Reviews

Blue noise by Debra Oswald

cover image

Random House, 2009.ISBN 9787741663754.
(Ages 12+) Drooling over the guitars in the local music shop one morning, Ash is accosted by a geeky looking boy about his age, who cajoles him into taking the guitar from the stand and trying it out. In the ensuing few minutes, the boy, Charlie, who is about to join Ash's school in year 10, tells Ash about his idea to form a band and invites Ash to join him. From then on, Charlie uses humour and his own brand of determination to take a group of disparate people and form them into a playing entity.
But each of the three has problems to overcome. Ash's brother is a gambling addict, making his family's life chaotic, as he steals and lies his way through life; Erin loves the blues band but finds it impossible to tell her parents about why she wants to remain at this school and continue with the band while Charlie lives with parents who come and go at the drop of a hat, his photographer father must pack and leave with his family, wherever the work turns out to be.
During the rehearsals, and performances, the festival they attend and the up and downs of life as a band, each of the three works out what is important in their lives and come together, Ash and Erin romantically, while Charlie realises that leaving does not mean severing ties with friends.
A warm, funny novel, infused with the sounds of music, this story will have broad appeal to middles school readers, and make an excellent choice as a text for early secondary students to study in detail.
Fran Knight

Merry Christmas, Splat by Rob Scotton

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9780007326259
(Ages 4-6) Splat the wide eyed, long limbed black cat is all agog over the closeness of Christmas. He cannot wait to see what he will get and writes to Father Christmas, asking for a big present. He explains that he has been a good cat and so, in his eyes, deserves a handsome gift as a reward. But his friend, Seymour, causes some disquiet, reminding Splat that he may not have been good enough. As a consequence, Splat offers assistance where ever he can, doing mum's dishes, dressing the Christmas Tree, shoveling the snow from the door. The reader will be able to see the difference between Splat's idea of helping and the reality of what he is doing. Eventually Christmas Eve comes along and Splat waits all night with his torch hoping to see Father Christmas deliver his gift. The last page when he opens his gift gives a whole range of options for the reader.
This is a funny look at Christmas and what children expect of the day. Astute teachers and parents will be able to lead the discussion to all sorts of questions about Christmas and what it means, with the idea of gift giving a major thrust. The illustrations are delightful, with the very funny Splat making a comeback after three other books in which he is the star. Children will delight at the mischievous fun of the illustrations and the humour shown in what Splat and his friend Seymour are doing.
Fran Knight

Hate that cat by Sharon Creech

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2009. ISBN 9780747599807.
(Age 9+) Recommended. What a delight to read this reprint of the companion volume to Love that dog. Jack is once again in Miss Stretchberry's class, writing a poetry journal, while learning about the elements of poetry from poems by Edgar Allan Poe, T. S. Eliot, William Carlos Williams, Valerie Worth, and Walter Dean and Chris Myers.
While Jack struggles with his Uncle Bill's caustic comments about free verse and learns about alliteration and onomatopoeia, the reader is drawn into his world through his wonderful descriptive poems about his dislike of cats, in particular the big black neighbourhood cat that is 'meaner than mean' and sneers at him. He is still recovering from the loss of his dog and knows no cat would ever compete. However, a Christmas present of a small black kitten which he names Skitter McKitter, makes him change his mind.
I particularly liked the way that I made connections with Jack's life and feelings through his poetry. Learning about his deaf mother as Jack wrote about sound and silence was particularly poignant. The book contains all the poems that Miss Stretchberry used as well as a long list of Books on the Class Poetry Shelf.
This is a joy to read as an individual and as a read aloud and would make a wonderful class introduction to poetry.
Pat Pledger

Snowy's Christmas by Sally Murphy and David Murphy

cover image

Random House Australia, 2009. ISBN 9781741664409.
(Age 4-6) Snowy has a soft white coat, which is very different to all the other roos who are brown and rugged. He bounces high, his ears skimming the trees while the other roos leap long and low. He feels left out, but his mother assures him that he is special. When Ash, a huge white kangaroo, finds him and tells him he is perfect for a job, he follows him on the adventure of his life.
In her captivating story with an Australian setting, Sally Murphy has managed to capture the spirit and fun of Christmas, while exploring the theme of fitting in and finding your own niche in life.
David Murphy's illustrations are bold with the vivid browns and oranges and bright blue sky of the Australian landscape. I particularly liked the roos and reindeer who have such cute faces, each different and unique. Santa in his bush hat is a delight and the Christmas decorations scattered around in unlikely places are fun to find.
The theme of an Australian Christmas is sure to appeal to young children who will love to see the white roos pulling Santa's sled. A good read aloud book, and one that the newly emerging reader will enjoy, this will enhance the library's collection of Christmas books.
Pat Pledger

Barack Obama: The making of a president by Dawne Allette

cover image

Tamarind 2009.
(Ages 9 +) Highly Recommended. This is a gem of a book which tells the fascinating, thought-provoking story of Barack Obama from his early childhood to his first hundred days in office. Barack's African routes and Indonesian childhood are covered in detail along with his complex family and his political ambitions. Reading about his upbringing, his nickname of Curly Eyelashes and his beloved basketball, young readers will identify with this very ordinary boy.
I found this a hugely uplifting and informative read. Allette writes powerfully, describing Barack's upbringing, his ambition and how hard he worked to fulfil it. Today when many children are obsessed with celebrity and claim the rather empty ambition of 'wanting to be famous' it is heartening to read the story of an ordinary boy who set out to make a difference in his community before realising that to really succeed he would need to change laws - and to do that only the top job would suffice. This is a story of real ambition, of hard work, of love and support. However, it is no fairy tale and Allette covers the challenges and problems that faced Obama as well as his achievements.
Fact boxes offer helpful background information and set Obama's story in the context of its time. Unsurprisingly prejudice is a recurring theme, from the era of slavery, right up to the modern day. During a visit to America in the 1960s, my sister remembers only too well the signs on cafe windows that read 'No Blacks'. Forty years on a black man occupies the most powerful position on earth. That is something worth celebrating and Allette does this in a hugely readable, dynamic and fascinating way. Buy it for your library, read it to your class, talk about it and use it to reinforce the message that Barack himself wants to convey: 'No dream is beyond our grasp if we reach for it, and fight for it and work for it'.
Claire Larson

Halloween in Christmas Hills by Karen Tayleur

cover image

Ill. By Heath McKenzie. Black Dog books, 2009. ISBN 9781742030302.
(Ages 5-8) Recommended. What will happen when Miles goes trick or treating to Stingy Jack's house? Miles Cameron is number 5 child in the Johnson family, and the whole family loves to dress up and celebrate festivals. Dad loves Australia Day, Easter is Mrs Johnson's favourite, and everyone dresses up as leprechauns on St Patrick's Day. When Halloween comes around Miles is determined to be part of the fun and even though he is warned not to go to Stingy Jack's house, he rings the doorbell and gets a big surprise.
This is a fun book that marks the different festivals that are celebrated in Australia and explains that Halloween didn't originate in America. As Miles tells everyone it 'began as a Celtic fire festival.' It will find many fans for its humour and sly illustrations.
Heath McKenzie's drawings of the wide eyed Johnson family are a delight and every page brought a chuckle as I followed their exploits as they put up Christmas lights, handed out Easter eggs and trouped around the neighbourhood on Halloween in their zany costumes. Working out just what the tricky ending meant was fun too!
Halloween in Christmas Hills is just sheer fun to read - and it could be a useful and very entertaining picture book to supplement a unit of work on festivals.
Pat Pledger

Who wants to be a poodle - I don't by Lauren Child

cover image

Puffin, 2009. ISBN 978014138490.
(Ages 4-8) Recommended. Trixie Twinkle Toes lives in the lap of luxury with a maid, a cook and a butler to cater to her every need but she is unhappy. Although she is adored by her owner, Verity Brulee, she would really love to leave all the pampering behind and just step in puddles.
Lauren Child has written a gentle satire about the fashion of dressing dogs up in clothes, and taking them to beauty parlours, when really all they want to do is to act like a real dog. Information on the back cover tells the reader that 'poodles were originally trained to hunt waterbirds' and Trixie Twinkle Toes certainly proves that she is a 'dazzlingly dangerous daring dog' when she rescues little Gripper from certain death in a puddle.
Appealing collages tickle the funny bone as the exploits of Verity Brulee and Trixie Twinkle Toes are brought to life by Child's expert mix of illustrations and cut-outs. The vibrant colours of Verity's elegant clothes and shoes will appeal to those interested in fashion, while dog lovers will rejoice to see that Trixie Twinkle Toes finally manages to act like a dog.
Pat Pledger

Bear and Chook by the sea by Lisa Shanahan and Emma Quay

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2009. ISBN 9780734411112.
(Ages: 5-7) Recommended. Bear decides it is time to go to the sea. The air is balmy and there is a holiday sky. Chook is very uncertain about this big adventure - they don't know the way and even when Bear assures her that he can find the sea, Chook is convinced that it is too far for her. Chook has a very frightening journey, but Bear reassures her that all is well. Once they get to the sea, they have lots of fun until a big wave dumps Bear and it is Chook's turn to bolster Bear's confidence about returning home safely.
Shanahan's text is a delight and her use of many sound words like 'honky-tonk-tonk-tonk' for a frog and 'rickety-clickety-rickety-clickety-chooo-oooo' for a train as they 'flomp, flomp, scratch, scratch' along to the sea make for a lively read aloud session. Short descriptive sentences and repetition will aid the beginning reader.
Emma Quay's illustrations are gorgeous. Beautiful blues, yellows and greens bring alive the countryside and the ocean. The personalities of Bear and Chook are quite distinct and the changing expressions of fear and joy on their faces is captivating. I was left with a lovely warm feeling about the power of friendship as I looked at the illustrations of Chook lolling against Bear as they watch the moon.
Themes of friendship, adventure and a seaside trip as well as the memorable illustrations will ensure that this becomes a favourite with classes and individuals alike.
Pat Pledger

Children of War : Iraqi Children Speak by Deborah Ellis

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 9781742371146.
(Ages : 12+) In the wake of her extraordinary Off to War: Soldiers' Children Speak, Deborah Ellis gives us this selection of stories from Iraqi children, whose lives have been disturbed by war. The 20 stories range from Haythem, aged 8, a boy with hydrocephalus caused by the enriched uranium used in bombs, to 15 year old Musim, who fled with her family to Amman after seeing the plight of women spiraling downwards in Baghdad, and 19 year old B.W. along with others who can only be known by initials. Each story tells a different tale of that child's life, interrupted cruelly by the conflict not of their doing, going on around them. Each story tells of how they have coped and are coping, in a land not of their birth, a place where they are refugees and outsiders, exploited, alone and living in poverty.
In a classroom where issues are discussed, this book will form a basis for conversation and thought. Students cannot help but be disturbed by the stories of children their age and the horrors they have seen and are involved in. This book will give faces to the horror scenes broadcast each night on TV.
Several stories, amongst the many, stood out. 15 year old Musim had hoped along with her family that things would improve after the first Iraqi war. But this did not happen. Women's lives were even more strictly regulated. Many were kidnapped, raped and beaten. When her father died, her mother remarried, but her stepfather grew more and more violent and threatening, when the bombs started. She vividly describes what it is like for people to live during a bombing raid, and so Musim and her family fled to Amman. Here at least she and her siblings can go to school, but the uncertainty is overwhelming.
A telling quote form Dwight D. Eisenhower completes the stories, and this is followed by an excellent glossary of terms, and two pages of websites where further information can be found. Of all of these, the most chilling is a site which keeps an up to the minute count of all Iraqi people killed. And we know that this count includes an excessive number of women and children.
Fran Knight

Pink by Lili Wilkinson

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009.
(Age range: 14+) Recommended. Pink is a colour so often associated with femininity and girls and so aptly used as the title for this novel which deals with peer group and personal identity.
Ava is trying to discover who she really is and where she truly fits in. As she begins a new school year having transferred to Billy Hughes private school she finds herself in with the ultra cool Alexis and her friends and also by default in with the misfit stage crew which is preparing props for the school production. As Ava experiences the huge diversity of the two groups she also finds her friendship with Chloe, her best friend from her previous school, challenged by the new surroundings and her continual uneasiness with who she is and what she is becoming. Through her actions Ava alienates the people who really matter most to her and it is only through another's actions she sees the bigger picture more clearly.
Lili Wilkinson is a talented author who seems to have an innate ability of tapping into the teenage mind and writing to suit their needs and likes.
Tracy Glover

The wrong grave by Kelly Link

cover image

Text Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9781921520730.
(Age 14+) Recommended for those who like their stories strange and scary, author Kelly Link has written a unique collection of horror/fantasy stories to keep the reader awake at night. Reminiscent of Neil Gaiman's work, these short stories are compelling and unusual reading. In The Wrong Grave, Miles decides that he wants to retrieve the poems that he put in his girlfriend's coffin, but has an unpleasant surprise when he opens the grave and digs up what seems to be the wrong girl. The wizards of Perfil live in high towers in a marsh, but the reader isn't sure if they exist or what they can do. Magic for Beginners is a strange tale of Jeremy whose friendships revolve around watching a weird TV show that doesn't appear regularly. In The Faery Handbag, a grandmother carries around a handbag, which may have a man-eating dog in it, or is it a whole village? The Specialist's Hat is the most frightening of all the stories, with twin girls encountering a scary babysitter who joins them in a game to show what it is like to be dead.
Link's stories are unpredictable and creative, leaving the reader gasping at the sheer strangeness of her imagination and the deviousness of her plots. I won't easily forget the dead girl whose hair writhed like snakes or the character Fox in the TV show The Library.
Making the stories even more appealing to teenagers are the insightful comments about girlfriends, kissing, parents and friendship that quietly appear in each story. Subtle humour is threaded throughout the tales and takes the edge off the horror. Shaun Tan's sketches at the beginning of each story are also a delight.
This is certainly a collection that I found so original that I will be seeking out Link's other works.
Pat Pledger

The Boat by Nam Le

cover image

(Age: Senior) This is an offering of invigorating and sometimes harrowing short stories by Vietnamese born Nam Le, whose family fled Vietnam in 1979, ahead of the northern Communist forces. Growing up in Melbourne, Nam Le knows the divided loyalties of someone living where they are not born. He gives us stories of homecoming and being a tourist in New York, of seeing his father after an absence of three years, of truthfulness, of braving the South China Seas, of Tehran and Melbourne, bringing a whiff of the exotic wherever they are set.
The first story tells of a father's visit when the writer is living in Iowa. The disunity between the two men after an absence of three years, is compared with his writer's block, an anxious time, made more impossible by the forth coming deadline. Suffering writer's block, people give him ideas about writing. Ethnic writing seems to be the rage, so cash in on your boat people stories, some say. The unflattering suggestions of his friends, undermines what he has already written and published, but he is again taken back to his childhood in Melbourne, where his harsh father exerted a discipline born of anger. But deadline approaching, he resorts to the stories of his youth, of the Vietnamese men meeting at this house, of telling stories of their youth, of the problems in his own family home, where he and his father bristled against each other. When the father reads his words, he offers to tell him the real story and does so, but the story written is burnt, further breaking the threads between the two men. This first story is a captivating look at father son relationships and the disparity between generations.
In Cartagena, the setting of the story is in the appalling corruption of drug soaked Colombia, where two men are discussing their contract to kill their target. The youth of the men is underlined by their innocent questions as they hustle the victim to the ground, in preparation for his murder.
Each story is most unusual in its perspective, and the glowing imagery makes the reader want to stop and go back to read the line again. Senior students will find these an accessible group of stories to read and discuss.
Fran Knight

Interview with Kirsty Murray

cover image

1. Do you see Vulture's Gate as a departure, especially from your historical books?
Vulture's Gate was a natural extension of the ideas I'd been exploring across all my earlier novels. I've always been interested in stories that wrestle with ideas about time, place, historical continuity and historical continuity and the resilience of children.

2. How did you develop the characters in Vulture's Gate? Are there links with those in the Children of the Wind series?
The character of Callum was inspired by a photo of a boy who was performing in a circus. What's always impressed me about children in the circus world is their flexibility - not only in the physical sense but in their ability to adapt to ever-changing circumstance. Bo began more immediately from the inspiration provided by my goddaughter, Roxane Walker. Eventually, both characters grew into their own distinctive selves, drawing influence from many of the children I have known. The principal connection to the characters from Children of the Wind series is Bo and Callum's resourcefulness. I think it's a very distinctive trait of immigrant children and, like Bridie, Paddy, Colm and Maeve, the children in Vulture's Gate have to face the same challenges in terms of finding home in foreign climes.

3. What for you were the main issues that you wanted brought forward in Vulture's Gate
Despite how bleak and dark some of the projections in Vulture's Gate may appear, it's essentially a story that is optimistic about children's ability to adapt and make culture afresh in the wake of environmental and social disasters.

4. The book ends with hope for the future. Is there to be a sequel and if so what direction will it take?
I didn't intend the book to have a sequel but I must admit that Bo and Callum aren't quite so easily put to bed. I do have notes and scenes from their further adventures but I'm working on other projects and trying not to let Bo and Callum hijack me yet again.

5. What childhood books do you feel have influenced your life as a writer?
The list would have to be very, very long. Alan Marshall, Astrid Lindgren, Frances Hodgson Burnett and Mark Twain were authors whose work influenced me. Lucy Fitch Perkins' 'Twins Series' had a major impact on my reading when I was in middle-primary. I loved the way she infused her stories with so much cultural and historical information. Ann Holm's I am David and Ian Serraillier's The Silver Sword were landmark books in my childhood reading alongside Hesba Brinsmead's Pastures of the Blue Crane and Ivan Southall's Ash Road.

6. What books have you recently read which are now amongst your favourites?
I'm both eclectic and voracious in my reading so my 'favourites' list is a shifting canvas. In the past few weeks I've loved David Metzenthen's Jarvis 24 and Katherine Constable's Winter of Grace. I've also enjoyed Kelly Link's extraordinary collection of short stories The Wrong Grave. I'm re-reading Ford Madox Ford's The Good Soldier which is an absolutely perfect novel that's worth revisiting again and again.

7. What have been the main influences on your writing?
My children, step-children, godchildren and the many students that I've met in schools and writing workshops have all exerted a huge influence on my writing. I'm also very influenced by landscape - both urban and rural - and find it very difficult to separate any story from the place in which it is set so Australia is a significant influence on everything I write.

Vulture's gate by Kirsty Murray

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 9781741757101.
(Age 13+) Highly recommended. A fabulous science fiction story with overtones of Mad Max, Vulture's gate tells the story of Callum, a young boy kidnapped by the dangerous Outlanders and Bo, Roboraptor Girl, who has survived alone in the desert since her grandfather was murdered. The world is a lawless place, and a bird virus has wiped out most of the women. When Callum manages to escape from his captors he discovers Bo's hiding place in the opal cave where she lives with her little robots, the roboraptors. Pursued by the Outlanders, they make a frantic dash across the desert in search of safety and Callum's fathers. But when they finally reach Vulture's Gate, perilous surprises are in store for them.
This a great survival story with lots of action and adventure to keep the reader interested. I loved the fast pace of the story and had to read quickly to the end to see whether Bo and Callum would survive. Their characters are vividly drawn and I found myself cheering them on as they faced terrible predicaments. The uniqueness of the Australian setting, the barren landscape and the ruined city of Vulture's Gate added to the atmosphere.
Many thought provoking issues are raised. The theme of women and girls being wiped out is a memorable one explored by Murray in a low key way. What would it be like to be regarded as an oddity if you were a girl? As a valuable rarity, what would powerful men want? What would it be like for Callum to be brought up by two fathers? The little roboraptors are fabulous and could be used to discuss genetic engineering and technology. The effects that a plague virus could have and devastation of the environment are also key themes.
This is a dystopian novel that deserves a place on library shelves. The ending leaves enough openings for a sequel, and I would love to read one.
Pat Pledger

Finding Home by Gary Crew

cover image

IIl.by Susy Boyer. Ford St Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9781876462871.
(Ages 6-10) A family arrives from England and taking up land in the bush, the father clears the trees and plants a crop. He is proud of what he has achieved, but when his son, a reader, tells him that the lone tree in his field is home to many cockatoos, the father cuts down the tree, making the birds find another place to roost or die. Paralleling this act of destruction, the boy, too, must leave or die in the barren place his father has created.
The sparsely written text builds quickly to a crescendo of emotional pull as the reader is drawn to the boy and his love of his environment, taking in the chasm between the view taken by the parents and the boy. The savagery of cutting down the tree, the only one left in the field, is underscored by the emotions felt by each of the participants. The boy can only watch as the birds fly around looking for their home, bewildered, confused, and angry, while the parents are oblivious to the damage they have done. The gulf between the members of the family is quietly resolved as the boy leaves the farm with the bookseller.
The brutishness of the parents is contrasted with the soft, sometimes dreamlike, drawings by Susy Boyer. Her illustrations give quietness to the pace of the book which is suddenly erupted by the close up pencil drawings of the parents as they take in what the boy has said about borrowing a book. And this abrupt change is reiterated when the tree is felled. Her use of coloured pencils and water colour give an unusual texture to the page.
But there is an oddity about the book which I found fascinating. Why did the boy leave? Why did the parents hate that he is a reader? Why did the illustrator encircle the boy and the hawker as they left the farm, with a halo of white? These and other questions will be eagerly discussed, along with other more obvious ideas. The thought of 'home' in the title is beguiling, as it covers so many different views of home in this book. And just who is 'finding home'? Conservation, environmental concerns, land clearing, settlement and colonization are just some of the topics of conversation I predict children will discuss in a classroom where this book is made available. And the idea of parents being cross with the child for reading a book! Well, I could go on and on.
Fran Knight