Reviews

Sweet sorrow by David Nicholls

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton 2019. ISBN: 9781444715415.
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Sweet sorrow is a lament to the end of childhood and to first love. A bildungsroman, the novel follows Charlie Lewis on his quest to get to know the lovely Fran Fisher, amateur actor and Shakespeare aficionado. In an attempt to impress, or get her number, Charlie agrees to join a production of Romeo and Juliet that the Full Fathom Five Theatre Co-operative are organising over the Summer. Without his mates to join him in his scorn, Charlie finds himself intrigued with the players and the drama students.
While he scoffs at theatre sports, Charlie finds himself with friendships completely different to the friendly scuffles and drunken antics of those he's known before. Being part of the play allows Charlie not only to get close to Fran, but also to grow as a person independent of the politics of the boys and rebelling against his parents' expectations. But the pressure of looking out for his father and navigating the ditch between his parents and him and his sister is almost too much. When the walls Charlie built to keep himself and his dad safe start to crumble, everything quickly comes crashing down.
Told both in the present and retrospect, Sweet sorrow follows the summer Charlie threw off social expectations he'd come to respect in school, he starts to work to pull his life together after the stress of his father's erratic behaviour, bankruptcy, and divorce sends him down a dark and spiralling path of failure. I would highly recommend this novel to boys twelve and up who struggle to fit in and achieve at school as they might find some parallels with Charlie.
Kayla Gaskell

Winston and the Wondrous Wooba Gymnastics Club by Tamsin Janu

cover image

Omnibus, 2019. ISBN: 9781760662509.
(Ages: 8-14) Highly recommended. Themes: Friendship, Adversity. Australian country town life is at the heart of this story, and its theme is the challenge to improvise when the going gets tough, while remaining positive through adverse difficulties.
Winston and his mother Carol, live in the little town of Wooba, home of Big Bread, a towering monument to local wheat farming. Winston is very proud of everything in Wooba (especially the decrepit Big Bread) and is eager to share it all with his new family from Dubbo, in particular, his new sister Macy.
But the move to Wooba dashes Macy's dreams of becoming an Olympic gymnast, and she's making her feelings known to all. How is Winston going to help Macy resign herself to living in the tiny town, and make progress towards her dream, while also saving the Big Bread and the economy of his home town. These are big challenges and Winston won't be able to rise to them alone.
The story follows the up and downs of the children as they bring adults alongside, learn lessons from life, from their friends, and from the adults who support them. And learn a lot about gymnastics along the way. Teacher's notes are available.
Long live the spirit of the Australian country town.
Donna Isgar

Wilder girls by Rory Power

cover image

Macmillan Children's Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781529021288.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Wilder girls is a gory dystopia, with the Tox mutating the systems of students at Raxter School for Girls. The mutation affects each of the girls differently, from coughing up blood and teeth to having dual hearts. Their only hope for a cure is the Navy and CDC who are desperately researching the Raxter phenomenon.
With restrictions on food and other resources, the girls are half wild with the Tox, a new order has been established from the old with fights and power struggles upheld by the remaining two teachers - Welch and Headmistress and the three Boat Shift Girls. Taylor, Carson, and Julie are charged with keeping the peace among students as well as the dangerous task of retrieving supplies dropped at the pier at irregular intervals.
The story follows Hetty and her friends Reese and Byatt. Having established their friendship prior to the Tox, the girls ties are only strengthened by their trials - that is until Hetty is called upon for Boat Shift and Byatt goes missing. People die all the time at Raxter but something about Byatt's disappearance is different. Hetty is determined to find and save her friend, no matter the cost. And the cost is bound to be high.
Brutal and thrilling, Wilder girls captures the fear similar to The natural way of things and The promised Neverland whilst remaining highly engaging. With the grittiness of This mortal coil and the familiarity of a high school setting, this novel has a feeling of authenticity as the girls struggle with not only the effects of the Tox but the social issues to do with violence, self-preservation, and the realities of survival. I would recommend to girls fourteen and up.
Kayla Gaskel

Victoria Bubbles and the great preschool adventure by Lizzie Dingle and Andrew McIntosh

cover image

Little Steps, 2019, ISBN: 9781925839005.
(Age: 3-5) Themes: Preschool, Adventure. Lizzie Dingle writes from personal experience; as a working mum she was worried about her oldest boy's first day at preschool. His teacher welcomed the youngsters with beautiful bubbles, inspiring the author to write her charming rhyming book Victoria Bubbles and the great preschool adventure. Her aim is help parents 'develop, nurture and create positive associations with preschool.' Andrew McIntosh's action-packed digital illustrations are bright and bold, they capture Bailey's emotions and uncover the wonderful bubble adventures he takes with his class and teacher. Take time to talk about the bubble shapes, the glittery scenes and the fun each child experiences.
Bailey's mother is very reassuring, encouraging him as they walk through the colourful playground. Inside he's greeted by Victoria Bubbles his teacher and hundreds of bubbles filling the room. When she holds our the most beautiful glittery wand and asks her young learners to make a wish, we know magic is about to happen. Inside the huge bubble, the children and teacher are swept away past rugged mountains, deep into the ocean and into a gorgeous serene rainforest. Rolling and sliding they slide down a snow-covered mountain and from the safety of the bubble, they enjoy a snowball fight. On into outer space and finally a rest at the beach before the bell sounds. What does Bailey share about his magical journey with his mum at the end of the day?
Lizzie Dingle's delightful story is just right for sharing, opening conversations about being confident, acknowledging concerns and creating a peace of mind, with their young children preparing for their first days at preschool, kindergarten or childcare.
Rhyllis Bignell

Baa baa black sheep: the fleeced fleece by John Barwick and Dave Atze

cover image

Nursery Crimes Case One. Big Sky Publishing, 2019. ISBN: 9781925675993.
Themes: Humour, Mystery. What a funny re-imaging, with a clever twist, of the popular nursery rhyme, Baa baa black sheep.
The central character in the story as an amateur detective is Little Miss Muffett, who is capable, smart, calm and practical. In Case One, she teams up with Baa Baa Black Sheep, to solve a crime, hinted at in the rhyme, but previously concealed.
Other familiar nursery rhyme characters also make appearances, as well as some popular fairy story characters. The book doggedly takes on the cover-up and complex web of crime and corruption to unlock the secret to this much loved, but confusingly incomplete rhyme.
The book's illustrations, in black and white, feature cartoonish characters and add to the humour of the book.
Donna Isgar

The Monster who wasn't by T.C. Shelley

cover image

Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781526600837.
(Age: 10-12). Highly Recommended. Themes: Monsters - fiction, Mythical creatures, Gargoyles, Families. This novel tells the story of a strange Imp boy born into the Monster world from the sigh of a dying man and the laugh of a baby. This unique combination creates an unusual creature who is eagerly awaited by the Ogre king Thunderguts. As soon as he is born the strange Imp is frightened by the underworld he sees, and he escapes to join a gang of lovable Gargoyles who take him into the world of humans to their home on top of a cathedral. His first few days of life are coloured by the feelings of wonder as he learns about his surroundings and the creatures he has come to know as his pack. A kind angel is his protector and helps him learn more about the world of monsters and humans.
The monsters are richly imagined and described in delightful detail by the author striking a perfect balance between scary and grotesque. Their actions towards humans are all controlled by a powerful sword that keeps them from harming humans in their realm. Thunderguts continues to look for the Imp so Daniel, his guardian angel, takes him to the home of a family to hide out. He is soon discovered by the children at a wake and they take him in as one of their own making him very happy to be part of a real family. But the human and monster worlds cross over when the family's baby Beatrice is kidnapped by pixies. The Imp, now called Samuel, must go back to the underground land of the monsters to rescue her and face the destiny the Ogre king has in store for him.
This adventure is fast-paced and full of action which will keep readers riveted to the book for the duration. Readers will identify with the main character of the Imp as he constantly tries to do the right thing without really knowing what he is doing.
The detail in the monster sequences in this novel are remarkable and could be quite frightening for younger readers. The themes of identity and belonging are powerful and the plot twists and turns to surprise readers and keep them guessing right to the end. A great first novel for T.C. Shelley, a Western Australian author. Teacher's notes are available.
Gabrielle Anderson

Going to the Footy by Debbie Coombes

cover image

Magabala Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781925936964.
(Ages: 1-4) Recommended. Themes: Football, Transport/Vehicles. Tiwi author and artist Debbie Coombes uses textured Tiwi art to illustrate Australian modes of travelling to the footy. This is a beautiful book for early childhood with a rich, earthy colour palate and Australian vocabulary, particularly meaningful for Tiwi kids. The large text is accessible and stands out on a bright background and the illustrations are exquisitely detailed but simple. The story starts, 'Everyone is going to the footy' and then we see people travelling off using different modes of transport; 'On a plane. On a barge. In a tinny'. The addition of safety wear (life jackets, helmets and seatbelts) on each vehicle is a nice touch and adds to the contemporary nature of the book, as do the splashes of bright colour. The ending is a little abrupt and doesn't come back to the going to the football idea; perhaps an added final page of a football scene would have helped. The information about the author in the back of the book says how travelling to the football is a huge part of contemporary Tiwi life. Coombes has perfectly combined traditional painting techniques learned from her grandfather with a joyous celebration of modern Tiwi life. It will also find a special place with many families around Australia who have fond memories of weekends spent heading off to the football or for who that is a part of their weekly experience.
Nicole Nelson

Monuments by Will Kostakis

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2019. ISBN: 9780734419224. pbk. 280 pgs.
(Age: 12+) Fantasy duology. Monuments is a fabulous light, fast paced, action packed and fun fantasy based in Sydney. I was so happy that it was based in Australia because urban fantasies with an Aussie setting are very hard to come by.
Will Kostakis has earned his spotlight as an Australian YA author. He is known for his ability to deliver heart-warming, witty and hard hitting contemporary fiction with very realistic characters. Will signed his first book deal at the age of 17 but had been pitching manuscripts at publishers at the age of 12. Monuments is Will's first fantasy, time travel book.
I extremely enjoyed reading Monuments and am so looking forward to the next instalment in the series.
OK back to the book. I found it easy to read and follow. It had many depictions of family relationships while also tackling important teen issues of change, friendships and fall outs, sexuality, and coming to terms with your own identity.
In Monuments we follow the story of Connor, a 16-year-old teen, with Greek heritage trying to avoid his best friend. He stumbles across a trapdoor to a secret chamber in his school. Here is where his adventures begin. Along the way we meet Sally, Locky and a few more interesting characters including some gods. All characters are unique with their own personalities. We probably can see a little of ourselves in some of the characters.
Monuments is a great book to read especially for teens because it depicts issues they face from day to day in a fantasy setting. This is one book I would have in my class so students could read.
Maria Komninos

Promise by Alexandra Alt

cover image

Omnibus, 2019. ISBN: 9781742991986.
(Age: Secondary students) Recommended. It is 1942 and 15 year old Lene lives with her mother in a Berlin apartment block, her father is away at the war. Above them are the Schlucks and she walks to school each day with their son Ludwig. Since they were squeezed together in the cellar during an air raid Lene feels they are becoming more than friends. Life is difficult with shortages, bombings and fear of being denounced as unpatriotic. League of German Girls (BDM) meetings are compulsory; they pack parcels for soldiers and mend uniforms. At 16 they are drafted for Flak duty, operating searchlights during raids. Hitler Youth is compulsory for boys. Both hate being part of the brutal organisations and Ludwig has been secretly listening to allied radio broadcasts, which is considered treason. Bullying and intimidation escalate. Kurt, one of the Hitler Youth harasses Lene. When her mother goes to Hanover to meet Lene's dad on leave she and Ludwig go to the cinema together but when they come out they are chased by Kurt and his friend Horst who have been promoted to the dreaded SS-Sturmscharfuhrer. They are dragged to headquarters where a gallows is set up and they are made to watch a boy their age hang 'that's what happens to boys who wag Hitler Youth drills, who lie and deceive and don't prepare for their heroic duties' p101
Ludwig decides it is not safe for them to be seen together and soon after Kurt comes to the apartment and forces himself on Lene, her mother comes home just in time and Kurt is posted to the front. The war is not going well and younger boys are being called up. Ludwig is called up at 17 on the same day his mother gets a letter informing them that Herr Schluck has died. 'What power do we, two kids, have against an overwhelming war machine? All we can do is refuse to be part of it and bear the consequences: a certain death.'p139. Before he leaves Ludwig tells Lene 'I want to stay alive and come back. I want to come back to you and Berlin, it's all I want.' p142. The second part of the book is after the war in 1946. In all the devastation people try to rebuild their lives. Lene has survived and come back to Berlin. 'I had to come back. To delve into the past in order to go on with my life . . . The past is never just about the past, it's also about the present, and the future too' p 153. In our uncertain times it is important to remember how prejudice and propaganda were used in wartime and this book neatly wraps the difficult moral choices of the time in a sensitive love story. Not only a useful addition to WW2 teaching material but an engaging coming of age story for a wide range of high school students.
Sue Speck

Hear the wolves by Victoria Scott

cover image

Scholastic, 2017. ISBN: 9781338043587.
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Themes: Alaska, Wolves, Survival, Bullying, Abuse. Sloan, partly deaf and still suffering the loss of her mother who left two years before, is left alone in her house by her father and older sister, when they trek to the neighbouring village for a meeting. Sloan finds several other people still in the village: Ms Wade who has injured herself and needs medical attention, Pilot and his abusive father, Nash, a young boy and their teacher, Mr Foster. Together they pack some supplies and head for the moored boat to go down river to the next town to get Mrs Wade to a doctor.
But the community has cleared the land, denuding the place of rabbits and hares the main source of food for the wolves, and Sloan's father, in building a fence has stopped the elk coming near the town. Wolves are now hungry, unable to keep themselves fed and so track the six people as they make their way towards the river. The trek should only take a day but is hampered by the injured woman and an alcoholic Nash trying to control the group, so the search for shelter becomes obvious as each night the cold and fear sets in.
This is a chilling read. A blizzard has blown in unexpectedly, the wolves are a constant threat in the background, the hatred between Pilot and his father is overwhelming and the ammunition is running out.
The book reminded me of many other stories set in the Alaskan wilderness, the Hatchet series of books (Paulsen) Call of the Wild (London) and The Great Death (Smelger), but in this one the wolves track and hunt their quarry, Ms Wade and Sloan all the while telling the reader of the behaviour of these animals, pushed to the brink by the destruction of their habitat.
Sloan has been afraid of being alone since her mother left and the extraordinary decision by her father to leave her to force her to survive is akin to a child being thrown into water to teach it to swim. But Nash's cruelty to his son is mind numbing. In this harsh landscape some people's humanity has deserted them and reading this book reminds us over again of the need for people to understand each other and work together to survive. And no where more so than in the Alaskan wilds.
Fran Knight

Can you find 12 busy bees? by Gordon Winch

cover image

Illus. by Patrick Shirvington. New Frontier Publishing, 2019.ISBN: 9781925594560.
(Ages: 2-6) Recommended. Counting Book. This is a follow-up to the CBCA shortlisted title Can you Find Me? This one is a counting and finding book as we are invited into a typical Australian garden to see who is living there. Within the soft, watercolour illustrations are hiding many creatures, great and small. 'I am 1 big blue-tongue lizard. I live in the garden. I like to lie in the sun. Can you find me?' The illustrations perfectly portray the different habitats of each of these creatures, even though they all live within the same garden (the leafy undergrowth of the lizard, the dark treetops of the owls, the reedy pond of the frogs). Most of the creatures are not difficult to spot but as the book counts up some of them are increasingly camouflaged into their background. The book uses animals and insects that most children are likely to see in their own gardens and the book aims to encourage them to appreciate and take notice of their own surroundings and the creatures that live around them. The text and the illustrations will help them to know where to look for different animals and what they may be doing (parrots sipping nectar in a banksia tree, bees taking food from the flowers, magpies poking about on the grass). The last page reminds the reader to take care of the creatures and their habitats: 'We love our garden. We hope it will be here forever'. Teacher's notes are available.
Nicole Nelson

The million pieces of Neena Gill by Emma Smith-Barton

cover image

Penguin, 2019. ISBN: 9780241363317.
(Ages: 15+) Recommended. Themes: Mental health, Contemporary. Emma Smith-Barton's debut novel draws on her own experience as a Pakistani child growing up in the UK.
Not only does Neena have to deal with the usual teenage search for identity but ten months of grief since the mysterious disappearance of her older brother Akash, whom she obviously adored. Her parent's grief exacerbates their cultural expectations of Neena and she begins to 'act out'. When they announce a new pregnancy, Neena really flips out.
Neena seeks solace in the company of Fi, her brother's ex-girlfriend - perhaps to feel close to him again or maybe to solve the mystery that is consuming her. She juggles the demands of school, work and home with her need to feel numb with Fi. A clandestine romance with gentle Josh, only adds to her pressures. Neena's confusion persists and she puts herself in danger visiting an older drug addict who may or may not know something about Akash's disappearance. Neena's childhood friend, Raheela, reaches out to her but is pushed away.
While we wonder what happened to Akash, the story is more about our increasingly unreliable protagonist and our concern for her mental state and destructive behaviour. Smith-Barton uses very mature themes and language to explore the consequences of not talking to someone about your feelings of loss and anxiety - feelings which potentially can spiral into psychosis.
We don't know who to believe in this story, perhaps not Neena. The fast pace and insightful writing teaches us far more about the complexity of grief and trauma than any hopes we harbour that Josh's love has the power to salve Neena's troubled mind. The million pieces of Neena Gill is riveting because it is a credible exploration of a family under pressure and fascinating because we wonder if the pressure came before or after the bad stuff? Emma Smith-Barton may have grown up between two cultures, but she is definitely a very astute observer of the inner life.
Deb Robins

Is it Halloween yet? by Susannah Chambers

cover image

Illus. by Tamsin Ainslie. Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760297404.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Halloween, Family. The instructions for making an origami bat at the end of the book was the first thing I looked at in this book about Halloween after seeing the sticker on the back cover. And once there, a piece of squared paper was found to try it out, and yes it works and will be easy to do with a group of kids obsessed with this old English and American observance now being seen more often in Australia. And the whole ritual is engaging, from making masks and dressing up, to sheets being used as ghosts, lots of spiders, things that go bump in the night, a host of bats, Halloween is a time for fun and lots of laughs.
And this is very much promoted in the book, Is it Halloween yet? Emily asks continual questions from her frazzled Mum, trying to keep up with the newest arrival in the family. Emily asks about ghosts, and vampire bats, pumpkins, Jack o' lanterns, witches' cats and eyeballs, leading the readers to ask their own questions about the customs of that day and why they are followed.
While some say that Halloween is not Australian and has no place in our calendar, many children and families are observing the day, joining in the family fun and togetherness that is promoted. Many families will make their own costumes, have a Halloween party, encourage 'trick or treat' in their own neighbourhood, hang bats from the clothesline and try carving a pumpkin (not as easy as it looks).
Dressing up is always great fun and this book encourages families to get involved.
And most people will not care that Halloween predates Christianity as a night of bonfires for ancient Celts to ward off evil spirits, becoming part of the Christian tradition on October 31 to rid evil spirits before All Hallow's Day on November 1, a time of feasting to honour those saints who did not have a specific day devoted to them.
Whatever its history, it can be a fun time for communities to work together, make costumes, and have a feast of all things ghoulish, and read Is it Halloween yet? with lots of fun.
Fran Knight

Mr Walker braves the night by Jess Black

cover image

Illus: Sara Acton. Penguin Random House, 2019. ISBN: 9780143793106.
(Age: 6-8) Themes: Halloween, Dogs - Fiction, Hotels. Mr Walker is a resident canine Labrador ambassador and greeter in the Park Hyatt Melbourne. His affable and accommodating personality makes him an excellent 'employee' and he is loved by all, but especially by his family; the hotel staff are also extended family. In this charming story, Mr Walker gets caught up in the excitement leading up to Halloween and a visit by the Aunt and cousin of Sophie and Amanda. There are walks, a few scary stories, some excitement and amazing activities planned by the incredible staff of the Park Hyatt. The entire story is focused on the perspective of Mr Walker and his insights into the Halloween night experience.
This is a lovely tale, as gentle as a Labrador! The Halloween events and discussions of events such as 'Trick or Treat' or the appearance of ghosts are also very gently handled, and even the telling of a 'scary' story really only impacts the responses of Mr Walker and the visiting cousin to some unusual noises. The theme does allow the possibility of some tension in the telling of the story, and so is a good preparation for mystery stories. There will be no sleepless nights for readers! Author Jess Black is also the author of many books enjoyed by young readers including the series: RSPCA Animal Tales, Kaboom Kids and Keeper of the crystals. Recommended for readers who are newly independent readers of chapter books.
Carolyn Hull

Giggly times, giggly rhymes 3 by Richie Cotton

cover image

Illus: Naya and Kostya Lazareva. Little Steps Publishing, 2018. ISBN: 9781925545968.
Themes: Poetry, Rhyme. Amusing poems about smelly things, animals and impossible things are presented with light and breezy illustrations with a quirky quality in this short anthology. The thirteen poems are written in simple rhyming couplets and are never longer than eight lines of text. Without setting the world on fire, it is a simple example of a poetry anthology.
This is probably not the best or most inspiring example of child-friendly doggerel, but some may find it an appealing faster alternative for pre-bedtime reading compared to a longer narrative!
Carolyn Hull