Reviews

When I was Ten by Fiona Cummins

cover image

Pan Macmillan, 2020. ISBN: 9781509876945.
(Age: Adult - late adolescent) Stunning in its impact, this is one of the most disturbing books that I have read. It takes us into a world of familial abuse that is shattering for the family members and devastating in terms of their capacity to face life. Attempting to live 'normal' lives, when a young person has experienced daily bullying, beating, punishment and violence, mostly by the father, is a tremendously difficult task. Even more difficult is to experience such a life when the abuser and bully is a parent. We are positioned to grasp the horror for the children as their father's actions and words cut like a knife, crumbling any sense of loving family that they may have managed to hold on to. The creation of a hell-on-earth for children cannot possibly enable them to mature normally, nor does it allow them to be 'normal' adults, and this is indeed the scenario for a particular family in this novel.
When the father goes too far in his criticism, supported by the mother, in a particularly dreadful episode of his violence, the daughters are banished to the cold, dark shed for the night. Along with his disgusting and shocking accusations, one sister finds that she can no longer bear any more of his violence, and she kills both the mother and father, stabbing them with a pair of scissors. In a magnificent gesture that will haunt her life, the other sister confesses to the murder and at that point the lives of both sisters collapse. Years later, a television producer seeks to revive this story and, having traced the sisters, the team move in on the story, compelling a reaction. When we read about what their father did and how the girls were treated, the only word for our response could be absolute horror.
Well-written and gripping, this story emotionally draws us in to the psyche of the sisters and the woman who befriends the innocent sister, in an interesting reflection of the anger and violence that is indeed part of the modern world, not only in the terrible actions of the father, but also in the notion of a 'story' that is discovered and used to make a 'winner' for the news media out of the dreadful experience of others. This novel is disturbing, as Fiona Cummins has constructed the narrative so that it reveals the reality that some people experience. It is a gripping tale, mixing the years across the connecting narratives, gradually including some of the more horrendous experiences and actions, threaded throughout the narrative. This brilliantly written novel would not be appropriate for a younger child or early adolescent; indeed, I would recommend it only for an adult or late adolescent reader.
Elizabeth Bondar

Loveboat, Taipei by Abigail Hing Wen

cover image

Simon & Schuster UK, 2020. ISBN: 9781471192852.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended for older readers, this coming of age contemporary romance is a delight to read. With strained family relationships, potential first love and new friendships, Loveboat, Taipei is a great read. Everett, Ever, Wong is living with a hidden dream. She dreams of dancing, not going into medicine as her parents plan for her future. It's her final year of school and she's got one last dance performance at the end of term, but her parents shock her with the news that they've enrolled her in an educational camp in their home country of Taiwan. Lacking the courage to fight her strict parents on their decision, Ever is off to Taiwan for Chinese Summer School, fearing the worst. She is pleasantly surprised to find it more of a party than a prison - called 'Loveboat' by the students. She learns to embrace her new found freedom, but will she find herself and her voice?
The story of an American born child of immigrant parents is not necessarily new, however this book deals with the complexities of relationships that children in this situation find themselves living with - parents who sacrifice everything for their children to have a better life, friends from different cultural backgrounds who can't understand the mentality that family expectations are everything, and the people who always have your back, no matter what. As Ever grows more daring through the book, finding her courage, I found myself expecting her to have the most amazing summer with her new friends, and found myself caring for her - despite her occasional bad choices . . . Fans of romance and coming of age stories will enjoy this book, as will readers who enjoy stories with cultural settings.
Themes: Coming of age, Parent/child relationships, Culture, Romantic relationships
Melanie Phillips

What do you call your grandpa? by Ashleigh Barton

cover image

Illus. by Martina Heiduczek. Harper Collins, 2020. ISBN: 9780733340864.
(Ages: 3-7) Recommended. With this debut book, Ashleigh Barton provides a heartwarming depiction of child-grandfather relationships around the world. 'In every country around the world are grandpas short and tall. Though they go by different names, we love them one and all.' Each page shows a grandpa and his grandchild somewhere around the world and a short verse about them: 'Here's the world's most dapper chap, in his vest and driving cap. Every week he's at the barber. Levi calls his grandpa Saba'. At the end of the story is a page explaining which language each name is from and countries where it might be spoken. Each page shows the special relationship between a grandfather and his grandchildren by depicting activities they might do together: bike riding, playing hide and seek, storytelling and telling jokes.
The inclusion of an Indigenous Australian language name and the fact that each name is not tied to a place or country shows how well thought out and inclusive this book is. While each illustration hints at a place or country, it doesn't specify and most could be anywhere in the world. There are children in countries all around the world using these name words for their grandparents, whether they are in the country where the language is prevalent or not. 'Across the globe these grandpas roam. Now let's meet one close to home. Sing it out from where you are. What do you call your grandpa?'
This is a beautiful and important book for children living in our culturally diverse country. Themes: Grandfathers, Languages, Rhyming story.
Nicole Nelson

Blood moon by Lucy Cuthew

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781406393446.
(Age: Yr 9 +) Recommended. This is not for the faint hearted, but is well worth the read. Frankie and her friends are going about their days, planning their futures, talking about their crushes, flirting with boys and enjoying life. Until besties Frankie and Harriet have a falling out over Harriet's poor decision making skills, leading to issues at school, in the wider school community and their circle of friends. Then Frankie has a very intimate moment with Benjamin, her first of any intimate moments, and she gets her period. Awkward. But both Frankie and Benjamin agree it's all good. Only blood. Whatever. Until the entire school finds out. And a horrid meme featuring Frankie goes viral. Frankie finds herself lost, alone and enduring online shaming to a volatile level. Who can she trust? What can she do? Is she disgusting, like everyone is saying?
My reaction to this book? Wow. Lives up to the hype. I really felt for Frankie, the ups and downs of her experiences, her changing friendships, her confusion over her romantic interest and the abyss of online bullying. I flew through the book in under a day, partly due to the unusual structure (the book is presented in an almost 'text message' format), though I flew through it mostly due to the gripping story. It is full of current pop culture references as well as issues in society - particularly around girls. A focus on astronomy throughout the book as a passion for Frankie and Harriet is well laid out and fits in to the story perfectly. Hashtags are incorporated throughout the story to emphasize thoughts and feelings, while the chapters are extremely short. I've not read a book like it. It is a powerful story, which should be read by all genders, more suited to older readers. I give it four out of five stars.
Book Club notes are available. Themes: Relationships, Periods, Bullying/Trolls, Shame, Feminism, Bravery.
Melanie Phillips

Big city atlas by Maggie Li

cover image

Pavilion, 2020. ISBN: 9781843654599. 64pp., pbk.
During this pandemic the world seems to have shrunk as nightly news bulletins bring the tales of heartache from the world's major cities into our lounge rooms. Even though we can no longer visit the cities that are becoming household names even to our younger readers, we can join Penguin on this adventure as he journeys around the world getting involved in the activities they have to offer.
Cities visited include San Francisco, Mexico City, Chicago, Toronto, New York, Washington DC, Rio de Janeiro, Buenos Aires, Dublin, London, Amsterdam, Paris, Berlin, Moscow, Rome, Madrid, Cairo, Istanbul, Cape Town, Dubai, Mumbai, Beijing, Seoul, Tokyo, Hong Kong, Singapore, Sydney and Auckland and the reader is invited to spot Penguin on the pages. With the information provided in speech bubble chunks, this is an engaging book that will interest and intrigue all budding young jetsetters - who may actually be able to travel by the time they grow up!
Barbara Braxton

There's a zoo in my poo by Felice Jacka

cover image

Illus. by Rob Craw. Pan Macmillan Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760783044.
(Age: 5-12) Recommended. Professor Felice Jacka is a world expert in the field of Nutritional Psychiatry and gut health and this book will satisfy all those poo-obsessed and curious children wanting to know more about the amazing stuff going on in their bodies. A snappy rhyme at the start of the book introduces readers to the idea that your poo is a zoo and the zoo keeper is you. Bright, funny illustrations of microscopic bugs help to guide readers through the sometimes complex and in-depth content, not all of which will be accessible or understandable for the youngest of the target audience. Separated into chapters, it looks at the bugs that live in our body, the role of bugs in our digestive system and their importance for our overall health, the importance of exposure to dirt and germs and what we should and shouldn't feed our zoo. There are also some easy recipes included at the back of the book that utilise gut-friendly, high-fibre ingredients such as lentils, legumes and wholegrains.
This is a super important book not just for children but also for parents who are trying to improve the gut health of their children. It makes it so much easier to get children on board with eating nutritious food when they understand the reasons for doing so and this book provides child-friendly and engaging content to enable this. This book will spur lively conversations around the dinner table around whether we are feeding our bugs the right sorts of foods and give children the language and scientific knowledge to explain why some foods are good for us and some are not. Some older kids will love reading this from start to finish but other parents may like to read parts of the book with their children separately to help them understand their digestive system and to encourage healthy eating choices.
This is a recommended addition to the non-fiction section of every school library. Themes: Digestive Health, Microbiota.
Nicole Nelson

Monty's Island: Beady Bold and the Yum-Yams by Emily Rodda

cover image

Illus. by Lucinda Gifford. Allen and Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760529864.
(Age: 6-9) Highly recommended. This is the second book in the Monty's Island series. Monty lives on a desert island with his friends and companions who are clearly introduced visually, early in the book. They are full of excitement as trading day has arrived and they eagerly anticipate the arrival of Jolly's Bring and Buy ship. Each quirky character has special items to trade and they set off for the long walk to the only safe landing place on the island. Along the way they hear the ship's horn and are surprised at how early it is. However it is not Jolly's ship but Bold's Better Bring and Buy ship. From the very start of the trading process something does not seem to be right and Monty and his friends are apprehensive about the trade transactions taking place. After the Islanders are given Yum-Yams, chaos descends, and it is up to Monty and his friends to solve the problem or they may be an environmental catastrophe on Monty's and the neighbouring islands.
Emily Rodda has written an entertaining and exciting story. She has a sound understanding of what young children enjoy and what they will be entertained by. The clever illustrations by Lucinda Gifford complement the text perfectly and will keep the young reader engaged to the end. This series would be an excellent read-aloud for classroom teachers or parents reading to children at home as the chapters are short and full of meaningful interaction. The third book, Monty's Island: Elvis Eager and the Golden Egg, will be released in January 2021. Themes: Desert Island, Friendship, Fantasy, Animals, Trading, Adventure, Excitement.
Kathryn Beilby

The sloth and the dinglewot by Nicole Prust

cover image

Illus. by Amanda Enright. New Frontier Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925594966.
(Ages: 3-7) Recommended. Rich, vibrant illustrations by Amanda Enright complement this slow, rhythmic story about a brave sloth who dares to go adventuring. The sloths are reminiscent of the sloth in Margaret Wild's The sloth who came to stay but the setting in this book is vastly different to the sparse suburbia portrayed there. The jungle scenes in the book are layered and textural, filled with plants, flowers and animals. The night scenes are especially beautiful, as elements seem to glow and the bright colours really pop off the page. The illustrations are similar in style to Leonard doesn't dance (illustrated by Judy Watson) and the story carries similar themes to Once upon a small rhinoceros by Meg McKinlay. The slow pace of the longish text sits well with the context of this slow sloth story, also allowing time to take in the magical illustrations on each page.
It's sunrise in the jungle and the sloths are still snuggling happily in their beds ('Some grumbled and groaned in their little brown hut, Some peeked at the sun and then closed their eyes shut'). But Samuel the sloth has had enough rest; he's ready for something more. 'He yearned for adventure, he yearned to explore, The sloths found him strange because he wanted more'. Venturing to the top of the tree, Samuel meets a strange bird: 'I'm the Dinglewot Jinglewot Dingledum Dee, If you want an adventure then please come with me!' Samuel is a little worried at first but with a little encouragement from the Dinglewot and some bravery he decides to give it a shot. And so begins his adventure, flying through the air, dancing with baboons, listening to the bat brass band and eating pineapple fritters in dinglewot world.
This is a sweet and fun story about venturing outside of your comfort zone and the rewards that can come from being brave enough to try something new: more adventures, great friendships and happiness. Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Adventure, Bravery, Rhyming story.
Nicole Nelson

The Phantasmic Detective Agency by Julian Leatherdale

cover image

Illus. by David Allen. Eagle Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780648194538. pbk., 283 pp.
(Age: 10+) A gripping, historical fantasy story set in London, 1911, Christmas Eve. Lily and Leo Keeper are children of the famous stage magician Edmund Keeler. Their lives are in danger and torn apart when their parents disappear while performing a new magic trick on stage. Along comes their eccentric Uncle Alfred who is a brilliant and notorious Sherlock Holmes-like paranormal detective.
Lily and Leo are led on an adventure to find their missing parents and along the way they find secrets their parents have kept from them. They are in a fast changing era of our history of giant warships, aeroplanes with bombs, spies and assassins and the fear of war with Germany.
While reading I found the story similar to reading Miss Peregrine's Peculiar Children series. It was full of secrets, espionage and monstrous creatures that threaten to destroy the Keeler family.
I enjoyed the reading the historical events and places they visited especially the Catacombs in Paris. I could picture them there as I have visited them and many other places that were mentioned.
I managed to find teacher's notes based on the book and think they would be a great history lesson with the students. Just imagine how you could use this novel in your class
This is Julian Leatherdale's first children's novel. He has written adult novel. I enjoyed reading The Phantasmic Detective Agency and can't wait to see what will happen on Lily and Leo's next adventure.
Maria Komninos

Her Perilous Mansion by Sean Williams

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760877361. pbk., 336 pp.
(Age: Middle school+) Sean Williams brings us his new stand-alone middle grade fantasy novel.
Her Perilous Mansion is a wonderfully written story about two children that find themselves working in some strange mansion miles from anywhere. Almanac is an orphan boy and Elta is the youngest of 12 daughters. They both have been invited to the mansion and work side by side in the largely deserted rooms. They never meet the inhabitants of the mansion but do talk to them through the walls, doors and chimneys. They soon realise that this is not an ordinary mansion and they are trapped there and quickly realise they have to solve a puzzle to leave.
I enjoyed reading this fun filled story of mystery, magic and fantasy. I wanted to learn more about the characters and their background that were living within the mansion and how they got there and why could they not show themselves.
I liked the way Sean has set the novel which kept you reading and solving the pieces of the puzzle to break the spell upon the mansion. He does know how to keep a reader reading.
Middle grade who enjoy fantasy with adventure will enjoy reading Her Perilous Mansion while trying to uncover the secrets the mansion holds.
Maria Komninos

A dance with Fate by Juliet Marillier

cover image

Warrior Bards book 2. Macmillan Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760784225.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended.  Following the Aurealis Award shortlisted novel, The harp of kings, once again the reader will be drawn into an ancient Celtic world, where Liobhan and Dau are determined to win a place on Swan Island's elite force. In their final bout, Dau accidentally knocks his head and loses his sight. Not knowing the awful treatment that Dau had received at the hands of his family, the leaders of Swan Island contact Oakhill. His family blame Liobhan for the accident and she agrees to go back with him and spend a year as a bond servant, but things are difficult there.  Both Dau and Liobhan are treated badly and dark secrets abound. Meanwhile Brocc is trying to fit in the Otherworld with Eirne, fighting the Crow Folk and struggling to understand why they behave as they do.
The story is told in the voices of Liobhan, Dau and Brocc, each chapter giving their points of view of what is happening. Oakhill is a dangerous place for both Dau and Liobhan. Seanan, Dau's older brother, has virtually taken over running the estate, as their father is ill, and the servants must tread very warily, obeying his often-cruel commands. Memories of the awful treatment that Dau and his dog received at the hands of his brothers plague him and he struggles with despair, but Liobhan is resolute and caring, determined to help him behave like the Swan Island fighter that he has been trained to be even though he is blind. The steps that bring them to an understanding of what is happening at Oakhill and the resolution that brings Liobhan, Dau and Brocc back together is exciting and satisfying, and will leave the reader wishing that the next instalment in the series was available to read immediately.
Themes of abuse, both human and animal, torture, redemption, misunderstanding between husband and wife and the growing relationship between Liobhan and Dau are key elements of A dance with fate. Readers will enjoy reading how Dau and Liobhan both grow in strength and maturity, and how Brocc's compassionate and inquiring nature may lead to identifying why the Crow folk act as they do.
This series is beautifully written and sure to please any fan of fantasy.
Pat Pledger

Edie's Experiments: How to be the best by Charlotte Barkla

cover image

Illus. by Sandy Flett. Penguin Random House Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760891763.
(Ages 8-12). Highly recommended. Being the new kid in a primary school is never easy and for Edie, who lives and breathes Science in her daily life, it can be a bit of a struggle to make others see the importance of her endless Science experiments and Environmental tests. This is the second book in this series which began with the book Edie's experiments: How to make friends .
Edie has settled into her class with her best friend Annie B, so when their teacher announces a science competition Edie is sure she and Annie can win it. However, a former student, Dean Starlight, who has spent the last year at a special Science school, returns. He is very popular with all the other students who all look up to him. He is an impressive student who always seems to have the right answers in the teacher's eyes and is extremely capable in class. However, when Edie tries to make friends with this apparent science soul buddy, he becomes quite sneaky and nasty, causing havoc with Edie and Annie's project with some very awful pranks.
Friendship and teamwork are important themes throughout this book and finding out the reasons behind Dean's behavior towards Edie forms an integral part of this story. Most of Edie's Science experiments involve an Environmental theme. Her family endures cold showers in her attempt to force them into saving water by having shorter showers as a homework project. Edie is all about doing small things to make an improvement to our environment and this is a lesson we can all take out of books such as these. She makes science look fun and cool for everyone.
I think these books could provide the kids who really like science an opportunity to engage with like-minded characters and follow their interests. Themes: Science, Experiments, Science competitions.
Gabrielle Anderson

Peppa Pig: I Love You, Daddy Pig

cover image

Peppa Pig. Ladybird, 2019. ISBN: 9780241371572. 32pp.
(Ages: 2 - 6) Recommended for lovers of Peppa Pig. Fans of the TV series are in for a treat as Peppa and George have lots of fun with Daddy Pig. Daddy Pig makes everything into an exciting adventure for the young pigs. When they go to the supermarket, he rolls the tins down his arm and into the trolley and fills it right up to the top. Lunch with Granny and Grandpa Pig turns into a Pirate lunch and Miss Rabbit takes them off in her helicopter to Daddy's work. There they sit in a big truck pouring concrete all over the playground and then they go off to the fair and fill in holes. What a fun day for everyone.
This is a lovely book to read aloud. Not many daddies could fly their children to work in a helicopter! Children will enjoy discussing what jobs their fathers do and contrasting them with the day out that Peppa and George had with their daddy.
As always with the Peppa Pig books, the bright colours and beautiful expressions on the faces of the pigs will keep readers involved, and toddlers will love the blue sparkly cover. Emerging readers will be happy to try and read about the familiar characters in the book, and the text, supported by the drawings, will aid their endeavours.
Full of enjoyment and illustrations of love, this will be a perfect book to read aloud on Father's Day.
Pat Pledger

Baby touch. Hello, Daddy!: a touch-and-feel playbook illus. by Lemon Ribbon Studio

cover image

Ladybird Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780241422328.
(Age: 0-3) New fathers will love reading this Baby Touch book to their little child. And any baby will love the touch-and-feel aspects of the books, feeling the soft nose of the horse, the black stripes on the tiger, the soft white fur of the dog and textured pink material of daddy elephant. The bright colours are very attractive and will hold the baby's attention, their simple shapes and design engaging.
A lot of fun can be had when reading the book, with the adult making the appropriate noise that goes with each baby animal and its daddy. There will be lots of neighing with daddy horse, roaring with daddy tiger, woofing with daddy dog, and tooting with daddy elephant. But the page that the baby will most love is the last page with its wonderful mirror with the words, Baby, look. Here you are!
Others in the series are Baby touch: Opposites and my little grandson's favourite, Baby touch: Night-night.
Pat Pledger

The Paris secret by Natasha Lester

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9780733641886. pbk., 450pp.
(Age: Secondary) Historical fiction at its best that will set you flying high above the clouds. Australian author, Natasha Lester brings us her new novel about three women who are bound forever by war. Lester's blending from fact to fiction is perfect in The Paris secret. I can just imagine how much research she did to make it this story feel real, making me feel as if I am there in the story.
The Paris secret is set in the 1930s, 1940s and present day Australia. It's a story about fashion, aviation, spies, romance, lost love, friendship that lasts a lifetime and war. We follow the story of Kat Jordan discovering secrets her grandma has kept for the last 65 years. We discover her role during the war and about the lengths people go to protect one another. Skye Penrose and her sister Liberty have an amazing story alongside Skye's soulmate Nicholas Crawford who is engaged to Margaux Jourdan.
Historical fiction is one of my favourite genres especially about women and how they survive in a man's world. I loved reading about the struggles of women pilots in the war, as men then didn't believe women had the intelligence and strength to fly planes. Well this story shows us otherwise and the role that some females played. We learn a bit about the Air Transport Auxiliary and how women were treated in concentration camps. I am not a fashion person but learnt quite a bit about fashion designer Christian Dior and his sister Catherine. I would really love to see the blue dress.
As an educational book, I think this is a great read for readers to learn about the struggles of single mums and female pilots and female spies with their struggles and what they achieved during the war.
Maria Komninos