Reviews

Bird to bird by Claire Saxby

cover image

Ill. by Wayne Harris. Black Dog Books, 2018. ISBN 9781925381122
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Birds, Trees, Convicts. In following the life of just one tree, Saxby and Harris reveal the European settlement of Australia, as the wood from the tree is used to build ships that are used to bring the convicts to Sydney, then reused to make a loom, reused again as part of a settler's hut, and then a part of the now derelict hut is fashioned by a wood turner.
In the beginning the tree grows from a seedling born out of a seed dropped by a bird flying overhead. The wood turner at the end fashions his piece of wood into a bird, completing the circle of life for the tree, bringing the story back to its roots.
Readers will eagerly follow the story of the tree from the seedling to the bird being used by children at the end. The bold illustrations show the tree as a seedling, growing to an enormous tree in the forest, used by birds until it is felled by woodsmen. They take the tree to the hungry city where ships are built and beds made in the ships for the convicts on their journey across the seas to Australia. Here the wood becomes a loom to fashion the wool, and when this is no longer used, it makes the roof of a settlers hut, until it is used by the wood turner to fashion a bird.
The sparse text reminds the readers of the uses to which just one tree can be put, and reflect the cyclic nature of life. The wonderful illustrations reference early Australian paintings, particularly of Sydney Harbour, and the style Harris uses recalls for me the techniques of impressionist painters such as van Gogh and Georges Seurat.
The book extols the virtue of recycling, of reusing resources, showing a perspective of Australia's history through the wood used to bring people here, but then reused many times to get the most from it. A gentle story of Australia's beginnings is given a broader scope through the illustrations showing Australia through time; beginning with the convict ships arriving on Sydney's shore to the building of looms to prepare cloth, the settlers' huts miles from the city, then back to the place it started, the harbour where children play with the last product of the original tree.
Fran Knight

The taste of blue light by Lydia Ruffles

cover image

Hachette, 2017. ISBN 9781444936742
(Age: Senior secondary, Adult) The title, and the enigmatic opening words, of Lydia Ruffles' stunning modern-world masterpiece plunge us into a disturbed young woman's life. The protagonist states that she 'is determined to 'find the old Lux' and 'sew' herself into that person she used to be. The closing words of this narrative are apt. Lux cannot understand why her life, at the elite Artists' boarding school in the verdant countryside of England, is causing her such angst. Even though she is medicated to help keep this new sensation of absolute terror at bay, she can still hardly sleep and life seems too hard to endure. Yet everyone, including her parents, who live far away in Hong Kong, continues to support her, even through her sometimes outrageous moods and actions. This situation is deeply puzzling for the reader.
Drugs, sex, anxiety and sleeplessness take their toll as her skewed brain responds to the world by translating everything into colour - in the physical senses, in food, emotions and in her interactions with others. Colour defines her world so dramatically, enabling her to just keep going. Terror, violent and inexplicable, stops her sleeping. Anxiety rules every moment of every day yet she is supported so gently by everyone, by kindness and understanding. In a masterful literary stroke, we discover that only Lux and the reader are 'in the dark' about her situation. We are drawn into her gradually dawning memories of her experience, emotionally and with a powerful, shared angst.
Sitting firmly in the modern world that has experienced violent attacks and murders, in a country that is desperate to retain its culture of decency, kindness and non-violence, Ruffles' revelation of the assault on peace alert us to her challenge. She seeks to remind us that we must work to preserve our world, to survive violence and terror, and infers that this will only be achieved through kindness, goodness, acceptance of others, in all their differences, and love. This powerful modern novel is suitable for older high school students and adults.
Elizabeth Bondar

The Curse in the Candlelight by Sophie Cleverly

cover image

Scarlet and Ivy book 5. HarperCollins, 2018. ISBN 9780008218300
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Themes: Mystery, Boarding Schools, Twins, Bullying. Fourteen year old identical twins Scarlet and Ivy return for a new year at Rookwood School leaving their distant father and evil stepmother behind. Eager to catch up with their friend Ariadne and take Miss Finch's ballet classes, the twins are happy to be back. As the school assembles for the first day's instructions, a dark-haired new student Ebony McCloud makes a grand entrance into the school hall. She has a mysterious presence about her, defiantly flouting the school rules and soon draws younger students into her group.
Sophie Cleverley layers this mystery plot with curious clues along the way; characters have hidden agendas and a presence of evil directs the actions. She balances this junior novel with familiar lessons, favourite teachers and every day activities. When Ariadne's archenemy Muriel Witherspoon joins Rookwood Academy she appears to have changed her bullying ways however Scarlet and Ivy are not convinced about her motives. When the celebrations on All Hallows Eve go terribly wrong, the twins work together to save Ariadne and expose the real prankster. Told from the sisters' alternate points of view, Scarlet and Ivy's new term proves to be filled with mystery, magic, secret escapades and growing friendships.
The Curse in the Candlelight is the fifth novel in this exciting series. Each novel reveals more about the main characters and their friends' home lives. The mysteries and different ways the twins work together to solve them make these novels just right for readers from 9-12 years.
Rhyllis Bignell

Alcheringa Snow by Toni Cary

cover image

Little Steps Publishing, 2017. ISBN 9780980723724
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Picture book. Alcheringa Snow is told from the perspective of Francine, a French Pyrenees dog. She is a huge mountain dog who dreams of climbing mountains. Francine is a dreamer and so are her friends. There is Banjo the green and golden bell frog who dreams of riding a snowboard. Readers can learn about how this type of frog spends the winter. Then there is shy Colin the copperhead snake who dreams of the coming spring. Find out where Colin sleeps when it is cold and when it is hot. Anna and Amy are echidnas and they dream of ants. The two wombats dream of eating grass all year round. Keep reading to find out about the dreams of magpies, cockatoos, wallabies and kangaroos.
Alcheringa Snow is a gorgeous picture book for readers of any age. The pictures are detailed real-life paintings that will invoke lots of conversation even before the words are read. The descriptive vocabulary is ideal for independent readers due to the great adjectives and descriptions of the animal's antics. Younger readers will enjoy this book as a read-a-loud before bed or even in the classroom. The story would make a great addition to any English program or descriptive writing unit. Alcheringa Snow would also be good in a Science program based on Biological Sciences and the study of Australian animals.
It is highly recommended for all readers.
Kylie Kempster

Landscape with invisible hand by M. T. Anderson

cover image

Candlewick, 2017. ISBN 9780763699505
(Age: Middle secondary - Adult) This small novel captures perhaps some of the less-voiced anxieties about what exists in deep space that might threaten us. Not the simple man-in-the-moon idea, but something deeper and far more catastrophic for earth. Anderson places us in a recognizable world except for the fact of our unseen and obviously unrecognizable 'overlords' being from 'other' places, not human and not just machines, but intelligent, demanding and frightening "Vuvvs" that demand obedience, recognition and submission.
In this novel the characters are placed in a world from which they can instantaneously visit other planets or modules that hover in space. Earth appears to be somewhat ragged, down-at-heel and much lesser than we might think of ourselves. Poor, abandoned by their father and husband, the families of Adam and his girlfriend, Chloe, struggle to survive financially and fear what might happen if they fail all together.
This is a book without a sense of great hope or change, yet it deals with human beings struggling to survive mentally and physically in a world that appears to be disadvantaged by its being an underling of a greater spatial world empire, and by its down-at heel state. Human beings are lesser and the characters try to reach the standards of behaviour and work expected by the 'others', the overlords. Human characteristics valuable and appropriate to us seem lesser, and the characters in this short novel are good people and offer us some hope, but not a lot, in this imagined world.
This is a strong and brave modern novel that addresses the idea of our perhaps not being alone, nor being in fact superior, or protected by any higher beings, living on the edge and in tension, on this planet in the universe that we inhabit. It is coldly challenging, blunt and suitable for middle secondary to higher secondary, and adult, reading.
Elizabeth Bondar

Parvana a graphic novel by Deborah Ellis, adapted from the film by Norah Twomey

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN 9781760631970
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Graphic novel. Themes: Afghanistan, Refugees, Taliban, Extremism, Survival. From the highly acclaimed and awarded novel, Parvana, comes this pared down version presented in a graphic novel format, destined to entrance another generation of readers who will seek out the original stories once they have finished the graphic version.
Every page is replete with the horror of living under religious extremism; the rules imposed upon the population of Kabul in which Parvana and her family live are part of the fabric of the story and its illustrations. In dark, threatening browns, reds and blacks, the ever present threat of arbitrary rule is made real. Parvana's father has lost his job as a teacher, now selling his skills in the market, there to be questioned by an ex pupil, scathing of education and learning. He is questioned too about Parvana, a girl, being allowed outside or having part of her face exposed, but when he is taken to prison, the family loses all contact with the outside world. As women are not allowed in the street alone, Parvana dresses as a boy to earn money to support her family.
The appalling regime and its impact are seen on every page as Parvana tries to earn money to help her father get out of prison. The usual rule of law has broken down, allowing men to use their power to further impose their wills upon women. Small touches of humanity shine through the gloom, as Parvana finds a school friend doing the same as she, when she reads the letters of illiterate people willing to pay money to find out about their families, and where someone helps Parvana in her search for her father.
But in the end although Parvana finds her father and her family have escaped the brutal man who would use them, the future is bleak.
Readers will ponder long after this is read about how they would survive, and about how all those children still under the rule of these fanatics are faring. A film made of the Parvana books, called The Breadwinner received an Academy Award nomination for Best Animated Feature in 2018, and it is on this film that this graphic novel is based.
Fran Knight

Lintang and the Forbidden Island by Tamara Moss

cover image

Random House, 2018. ISBN 9780143783459
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Adventure stories, Pirates, Fantasy, Seafaring adventures. Lintang and the Forbidden Island continues the gripping story of a feisty young adventurer on her quest to find Captain Shafira and re-join her friends on board the Winda. Tamara Moss creatively balances the elements of mystery, exploration and detailed imaginary creatures in this fantasy world.
Lintang's life changes dramatically just on her thirteenth birthday; all her plans are thwarted as their island is taken over by the United Regions. Fortuitously Captain Moon arrives with an apprenticeship offer for Lintang because of her previous experiences aboard the Winda battling the mythies. Life on Captain Moon's ship is regimented and dull, her one job is to watch and stoke the fire.
After a daring escape through a marketplace, the sea captain captures her and reveals his special plan. There is a bounty on Captain Shafira's head and Lintang needs to be secretly returned to the Winda. Each of Lintang's lessons aboard provide her with the skills need to survive in the dangerous world ruled by the Vierzan's and inhabited by the fierce mythical creatures. She is given her own sword and taught how to fight, Eire tests her to the limits of her endurance and Zazi teaches her the ways of their ancestors. The Mythie guidebook entries introduce the dangerous beings they need to fight as their journey progresses. The fast-paced action sees Lintang, Captain Shafira and the crew fighting their enemies on both sea and land.
Lintang's friends, Bayani, the pixie Pelita and the crew come alive in Moss's detailed and descriptive narrative novel. Rich with mythology, she continues to explore this magical world, explaining the existence of the Mythies. Her protagonist's personal growth in confidence is very relatable, from a lack of self-assurance, Lintang learns resilience, shows determination and reliance on her friends. What adventures await this feisty young hero? Read both of Lintang's stories to students in the middle primary and they will be captivated.
Rhyllis Bignell

Bad Dad by David Walliams

cover image

HarperCollins, 2017. ISBN 9780008254339
(Age: Middle - Upper primary) Recommended. "Dads come in all sorts of shapes and sizes. There are fat ones and thin ones, tall ones and short ones. There are silly ones and serious ones, loud ones and quiet ones. Of course there are good dads. And there are bad dads . . . "
Here, David Walliams has created a dad who, despite his failings, loves his son Frank immensely. Whilst racing Queenie, his old Mini emblazoned with the Union Jack, Dad has an accident and loses not just his leg but his title as "King of the Track". With Frank sleeping by his dad's hospital bed, mum finally walks out and leaves dad for another man. Eventually dad loses his job, along with his celebrity status, and falls into a depression. On Frank's eleventh birthday, dad gives him an amazing racing set and the pair spend many hours playing with it together. Soon thereafter, hard-faced debt collectors appear at the door and take everything Frank and dad still owns.
With Auntie Flip as a baby-sitter, Frank leaves the house one night to follow his dad on what he knows is an extraordinary outing. He witnesses Dad acting as the driver in a bank robbery, in order to pay off his debts. Thus begins an incredible adventure for the pair, culminating in Frank being able to fulfil one of his lifelong dreams. The addition of some hilarious characters, including the Reverend Judith the local vicar, lead to some unexpected twists and turns in the plot.
My first ever David Walliams book, this has convinced me that the comparisons to Roald Dahl are not without some substance. This was an entertaining, easy read and has explained the students' eagerness to devour each new Walliams title as it is released. Double spaced print, font which changes to highlight various words or parts of the text, and a liberal smattering of cartoon style illustrations, make this novel eminently accessible to boys and girls in the middle to upper years of primary school. I'm sure this won't be the last Walliams book I will read either, as it's a great romp.
Jo Schenkel

Little Lifesavers by Yvette Poshoglian

cover image

Ella and Olivia series. Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781743811498
(Age: Emergent readers) Recommended. When Ella and Olivia go to stay with their grandparents, along with their family, they decide that they want to follow in mum's footsteps and join the Nippers surf lifesaving club. With their new tops emblazoned with the words Two Pines Beach, the girls head excitedly to their first lesson. Despite them both trying their hardest, Angela, a mean girl, manages to make them both doubt their abilities and almost their decision to join. Mum and their Nanna are proud of the fact that the girls help each other and do their best.
Over the coming week, the girls continue to practise and improve their skills. By the time the next week comes around, they eagerly head off again, hoping to show the coach how well they have done. Will they be able to fulfil their dreams or will Angela manage to beat them again?
Not having read an Ella and Olivia title before, but knowing just how popular they are in school libraries, I put myself in the headset of our younger readers and realised that the stories are definitely aimed at young girls and encourage them to try new skills and adventures. As I neared the end, I'd predicted the outcome and found myself being totally engaged in the simple story. I hoped that the girls would manage to achieve their goals and was quite satisfied with the conclusion. I can see exactly why emergent readers love these stories so much and will be even more proactive in recommending them to this demographic in future.
Jo Schenkel

LuLu le baby Chef by Katrina Meynink

cover image

Little Steps Publishing, 2017. ISBN 9781925545661
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. LuLu le baby Chef is the story of a baby named LuLu and her amazing gift. She can whip up any meal, cooking amazing dishes and tasty foods. She tastes many foods adults have not had the chance to try. Unfortunately for LuLu, something is missing from her dishes and she just doesn't know what it is. So, LuLu travels around the world - to Italy, Beirut, France, Rome and Amsterdam. She experiments with different ingredients and even cooks with a famous chef. However, that one missing ingredient is never found. Lu Lu heads home. Was the answer always there?
LuLu le baby Chef is a beautifully illustrated picture book and the pictures alone will keep younger children busy for hours. The details are wonderful. The story demands to be read aloud thanks to the rhyme and rhythm in the words. Children will be able to learn about different foods and different countries as well as new vocabulary such as delight, tenderised and scrumptious. The story will be a good read-a-loud in both the classroom and at home.
Use the story to identify the elements of a narrative and complete oral retells. In Geography, map LuLu's travels and identify the different countries and continents.
This book is highly recommended for readers aged 4+.
Kylie Kempster

Missing by Sue Whiting

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2018. ISBN 9781760650032
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Themes: Crime, Adventure, Panama, Bats, Missing persons. When Mackenzie is told to pack and be ready to leave, she obeys her insistent father without demur, but once on the plane for Panama, she wants to talk to her Gran, the one stable thing in her life since her mother's disappearance five months ago. Told in alternate chapters, one in the present day as Kenzie and her father search for the woman in Panama, the other back in Sydney months before as concern builds after Mum's non appearance at the airport after photographing bats in South America.
Kenzie is about to go into secondary school, and her mother has insisted she go to a private girls' school, to be less distracted by the boys at the local state school. She is unhappy but with her mother gone, wants to do as she had planned for her. Her first day is unsettling, until she meets Billie. The two hit it off, partly because Billie does not ask about her mother.
In South America, Kenzie and her Dad go to Bouquete, the last place the woman was seen alive, and question again those who remembered seeing her. When Dad lands in hospital it is up to Kenzie to find out more information, and talking to a researcher in the town, finds that her mother spoke to him the day after the police thought she had disappeared. She gets on the bus, with Carlos from the hotel in her wake.
This is an engrossing read about one girl's search for her mother. Developed partly after Whiting read of the large numbers of missing people in Australia each year, she honed in on how the teenager would react and respond to such a crisis. She has succeeded, drawing us into Kenzie's world as she tries to make sense of all the things that happen around her, being buffeted from one thing to another. Whiting very successfully exposes the vacuum into which Kenzie falls, unable to trust anyone, scared and suspicious.
Australian author, Sue Whiting lives near Sydney and has won awards for several of her books, including Platypus and A swim in the sea.
This story would make a good class text, a great read aloud as well as a book to study.
Fran Knight

Bird builds a nest by Martin Jenkins

cover image

Ill. by Richard Jones. Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406355130
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Birds, Building, Forces, STEM. The seemingly simple tale of a bird building its nest is given a wider emphasis as the author and illustrator explain forces through pushing and pulling, and how we use forces to move things.
The bird rises with the sun and goes to look for a worm to eat. The first one she finds it very large and despite all her effort at pulling it from its hole, she is unable to move it. In smaller type the rule of physics is given, that the stronger something is, the more force it can apply. The bird sets out to find another smaller worm and is successful. Bird then sets out to find some twigs to build her nest.
The one she chooses is too big and a law of physics is again given: that the more something weighs, the more force is needed to lift it. She finds some smaller twigs and fashions her nest, pushing the twigs together. Another law of physics is given: when you push something you are applying a force away from you. In dropping one of her twigs, the author then is able to tell the reader about gravity, and then when the nest is complete she is able to lay her eggs.
Children reading this book will come to understand the laws of forces through the simple act of a bird building its nest, illustrated in sepia tones rendered in blocks of colour reminiscent of collage and block print techniques. The illustrations add a level of humour as the readers eyes follow the antics of the bird in going about her business. At the end of the book is a small index, with questions to ponder about the forces explained in the book.
A wonderful introduction to discussions about the forces we use everyday.
Fran Knight

I remember by Joanne Crawford

cover image

Ill. by Kerry Anne Jordinson. Magabala Books, 2018. ISBN 9781925360769
(Ages: 4-8) Themes: Memory, Childhood. This is the recollection of an elderly woman about the Murchison River camping trips she went on with her family when she was a child. While presumably based on the memories of the author, the elderly storyteller pictured is fictional. She begins, "When I was young, I remember . . . " and what follows is her reminiscing about how she felt, what she thought and the evocative nature of her memories ("I can almost feel the slimy, squishy river mud between my toes"). At the end of the book we are taken back to our storyteller who tells us about how memory can be elusive ("The memories don't come all that often, just flashes here and there") and are reminded of the fragility of memory but also about how sharing our stories keeps them alive. The illustrations help to bring her memories to life, not just how it was but how she remembers it (the wildflowers as far as her eyes could see, the dark water of the dam that terrified her, etc.). This tale will resonate with parents and grandparents all over Australia, who will have memories of similar cherished memories. In addition, most children who have ever been on a family holiday will be able to relate to the storyteller's excitement about packing things into the car, the anticipation felt driving to the destination and then the peaceful time spent with family. This could be a useful educational resource when dealing with memory, family history and oral traditions of storytelling.
Nicole Nelson

Tempests and slaughter by Tamora Pierce

cover image

The Numair Chronicles book 1. Lothian, 2018. ISBN 9780734418678
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy, Magic, Wizards, Sorcery, Puberty. Arram Draper is the youngest student in his class at the Imperial University of Carthak, and his gifts are so great that he is constantly being put into higher classes with older students. When he meets Varice, a clever girl with kitchen magic, and Ozorne, the left-over prince, he finds two friends who help him fit in and the three of them form a bond that will have far reaching consequences.
In this long, slow moving and absorbing story of the boy who will become the great mage Numar Salmalin, featured in Pierce's previous Tortall stories (Song of the Lionness series and The immortals series), the reader follows the schooling of the three friends. It is fascinating to see the growth of Arram's skills and beliefs and follow his encounters with gods, a sunbird and the friends that he makes among the gladiators and creatures in the river. His curiosity and well-meaning nature will endear him to the reader, who will empathise with his feelings about slavery and follow his ability as a healer and water wizard with great interest. Meanwhile Ozorne is schooled in the magic of warfare and the reader knows that danger will follow from that, while Varice is shown as a caring attractive girl who has great social and culinary skills.
I had read the books about Alanna (Song of the Lionness series) many years ago, and found the story of Arram so fascinating that I immediately borrowed the four books in The immortals series to find out about Arram (Numar) as a grown man.
Tempests and slaughter can be read as a stand alone story, and fans of the books originally set in Tortall will especially welcome this new series about a favourite character. Books by Tamora Pierce are must reads for any fantasy lover.
Pat Pledger

Dig, dump, roll by Sally Sutton

cover image

Ill. by Brian Lovelock. Walker Books, 2018 ISBN 9781760650056
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Themes: Machinery. School. Workers. The building of a school is shown in new light as the different machines are brought in to help in its construction. First is the bulldozer, crashing, rumbling, crashing and grumbling as it clears the ground. In two rhyming sentences the author distills the work done by this great machine, ending with the word that describes the machine and the refrain, 'coming through!'
From there other machines are described just as pithily, with the repeated 'here's a clue' and 'coming through', inviting children to yell these out as the book is read to them.
The bulldozer is followed by the digger, then the dump truck, roller, concrete mixer and finally the builders, building a school.
Each page is brightly illustrated with lots for children to recognise and ask about. The builders are all enveloped in fluoro vests and hard hats, inviting discussions about safety, each machine is wonderfully drawn, inviting children to look more closely at its separate parts, the builders are shown working with the machines to get the job done.
The first two lines of each stanza about a particular machine is full of movement and action, inviting students to move along with the words or sound them out.
I can imagine groups of kids having a great deal of fun with this story, moving, yelling, predicting, learning lines, making the noises of the machines and finally building the school. On the last page is an outline of the machines presented in the book with further information about their parts. Readers will love it.
Fran Knight