Reviews

Jae-Dee survives the home of many mothers by Jae-Dee Collier

cover image

Balboa Press, 2018. ISBN: 9781504315692.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Jae-Dee's sad story of abandonment to an Adelaide orphanage as a three year old in the 1950s is fictionalised, told from the point of view of the child. So it's the child's voice we hear as she struggles to make sense of the world she finds herself in, longing for love but always receiving rejection and humiliation from Sster, as the children call the nun in charge. Sster Grace couldn't be more removed from the idea of grace; she is harsh and cruel, beats the children in her charge and subjects them to cruel taunting and humiliation. Jae-Dee is a bed-wetter, and as a three year old has to drag her sheets to the laundry, hand-wash them, and drag the clothes basket to the clothesline.
Jae-Dee has beautiful memories of her parents, a handsome couple gliding across the ballroom. She longs to be with them. But whilst they are good intentioned, they are a fragile couple, her mother ill and teetering on depression and her father too fond of the drink. Nevertheless, for Jae-Dee it is the love of her mother and father that she constantly craves - she desperately wants to be reunited with them and with her younger sisters. It is the abuse and lack of love in the orphanage that becomes the most damaging experience.
Collier clearly writes from her memories; she captures exactly how a three year old struggles with the stairs, planting both feet on each step, and then how she skips to keep up with the nun's quick stride along the corridor. We share in the child's love of warm sweet food like rice pudding, and her detestation of boiled vegetables. And we empathise with her humiliation and embarrassment as she wakes each morning in a wet bed. From time to time, Collier adds a comment as an adult, reminding us this all really happened - children who were so in need of love and care, were kept in the most cold and uncaring environment, in an institution that was supposed to stand for love and charity.
At the end of the book, Collier includes the transcript of the Prime Minister's 2009 apology to the Forgotten Australians and former child migrants; a recognition and regret for the experiences of children who suffered neglect and abuse in orphanages, and a reminder that the protection of children is a sacred duty. It is to be hoped that in writing her story, Collier finds release from some of the memories, and strength in knowing she is a survivor.
Helen Eddy

The quiet at the end of the world by Lauren James

cover image

Walker Books; 2019. ISBN: 9781406375510. 352p; p/b.
(Age: Middle secondary+) Recommended. In a future where the human race is infertile, the last two people to ever be born confront the fear of loneliness when a mystery disease rages through an already dwindling population.
It's difficult to discuss what makes this book good, because its best aspects hinge on a plot twist that shouldn't be spoilt. It tackles some interesting ethical issues that are becoming increasingly relevant today, and some thought provoking takes on the future of humanity. Don't worry though, it's not all heavy futurism - the novel also contains some quite personal themes of love and secrets. It's quite engaging, with a unique narrative device of reading through archived chat-logs online, interspersed at precisely paced intervals with more traditional narration. The representation in the cast is inspiring - bi and trans will last as long as humanity does.
You will just have to read it yourself, it is a wonderful read. The book is suitable for middle secondary-aged readers due to the themes discussed, however it can be a good conversation with classes as to the diversity and power of humanity.
Vincent Hermann

Sea Bear: a journey for survival by Lindsay Moore

cover image

Greenwillow Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780062791283. 48pp., hbk.
Imagine you are a polar bear.
Your coat is thick. Your teeth are sharp.
Your front paws are paddles, your back paws are rudders, and you can swim for miles.
Your home has always been the sea and the ice.
A sea bear, far north in the Arctic, hunts and naps and raises her young. She moves with the ice, swimming, running, stalking seals, resting. She follows the rhythm of the sea and the seasons. But what happens when those rhythms change? What happens when there is no ice?
Told from the perspective of a female bear, the reader is taken on a journey of the Arctic seasons starting in spring when the ice is thick and the baby seals numerous, through to summer when the water warms and the ice melts, making it too thin to stand on and the seals more wary and quicker. Smelling land on the offshore breeze, the bear starts to swim to shore for food but it is a long arduous and perilous journey filled with lots of other creatures of the cold seas. But above all, polar bears are patient and so she continues knowing that the world will turn, the time will pass and winter will come again. Courage, determination, resilience - even in the animal kingdom.
As well as the evocative text, it is the illustrations which make this book a stand-out. Using a palette of a myriad of blues, the reader is treated to all the moods and times of this wonderland - starry night skies, ocean depths and shallows, the aurora borealis, the breaking ice pack and isolate seashore. While it could be a story of any sea bear, using the first person builds a connection with the reader so we are invested in her survival as well as that of all her kind. Her companions of the deep become less threatening as they pass by each other as Moore's illustrations reflect her Master of Science in Medical and Scientific Illustration.
A page of information about sea ice and polar bears and another introducing the creatures she passes on her journey to shore add to the value of this book which shines a light on the plight of Arctic (and Antarctic) creatures as global warming continues and the amount of sea ice declines each year.
A valuable addition to your environment and sustainability collection.
Barbara Braxton

The boy: His stories and how they came to be by Oliver Jeffers

cover image

HarperCollins, 2018. ISBN: 9780008294342. 168pp., hbk.
In 2004, Oliver Jeffers set out to do a painting of someone trying to do something impossible - a boy catching a star with a butterfly net - and that idea evolved not only into the book How to catch a star but into a series of four stories including Lost and found, The way back home and Up and down.
Now collected into one collection, this book also offers a unique look behind the scenes at the development of each book. As well as a letter from Jeffers himself explaining how the series grew (and may still do so, although that is unlikely), it contains more than 100 distinctive sketches, notes and ideas that he has chosen from his archives that show the thoughts, events and incidents that shaped the stories.
Apart from its inherent beauty, this book has much to offer about how stories grow in the minds of their creators, giving it an appeal and a use far beyond the target audience of the original stories themselves.
Barbara Braxton

Mummy Cuddle by Kate Mayes

cover image

Illus. by Sara Acton. ABC Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780733339431.
(Age: 1-5) Highly recommended. Themes: Bedtime, Parent and child, Mothers, Feel good book. A lovely gentle but very humorous book Mummy cuddle tugs at the heartstrings and leaves the reader feeling happy after reading it. Bunny creeps out of bed and 'brum brum', pushes a little car down the stairs and asks Mummy to play. Mummy is very patient and carries him back upstairs on her back and quietly answers questions while trying to get Bunny to sleep.
The narrative is sparse with most double page spreads having only two words: 'Mummy play?' Mummy talk?' 'Mummy brush?' 'Mummy pat' until finally 'Mummy dream' and 'Mummy cuddle'. Children will have fun predicting just what Bunny will come up with next in the quest to stay awake and many will know just what will happen. Sara Acton's outstanding illustrations done in soft pastels, with Mummy and Bunny outlined in black, are enchanting. The characteristics of both are clear - Mummy is such a loving, unflappable parent while Bunny is persistent but loving as well, even covering Mummy with a blanket as she sleeps on the floor. The endpapers are worthy of close examination, the front ones showing Bunny having a bath and getting ready for bed, while the back ones show an exuberant dance.
This would be an ideal book to share with children on Mother's Day in particular, but the message of parental love is one for any time. I can see it becoming a cherished book that celebrates the bond between mother and child.
Pat Pledger

On the come up by Angie Thomas

cover image

Walker Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781406372168.
(Age: Young adult) Recommended. On the come up by Angie Thomas is a hard-hitting contemporary young adult novel novel that brings light to topics such as racial stereotyping and discrimination of people due to their social class.
Bri has always dreamed of being a famous rapper like her dad so when she gets the chance to compete in an amateur rap battle in her inner-city neighbourhood she jumps on it. She believes that becoming a rapper is the key to saving her family from poverty and to rise above the racism and hate she experiences from being African American in her community.
The characters in this novel were realistic and unique from each other. Their personalities and ambitions in the novel were memorable and special to that character. This made you feel like you were getting to know and forming real relationships with the characters in the novel.
The plot was unique and spoke about racial inequality in a way that clearly highlighted the injustices minorities face daily in real life. These heavy topics are delivered in a non-graphic and easy to interpret way so readers young or old will feel as if they have gained knowledge and a deeper understanding of racial prejudice.
The imagery and language choices were true to the setting of the novel which is a predominately African American neighbourhood. It felt as if I was transported to America and could hear the characters through their realistic dialogue. The language choices were clear and easy to understand which is most likely because this book is aimed at young adults.
Overall, I would recommend this book to a younger audience who would like to know more about the injustices racial minorities face in modern day society. It is a fast paced but still emotional impactful read. If you enjoy realistic characters and an action packed plot this is the book for you!
Amy Folker (student)

52 Mondays by Anna Ciddor

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760523480.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Themes: family, dolls, childhood, Jewish customs. Anna is a young Jewish girl growing up in 1960's Melbourne, Australia. The story follows Anna, her two sisters and her extended family through a year of celebrations, illness and the hunt for the perfect antique doll. The story revolves around the hunt that is created by Anna's desire to own a doll just like the one in her favourite book Hitty, the life and adventures of a wooden doll, which she has borrowed from the library. Anna's mother is a willing participant in the hunt and after Anna reads in the final chapter that Hitty's final owner purchases her through an auction house; the family spends every Monday looking through a local auction place for the perfect antique doll.
The story also highlights the changing face of the world as the story looks at the changes within the family and the world around them, the excitement of making Deb mashed potato or eating kosher chicken from the supermarket rather than Nona having to make it. Anna includes the excitement of buying a half penny ice-cream from the Mr. Whippy van and the joy of shopping in the city.
Her imagery and gentle tone makes this book an easy read and will engage readers who are interested in history, family life and childhood memories. This would be a fabulous book to open up the lines of communication between the generations and encourage talk of childhood memories when there were no seat-belts in cars, being the chalk monitor was the highest honour at school and children drank free milk at recess.
Mhairi Alcorn

Master of Sorrows by Justin Call

cover image

Gollancz, 2019. ISBN: 9781473222878. 577 pages, paperback.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Contains violent scenes and depictions of death. High fantasy. The Academy of Chaenbalu has stood against magic for centuries. Hidden from the world, acting from the shadows, it trains its students to detect and retrieve magic artifacts, which it jealously guards from the misuse of others. Because magic is dangerous, something that heals can also harm, and a power that aids one person may destroy another. Of the Academy's many students, only the most skilled can become Avatars - warrior thieves, capable of infiltrating the most heavily guarded vaults - and only the most determined can be trusted to resist the lure of magic. More than anything, Annev de Breth wants to be one of them.
Master of sorrows is a strongly written dark fantasy novel, similar in tone and feel to the likes of We are blood and thunder by Kesia Lupo. Call does not hesitate to highlight the dark side of humanity, with the themes of lies, deception, discrimination, wars, and death featuring prominently in the novel. His worldbuilding is astounding and makes the story's setting feel grounded and real. He crafts a deeply flawed, young protagonist who bears too much at too young an age, making you feel empathy for Annev, rejoicing at his triumph and despairing as he falls while he fights for his chance in the sun. While Master of sorrows follows a trend of stories with academy-trained warriors, thieves and assassins, it stands out from the rest due to the protagonist's desire to rise above the brutality and act with mercy and compassion, which are often lost in similar stories. We see this empathy was developed through his bond with his mentor and as Annev experiences discrimination due to physical deformities, which in the novel, mark him as a vile agent of evil. Call speaks against this cruel and misinformed idea as he presents Annev as a flawed but deeply caring individual.
While this novel's themes are evident, the events seem jumbled and plot points were touched upon then never raised again in a way that felt unfinished or not explored to its full potential. There are also extremely disturbing descriptions not suitable for a younger audience. Despite this, this was a strong high fantasy novel full of both gritty realism and the buoyant kindness of the protagonist. I would recommend to people who enjoy stories such as Nevernight by Jay Kristoff and We are blood and thunder by Kesia Lupo.
Stephanie Lam(Student)

Cowboy and Birdbrain by A. Wallace and J. Hart

cover image

Scholastic. 2019. ISBN: 9781760661588. 185p
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Cowboy is not a ringer - nor an NRL footy player. He's an actual boy with a cow's head! He and his partner Birdbrain, also a hybrid creature, work for a delivery company called 'Iffy'. You guessed it, their motto: 'We Deliver FARTS - Fast And Reliable Tracking Services'. After a call-in from the Company Secretary, Ms Hambacon, (pronounced Harm Bayshon) Cowboy and Birdbrain are grudgingly given an important delivery deadline by their boss. Between their own incompetence and the interference of a rival delivery team, the duo must overcome a number of impossible hurdles to complete their mission.
This graphic story can't miss. Adam Wallace's far-fetched narrative is littered with funny word play and acronyms. The adventure melds perfectly with James Hart's quirky caricatures in a rich parallel narrative.
The mandatory page of stickers is an unnecessary incentive because middle schoolers will be lining up for the unavoidable giggles.
Deborah Robins

The secret runners of New York by Matthew Reilly

cover image

Macmillian, 2019. ISBN: 9781760559076. Paperback, 352 pg.
(Age: Upper primary - Secondary) A must read for thriller and dystopian readers. Think of Gossip Girl meets Mad Max. The story is about a shy girl, Skye, who moves to New York with her brother Red. They move in with their mum's boyfriend in a very affluent building. Skye tries to keep her head down at school but gets caught up with the elite kids of New York. Within the group Skye and Red join, are the Secret Runners of New York group who can gain access to a ground portal that transports whoever enters to the future which was effected by a Gamma Cloud.
Matthew Reilly writes about everyday life of a teenager and how they cope in society, while every day is leading up to a Doomsday when a Gamma Cloud is going to appear to end the world as we know it. As the runners keep going through the porthole they realise that the Gamma Cloud is real and they see what happens in the future.
Overall, I found the book easy to read and enjoyable. I was hooked from the start wanting to know what happened to the missing females from the same school and whether Skye would become one of them as well.
In schools, some great discussions you could have with students would be about bullying within the school and how it affected kids. Another topic would be about the poor, middle class and the rich and how what happened in the world affected these people.
All up, I found The secret runners of New York a great read. I did laugh at the dedication at the front: 'This book is for everyone who went to high school... and survived.' Cause yes I'm one of those people.
Maria Komninos

Ninja switch by Anh Do

cover image

Ninja Kid book 3. Scholastic, 2019. ISBN: 9781760662820. 186p.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Family, Humour. Nelson, Kenny, and their gutsy grandma deliver another hilarious adventure. Nelson, tired of being the school nerd, wants to let his cover slip a little at the annual athletics carnival. Despite Kenny's enthusiasm, both Mum and Grandma put the kybosh on his plans to win an event or two. We sense rebellion is afoot until unintentionally, Grandma's latest invention tampers with Nelson's super powers. In the same vein of Damian Young's, My Nana is a Ninja, Grandma takes on the mantle of Ninja. Sadly, Nelson's feeble performance at the Athletics Carnival is more dismal than ever and worse, he can't impress Sarah, the girl's champion. Ironically, it's a blessing in disguise since the new Carnival sponsor is very interested in the highest performing students. Too interested perhaps? Can Nelsen and his eccentric family, foil Dr Kane's plans to kidnap and unmask the Ninja Kid?
Nelson has Kenny and Ahn Do has Jeremy Ley to draw the pictures. Together they make a very amusing adventure for middle-schoolers and STEM students who will be inspired to construct gadgets which are functional and fun. One certainty is that everyone is bound to get a kick out of the much anticipated 3rd volume in the Ninja Kid series.
Deborah Robins

Courting Darkness by Robin LaFevers

cover image

His fair assassin, Counting darkness duology, book 1. Anderson Press, 2019. ISBN: 9781783448265.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. Themes: Historical fantasy, France - History, Brittany, Assassins. After devouring the three books in the award winning His fair assassin series, I was thrilled to read the story of Genevieve, a young girl who has been undercover for so long, that she is no longer sure that she will be called up as a daughter of Saint Mortain by the convent. She becomes embroiled with a prisoner and manages to take matters into her own hands. Meanwhile Sybella from Dark triumph, returns and is accompanying the duchess on her way to be married to the King of France. She is surrounded by enemies and her only hope is to get help from the novitiates who had been hidden in the French court so many years ago.
Although Courting darkness could be read as a stand-alone, with the author giving enough information to set the scene, readers would enjoy the book more if they had read the first three books in His fair assassin series, Grave mercy, Dark Triumph, and Mortal heart.
The story is told from two points of view, that of Sybella and Genevieve. Sybella relates the travails of Anne of Brittany, who is trying to save her country. Sybella is terrified for the safety of her two sisters and is desperate for help. Genevieve's involvement with the unknown prisoner and her uncertainty about Saint Mortain, give another view of what is going on, and the mystery surrounding the prisoner is tantalising.
The world of medieval France is enthralling, with the descriptions of the intrigue, the power mongering, the fear and the prisons taking the reader right into this time in history. Peopled with real characters as well as the fantasy daughters of Saint Mortain, it makes for a fascinating read for lovers of historical fantasy.
A difficult wait for the second book in the duology is in store for the reader, who is left on a tantalising cliff-hanger. Readers who like Juliet Marillier's books, the Witchlands trilogy by Susan Dennard and the Lumatere chronicles by Melina Marchetta are likely to enjoy Counting darkness.
Pat Pledger

Little Badman and the invasion of the killer aunties by Humza Arshad and Henry White

cover image

Illus. by Aleksei Bitskoff. Puffin Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780241340608.
(Ages: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Family relationships, Pakistanis in Great Britain, Rap music, Friendship, Missing persons, Good and evil. Humza Khan is a typical 11-year-old who is prone to making up stories and mucking around in class, but he does not see this as a problem because he knows he will one day be the most famous Rap artist the world has ever seen. He and his friends notice something funny happening at school when, one by one, the staff disappear and are replaced with Pakistani 'aunties' who seem determined to fatten up the children. The great food seems wonderful at first but slowly Humza, his friends Umer and Wendy realize it must be part of an evil plan. The friends are brought closer together by their need to solve this mystery. Humza's uncle, who is called Grandpa because of his aged appearance, is also a character that features in their hunt to find the truth.
Many Primary school boys will identify with Humza's character and through the story he grows as a person to know and fully appreciate his family through his adventures at school. As he says '. . . there is nothing in the world like an alien slug invasion to make you appreciate your loved ones . . . ' It is a fast-paced, rollicking story that will keep the audience reading to the end.
Throughout the story we are given glimpses of the Pakistani culture that forms so much of Humza's life in Britain. This may not be easy for children in Australia to understand but it could bring about some great discussion about immigration and refugees. The book is written in first person and would be a good story to read aloud with an upper primary class.
The author Humza Mohammed Arshad is an English actor, comedian and writer of Pakistani descent. He is best known for his web series Diary of a Bad Man (2010-2013) and Badman (2015-2018). Henry White is a comedy writer who has written for TV, on-line and most recently in children's fiction.
Gabrielle Anderson

The blue bench by Albert Asensio

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2019. ISBN: 9780648397304.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Diversity, Friendship. First published in Catalonia, this evocative picture book reveals more of its subtle depths on rereading. A park bench is at the centre of the tale, surveying all it sees as life goes on through the year. As seasons come and go, different people use the bench, different animals appear in the trees' branches, and a variety of people walk past. Each is portrayed on the pages of this book, like a time lapse camera, revealing a parade of life and activities.
The bench is painted, a squirrel collects nuts, pigeons mess up the ground around, but the painter, Peter comes back to clean up the mess. Over the years children play together in the sandpit and eventually two fall in love, a variety of people and their dogs sit on the bench, watching the world go by, the young and the old, the boy and girl coming together, paralleled by the birds in the tree. A nest is built, eggs appear,and the couple still sit on the bench, but one day when it snows, she sits on the bench alone, and keeps on coming to that same bench week after week, smiling in her memories. And then someone else sits beside her, the bench again a witness to the continuance of life.
A charming witty tale of the continuity of life, of seasons and generations, of the old adage, 'life goes on', gloriously supported by softly rendered illustrations emphasising companionship and continuance.
Fran Knight

Bizz Buzz Boss by Natalie McKinnon

cover image

Ill. by Margaret Tolland. Starfish Bay, 2018. ISBN: 9781760360566.
(Age: 3-6) Themes: Bees, Spiders, Animals, Respect, Behaviour Management. In Natalie McKinnon's picture book Bizz Buzz Boss a very bossy bee lords it over all the other garden creatures who are busy with their daily tasks. Little Spider loves to listen to the homely sounds as she rests in a curly leaf. She hears the 'drip, drip, drippetty-drip' of the tap and the owl family's twit-twoo (shouldn't they be asleep.) However, the bossy bee who has a strong sense of self-importance, explains that her job as pollen-collector is more significant than the worms, ladybugs and lizards.
Little Spider appeals to Bossy Bee's vain nature by suggesting the hard-working creature needs to rest, wrapped up in her silvery, sticky web. As the bee remains immobile, it observes the worm aerating and fertilising the earth, the ladybug nibbling the aphids off the lettuce and the lizard catching the pesky slugs. Humbled by these observations, Bossy Bee states,
Oh, Spider, I promise to stop being bossy.
I've learned a lesson today.
I'll respect other creatures and value their jobs.
We should work as a team every day!

There's the moral to the story, you need to value other's efforts and not brag about your own. Natalie McKinnon's simple rhyming verse spoken by each creature is overly wordy for the young readers this is targeted at. Margaret Tolland's colourful painted illustrations provide close-ups of each of the creatures working in their lush garden settings. Bizz Buzz Boss is a didactic tale suited for sharing with young audience.
Rhyllis Bignell