Reviews

The stone giant by Anna Hoglund

cover image

Gecko Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781776572731.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Swedish author, Anna Hoglund has created a fable like story of a young girl who saves her father using cunning and ingenuity. Translated for an English audience by Julia Marshall, the story is wonderfully supported by copper plate etchings with splashes of watercolour. The simplistic but never simple drawings are evocative of the bleak landscape and the sparse life of the girl and her father. He is a knight and must go out and deal with a giant turning people to stone. She waits at home alone, and as time passes she despairs that he will not return and so decides to try and find him. She looks at her mirror and asks herself what would happen if the giant saw himself in the mirror. She sets out with her mirror and a knife and swims through the cold, dark water not knowing where she is going. She stays overnight with a woman who gives her an umbrella and she moves on to find a land with many many stones. When the ground begins to shake and the giant approaches, she unfurls the umbrella, and the giant looks down through the hole he makes in it and sees himself in the mirror.
Her courage kills the giant and saves those turned to stone. She and her father now live in a peaceful land and neither will be alone again.
This is a lovely hand sized book which children will often return to, reading of the girl using her courage and ingenuity to rescue her father.
And the delightful illustrations will attract their attention as they read the text. Gecko Press publishes 'curiously good books' and the website tells us that one good book can spark a lifetime of reading. The books they publish are certainly books that spark interest and are very different to those offered by other publishers. Read more here.
Themes: Courage, Giants, Mirror.
Fran Knight

The Betrothed by Keira Cass

cover image

HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9780008158828.
(Age: Young Adult). Keira Cass fans have been eagerly awaiting for The Betrothed since the last book in her hugely popular The Selection series was published in 2016. Unfortunately, they may be disappointed when they read it. Unlike the author's previous works which focused on a Bachelor-style love contest set in a post-dystopian America, The Betrothed is a historical romance pivoting on a much maligned YA trope - the love triangle.
King Jameson declares his love for Lady Hollis Brite, a noblewoman who has grown up around the King, constantly vying for his attention. While initially delighted to have been singled out by the monarch, during their courtship Hollis meets Silas, an artisan from a refugee family that has fled a neighbouring country. Hollis is drawn to Silas, despite her inital attempts to resist him and when King Jameson proposes to her she must decide whether being queen is what she truly wants in life.
While the novel begins intriguingly and promises a fun romp, it soon devolves into cliche after cliche as Hollis 'ums and ahs' over what she should do and who she should choose. A frustrating ending is the unfortunate cherry on top for this disappointing plotline.
A positive for the novel is Cass' easy-to-read style. As in The Selection, her prose is frothy and bubbly; well suited to her target young adult audience. There are also some well-developed secondary characters who make for enjoyable reading. However, readers who were initially ecstatic for the start of a new Keira Cass series may find themselves reluctant to continue reading further. Themes: Love, Royalty, Friendship, Identity.
Rose Tabeni

In my dreams by Stef Gemmill and Tanja Stephani

cover image

New Frontier, 2020. ISBN: 9781925594928.
(Age: 6-7) Highly recommended. From the moment I laid eyes on the book In my dreams by Stef Gemmill and Tanja Stephani I was excited to read it. You are greeted with the most wonderous cover that has bright colours, hints of gold sparkles, funny creatures, and a whimsical feeling. I could not wait to open it.
I was not disappointed! This story is about the wonderful places that a dream can take you, how you can find fruit flavoured rainbows, race against pirates, fly on a dragon's back, and seek shelter in an igloo. Each page takes you to another magical, interesting place where you are drawn into the illustration looking at the characters' faces and imagining the dreams that could be conjured up from these very pages.
The same characters are seen throughout the book which adds some continuity and something to search for - and I especially love the little puppy who is often having the most amazing time running with sled dogs or riding on a dragon.
At the end there is a couple of pages about how the darkness and shadows can be a scary place for some children. The books states "They have no power over me. I can blink my eyes and they're gone" which is a great little message for many children and hopefully another strategy to add to their collection on particularly dark nights.
Overall, I absolutely love this book and think it would be such a great addition to any young child's library. I think it would be suitable for children up to 6-7 years of age, but as I really enjoyed it too I feel that children of all ages would probably be able to find something they could relate to within it. Teacher's notes are available. 5 out of 5!
Lauren Fountain

Respect by Aunty Fay Muir and Sue Lawson, illus. Lisa Kennedy

cover image

Magabala Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781925936315
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Across pages of disarming illustrations, full of colour and movement, redolent of the reds and browns of outback Australia as well as the bright blues of coastal environments, the theme of respect is drawn in tightly written authoritative prose. Fay Muir, a Boonwurrung Elder of the Port Phillip Bay area of Victoria, has worked with celebrated author, Sue Lawson, to create a story that is older than the red earth and older than the flickering stars.
Respect is held for stories, for the Elders, for Ancestors, for songs. It is held for the sea eagle, for the leaves on the trees falling to the red earth, for families who pass on their stories, for those who listen, learning from the Elders. Through learning to love and respect Country, we learn to love and respect each other as well as ourselves.
Respect is at the heart of any Aboriginal community and reaffirming respect will reinforce its application to all Australians who care about the natural environment and the people who live there.
Lisa Kennedy a descendant of the Trawlwoolway people of north east Tasmania, has used acrylic paint and collage to create her vibrant illustrations which bring together art, culture and story to promote respect: a quality that underpins Aboriginal sensibilities.
Themes: Respect, Aboriginal themes, Generations
Fran Knight

Dear child by Romy Hausmann

cover image

Quercus, 2019. ISBN: 9781529401424.
(Age: Adult - Senior Secondary) Highly recommended for people who can cope with books in the vein of Room by Emma Donoghue. Locked in a windowless cabin in the woods, Lena's life is bound up by rules made up by the man who captured her to be the mother to his two children. Everything is regimented, and there is severe punishment if she deviates from, or questions, his demands. Lena manages to break free from the cabin one night accompanied by Hannah, but her escape raises many questions. Who is she? What has happened to Lena who disappeared 14 years ago? Who is the man found dead in the cabin and what has happened to Hannah's little brother?
This is a tightly plotted thriller that keeps the reader guessing the whole way through with its twisty, exciting, and often heart-wrenching events. There are many tense moments, and the description of Lena's treatment in the cabin is not for the faint hearted. It is also disturbing to read about her attempts to make a normal life again and the grief and heartbreak of Lena's father Matthias and his desire to find out what happened to Lena is very compelling.
Written in three voices, that of Jasmin, Hannah and Matthias, the story unfolds as they tell their version of what has happened and how they feel.
The conclusion is stunning and very memorable. Dear child will leave the reader determined to read any novels that this talented author might produce in the future.
Pat Pledger

Manticores are not real by Nick Dyrenfurth

cover image

Illus. by Andrew McIntosh. Little Steps, 2019. ISBN: 9781925839500.
Manticores are not real is a picture book about Micah, a young boy who is awoken in his dreams by a manticore (a creature part lion, part flamingo and part gazelle with a man's face!) who takes him on an adventure to his mystical land with a pinkish sky, shimmering mountains and many other manticore friends. They attend a party and have a wonderful time. The story concludes with Micah being woken by his father, and he wonders if it was all a dream or if in fact . . . manticores were real!
To be honest I was not a huge fan of this book. The story was so similar to many I had read before: child has a dream, wakes within the dream, goes on adventure, wakes up in the morning and wonders whether it was all real or not; and unfortunately it didn't really hit the mark.
The rhyming throughout was clumsy and I found it hard to read with a good flow - I had to keep going back over sections to get them to sound right. There were words put in that seemed to be written just to keep the rhyme but did not make a lot of sense.
The illustrations were nice, I liked the colours and the attention to detail in the shading and landscapes.
I think this book could have been written about a real child who has had this very dream! This is a lovely gesture and will be an amazing keepsake for years to come. I think the rhyming could be refined a bit more to ensure that it is easy to read with flow and good intonation.
I give this book 2 out of 5.
Lauren Fountain

Girl from the sea by Margaret Wild

cover image

Illus. by Jane Tanner. Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760524302.
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. The whispers of a young girl, drowned at sea, reveal her longing for life. She sees a cottage by the sea where a family plays on the beach. She spies the cat and dog as she comes to the house, and they spy her. She follows the family as they collect shells along the water's edge. She longs to be with them, walking more closely to the mother. If she lived in the cottage, she tells us, she would sweep the floor, and make the children laugh, but her feet are always in the water. She wonders if they can hear her as she sings in the wind, or feel her as she wraps herself around them, or see her as she stands in the garden.
She is a breathe, a shadow, a murmur of a young girl lost in the waves, as she sighs for what might have been. The animals know she is there, waiting to be petted, and Mum becomes more aware of her presence as she makes her way along the beach, with just the suggestion of a third child by her side.
Margaret Wild's sparse prose give the bare outline of a lost child and what she has missed. Each sentence rings with longing as she sees a life that might have been. She watches the family which could have been hers as they go about the very ordinary things families do when together on a beach. She yearns to be with them, to be acknowledged, to be part of their days.
Readers will fall into Jane Tanner's illustrations, reminding them of times at the beach, playing with their siblings, watching the birds and dolphins, making sandcastles, collecting shells. She has used her darker coloured pencils along with charcoal and a charcoal pencil to develop the most exquisite of beach scenes. Dark and ominous, yet enveloping and comforting, the darker tones emphasise the loss of a child, drowned at sea. Her feet are always in water in Tanner's drawings, her hair wild and unkempt, her look wistful and full of longing. Shells appear on the beach and in their hands, near the gravestone and on the windowsill. The sepia images, sometimes tinged with blue, urge the reader to look more closely, to compare their own experiences at the beach with those before them, to imagine more of the story behind the few words and the images, to fill in the spaces.
This is an outstanding offering from two of Australia's foremost book creators, and will be lovingly read by children of all ages. Themes: Drowning, Sea, Longing, Family.
Fran Knight

Henrie's hero hunt by Petra James

cover image

Illus. by A. Yi. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760650858.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. This fast paced sequel to Hapless Hero Henrie (2019) will have instant appeal after Henrie receives a call on the Hero Hotline, a phone she is not allowed to answer. After all her hero status is not confirmed by the Melchior family, one in which only the male line takes up heroism.
With Aunt Ellie trying to get her away, and Henrie prevaricating on whether to answer the phone or not, thirty pages roll away with the two sparring over words, and Henrie speaking directly to the reader while the stage is set for another foray into the hilarious adventures of Hapless Henrie.
The girl on the other end is unsure but Ellie traces the call. Marley has rung them after finding an ad for the House of Melchior amongst her dead aunt's things. Her great aunt, Agnes Hunt has left clues behind leading the two to a dig in Egypt, uncovering Agnes's association with the Carter expedition of 1922 which resulted in the discovery of the tomb of Tutankhamen. Further investigation reveals that Agnes was accused of stealing a statue from the tomb. Marley is appalled and they are determined to find the answer to this mystery.
A trip to the Museum of Antiquities reveals not only that the statue Aunt Agnes was supposed to steal is not on the Tutankhamen inventory, but there is another operative after it as well. Violeta Villarne kidnaps Alex and Marley and bribes Henrie into handing over the tiny key found in Agnes' embroidery box. From there with Alex and Marley locked in the backroom at the museum, Henrie must work hard at outwitting the smart Violeta.
Petra James throws lots into the mix, ensuring middle to upper primary school readers will be absorbed with hieroglyphics, morse code, deciphering, espionage, walkie talkies using spy jargon, along with pages of text broken up with notes and letters, lists and instructions with illustrations by A. Yi, adding to the fun.
They will be intrigued with the sub plot of Henrie's search for her parents, last seen in Prague nine years ago, and this amongst many others layers will keep them reading right to the end.
Themes: Humour, Spying, Family, Egypt, Tutankhamen.
Fran Knight

The Puppet Show by M.W. Craven

cover image

Washington Poe book 1. Constable, 2018. ISBN: 9781472127440.
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Highly recommended for mystery lovers. CWA Gold Dagger Award 2019. Washington Poe is brought in to investigate a series of murders where the victims are burnt alive in prehistoric stone circles. His name has been carved into one of the victims and accompanied by Tilly Bradshaw, an awkward criminal analyist, he follows a trail that is obviously set up for him. I picked up The puppet show after thoroughly enjoying Black Summer, the second in the series as I found the personalities of both Poe and Bradshaw to be ones that I really liked and wished to read more about.
Craven's narrative is engaging and there are enough twists and turns to keep any mystery fan engrossed in trying to work out what is happening. And that ending was a surprise for me, which always makes for a more enjoyable read for a person who reads a lot of mysteries. There is a gradual fleshing out of the personalities of Poe and Bradshaw and the growth of trust between them makes for a great working relationship. Both are unusual characters, Poe dogged in his following of the case, over-riding his superiors and going his own way, and Tilly socially inept, but brilliant in her ability to analyse what is going on.
The cold landscape of Cumbria with its prehistoric stone circles makes an interesting background to the murders and the serial killer, nicknamed The Immolation Man, is one scary murderer.
This is a series that is sure to have a strong following from readers who enjoy clever plotting and excellent narratives.
Pat Pledger

Haywire by Claire Saxby

cover image

Australia's Second World War series. Omnibus, 2020. ISBN: 9781742769196.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. The second book in the new series of stories set during the Second World War involves a little known internment camp at Hay in western New South Wales. Here German boy, Max Gruber is interned as an enemy alien, sent from England on the notorious ship, Dunera to a place as distant from his home town as could be imagined. In Hay, Tom has just declined the opportunity to study in Sydney because his father needs him in his bakery. Disappointment covers him like a blanket as he watches the building of the camp, an enterprise his mother despises, reflecting the animosity of some of the town's folk for the Germans and Italians detained there.
Saxby neatly reveals the different positions taken by the town's folk, showing the conversation at the dinner table. The meeting up of the two boys, when Tom is delivering bread and Max is sheltering from the bullies at the camp, results in a friendship, but when Max is bullied again into doing homework for one of the older boys, he decides to escape.
In this timely plea for people  to accept others for who they are and not judge by appearances or prejudices, Tom sees Max for who he is, a young frightened boy who has endured immense hardship and sent to a place  beyond his comprehension.
The semantics around the words 'detention' or 'internment' or 'jail', are just so much wordplay then as it is now, and this book will encourage readers to know more of our past where internment camps were used to house prisoners despite having not been to court. That many of these men (900) chose to stay in Australia after the war, is testament more to their treatment by people such as Tom and his father, rather than the bigots in the community.
The story of the Dunera can be found here,  while that of the internment camp at Hay here.
Melbourne author, Claire Saxby writes fiction, non-fiction and poetry for children, with about forty books in print. 
The first in the series is War and Resistance by Sophie Masson. Themes: War, Internment camp, World War Two, Hay, NSW, Series: Australia's Second World War: Book 2, Friendship.
Fran Knight

The Lost Witch by Melvin Burgess

cover image

Andersen, 2020. ISBN: 9781783448357.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Leeds Book Awards Nominee for 14-16 (2019). This is not a book for the faint-hearted or for fans of easy to read stories about young witches. As the back-cover states, it is not suitable for younger readers, but for older readers, the combination of the supernatural and tough realism that Melvin Burgess, author of Junk, is famous for, makes for an engrossing, dark and compelling read. Bea has begun to see things that no one else can see - as the family are returning home late one night, she sees evil creatures, the Hunt, and discovers that she can summon help for the creatures that are being chased. Known as the Summoner, she has the rare ability to call the spirits of people and animals out of their bodies. She meets a charismatic young man Lars, who has taught her how to skate board as well as a young girl, Silvis, who introduces her to her grandfather, Odi, who warns her to be careful as the huntsmen want to use her to gain these magical spirits. However her parents believe she is hallucinating and take her to a hospital where she is chased by the Hunt but rescued by Lars and from then on Bea is confused, not knowing who she can trust and what is the right thing to do. Lars assures Bea that he is on the side of good and is against the Hunt, but gradually the reader becomes concerned for her well-being as she is introduced to drugs and begins to summon the spirits of living creatures.
Bea is a likeable but naive young woman who doesn't know where to put her trust and under Lars' influence seems unable to work out what is good and what is evil. He assures her that by helping him her family will be rescued and Bea goes along with what he wants her to do. The final, dramatic event when Bea must take responsibility for her actions and try to set things right will have readers on the edge of their seats.
Burgess' narrative is perfectly constructed, with twists and turns, leaving the reader wondering who can be trusted. His characters come alive and it is easy to believe this tale of myth and magic, witches and the Hunt. Bea's friendship with the loyal and sympathetic Silvis is a highlight of the story, but the failings of her father make a grim contrast, as the reader finds that parents are not always right and do the correct thing for their children.
Pat Pledger

The Unadoptables by Hana Tooke

cover image

Puffin Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780241453612.
(Ages: 9+ years). Highly recommended. The Unadoptables by Hana Tooke is an exciting and cleverly written middle grade read. The story is action-packed with mystery, danger, adventure and some very evil characters. In 1800 five orphans are abandoned in the same week in different receptacles at the Little Tulip Orphanage. Chapter One begins with the rules for abandoning babies being broken and an introduction to each child who is given an unusual name by the cruel and dastardly matron Elinora Gassbeek. The children, named Lotta, Egg, Fenna, Sem and Milou, have their own special qualities that they share with each other. They have never been adopted and have a strong familial bond and survival instinct. They are treated miserably and work all day and night for little food and no comforts. Milou is determined to find her parents and is a wonderful storyteller. She creates all sorts of reasons as to why she was abandoned and keeps a Book of Theories. Milou is the driving force behind the five escaping the orphanage after the villainous Mr Rotman offers to buy them from the matron to become child slaves on his ship. He and the matron are in partnership and profiting from the sale of the orphans. Milou with the help of the other children finds a home in the guise of a windmill using map coordinates left in her baby coffin. The abandoned property also contains an old rundown theatre and puppets similar to the one Milou has had with her from her arrival at the orphanage. Once at the windmill the five decide to stay and live there but need to earn money to survive. They embark on a grand plan to raise money by holding a puppet show for the local community and also in the hope of finding Milou's parents whom she strongly believes are searching for her. Added to this scenario is the suspicious neighbour, an official from the Kinderbureau, a man-eating dog, one of the children held captive, the dramatic rescue, plus a mysterious stranger and there is the makings of a great tale for avid readers of mystery and danger. Themes: Orphans, Family, 1800's, Amsterdam, Adventure, Excitement, Danger, Mystery.
Kathryn Beilby

Ten minutes to bed Little Dinosaur by Rhiannon Fielding

cover image

Illus. by Chris Chatterton. Penguin Random House UK, 2020. ISBN: 9780241386736.
(Ages: 2-5) This is a new title in a series of Ten Minutes to Bed books (including Little Monster and Little Mermaid). It's an overt bedtime story set in The Land of Nod (the endpapers show a map of the land and where each of the characters live) and is similar in concept to other books about bedtime reluctance such as Play and I Am Not Sleepy and I Will Not Go to Bed. In addition, a counting element is included as it counts down the minutes until bedtime from ten to one. 'Ten minutes to bed!' Mum tells Rumble. But Rumble just loves to have fun. So off he thunders, sending birds and frogs hopping and fluttering, splashing about in the mud and running all the way to an erupting volcano. 'Five minutes' say all the dinosaurs racing past him in a rush to escape the lava. 'Four minutes to bed . . . but where am I, I wonder?', he says when he finds a safe place to rest. It's rainy and thundery and getting dark when a shadow appears. It's Mum, come to take him home. 'Two minutes,' she said. 'You are never alone.' Before the last minute is even done, Rumble is in bed and fast asleep, snoring.
Rumble's romping journey will delight young ones, who will see in the illustrations the progression from sunset light to moonlight. The mountain forest where the dinosaurs live is vivid and magical and the depiction of light will cleverly calm and soothe children (glowing lights within the forest, moon and shimmering stars). There is a nice message here for children about being responsible and in control of their own body and winding down for sleep. Little Dinosaur seems to pay no attention to the countdown but by the end of the ten minutes he is already asleep. It may even help some younger children to set in place their own countdown to bedtime and assist with an understanding of self-settling. Themes: Bedtime, Counting Book, Rhyming Book, Dinosaurs.
Nicole Nelson

Barkley by Rebecca Crane

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651404.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Barkley is unsure of just what sort of dog he is. He compares himself to all the neighbourhood dogs: he is not big like the biggest dog, or fluffy like the really fluffy ones, or long and stretched out like the long greyhounds. He looks around and is concerned that he does not fit any category: he is not fast or fierce or fancy, and concludes that he is a nothing dog, a dog that no one values, and runs away. In doing this he becomes lost and does not know how to get back home. Now he is a tired, cold and wet dog, and very very lost. But in searching for Max, he comes across a poster with a picture of himself and Max on it, telling people that Barkley is a lost dog. The poster describes him as small, black and white and Max's best friend. Barkley puts the poster in his mouth and sets off to find Max. In searching for Max, Barkley finds that he is being searched for as well, and the two are reunited.
Now he is a very happy dog.
This lovely story, reiterating that we all have value, uses words to describe the traits of the dogs in the neighbourhood, and very easily, readers will be able to apply those words to themselves. All of the descriptive words (adjectives); long, short, fluffy, lost, etc could be used in a variety of ways in the classroom, introducing the role of such words and how they enhance meaning. The positive outcome uses affirming words, happy, best friend, encouraging the readers to apply them more widely. They will see the connection between these positive words and their self esteem, and recognise that Barkley's self esteem plummeted when he felt he had no value.
Themes: Self esteem, Mental health, Loss, Dogs, Friendship.
Fran Knight

Hodgepodge: How to make a pet monster by Lili Wilkinson

cover image

Illus. by Dustin Spence. Albert Street Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760877385.
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Artie an eleven year old science nut who definitely does not believe in monsters, ghouls, ghost or fairies, finds himself in an old house with his renovation driven single mother and her new partner David. Not knowing what to call David is only part of his problem, the main one being that he has moved in with his twelve yer old daughter, Willow.
Determined not to like her, Artie retreats to the attic where he finds an old book with recipes for producing monsters. Willow takes to the book instantly and focusses on which monster to create.
Each few pages of this very funny book has a fact file about a particular monster, and the whole book is presented with engaging cartoons, illustrations and different fonts. An easy read, the book is divided into twelve short chapters, each of about fifteen pages, thrilling the readers with witty text and comic illustrations.
The relationship between Artie and Willow develops despite their animosity and when they do create a pet monster, Hodgepodge, are at a loss as to what to do with it.
He causes some problems which are blamed on Artie and Willow, so they decide to send him back. Their attempts fail each time and the monster's farting shows that he is still around. But in the background is an oddly dressed gentleman wanting to help. They visit his museum but are unimpressed with his motives and so decide they must retrieve Hodgepodge.
The first in a sparkling new series, the misadventures of Artie and Willow are sure to win a wide audience.
Themes: Monsters, Pets, Humour, Step families.
Fran Knight