Reviews

Scribble sunset by Ann Shenfield

cover image

Hachette Livre (Lothian Children's Books) 2008.
(Age 7+) Ann Shenfield, a prize winning animation filmmaker, has come up with a delightful picture book that will fuel the imagination of anyone who reads it. A little girl is determined to find the sunset and on the way she scribbles down her thoughts about the clouds she sees, a magpie and its babies, and Jones, the one person she doesn't want to think about.

Her musings raise all sorts of ideas about perspective in art and the whimsical illustrations could stimulate the reader to ask questions about different intriguing paintings and art works. These could be used to send the reader off on a quest to investigate them.

Perception, about art and people, is another major theme. As the little girl muses: 'Some things depend on where you're standing.' - a line could be a line or it could 'be the ocean with a glorious sunset over the horizon.' The author also explores, in a very gentle way, how the little girl's perception of Jones changed when they reached the ocean and she got to know him.

I loved this book and the ideas and pictures lingered in my mind long after I read it.
Pat Pledger

Genius squad by Catherine Jinks

cover image

Allen and Unwin 2008
(Age 12+) Highly recommended for its originality, this sequel to Evil genius will enthral its readers with its high tech hero, Cadel Piggott, deciding to use his hacking skills to fight evil. With the Axis Institute for World Domination blown up and Prosper English in gaol, he and his friend Sonya are approached to join a group of talented kids known as the Genius Squad. But can he trust the people at Clearview House?

Jinks has mixed together a clever mixture of technology and computers with an appealing hero who is learning to have a conscience and sorting his way through right and wrong. Memorable characters crowd the pages and the plot twists will keep the readers moving along at a fast past.

Intelligent readers who like books about technology and who appreciate a brilliant plot and wonderful imagination will grab this fast moving adventure.
Pat Pledger

My life and other catastrophes by Rowena Mohr

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008 (series: Girlfriend Fiction)
(Age 11-14) Poor old Erin Costello, not only does she have to keep a diary, a written record to improve her expression, for English, but her parents have split up, and mum's new boyfriend, Creepazoid, has moved in, almost. Through the long diary entries, we see life totally from Erin's self absorbed perception. As she toys with the idea that Creepazoid is not all he seems, and she has to put up with him not only at home but at school, where he is the PE teacher, she also has conflicts with her best friend, Rami, an environmentalist who is trying vainly to get Erin more aware.

From one episode to another, the diary entries build the tension as the reader can see where it is headed, although Erin cannot. A very funny look at a self absorbed year 10 student, trying to be part of the play at school, watching her mum's boyfriend, and taking time off school the better to investigate him, this book will have broad appeal to girls in upper primary and lower secondary school.
Fran Knight

Kiki Strike: The Empress's Tomb by Kirsten Miller

cover image

Random House, 2007
(Ages 11-15 years) An amazing group of young girls gather as hi-tech crime solvers on the streets of New York. Led by Kiki Strike, who lays claim to the throne of Pokrovia, the friends combine their amazing talents and take the reader on a fast-paced story of intrigue and adventure. Combining school with a good deal of nocturnal investigation tests the girls, but they are determined to rid the city of its latest villain, even if they have to resort to some masterly, home-made potions and devices!

Ananka tells the story of the exploits of the six best friends with great humour and honesty, providing plenty of personal comments on the action. The reader is swept along by the author's appealing style and language. There are kidnappings, the theft and copying of valuable art pieces, and deceit and intrigue when one girl discovers her father's criminal past. With the help of some street kids, the girls go to extraordinary lengths to solve a mystery which threatens to entangle them all in a web they may not escape from.

The Empress's Tomb is a wonderful read, well told and constantly holding the reader's attention. Set in a modern city with an intriguing past, and full of memorable characters, this story is thoroughly enjoyable. This is the second Kiki Strike adventure – it follows Inside the Shadow City. It is highly recommended.
Julie Wells

The uncommon reader by Alan Bennett

cover image

Faber and Faber, 2007.
(Age Secondary to adult) The uncommon reader, by the delightful Alan Bennett is filled with glorious asides by the Queen, little passing barbs at the royal family, the government and its civil service, The uncommon reader is a hoot. Bennett has cast his acerbic eye towards Buckingham Palace, where the Queen spies a van at the back of the kitchens. Investigating, because the corgi is causing a stir, and one doesn't want another person bitten by the royal dog, she finds the City of Westminster traveling library, and it opens a new world of reading for her. So much so that the equerries are concerned that she is neglecting her public duties.

A wonderful read for anyone with a few hours to spare, The uncommon reader will make you laugh out loud. The twists taken by the story are wholly believable, and the championing of reading as an activity for all is sterling Alan Bennett. There should be a copy in every library.
Fran Knight

I do it by Andrew Daddo and Jonathan Bentley

cover image

ABC Books, 2007
(Age Junior primary) Applauding the teetering steps to independence, I do it, shows a young unnamed child pushing father aside in her attempts to emulate him and do things for herself. She can brush her teeth, put sauce on her sausages, and get some milk, even though some is spilt, and so on.

A charming repetitive rhythm is introduced which carries on through the book. But halfway through it abruptly stops as dad says no. Instead of the child saying I do it, she is shown how to do things and gives help to her father at something more difficult. The last page shows her not saying I do it, in response to being asked for a kiss, but telling dad, You do it. So the events are neatly resolved and turned around.

This is a slight but sympathetic look at a child's endeavours to do something for herself, despite the consequences. This book will appeal to pre school aged children and is well suited to a child care facility or kindergarten.  Bentley's illustrations will delight the reader as they tell a back story, showing things not in the text, adding a different level of meaning for the reader to look at, ponder and enjoy.
Fran Knight

Georgiana by Libby Hathorn

cover image

Hachette Livre, 2008.
Set in the early years of the Western Australian colony, this is the most amazing story of one woman and her attempts to make herself a home. She not only helped her husband, Captain Molloy, set up a house near Augusta on Western Australia's southern coast, but she planted a garden using the seeds brought out from England, as well as those sent to her by friends, but also saw the beauty in the flowers around her, planting them in her garden, mixing the native flowers with those she planted, and so developing a world wide interest in the flowers of this new land.

Georgiana Molloy was no ordinary woman, following her husband to a new country, she was curious, inquisitive, welcoming. She not only developed an interest in the plants, but accepted the indigenous people, asking them questions, meeting them, unafraid.  Religious to the point of fervour, she set up a prayer meeting on her front verandah, ensuring all those who worked for her husband and neighbours, attended. She made plans to build a church. Always dismayed at the lack of servants, many of whom took up land grants of their own, she accepted what she could around her.

Libby Hathorn's extensive research and refinement of this incredible story has produced a book that is accessible to all. Telling of the hardships and privations of the early settlers, their fears and restrictions, it also tells of a young woman, determined to make the best of the situation, marveling at the freedom the country offered her, and incredulous at the array of flowering plants. For students of Australian history, this book will fill in the background of the academic history books, for students looking at indigenous issues, or those applying to women in the early years of Australia, or those who just want a good read, then this will fit the bill.
Fran Knight

Love Divided by Vanessa St Clair

cover image

Piccadilly Press, 2008
When I first started this I thought it was going to be a girly, gossipy, teenage 'Bridget Jones' read - rather in the vein of sub-Cathy Hopins/Louise Rennison- a frothy read for young teens. I was initially a bit taken aback by the over use of the word 'crap' and 'crappy' as well as 'piss' and 'pissed off' . However it soon develops into the story of a summer romance - a first great love for both 16 year old protagonist Lucy and 18 year old Mally, whose Bangladeshi family place increasing pressure on their son to succeed in his application for Cambridge. Can their love survive across the religious and social barriers they face? The intense feelings experienced by teenagers - with the pressure of exams in the background, is skilfully portrayed, and, in the tradition of all great love stories, the couple are ultimately separated but with memories of a summer of love and a very special relationship that will stay with both of them for ever.. Part of a series of 'Love Stories' published by Piccaddilly Press.
Laura Taylor

I am Rembrandt's daughter by Lynn Cullen

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2008.
(Age 12-15) The painter Rembrandt van Rijn has lost popularity and is living in poverty and disgrace in Amsterdam. Cornelia, the daughter of one of his models, remembers life as it was when her mother was alive and when Titus, his son by Saskia, also lived at home before his marriage into the wealthy merchant class. Abandoned by their patrons and frowned at by the respectable, Cornelia tries to sell paintings and help her irascible old father. She plays in the studio as a child and understands colour and form, but is allowed only to model, never to paint. The fragility of life at that time is clearly shown when the plague sweeps through the city, the poorer areas particularly suffering.
The action moves back and forward in time, allowing the development of a quite complex and unbelievable plot twist. The sounds, sights and smells of life in seventeenth Amsterdam are captured quite vividly in this lively story. The language is in places clumsy and anachronistic but generally works well, and for those unfamiliar with Dutch names there is a character list.
The novel is capitalising on the interest in Dutch painters and has a list of Rembrandt's paintings. It would be particularly enjoyable for readers aged 12-16 years who are interested in Rembrandt.  
Jennifer Hamilton

M is for Magic by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Bloomsbury 2008.
(Age 13+) Eleven short stories ranging from the whimsical to the very scary make up this collection by master storyteller Neil Gaiman. The frightening ones remained with me long after I finished reading them. Their ambiguous endings demand that the readers use their imagination, which is often richer than the written word, to decide what could have occurred. What really happened to the Runt, a friendless, young boy who ran away and met a ghost in the dark? What would happen when the Black Cat finally could not fight the devil and keep the evil away? Other stories like the one where the hardboiled detective is hired by Jill Dumpty to investigate Humpty's fall, were laced with humour and word play and were fun to read.

The collection concluded with the poem, Instructions. Here is its conclusion:

'When you reach the little house, the place your
journey started,
you will recognize it, although it will seem
much smaller than you remember.'

Readers will indeed find that their world has grown larger after reading these stories.
Pat Pledger

Mia's Story by Michael Foreman

cover image

Walker Books 2007
(Ages 5-7) The sketches Foreman did on his travels through Chile are incorporated into this story of hope amongst the waste outside the city of Santiago. Foreman met Manuel, who with his fellow villagers, harvested the wasteland near their village and recycled it for sale to the city where it came from. Far from being a story of despair, Foreman's illustrations and the story he tells makes it a story of the future.

One day Mia's father brings her a puppy which he found alone in the city. But one day, Poco disappears, and Mia climbs onto her horse and together they go into the mountains on their search. Here they discover a field of flowers, and Mia carefully takes a clump, roots and all, back to her home. Planting them, they multiply quickly until they have spread over the village. She puts some of the plants into pots and goes with her father to the city to sell them. Eventually she and her father just sell the flowers, as the business becomes so successful, and they eagerly await the time when they can build a house form brick.

Foreman has taken a simple tale and told it well, surrounding the story with illustrations redolent of the background of the country of Chile. The story of hope and looking forward will have wide appeal, especially adding to our readers' knowledge of how other children live.
Fran Knight

The pumpkin eater from Pondicherry by Bruce Atherton and Ben Redlich

cover image

Lothian Children's Books. Hachette Livre, 2008
(Age 5+) The humour in this wacky picture book will appeal to children and adults alike and it is a great book to read aloud. When a monster, who loves to eat pumpkins, raids the veggie garden, it is time to do something about it!

Bruce Atherton's rhyming story is lots of fun and finishes with an explosive fart. Ben Redlich's drawings are truly imaginative and add to the humour.

This would be a good book for emerging readers who would enjoy the poetry and rhythm of the story. Older reluctant readers should get a kick out the illustrations and shortness of the tale.
Pat Pledger

The ghost's child by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Viking 2007
Finding a small boy in her living room one afternoon, Matilda offers him a cup of tea, and together they talk about her life. She is ingenuous, open and honest about the love of her life, Feather, who she met by accident one day on the beach. Her father had taken her around the world in search of the most beautiful thing, and she found it in Feather. When he left, searching for his own stillness, she was distraught and building a boat went off in search of him to ask him why he had left her.

But the west wind told her that life is for going, not stopping, and so after seeing Feather, and realizing that he had found what he wanted to do, she took stock of her life and made something more useful of it, learning to be a doctor and helping the unsighted. Now towards the end of her life, she knows her last voyage is near.
 
Hartnett offers us the most extraordinary writing, disarming in its perceived simplicity, evoking the most tender and terrible of emotions, leading the reader to question the most basic of life's values, asking us to ponder what life is about, why we are here and if love is all there is. And all the while offering us an intriguing story, with the most beguiling of characters.
Fran Knight

Anila's journey by Mary Finn

cover image

Walker Books, 2008
(Age 12+) Anila's Irish father is missing, but believing he will return to her, refuses to go to Madras with her guardians, the Hickeys, who have cared for her since the death of her Bengali mother. By staying in Calcutta her father will find her. But she must make a living and so takes her letter of introduction and her portfolio of bird paintings to Mr Walker at the Asiatick Society headquarters, for he has advertised for a draughtsman to accompany him on a trip along the Ganges.

The sights, sounds and smells of India during the first days of the nineteenth century are recalled in detail in this surprising book. Alternate chapters show Anila's early years, and present events as she journeys down the Ganges. There is a mystery as well as a loved childhood to consider, a secretive man on board the boat and a child found tied up in a courtyard. Many times I was reminded of Kipling's Kim, as I languidly floated along the river with this odd assortment of people, looking at India through the eyes of a young girl with an Irish father and Bengali mother, as well as those of an Englishman disenchanted with the results of colonisation.

A delightful book, with an engaging story and wonderfully unusual and diverse characters, this novel will suit the more discriminating reader from upper primary to adult, who will revel in the most delicious of writing.
Fran Knight

The Night Garden by Elise Hurst

cover image

ABC Books, 2007
(Age Junior primary) I was reminded of two classics, Tom Brown, Rose and the Midnight Cat, and Where the Wild Things are, as I read this new tale, of a girl who after painting a magical garden on her window, wakes to go down into the garden, now magically brought to life. The garden is an adventure playground with trees all misshapen and curved, hedges the shape of kindly monsters and strange dancing animals to play with.

Along with her cat, Strange, her imagination has no bounds as she plays, skips, jumps and runs through the place, until tired she returns to her bed to sleep. The illustrations are appealingly old fashioned in their execution, and will have some appeal to the younger reader as they look into the pictures trying to find different shapes and characters. Aimed at the pre school and kindergarten, The Night Garden can be read aloud.
Fran Knight

Comment: Shortlisted CBCA 2008 - Early Childhood
Pat Pledger