Reviews

The Lake by Natasha Preston

cover image

Childhood best friends Esme and Kayla return to Camp Pine Lake as counselors in training. They are both thrilled to be back but hold onto a dark secret. The last time they were at Camp Pine Lake, something bad happened. Really bad. They never told anyone about it, but someone out there knows what they did. And they want revenge. The Lake never forgets.

Author Natasha Preston presents us with another heart stopping thriller. Esme, observant, smart, quiet and paranoid and Kayla, pretentious, social, animated and anxious, the two main characters battle with their own guilt of what happened ten years ago all whilst trying to provide an exciting summer camp experience for the children. The characters can come across as cliche, the "plain Jane" brunette, the popular blonde, the jock, the mysterious boy, the damaged villain. Each has their own story and carries their own secrets. As the threats start coming in and become more targeted and violent, secrets start to reveal themselves and everyone becomes a suspect.

The plot starts off fairly slowly, giving us time to get to know the characters and witness their newfound relationships start to blossom. From early on readers find out exactly what happened "last summer", quickly escalating to a heart stopping, griping finale that leaves readers thinking . . . "BUT WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?!" In traditional Natasha Preston style, the book ends with a huge cliff-hanger, with no indication of a sequel. Lovers of YA thriller will enjoy this story, with constant twists and turns that will leave you constantly looking over your shoulder and perhaps avoiding dark forests for a while.

Themes Adolescents, Emotionally disturbed children, Murder, Thriller, Summer, Fear, Gun violence.

Emily Feetham

Took the children away by Archie Roach. Illus. by Ruby Hunter

cover image

Archie Roach first wrote Took the children away as one of the songs on his debut album, Charcoal Lane released in 1990 on the Mushroom label. Archie and his late wife, Ruby Hunter published the song as a book with Ruby's stunningly unambiguous illustrations in 2010.

It is fitting that a new edition be published not only to honour its unparalleled contribution to understanding and Reconciliation but to reach a new audience as the song marks its thirtieth anniversary. All readers will be shaken anew at the sentiments expressed in this now iconic song, and be touched by the photographs of Archie, Ruby and their families.

This wonderful hard cover edition reprises the song in full, and along with Ruby's illustrations, tells the disturbing story of the Stolen Generations, where Aboriginal children were taken by the authorities from their homes, their families, their culture, to be raised elsewhere. This wrench from their families imposed untold hardships on all concerned. Those who years later were able to trace some vestiges of their families, had to be satisfied with reminiscences from uncles and cousins rather than their own parents who had since died. This double blow has been a heavy burden to carry.

In this edition, Roach has included a few photos of himself and his parents, several of Ruby, but more from their married life, raising their own children as well as fostering others.

Tears will flow readily as the song is read and sung, the illustrations perused and the photos combed, while the healing power of music, especially apt with Archie and Ruby's story, shines forth as Archie's song ends on a note of resilience and survival, 'the children came back'.

The song has touched people from all over the word: other Indigenous groups with stolen children have taken this song to their hearts.

A Youtube clip of Archie Roach singing his song can be found here.

Charcoal Lane peaked at number 86 on the ARIA Charts in April 1991 and was certified gold in 1992.

In his introduction to this edition, Archie Roach explains that he sees life in terms of a circle and when that circle is broken for whatever reason, the good thing about a circle is that it can be joined up again. And this is done by joining hands. His charity, the Archie Roach Foundation, which seeks to help those caught up in the youth justice system can be located here.

For guidance in using this book in the classroom, Archie Roach has worked with the ABC to produce a series of informative clips supporting the book.

 

Themes Aboriginal history, Aboriginal themes, Stolen generations, Children, Song, Reconciliation, Survival.

Fran Knight

Igniting Darkness by Robin LaFevers

cover image

LaFevers brings this duology to a stunning conclusion in Igniting darkness. Following the adventures of Genevieve in Courting Darkness Sybella and Genevieve find themselves in the French court. Genevieve has been left alone for many years waiting for the call from the convent which never came, and has become the friend of the King, trying to guide him on a more tolerant path. She has unknowingly drawn attention to the convent and the assassin nuns and must use all her ingenuity and wit to help Sybella and to keep herself safe. Meanwhile Sybella has the arduous task of attempting to guard the Queen, the Duchess of Brittany. Sybella's younger sisters, in grave danger from her evil brother, have been spirited out of the court, under the protection of her love Beast, and Sybella is in danger of being accused of treason.

This is historical fantasy of a very high calibre. At the end of the book, the author recounts who are the real historical figures and the mixture of unique fantasy with novitiate nuns of St Mortain trained as assassins and real history makes for a heady and engrossing tale. Court intrigue is described vividly, and it is not difficult to imagine the scenes of the king and his advisors, church and state, and the manipulations going on by power hungry people. 

The relationships between Sybella and Beast and Genevieve and the prisoner that she helped escape add an extra dimension to the book and will thrill any reader who enjoys some romance in their reading.

I am very sorry to see this series ending and look forward to whatever Robin Lafevers writes in the future. Readers who have missed the His fair assassin series, Grave mercyDark Triumph, and Mortal heart will certainly want to go back and find out more about the nun assassins, while other readers would enjoy Lumatere chronicles by Melina Marchetta and any book by Leigh Bardugo.

Themes Historical fantasy.

Pat Pledger

Little Owl's bathtime by Debi Gliori. Illus. by Alison Brown

cover image

The latest in a series of books about Little Owl (Little Owl's Bedtime, Little Owl's Egg), this title will resonate with parents and children alike. Adults will recognise the battle to get children into and then out of (!) the bath and young listener's will identify with Little's Owl's bathtime blues and imaginative adventures. Alison Brown's (Snow BearYou Make Me Happy) gorgeously sweet illustrations seem to jump right off the page, perfectly portraying Little Owl's pizzazz and spunky attitude and bringing the characters to life.

Little Owl is a master of imaginative play and is guarding a castle when Mummy Owl says it is bath time. A predictable response from Little Owl ("NO, NO, NO, NO!" and some foot stomping) is met with mum entering the play space in order to negotiate. "Perhaps Puffle could guard the castle while you have your bath", she says. Her entreatment to find the bath toys in the "foamy foothills of Bubble Mountain" is enticing, as is the marshmallow reward for capturing every one but Little Owl is still not sure. Mum meets every protest or attempt at procrastination with an imaginative solution but ultimately Little Owl wants to keep playing...baths are boring. Finally Mummy Owl's creativity gets Little Owl in the bath where he has so much fun (of course, there is water all over the bathroom) that he doesn't want to get out.

This is a beautiful reminder to parents of positive ways to deal with everyday bathtime battles and encourages them to approach the problem from the child's point of view. Perhaps it will even spark the imagination of young readers (and parents), giving them a new perspective on boring bathtimes. 

Themes Bathtime, Imagination.

Nicole Nelson

Scatter her ashes by Heine Bakkeid

cover image

Thorkild Aske is employed by Milla Lind a successful Norwegian author, to find two missing girls. The ex-police officer, Robert Riverholt, that Milla once used was shot in the head by his wife, who then suicided. Not the most auspicious beginning for Thorkild.

Aske is ex-police as well but has a multitude of issues: his ex-wife, his dead girl friend as well as his failed suicide attempt and his current dependence on prescription drugs! He is unsure why he has been chosen. Milla's explanation that it is to help with the plot of her final novel begins to lose traction after a while. The story that the missing girls, Siv and Olivia, have run off from a home to Ibiza also fails to hold water when Asked discovers they willingly got into a car at a bus stop, presumably because they knew the driver. Police do have an investigation on the runaways Iver Isaksen and Kenneth Abrahamsen and seem to know about their history and their previous Ibiza adventure.

Aske begins to think the girls may have been murdered which is confirmed with the discovery of other bodies that show similarities especially having mobile phones held to their ears. He finds they also have high levels of potassium chloride B in their blood which implies being injected probably by someone they were familiar with.

The investigation takes a different turn when Millar reveals to Aske that Olivia is her daughter. She wants to have a relationship with her after coming to terms with the emotional trauma of Olivia's conception and early life and not being able to cope and giving her up when she was three years old. Aske also believes there are other complications. He is deliberately targeted in a hit run attempt which leads him to doubt if Riverholt's murder was committed by his wife. He begins to suspect Svein Borg of the murders of several people who in the past have been identified as suicides and he may have taken Siv and Olivia.

Bakkeid has woven a narrative in which the landscapes of Norway play a significant role. The complicated characters of Milla and Aske and their tortured relationship add to the unorthodox story line. The revelations in the end reveal several damaged characters, Svein Borg and the unnatural relationship with his mother and Askes need for his "happy pills" to keep him functioning and able to relate to those around him. Eventually truths are revealed and these free Thorkild Aske to return to his bedsit and a different future.

Mark Knight

Themes Murder, Kidnapping, Crime, Norway, Detective fiction.

Becoming : adapted for younger readers by Michelle Obama

cover image

We have all seen the pictures of Michelle and Barack Obama – seemingly the perfect presidential couple, and the image of a loving family with their two daughters. But as Michelle Obama reveals in her autobiography, it wasn't always easy. She and Barack had very different personalities but their common values united them and saw them through the difficult times in their life together. This edition is adapted for younger readers and seeks to provide an inspiration for girls and young women, particularly black women, to believe in themselves and strive to achieve their dreams.

The hardback edition, with over 400 pages, may seem a bit of a challenge for the intended younger readership, but the three sections, 'Becoming me', 'Becoming us', and 'Becoming more' are broken up with an attractive collection of colour photographs that draws us into her life. As the titles suggest, the first section is about her childhood in a working class family in Chicago, then her relationship with Obama and his political campaign, and then their time in the White House trying to achieve their vision for the nation.

Michelle Obama was not always the confident woman she now appears; as a girl she was often plagued with doubts about whether she was ever good enough. But she was blessed with hardworking parents that wanted the best for her, and always encouraged her. That and her own competitive spirit meant that she pushed herself to study and achieve the best she could, ultimately graduating from Princeton with a law degree.

Her relationship with Barack was one of opposites: she was meticulous, organised and driven, whist he, though a serious thinker, had a more easy-going calm approach to life. It is fascinating to read of how they complemented each other to become a team, united to meet the challenge of balancing family and political life.

As First Lady, Michelle Obama implemented a range of projects aimed at empowering girls, and encouraging all children to lead more healthy lives, and it is good to read about her achievements while in the White House, but I think the part that will connect with most readers is the early school years trying to break past the low expectations of her teachers and prove that she could do anything if she put her mind to it.

Themes Autobiography, Women, Self empowerment, Determination, U.S. politics.

Helen Eddy

Car crash : a memoir by Lech Blaine

cover image

This book is impossible to put down. The writing is compelling and the humour dark. The characters are richly drawn, complex and their language is real.

This book is based on real events. It begins in 2009 in Toowoomba, but the real story begins much earlier. It was meant to be a short trip back from a barbecue - with five in the car and two in the boot. The car crash kills three young men, leaves two on life support - and one walks away. His name is Lech Blaine. Is he as unharmed as people think?

In the aftermath of the accident country town rumours and social media hype propel the story of the crash in all directions. Was it drugs, alcohol, speed? The number of people at the barbecue increases exponentially and grief becomes a team sport. Lech was impervious to the grief, and in an altered state. He felt the pressure to perform in just the right way via social media and through interactions with the media circus that surrounds a fatal collision. Survivor guilt meant that he felt he had to succeed on all levels and become the prime minister.

This book tackles class and masculinity through his exploration of his relationships with family and friends. His parents are larger than life and their lives were inevitably shaped by the politics of the time and the toxic masculinity that is the heartbeat of many country towns and cities across Australia. In a community where it is socially acceptable for alcohol and drugs to numb the pain of existence, the reader is led to consider the ways that confronting, and talking about, grief could be less damaging and destructive.

Book Club notes are found here.

Themes Relationships (family, friends, romantic), Grief, Drugs, Trauma, Masculinity, Mental health.

Linda Guthrie

Pizazz vs the new kid by Sophy Henn

cover image

Pizazz vs the new kid is the second instalment in the Pizazz series by UK author and illustrator Sophy Henn. It's a cheeky, witty story told in first person by the chief protagonist Pizazz. Pizazz is a schoolgirl who is trying to fit in to her new school but this is a little difficult for her because she happens to be a superhero. She comes from a family of superheroes and it is such a nuisance to her because they are routinely called out to perform superhero feats and it just gets in the way of leading a normal life. Pizazz comes up against the "popular" girl group at school and they set her up in competition with another new "kid" at school who also happens to be a superhero. In the process, Pizazz learns about what is important and how to negotiate the "Serenas" of the world.

The message is good. The scenarios are relatable. The narrative is accompanied by graphic style illustrations and at times breaks into pure graphic comic style. The book is densely illustrated; the typography very, very much a standout feature. This means that the reluctant reader may be encouraged to read this book. Any child who is into graphic novels like Diary of a wimpy kid and Dog man could be interested in the Pizazz series.

The language in this text is chatty and very much like it is straight out of the mouth of a sassy primary aged child. Sophy Henn has captured the vernacular and the energy. The sentence structure is frequently run on so this is not the book that will encourage correct writing of English. It is chat not literature but it has its place in encouragement of the struggling reader. The message also is useful. At the end, the class photo shows that the "good kids" actually do get chosen to take leadership roles in the school and the cool girls end up with roles such as "school princess, "cutest cupcake" and "Bonny Baby."  Probably the irony of that will escape the younger reader.

Pizazz vs the new kid is a fun romp and another light addition to a graphic novel or hybrid graphic/ prose collection. An easy read for young students in the primary years.

Themes Super heroes, Fitting in, School life, Mean schoolgirls, Family.

Wendy Jeffrey

Antiracist baby by Ibram X. Kendi. Illus. by Ashley Lukashevsky

cover image

Antiracist Baby by Ibram X. Kendi will be an important read for sharing at any times but is made even more crucial by the "Black Lives Matter" movement. The book begins with the statement 'Antiracist baby is bred, not born' and is therefore taught to be racist from an early age by the adults in their lives. The reader is then presented with nine steps to make 'equity a reality':

1.       Open your eyes to all skin colours.
2.       Use your words to talk about race.
3.       Point at policies as the problem, not people.
4.       Shout, "There's nothing wrong with the people!"
5.       Celebrate all our differences.
6.       Knock down the stack of cultural blocks.
7.       Confess when being racist.
8.       Grow to be an antiracist.
9.       Believe we shall overcome racism.

Under each step is clever rhyming prose to expand on what is being discussed. Some of the language used is quite complex for younger readers and the glossary at the end is a welcome addition. The illustrations are bright, colourful and depict a range of different cultural and social identities. As well as a further reading section there are some ideas for parents and care givers to begin this necessary conversation about racism.

Themes Anti-Racism, Young Children, Values.

Kathryn Beilby

His only wife by Peace Adzo Medie

cover image

A wedding without a groom! Apparently it is possible in a Ghanian traditional wedding. When Eli's business commitments prevent him from attending his own wedding, his younger brother is able to be his stand-in. The family of Afi, the bride, prepare the celebrations, and Eli's family pay the bride price in presents. There are photographs and videos so that Eli can catch up on his wedding afterwards.

It doesn't seem a very auspicious start, and Afi has concerns, because the whole thing has been arranged by the wealthy businesswoman known as Aunty, Eli's mother, in a calculated plan to draw him away from the despised Liberian woman he has become involved with. For Afi, agreeing to marry a man she hardly knows is the opportunity to lift herself and her widowed mother out of poverty, study at a fashion school  . . . and everybody says that Eli is a good man.

This intriguing start to the story quickly draws the reader in; and the varied personalities and customs of the families in Ho, a village in Ghana, are described with humour, so it becomes hard to put the book down. As events unfold, Afi develops from a shy and compliant village girl to become more assertive about her expectations of life as a married woman.

It is Afi who provides the narrative voice, so we do not meet the 'other woman'; we only know what Afi has been told, and we share her fears and prejudices. As the story progressed I did find it a bit troubling that in a story about female empowerment, no sympathy was given to the Liberian woman, even though her situation is not unlike that of another woman that Afi befriends.

For the most part Medie's novel presents as an interesting and warmly humorous take on a Cinderella story, with fascinating scenes of Ghanian life, but the twist at the end gives it a punch that lifts it to another level and provides food for further reflection and discussion.

Themes Ghana, Women, Marriage, Polygamy, Deception.

Helen Eddy

A mother is a house by Aurore Petit

cover image

A mother is a house is written by French author Aurore Petit and has been translated into English. It is a smaller picture book which would be perfect for sharing with younger children. It covers all aspects of a mother's role in the life of her baby and toddler with simple rhyming text and vividly coloured illustrations. A mother is many things to her young child and this book very clearly encompasses many of these important attributes. While the title feels rather bland and unappealing, the sentiments expressed in the book will resonate with both children and mothers alike.

An interesting gift for a new mother or Mother's Day.

Themes Mothers, Children, Family.

Kathryn Beilby

Wolfboy by Andy Harkness

cover image

Wolfboy is hungry, very hungry and as the pages proceed he becomes very hungry indeed. He stomps around in the woods beneath the full moon yelling for rabbits. He searches through the murky creek, now huffy as well as hungry. He climbs up the creaky old oak still needing rabbits. He is now hungry and huffy and drooly, but no rabbits can be found. He becomes hungry and huffy, drolly and growly in his search for the rabbits, but even as he goes through the soggy bog, he cannot find them.

Each double page tell us where Wolfboy is looking for the rabbits, and repeats the words describing his emotional state as he cannot find them. But the readers can find them, they will see them on each page and call out for Wolfboy to turn around or look under the tree or under the lily pad. Readers will have a great time with this funny book, following Wolfboy’s obsession with finding rabbits to curb his appetite.

A neat solution rounds off this engrossing book, enabling the rabbits to survive the suspected onslaught of a hungry Wolfboy.

The illustrations are engrossing and details about how they were created appears on the publication page. It is worth reading to the kids as it will encourage them to look more closely at each image on every page, seeing how each of the pieces was built from clay, and then photographed. A video clip of Harkness showing how he created the images is available.

This book is a wonderful read aloud, encouraging adult and listener to put on voices, to stomp around the floor, to call out the words describing his hunger and then his eating of the moonberries, while participating in the reading and asking for it to be read again.

A promotion for the book making it come to life can be found here

Themes Imagination, Collage, Hunger, Humour, Read aloud.

Fran Knight

Super Cute : The sleepover surprise by Pip Bird

cover image

In a world where 'cute' rules, Sammy the Sloth is planning a surprise sleepover.  The World of Super Cute is full of bizarre cuteness - talking skateboards, a marshmallow canyon, fruit salad forests - only some of the strangeness dressed in cute fantasy attire. So, a sleepover planned with funsies dressed in onesies is sure to be intriguing! Unfortunately, there is an interloper who is not as cute and fluffy as some.

This is a book that is designed for the age-group that still likes fantasy to have lollies, sprinkles and magical bursts of flavour, with only a little bit of magical poo! Interspersed into the simple story are puns, rhyme and alliteration as word play amongst the playful characters. Written for the independent reader aged 5+, this is a very light-hearted burst of magical narrative.

Themes Fantasy, Friendship, Sleepovers.

Carolyn Hull

When you go to Melbourne by Maree Coote

cover image

A very quirky look at a complicated and involving place, readers who live in that city or are going on a visit will gaze adoringly at the range of things offered to them. They will love recognising facets of Melbourne's architecture, structures and culture, while perusing each page with a great deal of care. Many will see it as a game, playing 'who can spot the . . . ' as they read of things hidden on each page, listed at the end of the book, or tell each other stories of their adventures within the city, or spot the different buildings they know as they turn the pages.

The book is a journey, asking the reader to see the things the author saw when her mum took her to Melbourne. In four line rhyming stanzas aspects of the city are revealed, while the black outlined illustrations reprise many well known buildings, artefacts and icons of culture which Melbourne is known for.

Striding across the pages we see Norman Lindsay's characters from The Magic Pudding, and trams and gargoyles, gryphons, sculptures and signs. We start at Flinders Street Railway Station, travel past beautiful old buildings, get on a tram, go past the Forum, counting all the gryphons, walk down the lanes to see the artwork, check out the Giants on the clock, have a coffee in Burke Street, count the bridges over the Yarra, stand in awe in front of the State Library of Victoria, then to the Block Arcade for a cake at the tea rooms.

Kids will love finding the things hidden on each page, unconsciously learning lots about the sights and sounds of one of Australia’s premier cities, Melbourne.

Maree Coote's distinctive style of illustration will entrance readers as they note the bold black outlines, the playing with perspective, the bold colours and naive style of presentation. I loved Dogography( 2019) and this too is kinky and ingenious, making any reader look more closely at what is around them, and having a few laughs along the way.

Themes Melbourne, Humour, Architecture, Street art, Journeys.

Fran Knight

Chain of iron by Cassandra Clare

cover image

Chain of iron follows directly on from Chain of gold and sees Cordelia Carstairs engaged to James Herondale. She is secretly in love with him, but their marriage is a sham: James is in love with Grace Blackthorn and the pair agree to divorce after a year. Meanwhile there is a serial killer on the loose in London and the Merry Thieves, James' gang of friends, are on a desperate quest to find who is killing their fellow Shadowhunters.

Although Chain of iron is another large tome of 592 pages, Clare's flowing prose and exciting tension make it an easy read, especially for fans who are comfortable with her characters and setting. After reading Chain of gold and Tess and Will’s adventures in The infernal devices it was easy to settle into reading another familiar adventure fantasy, set in Edwardian England and full of twists and turns and danger. Cordelia's quest to settle the strangeness of Cortana, her beloved sword, brings some surprises, while James is still battling with the darkness that is his grandfather.

Fans will be happy to learn more about Matthew and the dark secret that he harbours, and Grace Blackthorn, although an unlikeable character, has moments when the reader is sympathetic with her life. Lucie's attempts to bring the ghost Jesse Blackthorn back to life bring another strong plotline to keep the reader engaged. And of course, Clare is an expert at writing romance and descriptions of Anna and Adrienne's romance and Cordelia and James' feelings for each other ramp up a notch.

And that cliff-hanger ending will have readers begging for the next book.

Themes Fantasy, Romance, Demons.

Pat Pledger