Reviews

Cat on the island by Gary Crew and Gillian Warden

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2008.
Gary Crew demonstrates just how powerful a picture book can be in getting across an environmental message to all ages in this new book, beautifully illustrated by Gillian Warden. When the boy asks his grandfather to tell him a story, he hears about his forebears, sent to an island to take up the position of lighthouse keeper. Moving, the family takes their cat, and when she gives birth, the kittens eventually travel all over the island, feasting on the small wrens which live there.

When one of the cats brings in a dead bird in its mouth, the lighthouse keeper wraps it up and sends it to the museum. This attracts the interest of the naturalist but when he arrives at the island to trap some of the birds, the only flightless wrens in the world, he cannot find any. They have all been hunted to extinction.

The island is real. Stephens Island off the coast of New Zealand hosted the family and its cat in 1894. Within two years, no wrens were left.

The seemingly simply told story is explosive in its message. Any person reading or hearing it cannot help but be dismayed along with the little boy who asked for the story to be told. The illustrations serve the story well. At first calm and liquid, getting increasingly menacing as the story progresses, the eyes of the cat become larger, until the double page spread of a heavily clawed and nastily toothed cat looms up in red, ready to attack the reader.
Fran Knight

Evening is the whole day by Preeta Samarasan

cover image

Estate, 2008.
Preeta Samarasan's Rajasekharan's family story is told through Aasha's eyes, and is set against the newly emerged state of Malaysia. Woven through the disintegration of this Indian-Malaysian family is the birth and struggle of a new country fresh from the colonial rule of Great Britain.

The Rajasekharans are a wealthy family; Appa is a successful criminal barrister and his wife, Amma has come from humble beginnings and is very aware of her social standing and works hard to make the coffee morning set. Poati is the mother in law who indulges all but Amma and her unfortunate servant, Chellan. The children of this loveless and soulless marriage are Unna, a precocious child and now an intelligent young woman about to go to study in an Ivey league university in the USA, Suresh and indulged younger brother and the youngest, Aasha, whose only support, Unna, is about to abandon her.

Ghosts are the only friends for Aasha after Unna suddenly and inexplicably no longer includes her in her world. She observes her family almost as an outsider, from her refuge point on or behind the green PVC couch. Through her we see the family moving further apart. Appa has his mistress and he spends most of this time with this family. Paati, who seeks favour from all, sets all against her daughter in law, who she considers an unworthy match for her son.

All the stories, the secrets and lies come spiraling together at the point of Unna's departure. And these are all symptomatic of the complexity that is Malaysia.
Mark Knight

Saltwater moons by Julie Gittus

cover image

Lothian 2008. ISBN 9780734410290
(Age 15+) Invited to spend the weekend at a shack owned by his parents, Sun agrees without hesitation, as she can see that Tycho is as interested in her as she is in him. But despite the sentimental cover, making this appear to be a schmaltzy romance, this book concerns the growing realization of Sun's betrayal by Tycho's friend, Mark. At the party Tycho is diverted by his former girlfriend, and the drunken Sun goes down to the beach with Mark. Here they have fumbling sex, Sun for the first time.
Sun is in year 12, and so feels she is in control of her life and where she is headed, but her decision to be with Mark, changes her view of life. Her relationship with Mark causes incredible friction between Sun and her best friend, and when Sun stays away from school through illness, on her return the spite towards her has consumed most of the year group. She turns more and more to Mark, despite the interest from Tycho still being there, and so she must resolve what is happening in her life. Most realistic, the behaviour and language of senior students is most real. Senior students will relish this story.
Fran Knight

The twisted citadel by Sara Douglas

cover image

Voyager, 2008.
(Age 15+) This is a quest fantasy in which the central protagonists Maximillian and Ishbel have to organise the people of their world to defeat the immediate threat of the Screalings (a swarm of monsters from the cold north) and an ancient evil from the south. To do this, our heroes have to regain their heritage of power in the twisted citadel. Unbeknown to them Ishbel and Maximillian have been groomed through painful childhood experiences by the devious snake and frog gods. Further complicating events is the fact that they love each other but events have parted them, leading to mistrust and misunderstandings on their reunion.

The Twisted Citadel is a great read for Sara Douglas fans as she brings back characters from the Axis books who escaped the destruction of Tencedor. The previously stand alone books that Douglas has tied in are Threshold which occurred 2000 years in the past and Under the Hanging Wall, which is in the recent past for the hero Maxim. The story refers to previous action but understanding is not dependant on having read earlier books. However to make sense of The twisted citadel reading The serpent bride is essential as most of the characters' actions are dependent on events in The serpent bride.

Whilst this is not as strong a book as The Serpent Bride, it carries the story along and I look forward to a rip roaring finale with our heroes saving the world. The size of the book and themes make this an adult read or an older teen read. I would recommend it for this audience.
Leanne Marjanovic

Bunker 10 by J A Henderson

cover image

(Age 10 +) Highly Recommended. Seven teenagers have been sent to live on a military base, apparently because of their superior intelligence, although none of them seem to know quite why they are there. All are about to be annihilated in a huge explosion on Christmas Eve - and this story is the countdown to their destruction.

Cheerful stuff! The uncompromising bleakness and violence in Bunker 10 is shocking enough, but hovering above it is the stark suggestion that these are not actually real children, but extremely sophisticated computer programmes.

Simulations are a specialty of this military base and it appears that a team of intelligence experts have been sent into the base to test the ultimate in simulation - computer programmes that can think and act independently and who believe themselves to be real human beings.

There is so much double crossing and ducking and diving that you have to really concentrate while reading Bunker 10, but this outstanding book more than repays the effort. On one level there is enough tactical action to satisfy the most ardent paint-ball fanatic. The speed of action is breathtaking with plenty of shooting and gore. On another level I found the whole story quite unsettling. We know simulations are an important element of the plot and I spent the entire book wondering whether the children were real or not and whether the massive explosion (we are told at the start there are no survivors) would really happen.

J A Henderson is a master. His use of the 'countdown' (each section starts with the time, adding to the sense of urgency) builds the tension until you are racing through, desperate to find out what happens. There are some great touches of humour - I loved the reference to Star Trek. Characterisation of all seven children is engaging - their idiosyncrasies add to both the realism and the humour and while the plot is wildly beyond the realms of reality (I hope!) who cares? This is a fantastic story which should impress the boys. Quick J A Henderson, write another one!
Claire Larson

Give me truth by Bill Condon

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2008. ISBN 9781741663310
(Age 13+) Two stories overlap in this new novel by Bill Condon. I loved No worries (2005) and felt that the voice of the adolescent boy in that story, trying valiantly to help his mentally ill mother was just prefect. I'm not so sure here, but kids will love the story about the breakdown of marriage and family.

Caitlin's mother has just found out that her husband has been having an affair. Caitlin tries to comfort her and is willing to keep quiet for the sake of her younger brother. But she has trouble talking to her father, and feels the whole family is about to erupt. David's family has had a major argument ending with David being hit by his father. His mother and the two children leave the house and move in with their grandmother. David feels he wants to talk to his father but his mother is adamant that he does not see him.

The two stories of Caitlin and David intersect when both teens and their friends audition for a school play. Both the protagonists are angry with their parents but have to hold some sort of secret within themselves while outwardly behaving normally. It puts an incredible strain on their friendships and time spent at school. Condon cleverly contrasts the two situations; Caitlin's where her parents are reasonably controlled and civil, David's where his parents are antagonistic and the father is out of control. The reader can see for themselves the choices being made by each family in a situation not conducive to making informed and reasonable decisions. It is at times a scary read, but adolescent readers will see themselves and/or many of their friends in this story.
Fran Knight

Artemis Fowl and the Time Paradox by Eoin Colfer

cover image

Can this wonderful series get any better? It certainly can! This is one of the best Artemis Fowl books yet. It is a fabulous adventure, cram packed with humour and thrills, danger and breathtaking near-misses. From his brothers calling him a simple-toon to him meeting his younger self (who tries to outwit him) the one liners just never stop. Mulch's exploding bum-flaps make an unwelcome appearance, and Holly becomes a teenager. There is a kiss, but you'll have to read the book to find out who's involved!
And the story? Well, Artemis and friends travel back in time to try and save Artemis' mum from what seems to be an old fairy virus. The cure lies in the brain of an extinct animal, the final one having being sold by Artemis Fowl when he was ten. However, travelling back in time can cause HUGE problems! Not only do you have to ensure you don't change the future, but you have to make sure you don't accidentally bring one of your old arch enemies back with you. The end of this book is just right and leaves you with an intense feeling of satisfaction. Aahh!
Nikki Heath

Spirit of hope by Bob Graham

cover image

Lothian, 2008.
(Age 5-7) Recommended. This is an uplifting book that warms the heart. The Fairweather family, a loving group, is always optimistic and cheerful. Dad works at the local factory and six days a week comes home to be welcomed with lots of attention from his large family. On the seventh day the family heads off to the docks for a picnic and one day they see a large ship, The spirit of hope, which has come from a faraway port. Then devastating news arrives: they have to move out of their house because it is going to be demolished to make room for a matchstick factory. All the Fairweather's friends gather around and help them search for a new home, but it seems hopeless until Mary's toy inspires them with a brilliant idea.
This delightful story is beautifully complemented by the illustrations, which bring the family, all their different characteristics, their love for each other and their surroundings alive in a most satisfying way. Colour is used really effectively to pinpoint the emotions of joy and spirit of hope of the family and the despair that occurs when all seems lost. Observant readers will notice Mary's toy and may guess the solution to the family's problems, while others will be pulled along by the descriptions of the fun loving family and their activities and will have fun looking back on the pictures.

This would be a good book to read aloud and the themes of love, family life, using your imagination and ingenuity could result in interesting class discussions.
Pat Pledger

Princess Ben by Catherine Gilbert Murdock

cover image

Pan, 2008
(Age 12+) A change of pace from the author of Dairy Queen and its sequel, The off season, Princess Ben is a fairy tale with a difference. When her mother is assassinated and her father and his brother the King disappear, Princess Benevolence is forced by Queen Sophia to acquire some of the characteristics befitting a princess. Used to running wild and having her own way, Ben uses every skill she has to hinder the queen's attempts to make her lose weight and groom her to rule the kingdom. When she is locked into a tower she discovers a passage that leads to an enchanted room and spends her nights learning spells and how to manipulate a magic broom. However her magical skills are inadequate and she is flung out into the world to fend for herself. When war looms she is forced to re-examine what she needs to do to look after her country.

This coming of age story has the reader empathising with Ben, who has been used to being the centre of her parents' world. Alone and unloved, she is determined not to turn into the sort of girl who is only interested in attracting the right type of suitor. Her courage and determination to become her own person keeps the reader engrossed as she thwarts Queen Sophia, pursues her magic skills and survives as a prisoner in the king of Drachensbett's army. The romance strand with Florian, the Prince of Drachensbett, is less satisfying to romance lovers, but fits in well with Ben's feisty character.

This would be an easy to read and enjoyable introduction to the genre of fairy tales retold and could lead to the exploration of more in-depth stories like those told by Robin McKinley.
Pat Pledger

One beastly beast by Garth Nix

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008.
(Ages 9+) Subtitled, Two aliens, three inventors, four fantastic tales, this book of short fantasy tales will intrigue and delight the avid Garth Nix/fantasy reader. Nix has always had a different view of the world, and his fantasy writing is amongst the best. For older readers, The Old Kingdom series is magnificent, and for middle school readers, The Keys to the Kingdom is just riveting. This book is for middle primary students and takes an askance look at some things we take as written.

The first story, Blackbread the pirate, takes the term video piracy literally, as a boy, Peter, on his way to return his family's DVDs to the video shop, is raided by pirates, Video pirates! The rats steal his videos and scurry down the sewers, followed by the Navy rats, resplendent in their blue and gold uniforms. When they ask Peter to join them, he cannot, being somewhat too large, but an Alice in Wonderland moment occurs, and Peter is transformed to the size of a rat.
This funny story is followed by The Princess and the Beastly Beast, Bill the Inventor and Serena and the Sea Serpent. All great fun and sure to please the middle to upper primary student, with illustrations by Sholto Walker.
Fran Knight

Issues of our time edited by Helen Sykes

cover image

Future Leaders, 2008. ISBN: 9780980332018
This book is for upper secondary students and has articles and essays by leading thinkers on issues such as climate change, reconciliation, sexuality, affordable housing, higher education and bioethics. It also has 9 fiction and 9 non fiction essays selected from work submitted for the Future Leaders Writers' Prize in 2007, from year 12 students all over Australia.
The essays by eminent thinkers such as Larissa Behrendt, Michael Kirby, Fiona Stanley and Julian Disney are lucid, comprehensive and very informative, but only Michael Kirby on Sexuality has an accessible, personable and inspiring style. The student non fiction section with articles on climate change, racism, depression, choosing a baby's sex , nuclear energy and violence are more original in style, vivid and readable. The essay on climate change was an opening address to a conference in 2019 and graphically painted the future we could face if we continue to ignore global warming. The book is worth getting just for these essays and is available for free.
The 9 fiction essays grapple deeply with topics as diverse as Uluru, homelessness, grief and memory, being and madness. The poetry of Jessica Bloom in Godot Alone is brilliant. Alec McKinnon displays compassion in the beautifully written The Oak Tree when the newspaper boy once again hears the old lady's story of her husband's death in World War 1. Ruby Rousell finds a positive in wearing a back brace for scoliosis.
Lend a copy to your year 12 English teacher: they will find something there to share with their students.
It's reassuring that there are students who can write and think like this. One hopes there are many more like them.
Kevyna Gardner

The world's bellybutton by Tanya Landman

cover image

Walker Books 2007.
(Age 7+) William Popidopolis sometimes wishes he had an ordinary name like Smith, but his Greek connection proves very exciting when, while holidaying in Greece, he is approached by a large swan who engages him in conversation. The swan turns out to be Zeus, the king of the gods and he persuades William to help him in a race against time to retie the knot that secures the world. With a trip to the Underworld and a chance encounter with his distant ancestor Odysseus, William, who is slightly lacking in the confidence department, discovers reserves he never knew he had. Coming up with an ingenious plan to defeat the Gorgons and retie the knot, William embarks on the adventure of a lifetime.

This is a fast paced short novel which will engage newly fluent readers and would also be suitable to read aloud. Chapters are short, and usually finish on a cliff-hanger, action outweighs description and the plot is straightforward and exciting. William is a likeable character and children will identify with his anxieties and uncertainties and delight in his success in conquering his fears and saving the world. Ideal for confident readers, both boys and girls aged 7 plus.
Claire Larson

By Royal Command by Charlie Higson

cover image

Puffin Books, 2008.
I've been looking forward to this book for some time, as Hurricane Gold was my favourite book yet, and raced through it in around 90 minutes!
James is supposed to be relaxing and staying out of trouble for a while. However, he joins up with the school ski trip and his stamina and survival skills are tested virtually straight away. After a few lessons on the slopes, James manages to save the life of a VERY annoying and drunk boy. He's also sure he is being watched. On his return to Eton, he befriends the new maid, who invites him to a meal in the park. Whilst there, he meets her friend, the school gardener. Unbeknownst to James, he is gathering materials to blow up the school whilst the King is visiting!
James saves the day. However, the pressure becomes too much for him, and he decides to run away (I won't say why - you'll have to read the book!) However, as always with James Bond, things are never as simple as they seem.
With the re-appearance of a long 'dead' villain, the murder plot and his brushes with Royalty, I certainly was not disappointed with this book. Roll on the next!
Nikki Heath

Boobela, Worm and the potion power by Joe Friedman

cover image

Illus. by Sam Childs. Orion Children's Books, 2008. ISBN 978184255 5415
(Age 7+) This large sized paperback, full of colour and energetic illustrations, tells the tale of Boobela, a child giant, adrift from her parents, and her friend Worm, who sits on her shoulders and offers advice. There are four stories in this volume, the third in the series, aimed at linking reading between picture books and novels.

The first story, The argument, sees a rift between Boobela and Worm, as she struts off down the street without her friend on her shoulder. She needs to explain to the other children she meets that she and Worm have had a fight, and she realises how silly she has been. When tragedy occurs and Boobela needs help, Worm appears and all is right. The four stories are easy to read, have large print and tell a small intimate story in the lives of the two protagonists.

While a battle rages about putting a recommended age on every book published, it is fascinating to see how this will affect book publishing. This book has a recommended age of 4+ on its publicity sheet. But it is far more than a picture book, and more involved. This book has 108 pages with about 100 words on each page, which in my way of thinking makes it a book aimed at 7+.
Fran Knight

Ironbark by Barry Jonsberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008. ISBN 9781741149555
(Age 14+) Imagine what would happen when a 16 year old boy, suffering from a major problem, Intermittent Explosive Disorder, goes to live with his grandfather in remote Tasmania? After he has been taken to court for violence in a shopping centre the unnamed protagonist is sent away by his wealthy father, who has paid extravagantly to have his son's violence judged as an illness and not hooliganism. He records how he feels and what happens in his journal.

Jonsberg brings alive the character of the boy, with his foul language, his bouts of dangerous anger, and his extreme views of his grandfather's shack and its lack of modern amenities. His relationship with his girlfriend, his ability to cook and his growing self-awareness are revealed through his writing. The reader also gains a thought provoking glimpse of the grandfather, who gradually reveals a sense of humour and understanding of his grandson's extreme anger. The local policeman, Richie, is loved by the locals for his wood chopping prowess, but he threatens and bullies the boy who has to report to him. An explosion is just waiting to happen!

The author uses humour to effectively depict the generation gap and there is plenty of action, especially the motorbike riding and illicit car driving that the boy indulges in. There are some puzzling touches of what may be the supernatural with a strange text message telling the boy how to find his way home from the mountain when he is lost and unexplained incidents at the end of the novel, which left me puzzled. However the ending is positive and boys will love the action and humour.
Pat Pledger