Reviews

Sold by Patricia McCormick

cover image

Age 14+ When Lakshmi is told that she is to go to the city and work as a maid, she is excited and grateful. She will now be able to send money back to her family in the foothills of Nepal, where, dogged by poverty, they can barely afford to put food in their children's mouths. As she travels further away from her mother, however, the trip becomes increasingly strange, until, finally in the city, she is locked in a room until she accepts that she is there to service the men who knock at the door.

In spare prose, set up in diary form, Lakshma details the life she leads with the other girls. Occasionally raided by police, she comes to realize that they are only there for the extra money from the brothel keeper. Sometimes some American men come in and speak to her of escape, but the stories she has been told about these men, keep her wary and afraid. Her attempts to save money are met with derision from one girl, who confides that she will never be allowed to leave, only being tossed out when she is no longer of any use.

The sweep of the novel is extraordinary, showing the reader just how these girls are sold into slavery, what their lives consist of and the collusion needed with authorities to keep them in the trade. Each of the girls' lives is told in much detail, so that the reader is in no doubt about what happens to them. Statistics at the end of the book, detail the extent of slavery around the world, and in particular the sexual slavery that goes on.

Read it and weep. Fran Knight

Larklight by Philip Reeve. Illustrated by David Wyatt

cover image

London : Bloomsbury, 2006 Available from Allen & Unwin

Age 10+ Larklight is a rip-roaring adventure science fiction book with a wonderful whimsical story and terrific characters. It is set in familiar Victorian times with the added dimension of the British Empire ruling some of the planets.

Larklight is a large dilapidated house that flies around in space in an orbit near the Moon. Art Mumby and his sister Myrtle live there with their scholarly father. One day Mr Webster, supposedly from the Royal Xenological Institute, visits and they discover to their consternation that he is an enormous white spider like creature, one of the First Ones, who captures their father and takes over Larklight. Art and Myrtle manage to escape in a lifeboat and are rescued by the pirate Jack Havock, who takes them aboard his ship the Sophronia. Many hair-raising adventures follow in their efforts to foil the First Ones and save the British Empire.

Wyatt's wonderful, funny and detailed drawings are a joy to look at and add to the enjoyment of the incredible creatures and objects that pervade the story. The book is one that booklovers will want to keep for its beautiful hardcover production with end papers featuring Victorian ads, long involved chapter headings and footnotes.

Apart from the breath taking adventures, readers will love the zany humour and references to Victorian customs and the weird beings that live in this world. Hoverhogs whiz around and clean up, winged ships, powered by an device called an Alchemical Wedding, flap their way through the aether and the Crystal Palace attacks London.

Readers can look forward to further adventures and lots of fun as it appears that there will a sequel.

Pat Pledger

Opal dream by Ben Rice

cover image

Random House Australia, 2006

Age 12+ The film tie-in of the story originally titled Pobby and Dingan tells the story of Ashmol, an 11 year old boy and his sister Kellyanne who inhabits a fantasy world with her two imaginary friends, Pobby and Dingan. After her father fails to bring her invisible friends back from the opal mine, Kellyanne insists that he goes to search for them. He strays onto another miner's claim, and is accused of 'ratting'. Kellyanne, grieving for her lost friends, becomes seriously ill and Ashmol, in a desperate bid to help her get well, organises the whole town to search for Pobby and Dingan.

Rice captures the atmosphere of the Australian outback in this quirky and moving story. The story is told by Ashmol, who loves his sister but considers her a 'fruit-loop'. All the characters are vivid and real. This story would perhaps respond to being read out loud and could promote much discussion about imagination, dreams and the power of love.

Contained in the same volume is another novella, Specks in the Sky, set in a camel safari centre in America. A mother and her two daughters see specks in the sky which turn out to be a team of crack parachutists who have bailed out during a top- secret mission. Questions are raised about identity and family relations in this unusual story.

Terrier, (Beka Cooper, book one. A Tortall Legend) by Tamora Pierce

cover image

Born into the Lower City, Beka's mother is a friend of some with influence and money and when she dies, Beka and her siblings are taken into the lord's household, where Beka decides she will train to be a Guard. Teamed with two Dogs, Goodwin and Turnstall, they are put on the night shift in the Lower City, a den of thieves, pickpockets and rats, and one of their first assignments is to discover why Crookshank's grandson has been killed.
The Shadow Snake, a story told to quieten children, has come to life and is stealing young ones from the streets, blackmailing their parents into their safe return.  Some, like Crookshank, do not believe in the Shadow Snake and refuse to pay, never seeing their children again.

Shy Beka, a Puppy, a trainee, has to follow her Dog's orders, but with her special powers she is able to pass on information. The city's pigeons speak to her, passing on the cries of the newly dead, wanting release, and she hears the cries of those children killed by the Snake. But some of the pigeons' cries are definitely not children, so the Dogs begin to investigate adult murders as well. The two investigations run parallel to the other until they become intricately involved, Beka finding that memories from her past help solve the kidnappings and murders.

The scope of Tamora Pierce's new novel is breathtaking. She tells a powerful story of a young woman coming of age, finding her place in the world. Enmeshed with magic, trials and mysteries, Beka Cooper will enthrall all of Pierce's fans and more. Pierce's mesmerizing world is endless as she peoples it with a huge cast of characters, all with a part to play within the magnificent medieval setting. A glossary at the end will help with the new words, and the list of characters with their parts is helpful for those gasping at the sheer size of the story. I loved it and was thrilled to find that this book is simply Book One. Fran Knight

Everyman's rules for scientific living by Carrie Tiffany

cover image

16+ Set in the Mallee during the 1930's, this haunting novel brings vividly alive the trials of farm life during the Depression and the lead up to World War 2. Robert Pettergree and Jean Finnegan meet on the government 'Better Farming Train' which brings city advice to farmers. They settle on a small farm, and Robert is determined to live by scientific rules and change wheat farming by using scientific methods. However natural disasters cannot be ruled by science and neither can love. The author gives an authentic voice to the characters, highlighting their humour, struggles and disappointment, making this an engrossing historical book to read.

Pat Pledger

One whole and perfect day by Judith Clarke

cover image

Allen & Unwin
Age 13+  Sensible 16 year old Lily has what she considers a 'freakish' family. Her father left home before she was born and her mother takes in stray people. Her grandfather has chased her brother Lonnie out of his home with an axe and her grandmother talks to an invisible friend Sef. When Nan decides to hold an 80th birthday for Pop and wants all the family there, Lily the sensible one, is left to try and get everyone together for one whole and perfect day.
Judith Clarke has collected together a group of engaging characters who face a series of engrossing and often humourous dilemmas to flesh out her themes of love and family.
This is a beautifully written and complex story that is difficult to put down.

Pat Pledger

Voices by Ursula Le Guin

cover image

Ursula Le Guin has written another outstanding fantasy book tackling thought provoking issues like religious fervour, revenge, cruelty, women's rights, leadershipand peaceful negotiation. Voices is the second book in the Annals of the Western Shore trilogy and follows the book Gifts where protagonists, Orrec, a storyteller and Gry who can call to animals, were first introduced as teenagers. It can, however, be read as a stand-alone. It is a compelling coming-of-age story.
 
Ansul, once a beautiful trading city with a famous library, has been conquered by the Alds, a desert people who fear the demons in writing and destroy any books that they find. One last small library is concealed in the Oracle House and it is here that fugitives bring books for safe keeping. 17 year old Memer and the Waylord are scholars and guardians of the library and the Oracle that lies hidden in it. When Orrec and Gry arrive with their half lion they are the catalyst for the uprising of a conquered people.

Pat Pledger

Dairy Queen by Catherine Gilbert Murdock

cover image

13+ This is the story of the summer when D.J Schwenk, a small town girl, learns to speak up for herself. As Brian Nelson, an aspiring football star says, "When you don't talk there is a lot of stuff that ends up not getting said". In this riveting first novel Catherine Gilbert Murdock portrays an unforgettable heroine, who is courageous and funny and who finally goes after what she wants. When her father is injured, D.J. takes over the manual work of their dairy farm. She agrees to train Brian, and this relationship pushes her to understanding herself and her family.

A wonderful book that was difficult to put down.

Pat Pledger

Lost Property by James Moloney

cover image

14+ James Moloney explores the rites of passage from adolescence into young adulthood in this story. 17 year old Josh Tambling appears to have everything: he is popular, smart and plays in a grunge band. When Josh takes a holiday job in the Lost Property Office at Sydney's Central Station, he realises that he has lost some important things in his life. His brother Michael refuses to let anyone know where he is living, and Josh is no longer certain of his religious faith.
This is an outstanding novel.

Pat Pledger

xxxHolic by Clamp

cover image

Translated and adapted by Anthony Gerard, Tanoshimi, Great Britain, 2006
(Lower secondary) Clamp, a group of 4 women who are Manga artists, is producing three Manga series of books in Japan, Tsubasa, xxxHolic and Gohou Drug. These comic books are widely popular in Japan, and are appearing in the western world to great acclaim.
xxxHolic, volume 1 introduces the hero, Watanuki Kimihira, who unwittingly falls under the spell of a witch, Yoku. She grants people wishes and in return they give her their soul.
Working in her shop he sees the array of people willing to use her services and following one such young woman, finds that she becomes more and more like a statue, as her body seizes up, until she stops in front of a truck, unable to move.
The book sized comics are entertaining and richly illustrated. I was intrigued with the perspective of the drawings and the story line. The comics introduce a tradition new to the west and will be lapped up by the target audience, the lower secondary students.
Fran Knight

Cold skin by Steven Herrick

cover image

Herrick's finely tuned verse novels are deceptively simple, as they describe a setting, elucidate a set of characters, unfold a plot, while you are lulled by the rhythmic nature of the writing. Before you know it you are engrossed, surprising yourself as you see links and plot developments, character foibles and hints of what may be ahead.

Larry and Eddie Holding are at school, a one teacher place, but they'd rather be working at the mine like everyone else in this one job town. Their father, a returned serviceman, is dejected; feeling cowardly because he didn't see overseas action during the war, and despite their poverty, will not allow his sons to go down the mine.

The small town is delineated by its inhabitants, a mayor who runs the local store, rich and proud, a policeman who wants to do well for his town, a teacher disenchanted with rural life and the lack of women, a publisher who sees all, and goes about his job quietly. When one night a young girl is found murdered, the town looks inward, closing ranks. Malice and suspicion ferments as Eddie watches, noting movement, the other watchers, the drunks and then his father, hiding something and unable to be at peace.

The climax of the story will shock and extend your students' discussions of right and wrong, of consequences and morality.

Fran Knight

The Great Gatsby by Nicki Greenberg

cover image

I came to this book with some trepidation, not knowing how someone could even give thought to changing a stalwart of literature to a graphic novel, and with strange creatures representing the characters. But I was engrossed, not quite from the start, but it certainly took me in the more I read. Drawn as a powder puff on a twig with a female body at the end of a long neck the wonderful character of Daisy, evokes our sympathy as she is revealed with all her insecurities and regrets, the epitome of a vacuous existence, the woman we all have seen splashed across the pages of women's magazines.

Her husband the brutish Tom, is drawn as a great lump of a man, hair sprouting from his chest and arms, elephant ears, beady eyes, and pig like teeth. Gatsby is an ephemeral sea dragon, with small eyes that peer lovingly at Daisy, always worried lest he do the wrong thing in her eyes. He lives only for her, his house and lifestyle built around the possibility of seeing her.

Each page has between 4 and 6 cartoons, drawn in sepia tones on a black background, with stamp like edging, like photos in an old album. Moth-like the characters play out their lives against the backdrop of 1920's New York, the Jazz Age, where new money is viewed suspiciously, but everyone comes to Gatsby's to be seen and exploit his generosity. For those who read only the graphic novel, the retelling is short but explicit, for those who go on to the novel, then the experience will be enhanced through reading both versions. For the astute teacher, reading the novel would be enhanced with this graphic version, giving as it does an updated view of the characters, a more modern perspective. The discussions emanating from such a comparison would be enthralling.

Fran Knight

Stride's summer by Jenni Overend

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2007
(Age 11-14) The summer he loses his father to the sea, Stride is unable to cope with the extra demands placed upon him by his mother. She too is grieving the loss of her husband and must take responsibility for the whole family on her own. Seeing Stride in his father's clothes and with the cockatoo, Ferd, unsettles her and his persistent lack of cooperation drives a wedge between them.

But this is also the summer he meets Jess, and her interest in him begins with Ferd. She has had experience with birds, and unsettles Stride, suggesting that he allow the cockatoo his freedom. Stride is not able to do this, seeing the bird as a link to his dead father. The two waltz around each other, Stride at first not wanting her to be anywhere near him, but gradually she insinuates herself closer and closer, until Stride looks for her on the beach.

The decision by his mother to sell their cottage is a catalyst for Stride to take off to his grandfather's place, but it is the height of summer, and the threat of fire is ever present.
A coming of age story about a boy learning to accept change in his life, this book will appeal to upper primary and lower secondary students, particularly boys.
Fran Knight

The island by Armin Greder

cover image

Highly recommended, this dark and mesmerising picture book for older children and adults is an essential addition to library collections. When an outsider is washed up on the beach, the local people are faced with the question of what to do with him. Fearful, but not wanting his death on their consciences, they isolate him on the end of the island, lock him in a goat pen and leave him. When he finally escapes and approaches them for food, they realise that 'their act of kindness had not been the end, but merely a beginning'. Growing fear and intolerance take over and he is finally condemned and the island barricaded against all newcomers.

Armin Greder's sparse prose and compelling illustrations present an overwhelming and chilling picture of the plight of refugees and the way that fear and racial prejudice can overwhelm even the voice of reason. The chilling illustrations are all done in dark tones with just a hint of teal and red, and bring to life the emotions of the refugee and the islanders. The anger and fear of the large and overwhelming islanders is almost tangible and the starving figure of the outsider is breathtaking.

A recipient of several European awards, this book could be used in the classroom in a variety of ways when introducing work on refugees, intolerance, racial prejudice and sharing. Teacher’s notes are available and outlines different strategies for teachers. Younger children would need to have discussion and follow up to show that with tolerance the bleak ending in the book need not happen today.

This is an unforgettable and very important book for our times.

Pat Pledger

The Truth About Emma by Gary Crew

cover image

At a first glimpse of the beautiful young woman on the cover of The truth about Emma, the reader would expect this book to be a teenage romance, but that is not Gary Crew's style. He delivers an involved, disturbing and memorable story that has quite a punch about the power of the press and the complexity of human relations.

Emma Burden has been the target of international media, with headlines about an affair with a university professor while she was still at school and accusations of murder. Journalist Rafaelo Innocenti, hoping to get his big break, interviews her to see if he can find out the truth.

Told in a series of thirteen interviews, Crew leads the reader through the convoluted details of the life of Emma Burden. The story is told with an intellectual quality that demands the reader's commitment. From the very beginning when Innocenti states that for a man and woman to fall in love, they must 'both understand and practise the meaning of two words: compliance and antagonism', Crew insists that his reader think about relationships much more deeply than a mere newspaper or magazine story demands. References to Emma by Jane Austen, Madame Bovary and Lolita also move the reader into a higher level of thinking.

At the same time, the issues are ones that are of intense interest to young people. Popular media emphasises fame, clothing, and appearance and Crew spends time setting a scene where beauty is all-important and wearing the right designer apparel essential. The casual approach to sexual relationships is also a sub plot. One can't help being reminded of the stories about Paris Hilton and other celebrities.

Crew maintains a high interest level as the reader is swept along, avid to follow the story of Emma and for younger readers this may be enough. More discerning readers will want to pursue the many threads in this story and will find themselves pondering questions of morality and celebrity.

Pat Pledger