Reviews

Scribble Witch: Notes in Class by Inky Willis

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781444951653.
(Age: 6-9 years). Molly Mills is a nine year old girl who loves pencil toppers and pencil cases but finds school a challenge. She and her best friend, Chloe, do not like their teacher Mr Stilton and Molly seems to put him offside throughout the school day. Tasked with planning a pirate story Molly just does not know where to begin. She is given a very old dictionary to help with her spelling and after dropping the dictionary Molly finds a paper drawing of a witch. Molly decides to cut the witch out and place it in her pencil pot. This is the beginning of the magical Veronica Noates aka Notes, a scribble witch. She knows that Molly is sad about her pirate draft but that is minor in comparison to the bombshell that Chloe drops on Molly. Chloe is leaving to go to a school closer to her house and has one more day left at Dungfields School.
Molly spends the rest of the day in shock and cannot even talk to Chloe. Chloe is hurt so spends time with Emily who Molly does not like. Meanwhile Notes is getting Molly into more trouble with her teacher by writing notes that are meant to help but do not. Eventually Chloe is let into the secret of Notes and the two girls spend the rest of the day watching Notes and her magic. Chloe's final day with Molly is one of fun and togetherness with Notes and Molly wishes Chloe could stay but it is not to be. However after disappearing for most of the day, Notes has come up with a clever way for the two girls to keep in touch.
Throughout the story are pencil drawings and handwritten notes and words by Inky Willis. The change of font and emphasis placed on special words creates a fun and entertaining read for younger students. The notes and scribbles written by Notes are written in a childlike and at times, confusing way and may need an adult to explain the meaning initially to the reader. A second book in this series, Scribble Witch: Magic Muddles is due out soon. Themes: Best Friends, Leaving School, Friendship, Magic, Witch, Pencil Toppers, School Life.
Kathryn Beilby

A perfect little monster by Penny Morrison

cover image

Illus. by Simon Howe. Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781742999944. 24pp.
(Age: 3+) Recommended. When Iris and her twin brother Fang go to school, mad things may happen. The children are monsters. Mum has to cover Iris' third eye and tuck in Fang's tail to make them look more like the other children, but Iris knows that her brother's behaviour will be embarrassing, because when he arrives he makes eye contact with the children, smiling and saying hello as they walk through the gate. During story time Iris rips into the books while the teacher reads a story, but he says thank you when handed an instrument during the music lesson, shares his toys with the others, plays on the playground equipment without damaging it, and doing craft leaving the pencils and paints as he found them. Iris is aghast, this is not what a monster should do, and readers will laugh out loud at the mayhem she causes as the story progresses, the hilarious illustrations showing the world of difference between good and bad behaviour, showing Iris and Fang to be complete opposites. Iris is a whirlwind of bad behaviour, reflecting some of the behaviour children will be exposed to when they reach school, but also showing children that this behaviour while totally unacceptable, will leave the person without friends.
A very funny look at expectations when children arrive at school, the story also quietly exposes new arrivals to the range of lessons and play they will have. Through Iris' bad behaviour, they will learn the sort of behaviour that is acceptable, not only to the teacher, but also their peers.
I love Mum's appearance almost out of sight, and the looks on the other students' faces are worth watching out for. This is a wonderful read aloud, encouraging children to join in as it is read, miming Iris' bad behaviour, realising that Fang is the better student. Themes: Monsters, Behaviour, School, First day at school, Twins.
Fran Knight

Anzac girl: the war diaries of Alice Ross-King by Kate Simpson and Jess Racklyeft

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760637019. 32pp.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Interspersed with telling and informative illustrations the diary entries of Alice Ross-King give a gruelling account of what she saw and suffered during World War One in France. Leaving from Melbourne in 1914, the young patriotic Alice was first stationed in a hospital in Cairo where she attended the many wounded and dying from Gallipoli. She was shocked, as were all the staff at the numbers and severity of their wounds. She was transferred along with the hospital to France early in 1916. Here many thousands of Australian troops were wounded at the Battle of Fromelles, her fiancee Harry one of the dead. She found it hard to carry on with this overwhelming news, but did so, eventually being transferred to a clearing station near the front. Here she spent a frightful night sheltering in a bomb crater after checking that her patients were all okay.
At Rouen many were convinced that the Germans were breaking through, and Alice's diary reflects her sombre thoughts and saddened state. But suddenly Armistice was signed: everyone was able to go home over the next few months.
This involving story, revealing the depths of despair and jubilation that Alice felt as she plied her trade amongst the worst battlefields of Europe will be easily read by the youngest of readers as well as bringing understanding about war and its brutality to older readers. The pages bristle with history, from the postcards and drawings of the men and the battles they fought, to the photographs and maps, letters and newspaper accounts. Between these illustrations are excerpts form Alice's dairies, bold, clear and unflinching. They allow us to view her life, one lived in the most straightened of circumstances beyond our experience but her words give us a glimpse of the world at the time and the sacrifices people made, many without question.
The almost naive illustrations by Rackyleft are amazing: unsentimental, unambiguous and revelatory. They enhance the text as it shuffles between the author's writing and the diaries of her great grandmother, the use of sombre colours making a clear statement about the situation Alice and her peers are in. Themes: Australian history, World War One, Nursing, Fromelles.
Fran Knight

Atticus Van Tasticus: The Map of Half Maps by Andrew Daddo

cover image

Illus. by Stephen Michael King. Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9781760892913.
(Age:7-11) Recommended. Silliness, pirates, and eccentricity combine in a rollicking tale of treasure maps divided into pieces that need to be reconnected. Atticus is the ship's captain, and his rag-tag crew get on well despite, and because of, their individual capacities for strange behaviours. When they are at risk of attack from another pirate ship - the Pegasis, and then from a marauding Viking ship (with an Abba-esque singing captain), they must escape . . . and do it quickly. A chance encounter with a raft containing another eccentric, but nearly dead character named Half Map, gives them hope of finding the missing piece from their treasure map. Before they know it, they are back under attack and must go all out to save their own ship.
Daddo has created a book of piratical lunacy with some rather sweet moments, and some typically boy-friendly yukky moments, in combination with quirky humour to entertain younger readers. There are some hidden quirks, for example the Abba references and jokes related to Abba songs; some naive poetry; the 'resurrection' of Half Map a number of times; and the somewhat incorrect map in four halves! Stephen Michael King's distinctive illustrations and inserted pieces of visual comedy add to the sense of fun in this book. This is a book just for the fun of it! Young readers will love the pirate attacks, swinging from ship to ship and the knowledge of conflict at close quarters (but sensibly there is very little violence described in any detail).
Recommended, not as literature, but for amusement . . . for readers aged 7-11. Themes: Humorous fiction; Pirates.
Carolyn Hull

Little Bilby's Aussie Easter egg hunt by Yvonne Mes

cover image

Illus. by Jody Michelle Pratt. Lothian, 2020. ISBN: 9780734419910. 16pp.
(Age: Pre-school) A group of bilbies is on an Easter egg hunt. They trundle through bushland and areas of scrub, finding other Australian animals and their eggs, begging the readers to identify what they see.
In rhyme, this solid board book encourages young children to think about the rhyming word, to watch out for rhythm and repetition. The words in bold will encourage the audience to call out the noises made by each animals, and to note the words in bold, teaching children the difference between high and low, near and far.
The book shows the animals in their natural habitat, offering a level of discussion after the book is read aloud.
This colourfully illustrated picture book showcases the diversity of Australia's egg-laying animals. Each page opens to reveal an egg in its natural environment asking the reader 'Whose egg could this be?' One that the audience will love to answer. Themes: Board book, Read aloud, Bilbies, Eggs, Easter.
Fran Knight

Beyond reasonable doubt by Gary Bell QC and Scott Kershaw

cover image

Elliot Rook, QC book 1. Raven Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781526606136. 352pp.
(Age: senior secondary/adult) I have three crime fiction books on the go, but once I picked this up, they were all set aside. Elliot Rook, fifty or so years old, a QC in a prestigious London practice, a successful old Etonian, is approached by a solicitor who tells him that his client has asked only for him. Billy Barber is an acquaintance from Rook's days in the Midlands, a product of the disgruntled ex coal mining towns in the shadow of Thatcher's Britain, a criminal who blames immigration for Britain's woes. Rook would prefer to forget all his dealings with this man, the brother of his closest friend through school and early adulthood, but Barber knows things about his past and he is forced to represent this racist thug when he is accused of murder. But he will not answer any questions from the police or Rook which forces Rook to make his own inquiries. The Girl was found naked, badly beaten and strangled along a disused railway track, and Barber's phone records tell the police he was nearby. His racist threats, known to all via media posts and action groups outside the mosque, make him a prime suspect.
At a loss to defend his client, Rook and his new junior, Zara Barnes, travel to Cotgrave in Nottinghamshire to trawl through some of his past. Here Zara is reminded of why she wanted to get out of the place, and Rook follows leads into Barber's life which get him almost killed.
A non stop breath taking journey sees all the work done by Rook and Barnes coming together at the Old Bailey, Court Number One, Zara's first case. Here the routines of the courtroom are explained as the case proceeds, making the reader fully aware of just how the system works without being overwhelmed with information. Bell makes it all so readable, so I was thrilled to see that this is the first in a series about the wonderful Elliot Rook a man whose past has implications everyday, making his decision making all that more complex. Themes: Crime fiction, Law courts, Trial, Racism, Prostitution, Trafficking.
Fran Knight

Never forget by Clare Hallifax and Simon O'Carrigan

cover image

Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743835050. 32pp.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. A unique look at World War 1, the illustrations in this book won't be forgotten easily by any reader. Dark brown colours and black outlines bring to life the story of the hardships and horror that the soldiers faced during wartime. The reader is taken through scenes of trench warfare, of wounded soldiers and the nurses who cared for them, of death and longing for the familiar blue skies of home.
It is not until the reader comes to the end of the book and reads the Illustrator's note by Simon O'Carrigan that it is realised that the illustrations were inspired by actual drawings and photographs by soldiers and war artists depicting what was happening around them. There are two pages of artwork reference material acknowledgements at the back of the book, and reading through them I was astonished at the depth of research that had gone into the book. References range from the works of well-known artists like Arthur Streeton to those of Elias Silas, a soldier. This realisation that the illustrations were based on the work of people who were on the battlefields makes it all the more poignant and the words below are a strong call for peace:
When you're lifting the fallen
amidst grieving goodbyes
it's home skies that beckon
as we ask ourselves why
those who urge us to fight
are not by our side.
Never forget.

As the section above reveals, the narrative is very powerful and could be read aloud slowly and carefully to help people realise the horror of war. The refrain 'Never forget' is repeated throughout and adds to intensity of the message about war.
There are many books about the Anzac tradition but this one stands out as original and heart-breaking. It is an important addition to any library collection. Themes: World War 1, War in art, Anzac Day
Pat Pledger

The League of Llamas: The Golden Llama by Aleesah Darlison

cover image

Puffin Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760894160. 118pp.
(Age: Year 3-6) How many gags can you make about llamas in a James Bond style llama spy adventure? Lots!
Phillipe Llamar LOL (League of Llamas Agent 0011) uses SPIT (Space Precision Initial Test) technology to try to thwart the enemy badgers, in particular General Bottomburp.
He is aided by fellow agent Lloyd Llamanator and meets a mysterious lady llama dressed in a red gown (llama in red).
No prob-llama! Except Lloyd is obsessed with eating and Phillipe loves to constantly look at his beautiful fringe.
Phillipe's assignment is to retrieve the prestigious 'Golden Llama' statue taken by General Bottomburp and he must use all of his highly skilled techniques and equipment, while driving around in his llamaborghini.
This is a fun, humorous 118 page novel about secret llama agents and their exploits. The text is interspersed with drawings and these stories will appeal to students in years 3-6.
The League of Llama series has a second title in print Llama possible and 2 more novels are coming soon, Undercover Llamas and Rogue Llama.
Darlison's previous books include picture fiction Little meerkat and Emerald, the green turtle's tale and novels, Running from the tiger and Ash Rover: Keeper of the Phoenix.
This would be a fun addition to any school library.
A short book trailer is available.
Jane Moore

Saint X by Alexis Schaitkin

cover image

Picador, 2020. ISBN: 9781529014273. 329pp.
(Age: Adult - Adolescent) This is an interesting novel told through more than one voice, and from a differing focus, as Alexis Schaitkin takes us through many years of wondering why and how a young woman on a Caribbean island may have died many years ago. The voices are different, and we realise that each is telling what is known to them, or just what they will reveal, some wondering, puzzled and still, many years later, very interested in just what happened to Alison.
There were many who believed that she was murdered, but the police could not arrest anyone, having insufficient evidence as to the truth of the stories that they were told by those who may have been involved in her death. Was it an accident or was she deliberately killed and, if so, why? We are left to ponder this question throughout our reading of the novel and we learn much about her family, friends, and acquaintances as the stories are told, some in the first person and others in the third person. The language is lyrical at times and clearly descriptive of the place and time, Schaitkin drawing us into the narrative and holding our attention.
This is a novel that is appropriate for both adult and adolescent readers, its language richly descriptive, its narrative both complex and enigmatic, its focus both challenging and absorbing.
Elizabeth Bondar

Only mostly devastated by Sophie Gonzales

cover image

Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9781444956481.
This is a powerful story of adolescence with its joy and its pressures, its highs and its lows. Sophie Gonzales draws us into the lives of the characters, evoking our empathy for them in their adolescence, their journey through school and their hopes for the future. Gonzales presents the world from the point of view of an adolescent whose feelings are complex and whose choices are determined by his recognition of who he is, and his definition as homosexual, presented in an utterly captivating, evocative and candid narrative. Portraying so vividly the joys and the disappointments of the lives of teenagers, Gonzales paints a vivid picture of the interactions of adolescents, with other adolescents, their teachers and the adults who are part of their lives, particularly with their parents. Her focus is on their questioning of the values that they discover, both good and not so good, describing, vividly, their fear of failure, in school, relationships and life. Yet she tempers this more serious aspect of adolescence with the excitement that lies at the heart of this time of change in their lives, based so much in their changing body, point of view and hope for the future. Gonzales focuses on young people's quest to find their path, while maintaining their own identity, evoking our empathy and enabling us to see how we all have to face the necessity of making choices, of listening and observing the world, and choosing to spend time with people who enable us to be true to ourselves. Choice is at the heart of this novel, seen so vividly in the attraction of the young male protagonist to another male, where Gonzales describes the description of the glow that envelops us when we first realize that we are captivated by some one else. When Ollie falls in love with Will, he is stunned. Through beautifully described reactions, thoughts and interactions, we see how this narrative raises questions about what it is to be human, about how to handle the dawning of alternative sexuality, Gonzales drawing us in with her focus on the right to be different, and ultimately so gently describing the indescribable joy that humans experience when they share the joy of love. This is a moving and powerful story of the joy and the ache of adolescence, of the fear that one won't be good enough in so many ways, and of the dread of failure, in school, work and mostly deeply felt, in relationships. Deftly drawn, these characters are alive and real, with their emotions so clearly understandable and their lives so beautifully described. Concerning the sexual attraction of the same gender, Gonzales' describes society's responses to same sex interaction, gently and realistically showing how we can accept and be proud of our inborn drives. Themes: Homosexuality, Cancer, Dating.
Elizabeth Bondar

Meet the Planets by Caryl Hart

cover image

Illus. by Bethan Woollvin. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781408892985. 32pp.
(Age: 3-6) Highly recommended. Blast off in a rocket to meet all the planets in the solar system, including Pluto the dwarf planet. In rhyming couplets, Caryl Hart has provided readers with a fun and informative book that is very enjoyable and which describes each planet and its characteristics.
Children will enjoy the rhymes which read aloud very well and they will have fun joining in and learning about each of the planets. Starting off with an introduction to the sun (I'm friendly but don't get too close now / or I'll frizzle you up to a fry!), the small child accompanied by a dog, zooms around meeting each planet in turn: speedy Mercury, Venus covered in fierce spitting volcanoes, Earth and its silver Moon, Mars covered in rust-coloured dust, Jupiter the biggest of planets, Saturn with its sparkly rings, freezing Uranus, ice giant Neptune and little dwarf planet Pluto.
Set against a black background, the planets are illustrated with wide eyes giving each a distinct character and the vivid colours also match the characteristics of the planets. I loved the illustration for Mercury, with colours streaming behind its grey and white face, making it easy to remember that it is the fast planet. Jupiter, vivid in yellow and orange, hugs its moon Ganymede and is huge, taking up a whole page. The end papers show the planets revolving around the sun in order. They are a perfect complement to the clever text and will really appeal to young children.
This book is a memorable and unique way to introduce children to the planets and will be enjoyed by all who read it. Themes: Astronomy, Planets, Rockets, STEM.
Pat Pledger

BumbleBunnies : The Balloon by Graeme Base

cover image

BumbleBunnies book 4. Angus and Robertson, 2020. ISBN: 9781460754030. 24pp.
(Age: 2-6) Highly recommended. Young children will be thrilled to read about the latest adventure of the Bumblebunnies in their yellow and black striped super hero suits and masks. Wuffle the puppy, Lou the kitten and Billington the duck are relaxing in the garden after all of the noise of the birthday party next door when a large pink balloon floats over the fence. The trio are frightened that it is going to burst and race off to find a place to hide, but the Bumblebunnies fly to the rescue.
As always Base's illustrations are exquisite. The suburban backyard is one that will be recognised with its flower gardens and wooden fence. The roses, lilies and iris in the backyard are beautifully detailed while each of the characters has a distinct personality that the young reader will be able to identify with. I loved the look of horror on the face of Billington the duck when he can't find anywhere to hide and then laughed as he stuck his head in the water in the pond. Of course he couldn't see or hear the others call out as the Bumblebunnies fly overhead.
The narrative is great to read aloud and the short sentences and pictures illustrating what is happening on the page would help the beginning reader work out the words and action. Young readers would also have fun coming up with ways that the Bumblebunnies could stop the balloon from bursting. And of course they will love the fact that they know who the Bumblebunnies are, while Wuffle, Lou and Billington remain ignorant of their identity.
This is a series that will become a favourite, with each book reading as a stand-alone. Themes: Problem solving, Super heroes.
Pat Pledger

The Republic of Birds by Jessica Miller

cover image

Text, 2020. ISBN: 9781922268044. 304pp.
(Age: 10-14) Highly recommended. I am a fan of fairy tales and folklore and was immediately drawn in by this imaginative and exciting tale of Baba Yaga, magic and maps. Olga is fascinated by the work of cartographers and loves to research their old maps and books. She longs to be a map maker but being a girl, this is denied to her. Nevertheless when her family is banished to the edge of the kingdom and her sister Mira is kidnapped by the bird army she decides to go into the Republic of Birds in an attempt to rescue her. But first she must learn about her magical ability to see into maps.
As the story progressed I was gripped by the story of the Baba Yaga, their magical abilities and most of all, the houses that they lived in and which moved around on chicken legs. Olga is not so thrilled to find that she is a Baba Yaga, as they are banished in her country, but she uses the skills she learns to go on an exciting adventure in search of her sister.
Descriptions of icy terrain, mountains and most of all the birds who inhabit the Republic of Birds are fascinating and make Olga's journey even more interesting as she battles difficult terrain and fierce birds to make her way to Mira, who is imprisoned in a cage and must dance for the queen of the birds.
Olga has always felt second best in her talented family, especially as Mira is a wonderful dancer, but her skills as a reader of maps and cartographer are what help her on her journey to find Mira and she realises that what she has is unique even if it is not as easily recognisable as the more overt skills of her family.
Readers will enjoy the richness of the folklore behind the story and helped by a map at the beginning of the book will be dragged into the adventures of Olga as she struggles across a difficult landscape. They may also enjoy Vasilisa the wise: and other tales of brave young women by Kate Forsyth. Teaching notes are available.
Pat Pledger

Mum's elephant by Maureen Jipyilya Nampijinpa O'Keefe

cover image

Illus. by Christina Booth. Magabala Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781925936728. pbk., 32 pp.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. The image of the mother lying with her back to the reader, clutching her teapot remains with me. It is a powerful reminder of just how lonely people can be despite what is going on around them. In her hand she clutches an old aluminium teapot, shaped in her children's eyes, like an elephant, a remnant perhaps of days gone by but one she still uses when her friends and family drop in to share a cup of tea on the rug outside in the sun.
Maureen Jipyilya Nampijinpa O'Keefe, a Kaytetye-Walpriri woman from the Northern Territory was reminded of her mother after finding a teapot in a secondhand shop. She wrote this story, brimming with love and understanding of her mother's life, revealing their lives on an outstation a long way from any town or city. Here the children play together, eating damper and jam for breakfast. Mum likes to clean the teapot, keeping it shiny, and has harsh words to say if anyone picks it up by the trunk, or takes it from the shelf as a plaything. Sometimes she sits all alone on her rug, talking to the elephant, telling it stories, and sometimes she shuns her family. But when she has visitors, especially the ladies dressed in their finery, afternoon tea is to be had, with the teapot in pride of place.
This beautiful story tells of life lived far from many of our students' lives in urban Australia: it tells of remoteness and how people live with that remoteness, it reveals the life of a sad woman, clutching the familiar to her, we see family life, the strength of the community, the routines of the day. And all is beautifully illustrated by Christian Booth, a Tasmanian artist with a feel for the environment which radiates from this book. The sweep of the orange sandy background, the few trees and sparing amenities is depicted, while the community's lives are lived on rugs on the red earth. Here the children play, the adults meet and drink tea and Mum finds refuge with her elephant. Booth's illustrations of the Aboriginal community are glorious: happy and poignant, boisterous and contemplative, revealing past memories and lives lived today. The sweep of colour draws the eye to all the details she offers, slyly revealing the teapot a small piece at a time, until it is all revealed. Themes: Aboriginal themes, Aboriginal life, Outback Australia, Depression.
Fran Knight

Will the Wonderkid: Treasure hunter of the Australian outback by Stephanie Owen Reeder

cover image

Heritage Heroes. NLA Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9780642279521. 132pp.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. In the summer of 1914-1915, 15-year-old Will Hutchison travelled with his father and a small party of men looking for gold in South Australia, travelling through some of the most inhospitable land, at the hottest time of the year, during the worst recorded drought.
We meet Will at the Adelaide Railway Station as he boards the train to begin his journey to Hergott Springs, now known as Marree.
The true tale of Will's arduous journey has been skilfully told by Stephanie Owen Reeder, bringing the reader along on the expedition, experiencing the heat, flies and the desperate search for water.
Will and the men use camels to travel and rarely meet any other people along the way. It is obvious how perilous their journey is, and the author compares their expedition to previous explorers, Leichardt, Sturt, Giles and Burke and Wills, some who perished crossing the continent.
Although the men did not discover gold, young Will found opals and discovered what is now Coober Pedy opal fields.
This beautifully crafted book describes Will's adventures through story, excerpts of information, old photographs, drawings and paintings.
This is the fifth title in the award winning Heritage Heroes series.
At the time of writing, the author currently has Trouble in the surf in the CBCA Notables for 2020.
I highly recommend this book to any school library.
Jane Moore