and changed the world no reader can pass by this book without recognising the young woman staring out from the cover. Her face and the events surrounding her medical evacuation to England were on every media report for months, and millions followed her plight. Shot in the face by a fanatic in the Swat Valley in northern Pakistan, while on her way home from school, she needed emergency attention. Her book concentrates initially on the family and her religion, her day to day life, her school and the increasing imposition of extremist views in Pakistan. These views that women should not be educated, that women were not allowed to leave home without a male relative with them, and only when wearing a full cover, came to the fore after the devastating earthquake of 2007, after which some preached that it was a warning from Allah. The ones who helped those affected by the earthquake were the followers of the extremist Fazlullah, and they were able to promote their views. As they grew stronger, fear bubbled through the community, TV sets were destroyed, polio vaccines rejected, and radio used to attract followers until many of their ideas became common usage in northern Pakistan, with opposing people being beaten and killed by the fanatics. But some spoke out against them, Malala's father, the school principal amongst others, and Malala too became outspoken from an early age, talking on the radio, and freely giving her views on girls' education.
Calls to Pakistan's army fell on deaf ears, and it wasn't until the Taliban started to be a murderous influence in Islamabad, that the army moved to act. But it was too late for Malala.
This is a riveting read, not only because it tells younger readers about this brave young woman and her fight against the tyranny of fanatics, but also because it speaks to us all about taking a stand against fanaticism, and coincidentally showing how easily fanaticism can take a hold on a community. I was constantly reminded of the rise of Nazism, and echoes of the rise to power of the IS in Iraq today.
Education is the key to overcoming fanatics like this. We take so much for granted in the west and this singular book reveals to our sometimes overprotected students, what lengths people will go to be educated, and what lengths some will go to prevent it happening.
This could be an adjunct to study alongside the many wonderful novels set in the Middle East, the novels of Deborah Ellis and Rosanne Hawke spring to mind. At the end of the book is a glossary, a timeline of events in Pakistan since partition, a series of book club questions and information about her current work. A map at the start of the book sets the story in its place in the world.
Fran Knight

An interview with a stranger: Terry Whitebeach

cover image

by Fran Knight
Dubbing herself a 'stranger in a strange land', the current May Gibb's Fellowship recipient, Tasmanian author, Terry Whitebeach, has found that her recipe for writing in the quietness and solitude of the apartment in Norwood has included visits to the Art Gallery and Botanic Gardens, as well as the odd lunch. Today we met at Cafe Ivy on Norwood Parade to discuss her body of work and its motivating forces.
Terry's body of work includes two poetry collections, Bird Dream, and All the Shamans Work in Safeway, an indigenous life history, The Versatile Man, radio plays for ABC's Airplay, as well as reviews and essays published in journals. With two young adult novels also behind her (Watersky (1998) and Bantam (2002) as well as two bilingual picture books, When I was a Boy in Sudan and When I was a Girl in Sudan (2014)), Terry is currently working on a novel for younger readers, a niche market which is undernourished.
In this multicultural country, Terry has met and taught many refugees in adult literacy classes. These people surely must be the epitome of a 'stranger in a strange land', having to cope with a different culture, language and ethos, often after many difficult years spent in refugee camps.
Whilst working in adult literacy, she met her Sudanese colleague Sarafino Enadio, and has worked with him to create four books. The first to be published were a pair of bilingual picture books for Sudanese as well as English speaking readers, with the aim of Sudanese and Australian children developing a better understanding of each other. These picture books depict the traditional life of children in Sudan.
Sarafino's ten years in a refugee camp were the catalyst for a young adult novel, Obulejo, Trouble Tomorrow, on which Terry and Sarafino also collaborated, after visiting South Sudan together in 2012. In 2014 they published an account of Sarafino's life, A Little Peace, a South Sudanese Refugee Story.
But Paper Chains is what she is working on while in Adelaide. A novel for younger readers, it is the story of the adventures of six sisters. As with all her novels, it began with an imaginary conversation. This time between a set of sisters. When Terry first 'overheard' the sisters talking to each other she felt compelled to begin to write down their conversations. At first it felt a little like eavesdropping, but Terry nevertheless continued to listen in.
I asked Terry if she had any difficulties writing from a female perspective, as her young adult books all have had male leads. None, she explained; she was brought up in a family of six girls, so has a rich resource from which to draw her ideas.
Although Terry was not forthcoming with many details of this new book, while in Adelaide she will further flesh out the story she feels she must write, of six sisters and their hair-raising adventures, and the way they face and overcome difficulties together and win through. The title of her new book, Paper Chains came to her as an image of a string female figures joined yet individual: its significance will become more apparent as the narrative develops.
As an author concerned with marginalised and silenced or excluded groups and individuals, speculation about the threads of her new novel have tantalised me and I look forward to reading it.

Oliver and George by Peter Carnavas

cover image

New Frontier, 2014. ISBN 9781925059083.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Rivalry, Cooperation, Friendship. The appeal of any book by Peter Carnavas is immediately apparent from the front cover. His unadorned pictorial style grabs the attention of the reader as his illustrations focus on the hub of the story to be found overleaf. Oliver and George are on the front page, one, a bear, engrossed in his book, while the other, a child with skates on his feet, is demanding attention. Just who is Oliver and who George, the cover demands.
Opening we find the boy, Oliver, ready to play, but George is still busy reading his book. Oliver does a number of things to distract George from his reading, throwing a paper plane and kicking his chair, and George gets mad, but then the crossness subsides and he continues reading his book. Oliver tries other things to distract George, but all to no avail, until he reaches out and takes the book. Then George erupts. Consequently a funny twist occurs which makes everything right again.
This is lovely tale of friendship, of recognising each other's needs and their private time, of cooperation and working together, and of resolution. Parents and teachers alike will be able to draw the readers into discussing a range of things about cooperating with their friends, of not being annoying to get their own way, of allowing other people some private space. Children will enjoy the story on one level, but be equally accomplished at realising there are lessons to be learnt. And Carnavas' delightful illustrations are given an airing on the endpapers, adding another level of interest to this wonderful book.
And George's total concentration on his book is a powerful image to have handy when discussing reading.
Fran Knight

Whale in the bath by Kylie Westaway

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743318584.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Picture book, Bath time, Whales, Humour. Sent upstairs to have a bath, Bruno finds a whale has taken it over, using his bubble bath and Dad's back scrubber. He loves the warm bath water and all he needs to make things perfect is some krill. But when Bruno goes to tell his sister and mother about why he cannot have a bath, they do not believe him.
He goes back upstairs to tackle the animal, but each time he is defeated by his logic and cunning. Eventually Bruno has a shower, and readers will laugh out loud at the turn of events, as the house does not have a shower in it. All the while, Jellett's hilarious illustrations underscore the story, adding another level of humour to a funny tale. His illustrations can also be seen in recent publications, Santa's secret, and The gobbledydook is eating a book.
Discussion about lying, about avoidance, of being believed can be drawn from this engaging tale, as Bruno struggles to tell people about his problem. Each of his family dismisses his tale as yet another avoidance technique, until dad comes home. Bruno is relieved that he seems to believe him, but even Dad lets him down. Many readers will have experienced similar events and will eagerly recognise Bruno's dilemma.
Very funny on many levels, this book could be used to encourage discussion about avoidance techniques, bath time and telling stories or lies. The whale in the bath could create great discussion about the mathematical improbability of such a thing happening, of size and shape, of volume, and of the whales in our environment. The possibilities are endless.
Fran Knight

Kick with my left foot by Paul Seden and Karen Briggs

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 978174331344.
'I pull the sock on my left foot
I pull the sock on my right foot
I lace up the boot on my left foot
I lace up the boot on my right foot . . .
It's time for footy!'
This is a charming story of a little boy who loves his footy and can do everything well with his right and left hands, except for when it comes to kicking. When the tries to kick with his right foot, the results are less than great. But kicking with his left foot is a totally different matter! In a place where footy is an integral part of life, being able to kick well is an important skill and there is great excitement when his left foot kicking is the clincher.
Accompanied by illustrations that depict the emotions of both the boy and his dog perfectly, this story really appealed to the younger readers in my family who are struggling with left and right, as well as with throwing and kicking. In fact, Miss 3 and a half immediately went outside and practised with both feet to see which one worked best for her. Many times the results were those shown in the pictures but with practice she began to improve, and now has also sorted out that left/right confusion.
The book is one of the Emerging Indigenous Picture Book Mentoring Project a partnership between the Little Big Book Club and Allen & Unwin in which six previously unpublished Indigenous writers and illustrators will have their work showcased in four picture books during 2014. Each creator has been partnered with a renowned mentor in children's publishing including Nadia Wheatley, Ken Searle, Nick Bland, Ann James, Bronwyn Bancroft, Boori Monty Pryor and Ali Cobby Eckermann to share ideas, techniques and inspiration for their first published work. The project has been funded by the federal government through the Australia Council and it means that not only will our cohort of children's writers be enriched but our students will have access to authentic texts that will work towards the understanding and harmony between our cultures that is at the heart of so many of the Australian Curriculum outcomes. Even though it is written for an early childhood audience, there is a lot that offers scope for comparing and contrasting lifestyles and landscapes that would enable younger students to continue the development of their critical thinking skills. Even determining which code of football is being played requires observation and justification!
Barbara Braxton

Alice-Miranda at camp by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House Australia Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781742757612
Recommended. This is the tenth in the incredibly successful Alice-Miranda series. This is my first time reading an Alice-Miranda and I have enjoyed the experience. Jacqueline Harvey places her characters and series in the timeless void inhabited by Milly-Molly-Mandy, The naughtiest girl in the school and the Chalet stories. These are comfort reads of the highest order.
In this adventure Alice-Miranda and her friends go on a hastily arranged school camp organised at the orders of Queen Georgiana, as it turns out the camp is right next door to Alice-Miranda's father's home. This has since become a retirement home for workers from the estate.
Of course mystery and mayhem of a most enjoyable type occurs. The author's visits to schools obviously correspond to 'research' and I found myself chuckling at the way she portrays the teachers in the book. I also admired the way that Jacqueline Harvey weaves in aspects of previous adventures so that a new reader such as myself can follow the back story.
I was taken by the sub-plot of the new girl Caprice and the subtlety of her bullying of Millie. The issues this raises of trust with the teachers and Alice-Miranda provide interesting moral lessons for the young readership.
This is a lovely written book for younger readers, with lots of fun and humour to be enjoyed. Well plotted, with acute portrayals and characterisation, I can see why this is a very successful series. Rest assured that the novice reader can pick up this title and have no difficulty at all becoming immersed in the world of Alice-Miranda, and will immediately seek to track down the entire series and join the eager crew of young readers anxiously awaiting the next instalment.
I will leave the last word to my Primary TL colleague Kim who says 'Alice-Miranda is a great role model for girls - a strong and independent child with a beautiful heart'.
Michael Jongen

The Summer of Kicks by Dave Hackett

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2014. ISBN 9780702253362
Recommended for readers aged 13+. Themes: Relationships; Family; Friendship; Teen coming-of age. With a central character with a burdensome name - 'Starrphyre', this book relates the love and pain-strewn path of this teenage boy as he juggles new love and old passion disastrously. Helped and hindered by his family and friends - his mother, an on-air Radio sex and relationship therapist; her former partner - a one-hit-wonder 80's band member; his sister, who is dating the ultimate loser boyfriend; his Gran - who attempts to predict the future; and his friendship group which is stereotypically full of outcasts. The misadventures for Starrphyre include starting a band with his friends in order to persuade girls to see them as above-ordinary. Unfortunately Starrphyre and his friends have little more than a disputed playlist. There is certainly no great musical talent amongst their number, and a chance meeting with a potential guitarist lands Starrphyre with a part-time job in a record store selling old-time vinyls and an accidental girl-friend. Accidents continue to litter his path, and kissing and poor choices send him on the relationship roller-coaster. This is not an unfamiliar plot, and is very definitely told from the point of view of a young male suffering the early doubts of his role in romance.
The author of this book will be well known to young TV viewers because of numerous roles on children's television as a presenter and cartoonist.
This is mostly an inoffensive tale (even with his Mother's unusual occupation sometimes providing advice) and provides some amusing moments.
Carolyn Hull

Snail and Turtle are friends by Stephen Michael King

cover image

Scholastic, 2014. ISBN: 9781743620236
Despite their differences, snail and turtle are friends who do almost everything together. From their shared activities including walking, running, hiding and being quiet together, they nonetheless enjoy different foods, parts of the day and creative styles. Although they prefer to go about things in different ways, they accept one another's choices and enjoy one another's company without question and, at the end of the day retreat to their shells, side by side, to sleep. Theirs is an almost perfect friendship, lived in harmony and based on mutual trust and respect.
Stephen Michael King's illustrations utilise his easily identifiable cartoon like style with the colour palette containing predominantly earthy shades of the garden plants and water. On the cover and throughout the book is a shiny 'trail' showing where the snail has travelled. Having already shared the book with a number of classes, the children love following the path and tracing the trail with their fingers.
This is a joyous and gentle story, simply showing the importance of people who don't have to be exactly like us to be true friends. Junior primary teachers will find this title to be a useful discussion starter about friendship and individual differences.
Jo Schenkel

Princesses are not just pretty by Kate Lum

cover image

Ill. by Sue Hellard. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408824252
(Ages 3-5) Recommended. Princess Allie, Princess Mellie and Princess Libby love dressing in beautiful gowns, having their hair done in lavish styles, and being generally very pretty. The trouble is, each thinks they are the prettiest, so it is decided they must have a beauty contest to find out who really is the prettiest princess. Luckily at this point the book takes a change in direction, as none of the characters seemed very likeable. Suddenly, though, each princess is faced with a problem which involves them putting another person's needs before their own, and each steps up valiantly.
This book would provide a great starting point for many discussions about stereotypes, selflessness and appearances. The illustrations are colourful and comical, making it an enjoyable book for reading aloud to young children. There are two other titles in the Princesses series.
Donella Reed.

We were liars by E. Lockhart

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760111069.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Wealth and power. Greed. Psychological injury. Truth and lies. Poignantly powerful and full of suspense, this book takes the reader through the distress of a major psychological incident to uncover the truth and lies at its heart. The central characters are born to wealth and privilege in USA, living in wealthy Boston and spending indolent summers on the family island near Martha's Vineyard. The greed and self-focus that hides underneath the impeccable outer veneer of lies, gives a view to the world of aspirational perfection which is, in fact, far from perfect. The reader is introduced to this world through the eyes of the psychologically damaged teenager, Cadence, who is struggling to remember her past. Her story and the unveiling of her 15th summer lost in the fog of amnesia, is woven with fairy-tale and literature stories of comparison. This weaving creates a beautiful association, leaving the reader aware of the dark and light of the narrative in the completed tapestry of We were liars. As is the case with all good suspense stories, the ending should only be known by those who are prepared to get to know the whole story and read the book. This would make an excellent film script.
I can highly recommend this book for mature readers. It is beautifully written, with a coming of age undertone, and also a moral tale with an unstated but implicit criticism of the consequences of great wealth within a family. I especially enjoyed the simplicity of sentence structure at the end of many chapters. This writing style choice is intelligent and perfect in revealing inside the mind of the central character.
[There is a small section within the book with swearing that may make this difficult for more conservative school libraries, but for readers 15+, this language choice is not surprising in context.]
Carolyn Hull