Reviews

Dust by Christine Bongers

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2009. ISBN 9781741664461.
(Age early secondary) Recommended. Set in Queensland in the 1970's twelve year old Cecilia, her twin Punk and four brothers, live with the harsh background of parents struggling to keep the land viable. Cecilia says 'We had rules despite our unruly appearance: never praise, never thank and never apologise. In this family, you don't show weakness or you'll be called a girl. And no-one wants that. Not even me.' Pp10,11. With this mantra Cecilia is appalled when her mother insists that she is nice to the Kapernicky sisters, Janeen and Aileen, who have recently moved next door. Cecilia and Aileen immediately dislike each other and hurl abuse when they can. Cecilia feels that there is something awry and her mother implies this but still wants her to befriend the girls. Beginning senior school has many challenges for Cecilia but the final assault comes when she finds the truth about the Kapernicky sisters. This is a well scripted, sensitively written novel of growing up and learning to understand the horrors of some people's lives and coming back to redress them.
Sue Nosworthy

Daniel X: Watch the skies by James Patterson

cover image

Doubleday, 2009.
(Age early secondary) Recommended. This is the second in the series and those followers of the first one will want to read this. Daniel, a teenage alien hunter, continues the search for the TV tyrant who is determined to destroy the planet. This is a fast moving action packed thriller which has an ever twisting series of technological events, akin to a television series. Daniel and his family plot to overcome the villain in an original and fascinating way. Daniel says 'I began by doing what any highly disciplined military commander would do on the eve of battle - I ate a four course meal' p180.Sounds like an adolescent to me! The novel obviously leads to the next book so the end is not as satisfying as it might be. But the followers will be waiting for the next in the series.
Sue Nosworthy

Sarindi and the Lucky Buddha by Janine Fraser

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN: 9780732287757.
(Ages 8-10) Highly recommended. Living in Indonesia, Sarindi believes he has all the luck he could possibly need, especially when he wins Jaya's lucky marble. With his loving, happy family, an income thorough his father's hard work driving the becak which his mother has 'made good as new' and the lucky bird, Sarindi wants for nothing until his luck seems to change and his mother becomes ill. Thus begins his search for a new kind of luck to restore her to good health. As Sarindi goes to make his prayers in the Hindu, Christian, Muslim and Buddhist places of worship, he continues to show courage and love and have faith that his mother's health will be restored.
Janine Fraser has created a lyrical and moving tale, perfectly supported by Elise Hurst's delightful illustrations. Sarindi and his parents are a genuine, down to earth family one would love to meet and spend time getting to know. This novel would be a great resource in a classroom unit on Indonesian culture, as an introduction to comparative religions and an example of resilience and family relationships. A highly recommended read!
Jo Schenkel

Fearless by Colin Thompson

cover image

Ill. by Sarah Davis. ABC Books, 2009. ISBN 9780 733320253
(Ages 3-7) This delightful picture book will have kids, parents and teachers laughing out loud as the antics of the new dog, Fearless take hold of them while reading this story. Thompson starts his story with vignettes of names not suiting the people who have them, and so we know that the name Fearless is a misnomer. Taken home from the Adopt a Pet store, Fearless is shown around the house in a variety of scenarios which belie the name he has been given.He jumps into his owner's arms when a car backfires and does so himself. He growls at the visitor's handbag until the nasty thing is hidden from view. He cannot bear to do his business outside and loves to eat the biscuits from the baby. All the while he is aware that it is his job to protect his family.
One night when a burglar calls, Fearless tries to greet him with his smile, showing off all his teeth. He tells the burglar that he is not allowed on the table with his growls and grunts and when his father comes downstairs the burglar races off without saying goodbye. The difference between the reality and what Fearless thinks is happening is very funny and instantly recognisable to all readers.
The water colour illustrations are superb, capturing the difference between what is said and what it really happening. The dog is portrayed with heavenly expressions, meek and mild, pleading and scared, excited and happy. The pages on which the dog has made a mess in the house are beautifully done, the looks in the dog's face redolent with meaning and I loved the drawings of the dog wound around his owner's legs. But these are only a couple out of many drawn with humour, movement and panache. A charming story full of wit, underlining the family and its relationship with their pet, this will be a hit wherever children are to be found.
A small jarring point is the complete use of the 32 page format, putting the publication page and the last page of the story together. But this will not detract from the sheer enjoyment of the story and the illustrations.
Fran Knight

The magician's elephant by Kate DiCamillo

cover image

Candlewick Press, ISBN 978 7636 4410 9
(Age 10-12) Highly recommended.When ten year old Peter Augustus Duchene is told by the fortune teller in the market place that the sister he presumed dead is alive he is confused and distressed for his guardian Vilna Lutz has always told him the opposite. Then when the fortune teller also prophesises that he should follow the elephant, Peter is not only bewildered but determined to find the truth.
This fantasy unfolds as in a dream with the magician conjuring an elephant when intending only a bouquet of flowers. Beautifully told with muted black and white acrylic illustrations, the font, and paper add to the surreal feeling pervading the novel.
From the acclaimed author of Because of Winn Dixie and The tale of Desperaux, and similar to Philippa Pearce's A Finder's Magic it's a book to read aloud and savour the shared experience.
Sue Nosworthy

A small free kiss in the dark by Glenda Millard

cover image

(Ages: Middle School)Recommended. When homeless, street kid, Skip, goes to the library to read books about art, his favourite subject, he finds a young boy, Max, waiting for his mother. War has started, and people are fleeing, the library building is partly demolished by bombs. Skip takes Max to safety, and they meet up with Billy, an older man who Skip knows. The three find shelter in an old amusement park, now made derelict by war, and here they scavenge from shops nearby, keeping a wary eye on the hotel, now used as a staging post by one of the armies. Billy tells Skip that they are in the third army, the ones who do not want war, and through the days and nights of the conflict, Skip comes to realise that there are many other people looking for shelter, avoiding war, making up the third army like them.
One day, another young girl, Tia, joins them with her baby Sixpence. The five muck in together to stay alive and out of sight, but all the while, Skip wants to find somewhere perfectly safe. The boy Max, tells them of his grandfather's place, out of town, a place where they could grow vegetables and live safely. And so they decide to try to find this place. The last section of the book tells of their escape from the city and light hearts as they near their destination.
This is a beautiful story, full of hope and survival, resonating with the bond growing between the cluster of disparate people, making them a family, something Skip has not been part of for some time. The writing with its beautiful imagery is just perfect, and this audio version, read by Craig Innis is an amazing thing to listen to. Innis' voice is just right, as he tells the story of Skip in the first person. His voice sings with the enthusiasm and idealism of the 12 year old, resonates with the older and wiser Billy, squeaks with the sound of the child, Max and takes on the voice of he sometimes devious Tia, not really telling them what she is about. The 5 hours listening to this audio version of this superb book went in no time.
Fran Knight

Running on the cracks by Julia Donaldson

cover image

Egmont, London,2009. ISBN 9781405222334.
(Ages 12+) Two lives collide in this unusual story set in Glasgow. With the combined themes of homelessness, pedophilia, immigration and truanting, the targeted audience will immediately feel at home with the tale. Leo has been sent to live with her aunt and uncle after the deaths of her parents. Here she feels out of place, especially when she wakes to find her uncle standing by her bed. Finlay, on the other hand comes from a loving family, but they are dispirited with his school performance and truanting.
Finlay sees Leo as she tries to steal donuts from the van where he works. Giving chase, he loses her, and returning to the van, finds that money has been taken while he was away and so he loses his job. Seeing an article in the paper about her, he rings the police, but running into her again, and hearing her story, he decides to help her hide from her family and find her grandparents who live in Glasgow but have never seen her.
Using the telephone book is a great scheme, but as her name is Chan, the vetting of each person listed is long and tedious. All the while Finlay must keep her hidden and keep her fed and clothed, help her look for her relatives. It's a big ask for a young man out of sorts with his parents who are watching his every move.
Some resolution occurs at the end of the story but I wanted more, and I can see lower secondary students loving it and talking about how things could be resolved. The novel's setting is brilliantly realised and the characters well drawn.
Fran Knight

The Amanda Project, Invisible I by Melissa Kantor

cover image

Harper Collins, 2009.ISBN 978000 7327270.
Set in the United States this book is about a girl named Amanda Valentino who disappeared from Endeavor High about 6 months after enrolling. The narrator Callie Leary is part of the popular I-Girls clique but secretly helped with Amanda's introduction to her new school. This wasn't easy as Amanda was a bit of a social outcast who didn't seem to seek friends and wasn't worried what others thought.
Then Amanda disappears and Callie is summonsed to the Vice-principal's office where she finds that Nia Rivera, a definite weirdo and the arty but good looking Hal Bennett are also there. Evidently Amanda had also befriended these two, which was pretty hard to understand. Vice Principal Thornhill gives them all detention for not telling where Amanda is but they are just as mystified as him. However Amanda has left the trio different clues and this disparate group eventually decide to work together to find out more about Amanda and where she is.They even have the brainwave of setting up a website to try to find other people that knew Amanda so they can discover more about whom she was and why she disappeared. However unraveling the truth isn't simple and the mystery just gets more and more complicated raising more questions and giving no answers.
And then the book ends! Looking inside the cover I find that Invisible I is the first of a series. I wish they would advertise such important detail prominently on the outside! Delving a little deeper I find that The Amanda Project is an interactive, collaborative fictional mystery aimed at teenage girls, told across a variety of different media including the 8-book series, a website that features games, writing, art and social networking, and a related series of blogs, satellite sites, music, and merchandise. Its on MySpace, Face book, and Twitter! Readers can be interactive at the website where they can help Callie, Nia and Hal find Amanda and do other fun stuff.
The numerous drawings and doodles throughout the book give it a unique and friendly feel which would certainly appeal to the targeted readers. Fourth Story owns all rights for the property, is producing the content for The Amanda Project with a creative team. HarperCollins has the publishing rights to the eight book series and is also an investor in the property. The book content is good and suitable for 12 years plus. Given the techno age in which we now live there is probably a market for embedding books into websites. A brave move that will be keenly monitored.
Kay Haarsma

The Painted man by Peter V. Brett

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9780007276141.
(Ages 15+) The night has been taken over by demons who rise from the ground, destroying everything in sight. People who have managed to survive hide behind a complex system of wards that keep the monsters at bay. They are too afraid to leave their villages to travel to neighbouring towns in case night overtakes them on the road and the corelings take them. Three children are born in isolation. A Messenger teaches Arlen about the crippling effects of fear. Leesha trains to become a healer after a suitor tells lies about her and Rojer's life is changed by a travelling minstrel. Each must overcome great obstacles to overcome their isolation and fear. Together they may survive to save the world.
Brett has created a believable medieval type world where demons rule the night and where magic wards are the only things that keep them out of the tiny settlements. They are truly terrifying beings and there is much bloodshed during the book. The disadvantages of isolation and the ignorance that it can breed are explored through the beliefs of many of the villagers and their fear of change. Brett also introduces city life and living in the desert and the different types of knowledge that is gained there.
The characterisation is particularly strong. The Painted Man is an enigma and I was fascinated following his growth during the book. Adversity hones Leesha's character and she develops into a strong heroine. Rojer is likable and the minor characters are rounded. I liked the possibility of a developing romance between the Painted Man and Leesha in future books.
This was a compelling and quite complex read with the main characters facing difficult decisions about what they have to do to save humanity from the corelings. Readers who liked The forest of hands and teeth by Carrie Ryan will enjoy this story and will look forward to future books in the series. The last section of the book sets the scene for Book 2, The Desert Spear, with the fascinating Shar'Dama Ka the Deliverer making an appearance.
Pat Pledger

The lucky ones by Tohby Riddle

cover image

Penguin,2009. ISBN 978014300569
(Age: 15 plus) Having just finished high school in Sydney in the 1980s, Tom and his best friend, Cain, drift through summer with parties, girls, music and cars. Tom begins art school where he tries to 'find out the meaning of life'. Life continues to change as his mother leaves home and when Cain moves in with Virginia, change is accelerated. The Harbour Bridge provides a constant presence and challenge, both physically and metaphorically, to the protagonists and it is through their attempts at climbing it that Tom is able to come to some realisations. Throughout the novel, life varies depending on which side of the bridge the boys are currently standing.
This is a slow moving novel, yet the very nature of the narrator's drifting only serves to heighten the mood and describes perfectly the time between leaving school and becoming a fully fledged adult as one seeks to discover what life is all about. The presence of the boys at Dylan's press conference cleverly highlights the erosion of their illusions about their idol as they are exposed to real life scenarios and the conclusion provides hope for the future.
Jo Schenkel

Snowy's Christmas by Sally Murphy

cover image

Ill. by David Murphy. Random House, 2009. ISBN 9781741664416.
(Ages 5-8) Picture book. This addition to the sackful of Christmas stories landing on my desk this time of the year, will find a home in many school libraries as it indirectly deals with the idea of the Australian Christmas song, Six White Boomers.
Snowy is different from the rest of his mob. He is white, and rejected by his peers. Miserably drinking at the billabong, his mother comforts him saying that one day the others will want to be him. A large white kangaroo appears and takes him to meet a mob of white kangaroos, and before you know it, Santa has arrived looking for six white kangaroos to pull his sleigh over Australia. Snowy's difference is needed and when the 6 white kangaroos are harnessed together, Santa pull his sleigh over Snowy's clearing so that all those kangaroos that teased him can see what he is doing. Predictably, they all call out that they would like to be him.
Neatly resolved, this story can be added to those that extol differences as well as being useful for the time of the year it is designed to promote, and its Australianess makes it another in a growing group of books targeting the overseas market.
Fran Knight

Halt's Peril by John Flanagan

cover image

Random House, 2009. ISBN 9781741663020. (Series: Ranger's Apprentice 9).
Highly Recommended. Arriving at Port Cael, the trio, Halt, Will and Horace are searching for the villain, Tennyson and his followers. Some 20 in all, they had been helped in their escape from Hibernia. At an inn, Will falters in getting information from the notorious Black O'Malley, while Halt takes sterner measures to extract the information they need. Finding their prey headed for Picta, where another group of their religious quacks are stationed, extorting money and goods form the local populace, Halt and the others follow. Overtaken by O'Malley and his band of smugglers, their captain is fearful until he sees the combined ability of Halt and Will at using their long bows.
The ninth richly entertaining adventure in the series Ranger's Apprentice, keeps the energy levels as high as the stories which have gone before. Camaraderie, high adventure, a keen sense of right and wrong, of helping the underdog along with bravery and resilience, are key elements in this fantasy series. Set in medieval times, the undercover agents, Halt and Will, range far and wide in their efforts to retain peace and security for their kingdom, Araluen. Joined by Horace, they have a jokey manner between them, often laughing at themselves but simultaneously keeping a fearful watch over their surroundings. Will, now a ranger, still defers to Halt, and their work in the field is still often that of the teacher and the student. Halt wonders if it will always be like this, and so we have a sense that the future may be different.
Tennyson and his band of Genovesan mercenaries are headed for their stronghold in northern Picta. Here another of their group has formed an enclave, where the Outsider prophet means to gather his forces before entering Araluen. Will has already killed one of the Genovesan mercenaries in Conmel, and so the battle lines are drawn.
In a tussle, Halt is wounded by a crossbow from one of the Genovesan warriors, and at first recovers well. But over the next day, he begins to mumble, often talking about people in the past and is unable to keep on his horse. Will senses that the arrow was poisoned and between them Horace and Will must decide what to do. Their decision is crucial to saving Halt's life and over the next week or so, Halt hovers between life and death. First Will rides off and fetches the healer, and then Will must capture a Genovesan warrior to ascertain which particular poison has been used. Tension mounts for the reader, as a funeral is held and Will, Horace and ride off from their hideout.
A stunning new chapter in the story of the Ranger's Apprentice, the 440 pages hums along at a furious pace, with the reader being drawn into Halt's world as he hovers between life and death. I loved it and couldn't help myself turning pages ahead just to check how things panned out, so involved was I in their lives. Readers from 8 to 80 will be thoroughly entertained by the adventures of this trio, and I look forward to the last two books in the series (The Emperor of Nihon-Jin, number 10 in the series is due out in November 2010).
Fran Knight

Interview with John Flanagan

cover image

Fran Knight and Pat Pledger met John Flanagan in Adelaide where he spoke about the release of his new book, Halt's Peril, the ninth in his best selling Ranger's Apprentice series. Here are his answers to Fran's questions:

1. Fran: Many of my questions are more of the admiring type than riveting questions. I loved the whole section (about half the book) of Halt hovering near death after being poisoned in Halt's Peril. Did you have an awareness of your audience as you wrote this?
 
John: Very obviously, with Halt's poison episode, I was only giving out small pieces of information to lure the reader on. When kids saw the word 'Peril' they thought it meant death, and we had tons of emails saying 'don't kill Halt', so all I can say is that there is a funeral. Children did not want Halt to die. 'Peril' means danger, but it was not long after J.K. Rowling killed off a character, so fans were very aware that someone might die.

2. Fran: I was expecting someone would die.

John: Well I do kill one of them (Fran: Shock!)
John: My readers follow the blog religiously, picking up any errors or hints about the next book. Australian kids have to be asked not to put spoilers on the web site because the United States are two books behind and the United Kingdom are on book 5 or six.

3. Fran: Halt to me has many qualities of a sympathetic priest, humble but knowing his own power, subtle, a guide for Will, trainer, teacher etc. Was this deliberate? Did you have anyone in mind as you created Halt?

John: Not at the beginning, but several years ago I realised that he is based upon my year 6 teacher, Brother O'Connor, a firm disciplinarian, a man who did not smile, short and wiry. Halt is the dominant character; Will is leaning about his strengths. There is a father son relationship. Halt has the depth of experience; Will will always be his apprentice.

4. Fran: Did you feel the influence of other fantasy novels and series as you wrote these?

John: I read the first of J.K. Rowling's books, but did not want to read any more because they could have influenced me.

5. Fran: All other fantasy writers use the imperial system of measurement for their books. It is quite refreshing to come across centimetres in a medieval fantasy novel. Was this deliberate?

John: Yes. And surprisingly the Americans like it and leave it as they think it is 'quaint'.

6. Fran: The built environment comes across very strongly in Will's adventures. How did you develop these environments?

John: Castle Redmont is based on a castle that we toured in France which had big ironstones which glowed red at sunset. The villages are based on Irish villages we saw during our honeymoon in Ireland. There I developed a fascination with the legends of Ireland, and spent many hours listening to stories told be locals I met along the way.

7. Fran: The map at the start of Halt's Peril is very bare. A criticism! I kept looking at the map at the start to see where they were, but couldn't find out. For number 10, could there be a better map?And on maps - it looks so much like Britain, with Ireland (Hibernia) off to the left. Why didn't you just make it the British Isles?

John: I wanted a place I made up, a place where I made the rules. I didn't want people emailing me and telling me that such and such was over here not here. I wanted control.

8. Fran: I somehow assumed that there would be 8 in the series, and then that Halt's Peril would be the final one. How many more can we expect?

John: There are two more. Number 10: The Emperor of Nihon-Jin is due out in November 2010. I realised that there was one relationship that wasn't yet resolved, so in book 10 that will be a main thrust. Number 11 will be the final in the series and will be set 20 years hence.

9. Fran: Why Fantasy?

John: I started off with 20 short stories cobbled into a book. Initially I wrote thrillers and spy y stories, but after 9/11 I retreated to fantasy, I felt it was wrong to use that format of realism. I did not want to write about the medieval world as such but would create my own with my own rules (eg coffee is part of several of the books, and I worked out a trail allowing coffee to be in Araluen, in response to one query about how coffee got there). I am assiduous with my accuracy but make my own rules. I wanted to write escapism, and that's where my efforts went during a lean year in advertising. I put all my efforts into selling my books, an artist friend developed pictures and front covers for the first four books, and we put these onto photographic paper, with the first 25 pages of the first story, with 4 glossy pages and book covers and 2 columns outlining the stories of each book. Knowing what the slush pile was like at publishers' offices, my agent took a publisher to lunch and presented his folder to her.

10. Fran: How far have the plans for a film of the first novel progressed?

John: I am very pleased with the work so far. Paul Haggis, the director who has taken up the option is trying to raise the money at the moment, and has been responsible in the past for Million Dollar Baby and In the Valley of Elah.

11. Fran: Who do you think is your audience?

John: I think both boys and girls will like my books. My first fan mail was from twin girls. Children started to read the books when they were about 11 or 12 and continued on until they were 17 or so.

12. Pat: What about reluctant readers?
John: Reluctant readers will enjoy these books because they have pace, adventure and humour. My 12 year old son didn't like reading and initially I wrote 20 short stories to get him interested. I wrote them as entertainments so things keep happening and they are exciting. The joy of writing is in being excited by children coming to me and saying that they didn't like reading, but finding my books got them into reading. The joy of writing is reflected in being able to do some good in helping kids love reading, which I didn't get in advertising.

Mama's song by Ben Beaton

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2009. ISBN 9781742031057.
(Age 15+) Mama's Song covers a week in the life of a teenage girl, Georgina, in which she runs away from home and gives birth to a baby in a country hospital.
The reader sees Georgina's character develop through the experiences of childbirth and caring for a newborn baby, including learning to breastfeed, and also through the relationships she forms with other characters based in the hospital.These include an older first time mother, Mary, who has battled infertility to have her baby and another young mother, Nasreen, whose premature baby is battling for life.
The main narrative is interspersed with a series of flashbacks which provide some background to Georgina's character and the situation she finds herself in.These include a sexual encounter at a drunken teenager party as well as Georgina's experiences at an abortion clinic and the decline in her relationships with her family and her peers.
While the novel does not celebrate teenage pregnancy, it does show the protagonist as someone who has the strength and resolve to take control of the situation in which she finds herself. At the end of the novel, the reader is left with a sense that Georgina and her baby (whose name is said to mean 'hope') will be okay. It does not provide any indication of the struggles Georgina might face once she leaves the sanctuary of the hospital but hints at a reconciliation with her mother and stepfather. This will presumably enable Georgina to return home and access family support in raising her daughter, something that not all teenage mothers will have access to.
I did find this a beautiful and highly readable book. I think would appeal to girls over the age of 15 as well as to adult readers. It is quite short so would be easily read by a less confident reader although encouragement may need to be provided to persevere beyond the first few chapters, which are a bit sparse on plot detail. The emotions surrounding birth and the early days of parenthood are keenly described and brought tears to my eyes on a number of occasions. I would love to see a sequel covering the period after Georgina leaves the hospital as I feel that this is where her real journey into motherhood will begin.
Catherine Seal

First Strike by Jack Higgins with Justin Richards

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN: 9780007300495.
John Chance and his twin children Jade and Rich are quietly having a meal in a United States diner when a man who was walking over to speak to them is shot. In hospital he says, 'If the birds have flown, they will try for the Football,' before lapsing unconscious. Unravelling this cryptic message is a key aspect of this mystery novel.
The plot is set in the United States with Jack Chance being a secret serviceman who has already saved the President's life once. An oriental woman with a long black plaited pigtail and missing warheads in China are other central parts of the drama that has its conclusion in a White House siege during a reception. A little hard to follow the plot at times but nevertheless a good old fashioned mystery that will appeal especially to secondary school aged boys.
Kay Haarsma