Reviews

Liberty by Nikki McWatters

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2018. ISBN 9780702260292
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Historical fiction. Liberty intertwines three stories: in 1472 France, Jeanne, a peasant girl learns that Charles the Bold and his army is preparing to attack her hometown of Beauvais; in 1797 in Ireland, Betsy becomes involved in the Irish uprising against English rule; and in 1960s Australia, a country girl Fiona becomes involved in university student protests against conscription for the war in Vietnam. Each of them is bereft of their mother, and each struggles in their relationship with their father, trying to assert their independence and clashing with cultural norms and expectations.
Though the lives of the three girls are different they each have to find their inner courage and spirit, drawing on the strength of their female forbears, the names recorded in the ancient Systir Saga - a book that links them all together and which has been handed down through generations of women.
The stories of the French and Irish girls are based on historical accounts: of Jeanne Laisne, or Jeanne Hachette, who rallied the French defenders by hurling herself against the enemy on the ramparts and tossing down the Burgundian flag; and Betsy Gray who fought fearlessly alongside her brother and her lover with the United Irishmen. And while the third heroine, Fiona, is fictitious, her story is based on the anti-conscription 'Big March' of 8 September 1967 in Brisbane, Queensland.
The central theme is liberty or freedom; Jeanne and Betsy become embroiled in physical battles and have to fight to defend themselves and their country. It is interesting that McWatters' modern story is not of a physical conflict but about standing up against forced conscription into war, standing for freedom to protest.
Although initially a little disjointed, the chapters soon pick up momentum, and the reader is drawn into the personal stories of each of the girls, and it is hard to put the book down, carrying the reader on to each dramatic conclusion. Students will enjoy the historical contexts, the courageous heroines and the developing romantic relationships. The messages about the value of education and feminist independence are all very positive. Teachers' notes are available.
Helen Eddy

The Restless Girls by Jessie Burton

cover image

Ill. by Angela Barrett. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408886915
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy; Princesses. Twelve excellent Princesses, all with talents unique and exceptional, are plunged into a virtual prison by their father, the King, after the unfortunate death of their mother. The grief over the Queen's death unsettles the King and makes him irrational in his attempts to protect his daughters. The girls are unable to find consolation from within their imposed locked room existence . . . until they find a hidden mysterious fantasy palace where they can again know joy. This fantasy experience gives them opportunities to live life abundantly (with talking animals and food of every description) and to dance again. But the secret life they are enjoying must be kept hidden. The King though becomes suspicious! Will they be released or will the escape into their fantasy palace come to an unhappy end?
Written in the lyrical style of a classic fairy-tale, Burton has written a wonderful story that esteems the intelligence of girls and reveals their capacity to solve problems and to express their loyalty to one another. The illustrations by Barrett are delightful and reveal princesses that do not have Anglo-Saxon heritage. Published as a hard cover 'fairy-tale' book, this would make a lovely gift or also a good read-aloud book.
Highly recommended for ages 8+
Carolyn Hull

The callback by Maddie Ziegler

cover image

Maddie Ziegler trilogy book 2. Aladdin, 2018, ISBN 9781481486392
(Age: 9-12) Themes: School life, Dance, Friendship, Identity. Teen Maddie Ziegler, one of the stars on Dance Moms and a judge on So You Think You Can Dance draws inspiration from her life experiences in her trilogy. In The Callback she writes about middle school life, rivalry at the dance studio, friendships, settling in to a new home and life in a new state.
Twelve-year-old Harper's life is super-busy; her family have just moved to Florida and she's joined a new dance studio. She's part of the elite team Dance Starz with five other girls who are very competitive. Their teacher Vanessa challenges the girls with individual solo performances in different dance styles and Harper's is lyrical, a style that she loves. Rival Megan is determined that the solo will be hers and sets about to cause problems by lying and sabotaging her team-mates' individual classes.
When Harper accidentally falls asleep in English because she's stressed about her dancing, her teacher keeps her back after class. As she explains about all her after-school dance classes, her teacher asks for her help. She needs a soloist to perform one dance in the school play of The Little Mermaid because the previous dancer had to pull out. Harper's life becomes even more busy; she's making new friends and enjoying helping with the school play's dance routines. At home, her younger sister Hailey is feeling left out and Harper tries to assist her with her new video adventure 'Hailey on the Daily' with some interesting results!
Maddie Ziegler's novel The Callback is a fun read with plenty of dance moves, school dramas and friendship issues just right for ages 9 to 12.
Rhyllis Bignell

Eva's imagination by Wendy Shurety

cover image

Ill. by Karen Erasmus. New Frontier Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9781925594232
(Age: 4+) Themes: Imagination, Family, Adventure, Problem solving. When Eva cannot find anything to occupy herself, Mum tells he to go and find her imagination. She takes her dog, Chops and sets off. First she makes a list, then puts on her boots, taking a wooden spoon from the kitchen as her stick. They walk through the long valley of the passageway into the dining room with its forest of tree trunks listening to a bird's call. Under the table they find a discarded table napkin, and then walk up the stairs into the mountains, to find a cave. Climbing under the bed to explore the cave her hand comes to rest on something furry, and she finds her lost doll. Walking down the passageway once more, she hops into a rainforest, a wardrobe full of exciting things to see. Frightened by something soft and furry hanging down across her face, Eva calls out 'snake', and runs for the stairs. Chops finds some books and the two return to Mum, sure that they haven't found imagination, but loaded with the books and the lost toy.
Readers will know that imagination is used all through the story and Eva has not lost anything, but rather uses it all the time. Readers will love recognising the familiar parts of the house, sharing their own stories of what each room holds for them in their imaginations.
This is a lovely family oriented tale of a child and her mum in the house, finding something to occupy her mind as she explores the place with different eyes.
Erasmus' illustrations, like those of Freya Blackwood, give a loving warm feeling of family and togetherness from start to finish. I love the contrasting darkness of the pages when shadows appear on the wall of the passageway and the area under the dining room table becomes a forest. When Eva climbs under the bed and goes into the wardrobe, each illustrations is increasingly dark, but still radiating the warmth and security of the house.
Fran Knight

The caged queen by Kristen Ciccarelli

cover image

Gollancz, 2018. ISBN 9781473218161
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy. Love. Loyalty. Roa and her sister, Essie, share a bond that goes beyond understanding and even death. Essie's spirit is trapped in the body of a hawk, living in the limbo between life and freedom. Roa's driving desire is to release her from this trapped existence, but to do so she must sacrifice another life, and the victim must be the young King, Dax. Dax comes from the Dragon people, and grew up with the girls to escape his own dangerous father. But he is also the one that Essie saved as she lost her own life. Roa is a strong, capable and feisty young woman and in order to save the people of her homeland she has negotiated a marriage with the hapless, Dax. Dax though has his own solutions to problems, and they are not pleasing to Roa, and his affections seem to be shared with too many other young women! This fraught relationship between king and queen swings from open dislike to something that surprises Queen Roa. With plots to destroy the allegiance that Roa's marriage has enabled, Roa becomes embroiled in the complications of her own confusion and in resolving her connection to her former love interest.
Foremost though, this is an amazing and highly readable fantasy tale with broken relationships, hidden love, knife fights, political subterfuge and romance. These are all immersed in the world where dragons may appear and communities share stories and aspirations, and sometimes resort to violent solutions to their problems. Even though this is not the first book in The last Namsara saga, it is highly readable on its own and can be recommended to lovers of fantasy and romance alike.
Highly recommended for readers aged 15+.
Carolyn Hull

Tilly and the Bookwanderers by Anna James

cover image

Ill. by Paola Escobar. Pages and Co. Book 1. HarperCollins, 2018. ISBN 9780008229863
(Ages 9-12) Recommended. Themes: Literary characters. Booksellers. Mystery. Missing persons. Anna James introduces a truly wonderful world where you can step into your favourite books and interact with much-loved literary characters.
Eleven-year-old Tilly's mother mysteriously disappeared just after she gave birth to her daughter and ever since Tilly's been living with her loving grandparents above their bookshop 'Pages and Co.' She loves to immerse herself in her favourite stories, hidden in in the nooks and crannies, settled on a bean bag or visiting with Jack who runs the little cafe. He loves to experiment with food, making delicious literary inspired treats.
Tilly arrives home from school dripping wet; it's holiday time and she's prepared for a rather lonely week, with lots of reading and conversations with Jack. When she discovers a dusty cardboard box with her mother's name on the label, Tilly's world is turned upside down. Her favourite book characters Alice in Wonderland and Anne of Green Gables appear in the bookshop. Tilly discovers an amazing ability: she can bookwander into any story she chooses.
There are whimsical moments and interesting encounters with the Avonlea characters. With the help of her friend Oskar Roux who loves reading even though he has dyslexia, they venture into Wonderland and Treasure Island. Mysterious and slightly sinister Enoch Chalk is the enforcer. He keeps the strict rules of bookwandering, making sure that that no-one is left in a book or forms relationships with the characters. Will Tilly uncover the mystery of her mother's disappearance and find the truth about her birth father?
Anna James' imaginative and magical novel authentically captures the voices of fictional characters and their worlds. There is a warmth and cosiness to her bookshop setting and an intriguing and mysterious darker layer in the 'Underlibrary'. Paola Escobar's black and white line drawings spring up throughout adding drama and excitement. This is the first in a trilogy and it does rely on the reader's prior knowledge of classic children's books. It also sets up the extensive rules of bookwandering.
Tilly and the Bookwanderers is an exciting junior novel just right for readers who have enjoyed classic children's novels and love the wonder of being drawn into the magic of books.
Rhyllis Bignell

Island born by Junot Diaz

cover image

Ill. by Leo Espinosa. Oneworld, 2018. ISBN 9781786074775
(Age: 7-9) Recommended. Themes: Culture. Identity. Lola lives in an ethnically diverse community and the teacher's instruction to draw a picture of her 'first home' causes problems for her because she cannot remember! Interviewing others who have come from her home island gives her opportunity to 'see' her home through their eyes. The result for the reader is a beautiful metaphor of what life must have been like on the tropical island that they left. Not everything though was perfect on the island, with allusions to the reasons for Lola's resettlement in her new country. Lola's final picture includes all the aspects of the island of her birth in brilliant detail. (A somewhat cryptic reference to a 'monster' might need some adult help to explain the metaphor for something awful that the island had to deal with - perhaps political turmoil or conflict. And another reference to her grandmother's or her abuela's psychic may also need explanation or caution.)
Leo Espinosa, an award-winning illustrator, from Bogota in Columbia, illustrates this gentle exploration of identity with wonderful colour and vibrancy. The language of the island is Spanish (not everyone in the world speaks English!) and is included naturally and with references to terms and titles, which gives a reminder of diversity in the world. The author's background is from the Dominican Republic and later, New Jersey in USA, and so the book has an Americas influence which may not be understood by all readers, but it certainly would open eyes to how others live in the world and why some may choose to leave their 'home country'.
Recommended as a book to be shared and explained, for younger readers aged 7-9.
Carolyn Hull

Mary Lee: The life and times of a 'turbulent anarchist' and her battle for women's rights by Denise George

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2018. ISBN 9781743055960
Highly recommended. Themes: Biography. Mary Lee. South Australian history. Women's rights. Politics. Denise George has written a wonderful biography of one of the under-recognised pioneers in South Australian history - Mary Lee. Mary Lee was born in tough times in Ireland; later she worked hard in England as a teacher and came to South Australia in 1879. Her drive, faith and passion to assist those who were under-privileged came too and enabled her to make a difference in our society. Mary saw injustice and instead of remaining silent, she spoke out and wanted to ensure that inequality was addressed. From relatively humble beginnings, she argued and pressured local politicians and influential people to make it possible for women to have a voice in politics by gaining the right to vote. The result of her agitation and advocacy was to inspire many to become involved in the Women's Suffrage fight; to put pressure on the male politicians of the day; and ultimately to enable South Australia to become the first Australian state to provide the vote for women, and (somewhat accidentally) to be the first government to allow women to stand for political office. Her story though reveals that if not for her feisty and determined advocacy, this 'first' for South Australia would not have occurred when it did. Looking back in history can be confronting as we are reminded that the things we now consider obvious rights have in fact not always been the case. (I was stunned by the reference to the need for advocacy to change the age of consent - initially raising it from age 10 to 12, and also of the prevailing attitude of the men towards the intelligence of women in that era.) The world has indeed changed for women since Mary Lee lived and worked, and her role in promoting women's rights in South Australia should be remembered and acknowledged, and not just by those who are female.
This is a great book for those who love history and are interested in the history of South Australia and particularly the position of women in our history. It certainly should be on every library shelf in South Australia, but also would make a great gift for history buffs. Denise George has accessed many sources to paint a picture of a woman, who because of her gender perhaps did not always have her private life recorded for posterity. Fortunately, her advocacy has left a collection of powerful letters and writing that George has used to tell the story of this amazing woman who worked hard into her senior years on behalf of South Australian women.
Highly recommended.
Carolyn Hull

Scapegoat by Ava Keyes

cover image

Ill. by Aleksandra Szmidt. Little Steps Books, 2018. ISBN 9780648267461
(Age: 4+) Themes: Bullying. School. Families. Scapegoat finds that he is on the lowest rung at home. Making a bit of a mess sees him being told that he is useless and causing his mother's stress. When at the pond in the park he becomes totally wet after playing with his brother, his father takes up the mantra of Scapegoat doing the wrong thing, his screaming and shouting causing him to be stressed. As a result their outing is curtailed, making Scapegoat feel responsible for stopping the family's fun. No matter what the animal does, he seems to get on the wrong side of his parents, who treat him with disdain
But at school he is a bright, energetic student, and he tells his teacher, Mr Sheep of his problems at home. He consoles him, telling him that he should never apologise for being himself, and that parents are sometimes under stress and certainly do not mean to be mean.
At parent teacher night, Mr Sheep approaches the problem with Scapegoat's parents and the problem is turned on its head.
Neatly resolved, this unsubtle reminder that parents can be bullies as well as siblings and members of the peer group, the teacher is seen as the mediator for Scapegoat's problem, and brings the parents to some understanding of their child's unease.
This could be another book to add to the group which deal with bullying, and presents a different form of bullying which may not have been discussed in class.
Fran Knight

Between us by Clare Atkins

cover image

Black Inc, 2018. ISBN 9781760640217
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. KIN016 - this is Ana's number. She is an Iranian asylum-seeker brought from Nauru with her mother and 3 year old brother Arash to temporary detention in Darwin, because her mother is expecting a baby and is suffering from pre-eclampsia. Ana is haunted by the memories of something that happened to her in Iran, something she can't talk about, but coming to Darwin means that at last she can go to school, learn English and study her favourite subject, Science. And it is there that she meets Jono, the trouble-maker at the back of the class. Jono and his friends are bored with school and experimenting with drugs and alcohol. But his attention is caught by the nerdy girl with her head wrapped tightly in a scarf.
The story is told in the alternating voices of the three main characters: Ana, Jono and Jono's father Kenny, just starting as a security guard at the detention centre. The three voices are so real: Ana - fearful and uncertain but desperate to learn; Jono - rebellious, in conflict with his father, finding escape in heavy music and risk-taking; and Kenny - struggling as a single parent, not knowing how to handle his son, and suspicious of the motives of the young detainee.
It is a beautifully written book, the voice of Jono initially written in verse, and that of Ana in prose, but then this is reversed as their interests change and develop. Eventually as the pace builds, a sentence begun by one will be finished by the other as each picks up the story.
Atkins vividly brings to life the world of the teenagers - the uncertainty and doubt, the budding friendship, the mistakes and misunderstandings. Ana and Jono's romance is threatened in so many ways. The tension in the relationship between Ana, Jono and Kenny gradually builds to an explosive crisis point . . .
Atkins has obviously researched the world of the detention camp: the traumatised asylum seekers, separated from family, always in fear of jeopardising their refugee application, and the hardening attitude and indifference of the guards as they enforce cruel and meaningless rules. Newbie guards either harden or break. Kenny is afraid of which way he will go.
The book gives a fictional expression to the experience of cruelty and hopelessness described in the non-fiction No man is an island (2016) by Adele Dumont, about her time as an English language tutor at Curtin detention centre in Western Australia. In fact students could compare the two books for a transformation task, picking up on the minor character of the naive caseworker Eliza in Between us and consider the story from her perspective, as a worker in the detention centre.
Between us is a truly gripping story, the voices draw you in, and then the pace builds so that it is impossible to put down. I read this in one sitting and was left reeling at the end. It is such a powerful story, extremely well written, the people and situations are so authentic, you know as a reader that while Ana, Jono and Kenny are fictional, their story reflects real people and real situations.
Helen Eddy

Witch tricks by Sibeal Pounder

cover image

Witch Wars book 6. Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2018. ISBN 9781408894125
(Age: 9+) Witch Tricks follows the concurrent and intersecting antics of the Witches and Fairies of Sinkville. (Ever wondered what lies beyond the plughole?) While Fran the Fabulous Fairy schemes to be the star of a TV wrestling show called 'Fairy Fightz', Tiga Whicabim and Fluffanora Brew are not having much luck in joining the exclusive secret society of the Points. The girls in the Points are trying their hand at a spell to bring the Ritzy Six back to Pearl Mountain so they can be taught how to wreak havoc by the best in the business. Meanwhile, we are left wondering why Felicity Bat is laying low and talking to her boots, which are suddenly very heavy.
The Points are surprisingly successful at conjuring forth the Ritzy Six who dash off to Pearl Mountain before the reader can blink. If you don't know where that is, check the illustrator's map. Tiga and Fluffanora, aided by Peggy Pigwiggle, must somehow beat the both Ritzy Six and the Points to the top of Pearl mountain to keep Sinkville on an even keel. The journey to the mountain top is eventful and takes up a lot of the story. While Fran is incapacitated, Patricia the TV show Producer, has to be very inventive to save the next episode of 'Fairy Fightz'. Pounder manages to keep her reader's in the loop by visiting the set of 'Fairy Fightz' and writing articles for the Ritzy City Post, when she is not checking in on Felicity and her heavy boots (complete with a shrunken Panda) at Linden House.
Chatty like all their adventures, you'll have to listen carefully to know how the witches and fairies deal with the infamous Ritzy Six. One high point is Aggie Hoof's joke about what Felicity should name her Panda. Illustrations by Laura Ellen Anderson help new readers to place the numerous characters - be they witches or fairies. The book finishes with sample chapters from Pounder's latest Bad Mermaids series and a letter about her childhood writing inspirations to likewise inspire young writers. Witch Tricks is definitely a spin-out if you are a pre-teen who likes erratic, plot driven escapism.
Deborah Robins

Diary Disaster by Meredith Costain

cover image

Ill. by Danielle McDonald. Ella Diaries book 14. Scholastic, 2018, ISBN 9781743818077
(Age: 7-9) Themes: Diaries, Turtle Conservation, Camping. Ella is a bubbly, bright character who loves to record and sketch all her activities, her feelings and the dramas of her life in her diary. Peach is a dominant colour in this fourteenth junior novel and for fans who love Ella's recounts, this shows that her enemy Her Royal Pushiness Princess Peach Parker is involved. Ella's excited to board the ferry for a five-day school excursion to Turtle Island. There will be beachcombing, craft, and lots of fun with her friends. What is fantabulously FABULOUS is the opportunity to watch baby turtles hatching and learn about their conservation.
Ella's one concern is how to hide her diary; she disguises it inside an old book cover with the title of 50 Scrumptious Ways to Cook Green Vegetables! Peach Parker and her two annoying friends push their way on to the bus and grab the favoured back seats much to Ella's annoyance. Adding to her woes, is the fact that Peach, Prinny and Jade are all in her cabin as well.
Nature walks, creative murals with natural objects, driftwood, shells and found objects and a visit to the lagoon are some of the highlights on Monday and Tuesday. Wednesday morning the mood changes, there's different style of writing, bolder and darker and peach becomes the predominant colour: yes Ella's enemy Peach has stolen her diary and taken over the commentary. She adds unflattering details about Ella's beach volleyball skills and she gives Ella and Zoe the worst jobs during the mural making - cleaning up. How will Peach and Ella resolve their problems?
Meredith Costain continues to write fun and relatable stories for a younger audience who love Ella's unique expressions, world-view and cute sketches. Diary Disaster is another entertaining and easy to read chronicle of Ella's life.
Rhyllis Bignell

The Storm Keeper's Island by Catherine Doyle

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408896884
(Age: 11-14) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy; Magic; Fear and Bravery; Memory. Eleven year old Fionn and his older sister, Tara, are returned to the ancestral home of their mother and late father on Arronmore Island off the Irish coast. Their mother's depression means they must learn to survive in the isolated community with their grandfather, the mysterious Island Storm Keeper. From the moment the scared Fionn steps off the ferry it seems that the Island's magic rises up to meet him. Will he be the one to save the Island? Slowly he discovers his Grandfather's secrets as Candlemaker and Storm Keeper, but his bravery is sorely tested when Tara's friendship with another boy on the Island prompts him to find answers to the Island's secrets - perhaps to his peril. And the mysterious candles store memories and provide opportunity to travel back to other times, testing the bravery of the young Fionn, but giving him opportunity to understand the Island's secrets.
With mystery and magic circling in amazing ways and with an undercurrent of trapped sinister magic ready to unleash itself, this book will entrance young readers that love fantasy tales. At times it is a little bit scary, funny, enigmatic, sad and yet hope-charged. It is written in a delightful way, rich with metaphor and with wonderful descriptive passages and endearing character descriptions. The wonderful Grandfather is an absolute delight.
Highly recommended for readers aged 11-14
Note: this appears to be the first book in the series.
Carolyn Hull

Liars: The truth app by Jack Heath

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781743817766
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Themes: Cybersecurity; Adventure; Crime; Conspiracy. Jarli is a coding Whiz-kid who has just developed a 'Truth-detecting' app and released the code for assessment by others and it instantly created waves around the world. The interest didn't just come from the fellow app-developing community and the impact of the app made him the target of lots of unwelcome attention. At the same time, his father also seems to have big problems. The attempt on their lives when a car barrels into them after Parent-Teacher interviews demonstrates that their world has been plunged into dangerous territory, and everything has lost its standard stability. And there is no way anyone can lie to cover their tracks because the app will reveal every untruth! This early chaos then escalates further in a race to protect family and friends in an adventure that occurs at an intense pace. The tech-savvy action is akin to a conspiracy thriller involving teenagers.
Every teen will love this action adventure. There is never a dull moment and everything moves with roller-coaster intensity. Readers will be desperate to find out 'who, what or why', and there will be more in the series!
Highly recommended for readers aged 13+
Carolyn Hull

Marvel Fearless and Fantastic! Female Super Heroes Save the World by Sam Maggs, Emma Grange and Ruth Amos

cover image

DK, 2018. ISBN 9780241357491
(Age: 8+) Themes: Superheroes; Women. Characters from the Marvel world encourage people to be determined, daring, compassionate and curious. Under each of these headings are described superheroes who embody these qualities. So under the heading 'Determined' the reader will be inspired by Captain Marvel, Spider-Woman and Jessica Jones among others. Superheroes described as being daring are Hawkeye, Misty Knight, Mary Jane Watson and many more. The endearing Squirrel Girl leads the list of compassionate superheroes, mingling with Medusa, Singularity and Pepper Potts. Among the curious are She-Hulk, Kitty Pryde and Spider-Girl.
Each superhero is given a full page of text describing how she developed her superpowers and who she has worked with and on the opposite page is a full page coloured illustration, which gives a glimpse into her character as well as the costume that she might don when on rescue missions.
There is a diverse range of women from many backgrounds including Black Widow, a former Russian assassin, Ms Marvel a 16 year old Pakistan-American Muslim girl, Korean American Silk, and Nico Minoru, of Japanese-American parents. Some of the superheroes like Dr Toni Ho and Ironheart, rely on their intelligence to get things done and would make great role models for young readers.
This is a fun book to dip into and readers are sure to find a number of superheroes whose stories they would like to pursue.
Pat Pledger