Reviews

Callie by Ruth Park

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2009. ISBN 97807322892 .
(Ages: 8+) This reissue in one volume of Ruth Park's Callie's Castle and Callie's Family will win the hearts of many new readers as they are pulled into the story of Callie, at a crossroads in her short life, dealing with step sisters and brothers, missing her own father terribly.
Callie's father died when she was three, but it is only now, as her mother and stepfather and siblings, move to a new house, that her fears come to the surface. Irascible at school and at home, it takes her grandfather, an old Scots, to put his finger on the problem, and look for a solution.
The superb writing make this a sure fire winner as a read aloud, and the book will be picked up by middle to upper primary readers. The cover illustration will unfortunately be a put off, old fashioned as it appears, but the story, first published in 1974, has lost none of its appeal. Some readers will notice that the children do not rely on mobile phones and play outdoors, instead of in front of a computer, and Callie is at ease asking strangers for directions, but this points to a different time, albeit 30 years ago. The central issues of finding one's voice and having a space of your own will not be lost on today's readers.
Fran Knight

Dark angels by Katherine Langrish

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9780007214891.
(Age 11+) Recommended. After being abandoned by his parents at the monastery at the age of five, and terrorised by Brother Thomas, Wolf flees to the hills, where he is pursued to Devil's Edge by a pack of dogs. Believing that they are the Hounds from Hell, he runs and becomes even more terrified when he glimpses a strange little figure escaping into a cave. This is a place known to be inhabited by elves, goblins and demons. When Sir Hugo finds him, Wolf leads him to the elf child and finds himself at Sir Hugo's castle, looking after the strange creature he names Elfgift. Nest, Sir Hugo's daughter, is determined to do something worthwhile before she is married and with Wolf she takes the elf child into her care.
I was drawn into this compelling medieval tale right from the beginning. It is so engrossing and well researched that it took me straight into the times of the Crusades, into a world on the border of Wales and England, where Celtic myths are mixed with Christian beliefs. The description of a place where people look at things differently makes for fascinating reading. The simple acceptance of the supernatural by the inhabitants of Sir Hugo's castle adds depth and interest. I found myself, like the characters in the book, believing in the existence of the White Lady, an ethereal ghost who begs to be allowed inside and the hearth hob who plays mischievous tricks on Wolf.
Langrish's characters are wonderful. I became absorbed in the character of outspoken Wolf, and longed for a happy ending for strange Elfgift and Nest. The unhappy Sir Hugo, obsessed with the belief that he could recover his wife from Elfland, and the dangerous jester who beguiles him with strange songs and stories, are brought magnificently to life.
There is plenty of action for those who like adventure stories. With its vivid descriptions of medieval life, strong characters and often frightening mysteries, this is a book that was very difficult to put down.
Pat Pledger

It's Yr Life by Tempany Deckert and Tristan Bancks

cover image

Random House Australia 2009.
(Age range: 14 - 16). Recommended. Two students from opposite sides of the world are forced to email each other for a year 10 English assignment. Milla lives in Hollywood with all the trappings of a successful family. Sims is a street kid living in Byron Bay in a foster home. Neither are keen on the idea of the assignment, however as they begin to correspond they find a link developing and soon they are dependent on each other as they try and solve the mysteries they both find creeping into their lives.
Milla discovers footprints outside her bedroom window and is anxious to know who they belong to and why the person is sneeking around her home. Sims discovers body parts in a bag whilst searching for food in a local supermarket dumpster. Unsure whether to go to the police or whether one of his house mates is involved he confides in Milla to try and decide what best to do.
The communication between the characters, written in true email teenage speak adds to the suspense of the story. Often short and to the point, other times detailed and full of information, as the characters try and support each other through the trials of their lives.
Tempany Deckert and Tristan Bancks communicated solely by email to compile this novel giving it an authenticity that helps the reader to stay engaged with the storyline and compelled to continue reading to ensure the issues facing Milla and Sims are resolved.
Tracy Glover

Crossing the Line by Gillian Philip

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2009. ISBN 9780747599937.
(Ages: 13+) I found this a harrowing read, the tension mounting as each chapter goes by. Even though the reader knows that a boy is dead, the alternate sections, Then, telling of the past, and Now, relaying what is happening as a result, does nothing to unclench your muscles as you read. The bullying and terror tactics of some of the students, including the hero of the story, unsettled me, and lately I have read some gruesome books for adolescents.
Going to high school, Nick makes the wrong choice. He sides with one boy in a fight and so becomes part of the gang that goes around bullying and thieving from younger kids. On one occasion he says no, and becomes instead an outsider, a boy with a geeky friend, but when that friend is bullied again, a second person steps in, Aidan, his sister's boyfriend, who is killed. His sister, Allie now has an invisible friend called Aidan, who she speaks to all the time, setting a place for him at the table, ensuring he is with the family on outings. Aidan's mother cannot accept that Allie still does this, a year after his death, and asks Nick to step in.
Told in alternate sections, the story trickles out information of the situation at school, the groups, the bullies and those who try to stop it. It is familiar ground, but the way the story is told is electrifying. Told from Nick's point of view, he also tells us of his battle scared family, ill equipped to cope with what is happening, also trying to manage an aged, demented gran living with them. This book gives a background to some of the violence we read of in the papers, where youths use knives as their weapons against others.
Fran Knight

Angel Cake by Cathy Cassidy

cover image

Penguin, 2009. ISBN: 9780141325170
(Age 9+) When Anya, her sister Kazia and their parents move to Britain from Poland, each is filled with dreams of a place in which they can have a better life. Teenage Anya imagines a pretty picture book cottage complete with whitewashed walls, rambling roses growing around the door and a wonderful garden. Her arrival in Liverpool falls far short of the images gleaned from her story books. Not only is her home unattractive, her hopes of quickly making new school friends and automatically fitting in seem impossible to achieve.
Once Anya meets Dan, the school 'bad boy', she sees another side to him and hopes that he will prove to be the 'angel' he presents himself to be when they are together. Through Dan, she experiences a different side of Liverpool, and begins to make friends. Problems arise, however, and suddenly the concept of returning to Krakow seems to be the worst possible thing which could eventuate. This is a story of friendship, resilience, romance and the desire to belong.
Cathy Cassidy has delivered yet another novel which will be devoured by girls. Her style of writing is engaging and easily read, the jelly bean coloured covers are appealing and eye catching. As with her novels, Cassidy's website is interactive, presented using colour, stylised imagery from the covers of her books and keeps her fans up to date with new titles and author information. Here, the author promotes the importance of friendship, daydreaming, reading and writing, major themes in her books. Cassidy reveals that she is an 'agony aunt' and genuinely seems to know and understand her readers and their concerns. Angel Cake is another title which will never be left on the shelf!
Jo Schenkel

Free to a good home by Colin Thompson

cover image

Random House Australia, 2009. ISBN 9781741663181
Peter and Sally Smith are not ordinary children. They, along with their parents, are known for collecting things, but none more strange than the day the children go shopping and come home with an old lady. Drawing on the tales children give their parents about finding a stray cat or dog, and the cry of  'it just followed me home,' Thompson has created an intricate and absorbing picture book about an old lady and her stay with the Smith family. I loved every page, as I turned each over to find other things to look at and think about, drawings to unravel and words to ponder.
As the children give their parents reasons for the old lady to stay, she slips into their routines, cooking, cleaning, helping the kids with their homework, mowing the lawn, all the while with the Smith parents asking questions about who she is and why people are not looking for her.
As with Thompson's books, there is no resolution but questions and ideas. Some of the pages are very bleak, giving an impression that something nasty is about to happen, and the way the old woman, now 'Granny' has them all tied up at the end, but with Christmas lights, gave me the eerie feeling that she was taking over. Wonderful illustrations full of things to look at and think about, the submarine in the Monet painting is a hoot, and the little things scattered on every page a delight.
Fran Knight

Journey of dreams by Marge Pellegrino

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2009. ISBN 9781845079642
(Ages 12+) With planes overhead dropping poison to deforest the land, young men rounded up and taken by the guerillas and the army to bolster their numbers, and mother railing against the civil war around them, the village is in turmoil. But when one of her sons is taken, mother and her younger son escape to Mexico. Father and the other three children escape the village as the guerilla army moves in, killing everyone and burning it down. Their escape route to Mexico is fraught with danger as they must elude the forces ever at their heels and the bureaucracy which seeks to send them back. All the while they must be canny enough to avoid the pitfalls which besiege all those on the refugee route to another land.
A heart stopping survival story of a young girl and her family fleeing the war in Guatemala, Journey of Dreams is about every refugee, forced from their home and country by war beyond their power and understanding. This books takes the reader into a little known war in a continent few of us are even aware of. It would sit well in a study of refugees which might include books like Mahtab's Story (Libby Gleeson), Soraya the storyteller (Rosanne Hawke), and the Parvana trilogy (Deborah Ellis).
Fran Knight

Chook Shed Snake by Phil Cummings

cover image

Scholastic, 2009. ISBN 9781862918115.
(Ages 7+) One of a series published by Omnibus, called Mates, Chook Shed Snake has broad appeal, as Phil Cummings, once again, draws upon his wonderful childhood memories to relate a story about dad and the snake in the chook shed. Filled with warm, endearing characters, families everyone dreams of, and augmented with Greg Holdfeld's illustrations, this book, one of four in the series will be well used in junior primary classes, where the print size and short chapters make it instantly appealing.
Dad, sent by mum to mend the chook house, a task he had been promising to do for years, is squeamish after Harry spies a snake heading towards the little building. He gingerly uses the rake to pull away the straw to see where the creature could be hiding, but is pecked by one of the chooks, and decides to leave the task to another day. Full of gentle humour, the details about life on a farm remind us all of childhoods in the past with love and affection.
Others in this fine series, include Thorpey by Ruth Starke, The Wombat and the Giant Poojam by Jackie French, and The Smartest Dog of All by Ian Horrocks.
Fran Knight

Boy on a Wire by Jon Doust

cover image

Fremantle Press, 2009. ISBN 9781921361456
(Ages:15 - adult) Highly recommended. Boarding at one of Perth's private schools from his farm in SW Western Australia, Jack learns that the life of a student is far from the happy and carefree life he knew at his local primary school. Hit by teachers and prefects, bullied by other students, the brutality of the boarding school is one which affects him for many years after he leaves.
But he is no victim; Jack asks questions, enraging staff and students alike, making him the recipient of the slipper, the cane and the sandshoe, his words cutting the cornerstone of their privileges and customs. It is accepted at home that this will happen to him, and a code of silence ensures that it continues. Jack supports one other new boy, a quiet, solitary figure who has come to this school from the now, well known school to the north of Perth, where abuse was exposed. Jack is religious and it is this part of his life which gives him some comfort, although the questions he constantly asks of god are never answered, and the chasm between his religion and the practice at this school is overwhelmingly deep.
At times very funny, many times scarcely credible, but often moving and sometimes sad, this semi autobiographical story of a boy's life, growing up to be a man, will enrage, endear and instruct its readers, as they follow the boy balancing on the wire. The models of manhood he sees about him everyday in no way reflect what is expected of him as he grows to manhood, and the behavior of those paid to care for him is dreadful indeed.
This highly original story will be picked up eagerly by senior students. Comparisons with Catcher in the Rye, and Lord of the Flies, amongst others spring to mind as a boy struggles to survive in an alien environment, and search for some meaning in his life as he approaches adult hood.
Fran Knight

Frannie in pieces by Delia Ephron

cover image

Harper Teen, 2009.
ISBN 9780060747183.
(Ages 12+) Recommended. Frannie is fifteen and angry about her artistic father's premature death. Her mother has remarried Mel and Frannie finds them both boring and distasteful. Everything about her father is important to her and when she finds a beautifully carved box with 'FRANCES ANNE 2000' on it she assumes it's for her birthday. As the mystery of the contents of the box gradually unravels, Frannie learns about life, a boy and her Mother and Mel. Cleverly constructed, the plot engages the reader who, with Frannie, is fascinated with the time changes and the assumptions that aren't necessarily what they appear. It's an engaging read as Frannie learns about love, friendship and her caring family.
Sue Nosworthy

The book of a thousand days by Shannon Hale

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2009. ISBN 9780747597810.
(Ages 10+) Highly recommended. Award winning author Shannon Hale has written another memorable heart wrenching tale of heroism and courage. Based on the Grimm Brothers' story, Maid Maleen, Hale has set her tale in Asia. Lady Saren refuses to marry Lord Khasar, the man her father has chosen for her because not only is she is terrified of him, but she is in love with Khan Tegus. Her father is furious and locks her in a tower with her maid, Dashti, until she comes to her senses. But even the tower doesn't keep them safe from the evil Khasar, who arrival brings great danger, while Khan Tegus's appearance brings hope.
Told from the point of view of Dashti, in the form of a diary, the reader is swept into the lives of Saren and Dashti as they struggle to survive in the tower. Even though they have been left enough food and firewood to survive for seven years, the tower has been completely walled up so they live in darkness except for the meagre light that comes from the fire and candles. Rats attack their food and the guards outside desert them. Dashti's diary descriptions are compelling and the reader will never be able to think of being shut in a tower without shuddering.
Hale doesn't follow the usual rules for a fairy story. Her heroine is not a beautiful princess, but the lady's maid, a Mucker girl who has been raised on the steppes and who has a disfiguring birthmark on her face. However it is Dashti's indomitable spirit that keeps them from falling into deep depression and it is her perseverance that eventually gets them out of the tower. She is the brave one, who records their story and who is prepared to die for the love of her life. Saren is weak and whiny and would never have survived without Dashti.
This is an exciting read, with a wonderful heroine, adventure, courage, plot twists, romance and heartbreak. Rich in vivid descriptions, some charming illustrations and a very exciting and satisfying conclusion, this book is a keeper for fantasy and fairy tale readers. It would also be a powerful read aloud.
Pat Pledger

Naked Mole rat gets dressed by Mo Willems

cover image

Walker Books, 2009.
(Ages 3-7) Recommended. Naked mole rats are a little bit rat, a little bit mole and are all naked, except for Wilbur the naked mole rat who likes to get dressed. All the other moles think that he is very peculiar and go to Grand-pah complaining about his lack of nudity. Grand-pah is very wise and after much thinking makes a proclamation. But his response is a big surprise.
Award winning author Willems has created a funny and appealing race of creatures with his little naked mole rats. Young children will find them irresistible. The illustrations are a delight with each naked mole rat looking individual - just by changing the shape of the ears and eyes in the illustrations!
It is a great story about being prepared to be an individual and sticking to your beliefs even when everyone else thinks that you are wrong. The message of being prepared to look at things in a different way and answering the question 'Why not?' is never didactic but rather couched in gentle good humour. A memorable book for all the family.
Pat Pledger

Malcolm and Juliet by Bernard Beckett

cover image

Text Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9781921520327
(Ages 14+)Recommended. A group of 16 year olds in various schools, all with some connection, each with their own idiosyncrasies, are mixed up with Malcolm, intent on winning this year's science prize with his research into the first sexual experiences of his peers. What you get is rather wry, but very funny novel about teens and their activities. Beckett hits just the right note of humour in this look at teenage conduct and his mix of a range of adolescents is masterful, as the climax swings into view.
Kevin lusts after Brian who lusts after Charlotte who lusts after Malcolm, who thinks he has no show of seeing Charlotte, but his friend Juliet who is being blackmailed, tries to setup a sex talk line and lands Brian, who finding out who the voice on the end of the line belongs to, is chasing her. Complicated? No the novel glides along smoothly and wittily, making me laugh out loud as Malcolm asks the oddest of people to be interviewed. At one stage his mum consents to be interviewed and we hear of her first sexual experience, and Charlotte, who is a virgin, details what she hopes to be her first experience, and Malcolm, knowing he could never match her description, gives up on her. Very funny, lots of witty looks at teenage culture, hits at education, principals, predatory males, and culture.
So Romeo, sorry Malcolm, must avoid all the pitfalls of blighted love to reach his goal. His inexperience, combined with his goal of winning the science prize, makes him an amiable protagonist, one we all want to succeed. A marvelous novel for teens of all ages to read and share.
Fran Knight

Sharp Shot by Jack Higgins and Justin Richards

cover image

Harper Collins, 2009. (Series: Danger runs in the family)
(Ages 12+) John Chance on a dangerous mission in Iraq in 1990, sets the scene for an equally danger filled operation today as his two children are kidnapped by an old enemy, blackmailing him to return a statue left in the desert all those years go. The stage is set for a thrilling, fast paced adventure as the twins, Jade and Rich must make some fast and decisive decisions while their father is away.
Escaping a group of highly armed and dangerous killers, Jade and Rich throw in their lot with the stranger who came to their door asking for help. They realise that he is not what he seems when Rich is taken by the pursuers, and Jade, left with McCain, comes to understand that she is being held. Their father, in an effort to free Jade, complies with McCain's requests, and in coming to the desert to swap the statue for the girl, is left with his small party alone and bereft of anything which may save their lives. But in the manner of all good thrillers, they are rescued, and can then fight back.
A credible, page turning adventure, this story, one in a series about the Chance twins, will please high spirited upper primary and lower secondary readers, wanting something closer than World War Two, and complete with descriptions of the weaponry and technology now used in war and peace.
Fran Knight

The absolutely true diary of a part-time Indian by Sherman Alexie

cover image

Anderson Press, 2008. ISBN 9781842708445
Highly Recommended. Humour belies the undercurrent of poverty and despair tugging at the heels of the diarist, Arnold, as he tries to alter the accepted path for boys like him. He enrolls at a more academic school, twenty miles from his homeland. That the school is a white middle class institution in a town where Arnold and his people from the nearby Spokane Indian Reservation are not wanted makes for some cutting and deft observations about racism. Drawing heavily on his background, Sherman Alexie is able to nimbly circumvent political correctness and tell it like it is. Arnold's teacher gives out the geometry books on the first day of high school. Arnold is keen to get stuck into this new subject, and when he opens the book to find it was used by his mother, 30 years before, he knows that he will never break out of the mold. Opportunities given to Indigenous kids are just not there. At the nearby white school, he finds himself the only Indian student in a sea of white faces. The customs at his last school must be unlearned, his culture put behind him and his loyalties divided between the two worlds he inhabits. Some people on the 'rez' avoid him, his best friend deserts him, but some are proud, and his uncle calls him a warrior for doing something so brave.
In different hands this book could have been cheesy and even insulting, but Alexie's intimate knowledge of the reservation makes this a uniquely powerful read. The story cries out for recognition of the Indian plight. Moved to reservations with little opportunity for employment or activities, poor education and blighted by racism, Arnold speaks for his generation. The path he chooses is burdened with pitfalls however, in having to live a divided life, being seen as a traitor on one hand, and a curiosity on the other.
The debate over indigenous people writing their own stories flourishes, none more vocal than the website hosted by Debbie Reese in USA. She applauds the writing of indigenous people, particularly American Indians, and deplores the writing of non indigenous writers using an indigenous point of view. Her views are widely used and her website often quoted. The recent issue of Fiction Focus, an adolescent fiction journal from the Western Australia Education Department, outlines some of the current debate about indigenous writers writing their own stories, in an article called Whose Story? Indigenous Peoples in Fiction, and gives information about some of the books written by indigenous writers, including the excellent, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie.To find out more about Sherman Alexie's background, go to http://www.fallsapart.com/. And to find out about the reservation he grew up on, visit, the official website for the Spokane Tribe in Washington.
Studying this novel in the classroom would be a knockout for lower secondary kids. It will turn their faces to the reality of living in an indigenous community whether in Australia or USA or New Zealand. Stories written by other indigenous authors could be studied, and some written by non indigenous authors could be looked at to compare the tone. As part of a unit of study about racism or prejudice or specifically North American Indians, this novel has all points covered. I would expect that many schools will buy this as a class set.
Fran Knight